This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I think it is a stretch to brand millions of people as far right loons because a few thousand are. You see this is where you and me differ I think it is a stretch to stereotypically brand any set of people or community by a sub set of that people/community. I think stereotyping requires people to judge the many by the actions of the few, you hint at the black community has having a disproportionate propensity for knife crime and yes the news does report the perpetrators as black but what actual percentage of the community is that do you know? How many are repeat offenders do you also know that, so the point I'm making it could be any percentage. You say "it is a stretch to brand millions of people as far right loons because a few thousand are" but would that be a comparable percentage between the members of the black the community committing knife crime and the thousands far right loons in comparison to the millions. Until you know those facts you can't seemingly support one stereotype and defend another.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
You see this is where you and me differ I think it is a stretch to stereotypically brand any set of people or community by a sub set of that people/community. I think stereotyping requires people to judge the many by the actions of the few, you hint at the black community has having a disproportionate propensity for knife crime and yes the news does report the perpetrators as black but what actual percentage of the community is that do you know? How many are repeat offenders do you also know that, so the point I'm making it could be any percentage. You say "it is a stretch to brand millions of people as far right loons because a few thousand are" but would that be a comparable percentage between the members of the black the community committing knife crime and the thousands far right loons in comparison to the millions. Until you know those facts you can't seemingly support one stereotype and defend another. I get that but let's break it down farther.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I get that but let's break it down farther. If you get it why on earth did you ask me that question, are you being a little ironic (seeing as that is the word of the day. Ok I'll explain it in simple terms if the membership of white supremacy groups is of 'White' ethnicity and assuming you are the same ethnicity, is it fair to stereotype you as a white supremacist?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
You see this is where you and me differ I think it is a stretch to stereotypically brand any set of people or community by a sub set of that people/community. I think stereotyping requires people to judge the many by the actions of the few, you hint at the black community has having a disproportionate propensity for knife crime and yes the news does report the perpetrators as black but what actual percentage of the community is that do you know? How many are repeat offenders do you also know that, so the point I'm making it could be any percentage. You say "it is a stretch to brand millions of people as far right loons because a few thousand are" but would that be a comparable percentage between the members of the black the community committing knife crime and the thousands far right loons in comparison to the millions. Until you know those facts you can't seemingly support one stereotype and defend another.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
If you get it why on earth did you ask me that question, are you being a little ironic (seeing as that is the word of the day. Ok I'll explain it in simple terms if the membership of white supremacy groups is of 'White' ethnicity and assuming you are the same ethnicity, is it fair to stereotype you as a white supremacist? Wouldnt bother me as I'm not!
|
|
|
My omments in bold Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Ok, I urge all who read this to watch that video and especially the parts where the working class are shown. At that point you can make the decision for yourself of the footage and whether this poster is a liar or at the very least can be said to be a reliable reporter of an event. You appear to be incapable of determining the difference between an opinion and a lie. It seems you believe as your opinions always equal the truth, others are lies. The point being made by my comments was not intended to be a frame by frame analysis of the various scenes but a rebuttal of the idea that our ancestors lived in a homogeneous society when the truth is that it was every bit as stratified as ours is today. The problem here is I have no respect for you. While it's obvious that you are intelligent I regard you as ethically immoral. While we have considerable political differences this is in principle due to your support of the Police during the rape scandals.It isn't helped by your pin dancing, elitist near worship and...to my mind at least regular misleading statements to suit whatever position you wish to take. However, these latter reasons are dwarfed by the former.As for how I describe you or what I say here, while I will consider reasonable requests (ie back up claims of lying) that's about it. OMG we are back to this as again as the justification for your abhorrent attitude. I refuse to explain again why you are wrong. Frankly spoken if that is truly what lies behind your words I suggest you seek some help. I have tried, very patiently and without rancour, to do so, and others have too but it appears not to penetrate. To describe someone you have never met as "ethically immoral" is really very insulting, especially as it's completely untrue. I consider this a lie. The evidence is that I've never read anything from you that can be said to be socially conservative. I have little doubt that you care about your fiscal situation and that anything remotely connected to your wealth is strictly conservative. However, that's no different to the far left running Google or Facebook. Tell us, where do you differ from the far left on any social policies? I am not a social conservative and have never claimed to be. I am fiscally conservative and socially liberal. I am very much in the middle of UK politics and have admiration for politicians from both major parties. I admired Macmillan, Heath, Heseltine, Clarke and Cameron (until Brexit) and not Powell or Thatcher. I admired Blair and thought Corbyn awful. The "far-left" don't run Google or Facebook. What a ridiculous assertion. That you even might think that to be true just shows how distorted your thinking is. They certainly don't pander to the right, but that just means they are behaving responsibly. Where do I differ to the "far-left"? How about in everything! I don't believe in the public ownership of all state assets. Only those where the national interest dictates it or where the roles are more efficiently done collectively. I believe in rewarding enterprise, innovation and hard work and not in protecting the lazy. I could go on. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2021 2.47pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Ok but if it's going to be a fair comparison what percentage of the total 3% actually commit those crimes?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Wouldnt bother me as I'm not! I didn't ask you if it bothered you I asked if it would be fair. All black kids or just the ones who carry them?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
Ok but if it's going to be a fair comparison what percentage of the total 3% actually commit those crimes?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
So you don't know the answer? If not are you are basing your stereotype on an opinion?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
So you don't know the answer? If not are you are basing your stereotype on an opinion? Obviously not as it's a statistically based. All that is required is to compare it to other groups. The percentage of a percentage is irreverent in that regard. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2021 4.25pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Obviously not as it's a statistically based. All that is required is to compare it to other groups. The percentage of a percentage is irreverent in that regard. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2021 4.25pm) I think you need to make up your mind if its a statically based opinion the percentage of 3% is 100% of the black community so the percentage of a percentage is completely relevant. So which part of your logic above is true?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
I think you need to make up your mind if its a statically based opinion the percentage of 3% is 100% of the black community so the percentage of a percentage is completely relevant. So which part of your logic above is true? Make up my mind? What I stated was clear. The percentage of the percentage is only relevant in comparison to other groups. However, when it comes to violence I can safely predict....using stereotype that blacks will top that list. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2021 4.40pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
I didn't ask you if it bothered you I asked if it would be fair. All black kids or just the ones who carry them? Yes it's fair in your world I suppose, but you are black and I'm white. None of my friends carry knives, do any of yours?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Make up my mind? What I stated was clear. The percentage of the percentage is only relevant in comparison to other groups. However, when it comes to violence I can safely predict....using stereotype that blacks will top that list. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2021 4.40pm) So you jumped in answering a question for another poster not realising the point I was making was a general one comparing two groups? Best leave to the question for him to answer then. But just to be clear what you stated was contradictory especially as you didn't know what you were answering.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
So you jumped in answering a question for another poster not realising the point I was making was a general one comparing two groups? Best leave to the question for him to answer then. But just to be clear what you stated was contradictory especially as you didn't know what you were answering.
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger Surely it's more about so much crime being committed by members of such a small demographic. The disproportion is enormous and impossible to excuse away. If it was such a small proportion of that 3% then we could solve most violent crime by locking up a few dozen people. Belmont replied So you don't know the answer? If not are you are basing your stereotype on an opinion? I regard your responses as an attempt to deflect and little else. You know that all the statistics are against you and hence you want to obfuscate. However, if you don't want my input, fair enough, I'll drop out. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2021 4.57pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
So you jumped in answering a question for another poster not realising the point I was making was a general one comparing two groups? Best leave to the question for him to answer then. But just to be clear what you stated was contradictory especially as you didn't know what you were answering. Google the facts; met police perpetrators of knife crime since 2008. A freedom of information request has been answered. You dont want the truth but it's there in print. 50% more blacks than whites knicked for knife crime in london. Total knife crime in the uk was 38% black people but 65% in london.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Google the facts; met police perpetrators of knife crime since 2008. A freedom of information request has been answered. You dont want the truth but it's there in print. 50% more blacks than whites knicked for knife crime in london. Total knife crime in the uk was 38% black people but 65% in london.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger Surely it's more about so much crime being committed by members of such a small demographic. The disproportion is enormous and impossible to excuse away. If it was such a small proportion of that 3% then we could solve most violent crime by locking up a few dozen people. Belmont replied So you don't know the answer? If not are you are basing your stereotype on an opinion? I regard your responses as an attempt to deflect and little else. You know that all the statistics are against you and hence you want to obfuscate. However, if you don't want my input, fair enough, I'll drop out. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2021 4.57pm) I really don't have time to draw you a picture but can I suggest you read from when I first posted today gbut to help you out: Hrolf wrote this "I understand your logic but would argue that when members of a demographic which makes up only 3% of a population commits 80% of total violent crime, that would not have equivalence with 0.0001 percent of the White population being members of far right wing groups." I wrote this "Ok but if it's going to be a fair comparison what percentage of the total 3% actually commit those crimes?" I really don't know what you think you were answering but it wasn't any point I was making.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.