You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 42 of 65 < 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 >
Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Apr 19 9.50am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

How many penalties have we scored this season? It feels like 80% of our goals at home are penalties. Is Luca top goal scorer?

He is, as he was last season. I think he’s scored more than anybody else since he signed for us.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Apr 19 10.20am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Very good ME, there can be no practical argument against what you say here. I would add to that by looking at the way the top 2 teams in the country currently play. High pressing, fast flowing football that relies on quick interplay between a flexible attack who can slot into each other’s positions. We unfortunately are a one trick pony insofar as we sit in a rigid formation that sinks deeper and deeper as we get under more and more pressure with the occasional relief of a counter attack where we look to try and nick a goal.

Roy without doubt has a system that works to get you a certain amount of points per season, but it is not forward thinking and is not entertaining. I believe we have good enough players to play in a more expansive manner and that’s where I 100% agree that if we want to improve as a team then we need a different approach and ultimately that means a different manager.

I don’t agree with the argument that we have tried this already with Pardew and FdeB, they were just the wrong people for the job. The former had no idea about defending and the latter, well, absolutely no idea about football at all based on his latest managerial history. If we can find a manager that can combine the defensive organisation of Roy with the forward play of Pardew then we will I believe progress to a different level. As Maine Eagle has pointed out, we are currently stifling the talent that we have and it isn’t pretty to watch.

The next managerial appointment is massive for Palace not only to improve us but to show the talented individuals within our squad that we want to play to their strengths. Over to you SP, it’s not going to be easy but the next appointment is critical and it has to come this summer.

Of course there is a practical argument.

And it's based around people having an inflated view of the abilities of the squad and the merits or otherwise of Max Meyer, and the way they are managed.

You use the top 2 clubs as a comparison to the way Palace play. Are you being realistic in doing so ? The Premier League has become a League within a League. Take a look at the table and the gap between the those top 2 and then the next 4 clubs. Then look at the gap between 6th and 7th place. The top 2 have the resources and players available that make their systems work for them.

Like it or not, the Pardew and FDB argument is relative to this discussion. Those appointments were both made with the intention of changing the style of football. Pardew had limited success and FDB - well, not given a real chance but recent history suggests that Parish was right to take early action.

I'm encouraged by your acknowledgement of Hodgson's defensive organisation. I don't fully agree that he is stifling talent. AWB is progressing well. Townsend has performed far better under Roy than he did under the manager that signed him, Pardew. Zaha would have had a more consistent season had he not have been played out of position when required. We lack flair players in midfield.

The jury is divided when it comes to Meyer. But his inability to hold down a regular place is being blamed solely on Hodgson which I think is unfair.

Hodgson is by no means perfect. Could he do better ? - Yes. The home form and overall performances have been dire overall and I think this is clouding people's judgement. The 2 performances against Brighton were hugely disappointing.

But I'll say it again - the dividing lines in our part of the league are thin. If we had taken 6 points from Brighton we would be above West Ham and 11th. And Brighton would be in the bottom 3.

If Steve Parish decides to part company with Roy in the summer, that's his decision to make. Ultimately he is a businessman with a lot of money at stake. And that's when the emotion has to come out of it. He may well decide that his investment is in safe hands under Roy....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 06 Apr 19 10.21am

Taking the big clubs out of the equation I'm interested to know which club in the PL people would like Palace to emulate if they could? For example, a lot of people have said they'd love Benitez, but he has been accused of being overly negative this season. I like the way Wolves play, but they are erratic going from the sublime to the terrible at times - plus they spent over £100 million to get where they are. Bournemouth play some good stuff at times but their defence is shocking.

As much as it pains me to say, based on the players we have, I would say Watford are the benchmark. If we could bring in someone like Mitrovic I think it would also be our best chance of success. At times under roy we just look a bit too nice and I think it has cost us in games. The quick interchanges are great on the eye, but attacking the box with purpose is more exciting.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Apr 19 10.57am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Taking the big clubs out of the equation I'm interested to know which club in the PL people would like Palace to emulate if they could? For example, a lot of people have said they'd love Benitez, but he has been accused of being overly negative this season. I like the way Wolves play, but they are erratic going from the sublime to the terrible at times - plus they spent over £100 million to get where they are. Bournemouth play some good stuff at times but their defence is shocking.

As much as it pains me to say, based on the players we have, I would say Watford are the benchmark. If we could bring in someone like Mitrovic I think it would also be our best chance of success. At times under roy we just look a bit too nice and I think it has cost us in games. The quick interchanges are great on the eye, but attacking the box with purpose is more exciting.

I hear that Brighton are casting eyes in his direction.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Apr 19 11.45am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There is one.

Parish lives year to year or 6 months to 6 months struggling to keep his investment in the premier league in the hope that somebody will buy the majority shareholding of the club or hopefully all of it.


You forgot to add "IMO"

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Apr 19 11.49am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER


You forgot to add "IMO"

And which I know not to be true as well.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 06 Apr 19 12.34pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Re the 2nd paragraph I’ve seen little this season to suggest that a midfield with choices from (Luka aside) Kouyate, Meyer, Schlupp, McArthur, Riedewald is capable of bringing expansive football.

An interesting point. A sizable number of our first team have played at international level and should be well used to the demands of technical football.
The choice to play dire, insipid, negative football comes solely from Hodgson - I and others believe with the squad available and a forward foot philosophy to game management we can do better.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (06 Apr 2019 1.20pm)

 

dg1937 Flag 06 Apr 19 1.07pm

There are probably only six managers in the PL whose job description is 'get a place in the top 4 and look like we might be in with a chance of winning something.' The other fourteen managers have a job description that reads 'for God's sake don't get us relegated and a cup run until we come up against a top six club would be nice.'

Obviously there are teams in the fourteen that over achieve from time to time: Leicester (spectacularly); Burnley last season, Watford this season. Everton and West Ham would like to be over achievers one day but haven't made it at all or for a while.

I know a Sunderland fan who says that he is enjoying going to football this season for the first time in years. Even before they were relegated, the constant grind of fighting relegation every year simply wasn't fun. We are probably now in the same boat (in terms of the annual grind and not having much fun) and there isn't much doubt that one year we will draw the short straw and go down.

Roy is fulfilling his job description and I suspect will stay in the job: as long as he wants to; or until it looks like he might take us down. Watch his press conference this week and see how much importance the club attaches to not getting relegated (hardly a startling revelation).

Playing in the Championship (or even League One) might be more entertaining (it might not of course) but, as long as we are in the PL, I think 'entertainment' will be in short supply regardless of who the manager is (you're wasting your time if you think Benitez is the answer) - a fight for survival is rarely pretty. I know that's gloomy and pessimistic but it's the way I see things now.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Apr 19 1.40pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

An interesting point. A sizable number of our first team have played at international level and should be well used to the demands of technical football.
The choice to play dire, insipid, negative football comes solely from Hodgson - I and others believe with the squad available and a forward foot philosophy to game management we can do better.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (06 Apr 2019 1.20pm)

As others have said very little flair or attacking quality in there. Most can do a job as an up and down or defensive mid at lower premier league level but bring little in the final third. Meyer has only shown flashes when the opposition defend deep.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 06 Apr 19 1.47pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

As others have said very little flair or attacking quality in there. Most can do a job as an up and down or defensive mid at lower premier league level but bring little in the final third. Meyer has only shown flashes when the opposition defend deep.

I think if we want ceativity in the midfield, we'd havd to change the system. Playing a loan striker with wilf and andros on the wings, Roy likes playing defensive midfielders in the center. The creativity should come from the wings, but then you need midfielders to hit the box. Which is where our problems lie.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Apr 19 2.03pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I think if we want ceativity in the midfield, we'd havd to change the system. Playing a loan striker with wilf and andros on the wings, Roy likes playing defensive midfielders in the center. The creativity should come from the wings, but then you need midfielders to hit the box. Which is where our problems lie.

Roy hasn’t had much choice but to use defensive midfielders because it’s all we have. He was happy enough to use RLC and Cabaye last season and has persevered with Schlupp because he can run with ball and maybe nick a goal although IMO he’s not at the level needed.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 06 Apr 19 2.16pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Roy hasn’t had much choice but to use defensive midfielders because it’s all we have. He was happy enough to use RLC and Cabaye last season and has persevered with Schlupp because he can run with ball and maybe nick a goal although IMO he’s not at the level needed.

But it is his choice to have them playing so deep and not getting into the box, leaving the striker isolated.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 06 Apr 19 2.44pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

But it is his choice to have them playing so deep and not getting into the box, leaving the striker isolated.

Absolutely my thoughts. Our midfield don't make timed runs into the box because the game plan is not to. RH insists on his 3 defensive mids, even at home! How are we to get players in the box when they are all under instruction to sit back? No wonder the opposition have such an easy job of organising defensive duties...

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Apr 19 2.53pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

But it is his choice to have them playing so deep and not getting into the box, leaving the striker isolated.

Schlupp and McArthur have had plenty of ball around the opposition area but have lacked a bit of quality. It’s being so reliant on the wingers (or one winger) for attacking flair that’s made us so one dimensional at home IMO.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Apr 19 4.12pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

And which I know not to be true as well.

All I’ve said there is the case atm, unless you’re saying Parish has planned ahead and isn’t hoping a buyer comes in.

 


COYP

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Apr 19 5.18pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

All I’ve said there is the case atm, unless you’re saying Parish has planned ahead and isn’t hoping a buyer comes in.

Parish lives year to year or 6 months to 6 months struggling to keep his investment in the premier league in the hope that somebody will buy the majority shareholding of the club or hopefully all of it.

Your words. Where's your evidence that this is how he thinks ?

Sorry but you are talking bollix.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

davehuggins Flag 06 Apr 19 5.31pm

For all those who want RH gone, today just shows why he should stay. Brilliant away performance with the perfect result. Just be careful what you all wish for. Thanks Roy from me.

 

DeVito Flag Surbiton 06 Apr 19 5.41pm

But we really need a new, shinier, younger manager with fresh ideas and likes to play on the front foot. You know, someone like Eddie Howe...

Oh wait a minute

Edited by DeVito (06 Apr 2019 5.42pm)

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 06 Apr 19 5.47pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

For all those who want RH gone, today just shows why he should stay. Brilliant away performance with the perfect result. Just be careful what you all wish for. Thanks Roy from me.

A well done from me as well. 5 games to go and safe which for me is a job well done. He has used the players we have to outperform enough teams to keep us up. He now has the opportunity to entertain the fans with a different style of play, assuming that they are capable of it. They probably can but we will not necessarily win doing it. We are what we are. COYP

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Apr 19 5.51pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Of course there is a practical argument.

And it's based around people having an inflated view of the abilities of the squad and the merits or otherwise of Max Meyer, and the way they are managed.

really, I didn’t mention any individuals I merely said our team are capable of playing a different style of football given the chance.

You use the top 2 clubs as a comparison to the way Palace play. Are you being realistic in doing so ?

no I didn’t, I said the top two teams play in a certain way, I didn’t compare us to them, I said they are successful by pressing high up the field and having a fluid attack

The Premier League has become a League within a League. Take a look at the table and the gap between the those top 2 and then the next 4 clubs. Then look at the gap between 6th and 7th place. The top 2 have the resources and players available that make their systems work for them.

so are their players so much better and fitter that they alone can press high up the field. I’m pretty sure our players could do that

Like it or not, the Pardew and FDB argument is relative to this discussion. Those appointments were both made with the intention of changing the style of football. Pardew had limited success and FDB - well, not given a real chance but recent history suggests that Parish was right to take early action.

not sure I understand your point, I made the point that they were failed experiments because of their flaws.

I'm encouraged by your acknowledgement of Hodgson's defensive organisation. I don't fully agree that he is stifling talent. AWB is progressing well. Townsend has performed far better under Roy than he did under the manager that signed him, Pardew. Zaha would have had a more consistent season had he not have been played out of position when required. We lack flair players in midfield.

The jury is divided when it comes to Meyer. But his inability to hold down a regular place is being blamed solely on Hodgson which I think is unfair.

i didn’t mention Meyer at all so not sure what you mean, however my own opinion of Meyer is that he is very talented but needs to settle in the PL.

Hodgson is by no means perfect. Could he do better ? - Yes. The home form and overall performances have been dire overall and I think this is clouding people's judgement. The 2 performances against Brighton were hugely disappointing.

i couldn’t agree more with this paragraph

But I'll say it again - the dividing lines in our part of the league are thin. If we had taken 6 points from Brighton we would be above West Ham and 11th. And Brighton would be in the bottom 3.

not sure of the relevance of something that didn’t happen

If Steve Parish decides to part company with Roy in the summer, that's his decision to make. Ultimately he is a businessman with a lot of money at stake. And that's when the emotion has to come out of it. He may well decide that his investment is in safe hands under Roy....

fair comment but I don’t want to watch that rubbish year in year out and im sure there are lots of fans who feel the same way. I don’t think Roy is a bad manager, I would just prefer someone else with a more proactive approach. As I said originally the next manager is crucial to how Palace develop as a team

 

Page 42 of 65 < 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread