You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 40 of 44 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >
Helmet46 Flag Croydon 07 Jan 17 2.59pm

Originally posted by gambler

No I'm not pretending otherwise. Of course that's the case.

I'll think we'll have to agree to differ though. In my view it's their days off. If the company don't have enough drivers then it's the company's fault. The passengers safety on the drivers days off can't possibly be their fault.

Happy to agree to differ. Be a boring place if we all agreed

 

gambler Flag Kent 07 Jan 17 3.00pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Happy to agree to differ. Be a boring place if we all agreed

Indeed.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Jan 17 3.16pm

Originally posted by 7mins

^
Correct. Relying on O/T was a deliberate company policy during my employment there.

Can I politely ask then.. why did drivers work the overtime if it was not in their contracts? Presumably to earn extra money (fair enough)but did this not play into the company's hands?

 

gambler Flag Kent 07 Jan 17 3.52pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Can I politely ask then.. why did drivers work the overtime if it was not in their contracts? Presumably to earn extra money (fair enough)but did this not play into the company's hands?

I'd say the benefit is all with the drivers, dont know why you may think it plays into the company's hands? They can work overtime and earn extra but also use it as a bargaining tool and withdraw from working when needed.

The problem for the company is that it is so much cheaper than employing more staff. And in the franchises it's all about profit for the company and is all short term focused. They don't want to train up loads of staff knowing they may lose the franchise in the future.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Jan 17 5.09pm

Originally posted by gambler

I'd say the benefit is all with the drivers, dont know why you may think it plays into the company's hands? They can work overtime and earn extra but also use it as a bargaining tool and withdraw from working when needed.

The problem for the company is that it is so much cheaper than employing more staff. And in the franchises it's all about profit for the company and is all short term focused. They don't want to train up loads of staff knowing they may lose the franchise in the future.

Yep. Train drivers are in the top 10% of wage earners. It was difficult to get them to work overtime. It seems their goodwill has all but disappeared. We used to get production managers to phone drivers at home and convince them to work. It wasn't easy. If you worked for a s***ty company, would you do them favours?

 

gambler Flag Kent 07 Jan 17 5.14pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Yep. Train drivers are in the top 10% of wage earners. It was difficult to get them to work overtime. It seems their goodwill has all but disappeared. We used to get production managers to phone drivers at home and convince them to work. It wasn't easy. If you worked for a s***ty company, would you do them favours?

I'll do it for 12

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Jan 17 5.30pm

Originally posted by gambler

I'll do it for 12

Ha. If I had a £1 for every time I heard that.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Jan 17 2.19pm

[Link]

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 10 Jan 17 6.23pm

SeeCorbyn has stated he may join the picket lines! Of course there is no political agenda to this dispute..it's all about safety!!
Didn't see him join the junior doctors on the picket lines..perhaps their Union doesn't donate enough (if any)to the Labour party

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Jan 17 6.31pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

SeeCorbyn has stated he may join the picket lines! Of course there is no political agenda to this dispute..it's all about safety!!
Didn't see him join the junior doctors on the picket lines..perhaps their Union doesn't donate enough (if any)to the Labour party

Ignorance is bliss.

[Link]

corbs.jpg Attachment: corbs.jpg (65.07Kb)

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 10 Jan 17 6.41pm

I take it Corbyn is not wedded to free movement of people affected by the strike?

Edited by hedgehog50 (10 Jan 2017 6.41pm)

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 10 Jan 17 7.41pm

You're all wasting your time. None of the pro-strike supporters on here (a couple of whom tell us they know loads about trains and driving them and southern and unions etc but sweet fa about the effect on the travelling public of the action of their heroes as, by their own admission don't commute) will never admit the union might be even slightly wrong.
Look, if it really is about safety - I'd support an all out strike until it's sorted. Safety surely isn't part time. If it's that bad a total walk out until the issues are rectified is the only way to deal with it.

 

Part Time James Flag 10 Jan 17 7.53pm

Today is the first time I've had to commute North from where I live rather than South and I have to admit that I actually wasn't aware quite how bad it was. I cannot believe how unsafe that journey is while the strike is going on.

If this is all about safety then Watership Down was all about cows.

 




Helmet46 Flag Croydon 10 Jan 17 8.12pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Today is the first time I've had to commute North from where I live rather than South and I have to admit that I actually wasn't aware quite how bad it was. I cannot believe how unsafe that journey is while the strike is going on.

If this is all about safety then Watership Down was all about cows.

You want to see it during the RMT strike and overtime ban. It's ok to compromise safety in a strike about safety when you strike. Like I say, if they went all out until it was resolved safety wouldn't be risked.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Jan 17 8.17pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Today is the first time I've had to commute North from where I live rather than South and I have to admit that I actually wasn't aware quite how bad it was. I cannot believe how unsafe that journey is while the strike is going on.

If this is all about safety then Watership Down was all about cows.

Why then did drivers refuse a pay off to return to work?

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 10 Jan 17 8.41pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Why then did drivers refuse a pay off to return to work?


Wasn't that the Conductors? Like I say, if it was all about safety they'd be all out as they wouldn't want to compromise their obvious principles by making things unsafe when they're on strike.

Edited by Helmet46 (10 Jan 2017 8.48pm)

 

Part Time James Flag 10 Jan 17 8.56pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

You want to see it during the RMT strike and overtime ban. It's ok to compromise safety in a strike about safety when you strike. Like I say, if they went all out until it was resolved safety wouldn't be risked.

Well there was an RMT strike and an ASLEF strike today.

 




Helmet46 Flag Croydon 10 Jan 17 9.11pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Well there was an RMT strike and an ASLEF strike today.

So there were more or less no trains today and loads of people worked from home.
When it's just RMT and overtime ban (so every other day) the trains run but there are a lot less, they go to different stations, tend to be shorter (so Southern put fewer carriages on as they think they can get away with blaming the staff for that, I suspect) and a full commute. The net effect is massive overcrowding on both platforms and trains - so an awful lot more danger.
Ironically I arrived at Upper Warlingham on Friday and our 'guard' just stuck his head out of the cab window where the train joined, looked up and down and that was it. Phew, thank goodness for that. I felt a lot safer after seeing that.

 

Part Time James Flag 10 Jan 17 9.27pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

So there were more or less no trains today and loads of people worked from home.
When it's just RMT and overtime ban (so every other day) the trains run but there are a lot less, they go to different stations, tend to be shorter (so Southern put fewer carriages on as they think they can get away with blaming the staff for that, I suspect) and a full commute. The net effect is massive overcrowding on both platforms and trains - so an awful lot more danger.
Ironically I arrived at Upper Warlingham on Friday and our 'guard' just stuck his head out of the cab window where the train joined, looked up and down and that was it. Phew, thank goodness for that. I felt a lot safer after seeing that.


There was about a 50% reduction in train service I believe and the trains were rammed. I'm not sure what could be more dangerous, I saw several people almost get trapped in the closing doors. I was pinned between two men who were both pushing against each other and subsequently squashing me between them. My face was so buried in the coat hood of one of the guys I couldn't breath for a while. I dunno, it felt pretty unsafe.

 




Part Time James Flag 10 Jan 17 9.30pm

Although I don't know why we need to argue about who has been on the more dangerous train! Just saying the Thameslink trains today didn't indicate to me that anyone had chose to work from home. I've never been so crushed before that I was barely able to breathe that's all. About a third of the people on the platform weren't even allowed to get on our train due to the overcrowding.

 




Page 40 of 44 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong