You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 42 of 44 < 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >
steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 12 Jan 17 4.47am

Originally posted by 7mins

Train drivers earn 50k+
But that has nothing to do with this dispute, ASLEF have always been against losing guards on southern/South Central/Connex. Even when we had a labour government.

Train drivers are highly trained, and in demand... this means their wages reflect this.

For a TOC to cancel a peak time train on a busy commuter route, can cost over 10k. A driver can earn his company the equivalent of his yearly salary in one day.

The money quoted earlier was what has been advertised on their website for new drivers, you'd think one the managers would have told you before releasing the job advert.

[Link]

Edited by steph_eagle (12 Jan 2017 4.51am)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 12 Jan 17 5.52am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Exactly. If they were that bothered about safety, they'd down tools and not return until the matter was resolved.

This point gets ignored by pro-strike / pro-union posters.
I mean they're on pretty good salaries and it would force the issue and also really demonstrate that their obvious principles are absolutely clear and non negotiable with regards to safety. However making it a lot more unsafe on strike days and knowingly increasing the burden and prosecution risk for their Thameslink colleagues smacks of a slight touch of hypocrisy to me.

Edited by Helmet46 (12 Jan 2017 6.29am)

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 12 Jan 17 9.32am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Oh that's it the must be true!! If you read this thread drivers are in the top 10% of earners in this country so a few days strike will not break the bank. I have been a Union member for over 40 years so please don't call me mad

You asked if there was any evidence. There is. You don't have to believe the evidence (as I intimated, I don't fully believe it), but it exists.

I stand by what I said, the idea that losing half a month's pay doesn't hurt someone is farcical. They might be voting to strike for reasons other than safety, but they aren't going to be going on prolonged personally costly strikes just to give the government a bloody nose.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Only 10 a year!! Flag 12 Jan 17 10.14am

Originally posted by OknotOK

You asked if there was any evidence. There is. You don't have to believe the evidence (as I intimated, I don't fully believe it), but it exists.

I stand by what I said, the idea that losing half a month's pay doesn't hurt someone is farcical. They might be voting to strike for reasons other than safety, but they aren't going to be going on prolonged personally costly strikes just to give the government a bloody nose.


Edited! I promised myself I would not be dragged back into this cyclical debate.

Edited by Only 10 a year!! (12 Jan 2017 10.14am)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Jan 17 11.13am

[Link]

Interesting release from the RMT.

RMT General Secretary Mick Cash said;
“As with the Southern contract, the government is inserting clauses into new franchise agreements which will mean the tax payer will bankroll Teresa May’s war on the unions.

“It is absolutely scandalous that the public purse will be footing the bill for any industrial action taken against private rail companies. We also now know that that at the same time rail bosses are going to make over £1 billion implementing the government’s policy of getting rid of guards.

“It is clear that the Southern and other disputes are nothing to do with modernising our railway and everything to do with old fashioned union busting and cost cutting.”

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 12 Jan 17 12.37pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

[Link]

Interesting release from the RMT.

RMT General Secretary Mick Cash said;
“As with the Southern contract, the government is inserting clauses into new franchise agreements which will mean the tax payer will bankroll Teresa May’s war on the unions.

“It is absolutely scandalous that the public purse will be footing the bill for any industrial action taken against private rail companies. We also now know that that at the same time rail bosses are going to make over £1 billion implementing the government’s policy of getting rid of guards.

“It is clear that the Southern and other disputes are nothing to do with modernising our railway and everything to do with old fashioned union busting and cost cutting.”

Its pretty scandalous that the Helmet46 purse is being used to foot the bill for my increased costs in ensuring that I don't lose my job because of strike action.(Hotels, Taxis etc). Might send an expenses claim to the RMT and Aslef.
I may actually cost the public purse more as when I lose my job, because of Southern and the Unions, I will claim benefits (which the free legal advise given by my union membership should help me secure). Everyones a winner. (Oh, except the commuter who is even more unsafe than ever before, in this strike about safety. Oh and the taxpayer. Oh and the country as its costing a bomb. Oh and a lot of Companies as they can't trade without employees).

 

7mins Flag In the bush 12 Jan 17 12.41pm

Originally posted by steph_eagle

The money quoted earlier was what has been advertised on their website for new drivers, you'd think one the managers would have told you before releasing the job advert.

[Link]

Edited by steph_eagle (12 Jan 2017 4.51am)

Drivers earn 46k for first year, then after a years service it jumps to 49k a year, plus they get paid extra for working Sundays, they're contracted to do 17 a year. Thus pushing their salary over 50k.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Jan 17 1.09pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Its pretty scandalous that the Helmet46 purse is being used to foot the bill for my increased costs in ensuring that I don't lose my job because of strike action.(Hotels, Taxis etc). Might send an expenses claim to the RMT and Aslef.
I may actually cost the public purse more as when I lose my job, because of Southern and the Unions, I will claim benefits (which the free legal advise given by my union membership should help me secure). Everyones a winner. (Oh, except the commuter who is even more unsafe than ever before, in this strike about safety. Oh and the taxpayer. Oh and the country as its costing a bomb. Oh and a lot of Companies as they can't trade without employees).


Did you read the rest of the link?

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 12 Jan 17 1.17pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

[Link]

Interesting release from the RMT.

RMT General Secretary Mick Cash said;
“As with the Southern contract, the government is inserting clauses into new franchise agreements which will mean the tax payer will bankroll Teresa May’s war on the unions.

“It is absolutely scandalous that the public purse will be footing the bill for any industrial action taken against private rail companies. We also now know that that at the same time rail bosses are going to make over £1 billion implementing the government’s policy of getting rid of guards.

“It is clear that the Southern and other disputes are nothing to do with modernising our railway and everything to do with old fashioned union busting and cost cutting.”

***Yawn*** that old chestnut? Sing a new tune will you?

 


Pro USA & Israel

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 12 Jan 17 2.32pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


Did you read the rest of the link?

Nope - all the links posted get really dull, boring and one sided so assumed you would have picked out the bits that suited your position on this nonsense.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Jan 17 4.14pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Nope - all the links posted get really dull, boring and one sided so assumed you would have picked out the bits that suited your position on this nonsense.

It gets to the nitty gritty of what Cash said.

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 12 Jan 17 5.26pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

It gets to the nitty gritty of what Cash said.

Thought you said it wasn't about cash

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Jan 17 5.53pm

Originally posted by mezzer

Thought you said it wasn't about cash

Hehe
I used to think Johnny Cash was money for condoms.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 12 Jan 17 6.38pm

I havnt read through this thread but would just say the transport system is a public service and as such should never be disrupted by strikes . Contracts for the franchise and employees should be watertight and upheld by both sides .

 

7mins Flag In the bush 12 Jan 17 11.42pm

Originally posted by Elpis

I havnt read through this thread but would just say the transport system is a public service and as such should never be disrupted by strikes . Contracts for the franchise and employees should be watertight and upheld by both sides .

Southern signed a agreement with ASLEF to consult them on any extension of DOO... they imposed it without consultation...in fact they actively hid their intentions when they met with union reps when they won the current franchise.

So you're 100% right, if the agreements in place were honoured... there would be no strikes.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 21 Jan 17 7.55am

If memory serves,when I lived in Streatham in the 1990s the trains I rode were DOO(Streatham/Selhurst & Streatham Hill/Norwood Junction). Of course, it was still BR/NSE.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

7mins Flag In the bush 05 Feb 17 3.28am

Just read the deal struck between ASLEF and Southern. It's the same deal offered 3 months ago. 2nd person rostered on all trains with safety critical training. Driver controls dispatch with OBS assisting during times of degraded working. It seems Southern wanted to see how strong the strike was before conceding.
They've agreed to...
*Safety critical training for OBS
*Rostering a OBS on all trains that previously had a guard (good news for wheelchair users/blind/assisted travel)
*platform dispatch at certain locations
*improved cctv (Southern have been aware of poor quality cctv since introduction off class 377, but HD cctv is mega expensive)
* OBS's to help with dispatch during degraded working.
* ASLEF have also secured a commitment from Southern to employ more drivers (Southern won't be happy at that at all... they have always had a policy of getting as much from as little drivers as possible). Also ASLEF have made Southern agree to employing new staff on permanent contracts and not agency or zero hour contracts.


The only sticking points I see are... the "exceptional circumstances" clauses... this relies on drivers trusting Southern... when I was there... there was no trust at all (can't blame them, we did get caught telling porkies twice)

Also Southern are going to rewrite DRI... this is the drivers employment contract, it will probably be the same as other TOC's That GTR own... this means they will have to pay Southern drivers parity with Thameslink/South Eastern.

Also Southern have been using industrial action as a excuse for their poor performance... they've also over played the "unofficial industrial action" in truth, there was none... now the industrial action is over... they will be in massive trouble if the service continues to be piss poor. They now need drivers (who they have thoroughly pissed off and lied to) to give up their days off... Southern management are s***ting themselves... I expect they will negotiate a short term financial inducement for drivers to work rest days... this will be temporary... we did it in 2005 when we were so poor we nearly lost franchise.

If drivers really wanted rid of Southern.... they could not work their days off.... Southern would be gone in months. As it stands... they have 70% of drivers needed.... with annual leave and sickness... it could be closer to 65%..... Southern are now fighting for their lives to keep franchise with no excuses to hid behind.... and relying on goodwill from staff they have pissed off.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 05 Feb 17 7.07am

Originally posted by 7mins

Just read the deal struck between ASLEF and Southern. It's the same deal offered 3 months ago. 2nd person rostered on all trains with safety critical training. Driver controls dispatch with OBS assisting during times of degraded working. It seems Southern wanted to see how strong the strike was before conceding.
They've agreed to...
*Safety critical training for OBS
*Rostering a OBS on all trains that previously had a guard (good news for wheelchair users/blind/assisted travel)
*platform dispatch at certain locations
*improved cctv (Southern have been aware of poor quality cctv since introduction off class 377, but HD cctv is mega expensive)
* OBS's to help with dispatch during degraded working.
* ASLEF have also secured a commitment from Southern to employ more drivers (Southern won't be happy at that at all... they have always had a policy of getting as much from as little drivers as possible). Also ASLEF have made Southern agree to employing new staff on permanent contracts and not agency or zero hour contracts.


The only sticking points I see are... the "exceptional circumstances" clauses... this relies on drivers trusting Southern... when I was there... there was no trust at all (can't blame them, we did get caught telling porkies twice)

Also Southern are going to rewrite DRI... this is the drivers employment contract, it will probably be the same as other TOC's That GTR own... this means they will have to pay Southern drivers parity with Thameslink/South Eastern.

Also Southern have been using industrial action as a excuse for their poor performance... they've also over played the "unofficial industrial action" in truth, there was none... now the industrial action is over... they will be in massive trouble if the service continues to be piss poor. They now need drivers (who they have thoroughly pissed off and lied to) to give up their days off... Southern management are s***ting themselves... I expect they will negotiate a short term financial inducement for drivers to work rest days... this will be temporary... we did it in 2005 when we were so poor we nearly lost franchise.

If drivers really wanted rid of Southern.... they could not work their days off.... Southern would be gone in months. As it stands... they have 70% of drivers needed.... with annual leave and sickness... it could be closer to 65%..... Southern are now fighting for their lives to keep franchise with no excuses to hid behind.... and relying on goodwill from staff they have pissed off.

Why did ASLEF cut a deal without including the RMT?

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

7mins Flag In the bush 05 Feb 17 9.57am

Ask TUC. They chaired the meetings.

At a guess, I would say they had different agendas. If they had the same, then it would make sense to jointly discuss the deal. I can't see RMT worrying about the driver indemnity insurance stuff

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 05 Feb 17 10.16am

Originally posted by 7mins

Ask TUC. They chaired the meetings.

At a guess, I would say they had different agendas. If they had the same, then it would make sense to jointly discuss the deal. I can't see RMT worrying about the driver indemnity insurance stuff

It appears from the outside that Southern has divided and conquered.

Not knowing the negotiations, but from what I have read, it appears that the RMT is bitter about ASLEF agreeing a deal on their own.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Page 42 of 44 < 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong