You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 40 of 91 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Nov 19 4.20pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

PL or Championship I’ll still be a Palace supporter, but I’ve had enough of watching the dross we see currently. It’s boring, predictable and does not entertain. I find myself watching only because I’m hoping for something different to happen, but it’s like Groundhog Day, nothing changes.

I can’t understand the love in some have for Roy, he has players within the club that could change a game, but hardly picks them for the bench let alone the team. He just doesn’t trust youth or anyone that isn’t defensively minded. That for me is a massive downside to his managerial style.

I’d rather lose 4-2 against the top teams giving it a go than 2-0, at least we would see some action in the opposition half. It is 5 times already this season we have failed to score in the league and no-one can say that is a decent stat.

I agree with your first paragraph. After 52 years of going to games, it's hard to work up much enthusiasm at the moment.

As for Roy, he's doing more good than harm but it's the methodology that is a struggle. I think there's a perception that there is ' another ' AWB just waiting for a chance but from what I've seen, there just isn't. Of the so called flair players, Meyer hasn't done enough to justify a regular start and Camarasa looks like a cheap gamble that hasn't worked out. Yes, we need a creative midfield player but they need to be more proven and dare I say it, more expensive than those two.

I'll continue supporting the club and will renew my season ticket again, but if Bromley get promoted to the Football League then I'm tempted to take a year out and follow them.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Nov 19 4.28pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I agree with your first paragraph. After 52 years of going to games, it's hard to work up much enthusiasm at the moment.

As for Roy, he's doing more good than harm but it's the methodology that is a struggle. I think there's a perception that there is ' another ' AWB just waiting for a chance but from what I've seen, there just isn't. Of the so called flair players, Meyer hasn't done enough to justify a regular start and Camarasa looks like a cheap gamble that hasn't worked out. Yes, we need a creative midfield player but they need to be more proven and dare I say it, more expensive than those two.

I'll continue supporting the club and will renew my season ticket again, but if Bromley get promoted to the Football League then I'm tempted to take a year out and follow them.

Fair points, but I see it slightly differently. Meyer, Camarasa, Lokilo and the other youngsters just can’t pay the defensive game Roy wants them to and that is the reason they are not picked. They are good enough players, just not for Roy’s tactics.

 

est1905 Flag 11 Nov 19 5.46pm

Originally posted by Beastie

This post has been merged from a topic called 'So jealous of many teams right now' by Midlands Eagle

Weird way to look at things. We formed relatively late, in 1905. Doesn’t seem fair that we’re above scores of teams who went before us.

Every club has ups and down. The weird thing is we’re virtually at our peak as a club but so many of our fans seem to think we’re entitled to more.

Remember Charlton and Curbishley?
Be very very careful what you wish for.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Nov 19 5.54pm

Originally posted by est1905

Remember Charlton and Curbishley?
Be very very careful what you wish for.

Curbishley was at the 'Valley' at Charlton's last home game, against Preston, and was sitting alongside Keith Peacock who was his assistant at the club.

Curbishley signed Dean Kiely, our current goalkeeping coach, for Charlton from Bury.

 

est1905 Flag 11 Nov 19 5.55pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

PL or Championship I’ll still be a Palace supporter, but I’ve had enough of watching the dross we see currently. It’s boring, predictable and does not entertain. I find myself watching only because I’m hoping for something different to happen, but it’s like Groundhog Day, nothing changes.

I can’t understand the love in some have for Roy, he has players within the club that could change a game, but hardly picks them for the bench let alone the team. He just doesn’t trust youth or anyone that isn’t defensively minded. That for me is a massive downside to his managerial style.

I’d rather lose 4-2 against the top teams giving it a go than 2-0, at least we would see some action in the opposition half. It is 5 times already this season we have failed to score in the league and no-one can say that is a decent stat.

Utter nonsense, it was Roy that notice AWB and trusted he was good enough to throw in at the deep end.
There are some true morons on here that seem to think our youth players are all world beaters. News flash, they are not. We (as with many Prem clubs) have some promising youngsters with big potential. This is the Premiership where every point is precious. Roy cannot afford to risk Palace's place in the division as well as his own job/reputation on potential. We simply cannot to take the gamble and it wouldn't be fair to put that kind of pressure upon a youngster unless the coaching staff are 100% certain he is ready either.
Sure, Once we gain mathematical safety and are no longer chasing league position, other possible outcomes fine, throw in a couple of youngsters and see how they do.
Not exactly covered themselves in glory every time they have been given a chance in the cups though have they?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Nov 19 6.02pm

Originally posted by est1905

Utter nonsense, it was Roy that notice AWB and trusted he was good enough to throw in at the deep end.
There are some true morons on here that seem to think our youth players are all world beaters. News flash, they are not. We (as with many Prem clubs) have some promising youngsters with big potential. This is the Premiership where every point is precious. Roy cannot afford to risk Palace's place in the division as well as his own job/reputation on potential. We simply cannot to take the gamble and it wouldn't be fair to put that kind of pressure upon a youngster unless the coaching staff are 100% certain he is ready either.
Sure, Once we gain mathematical safety and are no longer chasing league position, other possible outcomes fine, throw in a couple of youngsters and see how they do.
Not exactly covered themselves in glory every time they have been given a chance in the cups though have they?

If you want to meet up to discuss calling me a moron to my face I’ll gladly oblige. Keep your offensive responses to yourself. You don’t know everything. For a start it was Ward’s injury that forced Roy to play AWB even though he had been pulling up trees in training for months.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Nov 19 6.06pm

Originally posted by est1905

Utter nonsense, it was Roy that notice AWB and trusted he was good enough to throw in at the deep end.
There are some true morons on here that seem to think our youth players are all world beaters. News flash, they are not. We (as with many Prem clubs) have some promising youngsters with big potential. This is the Premiership where every point is precious. Roy cannot afford to risk Palace's place in the division as well as his own job/reputation on potential. We simply cannot to take the gamble and it wouldn't be fair to put that kind of pressure upon a youngster unless the coaching staff are 100% certain he is ready either.
Sure, Once we gain mathematical safety and are no longer chasing league position, other possible outcomes fine, throw in a couple of youngsters and see how they do.
Not exactly covered themselves in glory every time they have been given a chance in the cups though have they?

The 'Mood music' is that there aren't a plethora of youngsters putting pressure on the first team squad and in our current position,Hodgson does not have the luxury of giving them a runout in the team in the PL.

Hodgson's sole objective is to avoid relegation and he has used his vast experience to formulate a 'Plan A' based on the players at his disposal.Not an easy watch at all but if we survive there won't be too many complaints.

Just to add that with Hodgson at the helm and a lack of more inventive signings the 'Plan A' will continue if it has ensured we remain in the PL.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 11 Nov 19 6.54pm

Originally posted by est1905

Remember Charlton and Curbishley?
Be very very careful what you wish for.

Bet you get shouted down over that.
However , you are right.
One of my best mates is charltonista.
Refuses to talk about 'curbs' as he calls him.
Has let slip about what a bunch of self entitled w***ers a lot of their support became.
Also curbishley did not take them to the next level. Which was down.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 11 Nov 19 6.59pm

Just out of interest which lower to mid table clubs have gone on to the mythical next level.
2. Chelski and Man Citeh. Wonder what they have in common.?
Leicester are giving it a go but not fully established in the upper echelons yet.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Nov 19 7.31pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Just out of interest which lower to mid table clubs have gone on to the mythical next level.
2. Chelski and Man Citeh. Wonder what they have in common.?
Leicester are giving it a go but not fully established in the upper echelons yet.

Also consider the amount of money that West Ham and Everton have spent trying to get to that mythical next level....how's that working out ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Nov 19 7.39pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Also consider the amount of money that West Ham and Everton have spent trying to get to that mythical next level....how's that working out ?

Excellent point. Leicester are the exception to the rule the other mid lower table clubs may spend a fortune and will only improve to hovering around the top 5/6 if they are lucky.

 


One more point

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 11 Nov 19 8.45pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Excellent point. Leicester are the exception to the rule the other mid lower table clubs may spend a fortune and will only improve to hovering around the top 5/6 if they are lucky.

Leicester couldn't prevent a very good defender from being excited to leave ..privileged could be Leicesters reward but they have no say in it.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Nov 19 8.52pm

Originally posted by est1905

Utter nonsense, it was Roy that notice AWB and trusted he was good enough to throw in at the deep end.
There are some true morons on here that seem to think our youth players are all world beaters. News flash, they are not. We (as with many Prem clubs) have some promising youngsters with big potential. This is the Premiership where every point is precious. Roy cannot afford to risk Palace's place in the division as well as his own job/reputation on potential. We simply cannot to take the gamble and it wouldn't be fair to put that kind of pressure upon a youngster unless the coaching staff are 100% certain he is ready either.
Sure, Once we gain mathematical safety and are no longer chasing league position, other possible outcomes fine, throw in a couple of youngsters and see how they do.
Not exactly covered themselves in glory every time they have been given a chance in the cups though have they?

When I'm Roy's age (if I'm lucky) I wont give a monkeys about a job or reputation.
If he can play a different system for say 4 or 5 games and it goes south then us 'morons' will shut up and accept we need to be defensive and boring.
At the end of last season we played attacking football. Ok so we were safe but our opponents wernt totally and we didnt get gubbed.
It's different games against different teams.
Top 6-8 yes defensive.
Bottom 6-8 get into them.
Middle teams change midway as and how the game is playing out.
I dont expect it to be like city or the bin dippers but a bit of excitement for my 1k a year would be nice.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 11 Nov 19 9.13pm

for me...the salient point here whatever your POV is that first & foremost the target for everybody involved in the club is to stay in this league year on year...that will be the blueprint in which the seasons plan is built on.

if we fail to do that...we could very easily be financially f***ed.

i also assume roy gets a extra million quid or so at the end of the season for achieving this...that alone for me would be enough to be pragmatic until a point we know were not getting sucked into trouble.

it is not unconceivable to think we could have 30 points by new years day...i would assume then maybe we could afford to play with a bit more freedom, im sure that would appease some of the more critical of posters on this forum.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Nov 19 9.19pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

for me...the salient point here whatever your POV is that first & foremost the target for everybody involved in the club is to stay in this league year on year...that will be the blueprint in which the seasons plan is built on.

if we fail to do that...we could very easily be financially f***ed.

i also assume roy gets a extra million quid or so at the end of the season for achieving this...that alone for me would be enough to be pragmatic until a point we know were not getting sucked into trouble.

it is not unconceivable to think we could have 30 points by new years day...i would assume then maybe we could afford to play with a bit more freedom, im sure that would appease some of the more critical of posters on this forum.

You could try this earlier and go back defensive with a big finger in the air to all of us who were wrong if we get trashed.
For all roy knows the team may even surprise him.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 11 Nov 19 9.30pm

Originally posted by cryrst

You could try this earlier and go back defensive with a big finger in the air to all of us who were wrong if we get trashed.
For all roy knows the team may even surprise him.

yeah we tried that before & it cost pardew his job after doing a solid job...then we had to swallow fireman sam being in charge of the club as a result.

its very easy to have these ideas of grandeur when were not the ones charged with ensuring the beanstalk keeps producing magic beans.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


The Dolphin Flag 12 Nov 19 9.08am

Pardew's football was kamikaze.
If he had done his job properly and been sensible he might even still be in charge!
Allardyce and Pulis did what it said on the tin but it was more exciting and passionate than what we have to watch now!
I agree with the Charlton - " be careful what you wish for" - but we have to change sometime.
We have made some monumentally bad signings and paid them silly wages because we felt we had to when we didn't and so we are tied into yet another few years of seeing them off our books - unless of course your name is "sicknote" Wickham or "Barn door Benteke" in which case you get a new contract for doing nothing at all!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Nov 19 9.13am

Originally posted by cryrst

You could try this earlier and go back defensive with a big finger in the air to all of us who were wrong if we get trashed.
For all roy knows the team may even surprise him.

How exactly are we going to keep possession in attack when we fans let alone the opposition know we cannot complete enough passes to sustain attacks for any length of time, our players collectively are not able to do this and I'm pretty sure deep down you know this too, it's just frustration ..we are where we are at this moment and we have to accept it.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 12 Nov 19 9.17am

They keep lumbering Roy with players he doesnt want so Roy in turn refuses to pick them. I think he wanted Kouyate Ayew Cahill McCarthy and Guaita but none of the rest

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Nov 19 9.19am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Pardew's football was kamikaze.
If he had done his job properly and been sensible he might even still be in charge!
Allardyce and Pulis did what it said on the tin but it was more exciting and passionate than what we have to watch now!
I agree with the Charlton - " be careful what you wish for" - but we have to change sometime.
We have made some monumentally bad signings and paid them silly wages because we felt we had to when we didn't and so we are tied into yet another few years of seeing them off our books - unless of course your name is "sicknote" Wickham or "Barn door Benteke" in which case you get a new contract for doing nothing at all!

Pardew was extremely entertaining but it wasn't always for our pleasure, fans are saying that Hodgson should be doing the same with the same ability of players, it'll end exactly the same very entertaining but not just for us, solid is the key word and Pardew was a disaster with being solid, his biggest and most stupid mistake was not playing Murray when he was fit after his horror injury and for that alone his should have been shot.

 

Page 40 of 91 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread