This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Interesting, and positive, statement from Michael Vaughan, yesterday:- Well done Michael. He said that things have changed very fast. Along with comedy.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Apologies for my part Becky. I get a little tired of baseless insinuations, accusations and personal comments, so on occasion I feel the desire to retaliate.
The trouble is that this has overwhelmed the good intentions of the modding structure and is lost in the bickering. Little about any of this will change. It's an ongoing abuse of the platform that drives decent people away from the site, so if you're talking about rule breaking lets get it right. Please get a bit of perspective. Wisbech is a decent bloke with cancer knocking on 80 with relatively typical views. It's ridiculous that you clearly have such complete and utter hatred for the man. You can only shake your head at this stuff.
Edited by BlueJay (27 Nov 2021 1.34pm)
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I will make the point that particular judgements of posters, site interactions, and especially what can and can't be said and how that is interpreted are for Hol. I would agree that it can get too negative for a pleasant reading experience some times. However, it's also true that some posters get particularly negative of Hol and seem to wish to continually attack it because it allows discussions they don't like. If they want to shut down speech there are other sites they could post in. When atmospheres become too polluted to reasonably accommodate typical, mainstream views that becomes the attack on free speech. There is of course though something to be said with operating on the basis of what site owners would reasonably want or knowingly accept on their platform (hence rules). People ought to understand that 'tolerance' is not only something that they (fail to) gift others, it is often something they routinely receive in return in some form even if they don't see it that way.
Anyway, if anyone ever wants a natter I'll be in general, game threads, or the covid thread. What a heady mix. Take care all. Edited by BlueJay (27 Nov 2021 2.53pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
When atmospheres become too polluted to reasonably accommodate typical, mainstream views that becomes the attack on free speech. There is of course though something to be said with operating on the basis of what site owners would reasonably want or knowingly accept on their platform (hence rules). People ought to understand that 'tolerance' is not only something that they (fail to) gift others, it is often something they routinely receive in return in some form even if they don't see it that way. Any gleeful attempts to get people booted off (whoever is doing it) is pyrrhic victory territory, because when one person goes it increases the likelihood of the same happening to their opposites. Some might not see it that way if they think they 'rule the roost', or 'will be here longer than others' or whatever.. but ultimately the sum of peoples posts is there to see, and there's plenty here with little to be proud of
I don't think it's true to say that mainstream opinions aren't found on Hol. I don't even think that interpretation is close. Also, If people choose not to post, that is the operation of choice, and so that isn't an attack on free speech. Hol does quite well in terms of posts compared to some other sites. I have always defended free speech (as have you, though perhaps not so much recently) however I also agree that a private site has the right to make its own interpretations of its own rules. I see that continually attacked by people who have the choice to attend sites that much more closely resemble their desire for restricted opinions. I think that is a point worth making.
Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Nov 2021 2.58pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't think it's true to say that mainstream opinions aren't found on Hol. I don't even think that interpretation is close. Also, If people choose not to post, that is the operation of choice, and so that isn't an attack on free speech. Hol does quite well in terms of posts compared to some other sites. I have always defended free speech (as have you, though perhaps not so much recently) however I also agree that a private site has the right to make its own interpretations of its own rules. I see that continually attacked by people who have the choice to attend sites that much more closely resemble their desire for restricted opinions. I think that is a point worth making.
Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Nov 2021 2.58pm) Where people are uncompromising, whatever they believe it is an ill fitting mix for people who prefer a more reasonable exchange of views. There is much talk of activists, it may help for people to realise when they are one. You're right, people have a choice about posting or not. Realistically I don't think it would be helpful for anyone to be banned no matter how much they wind each other up. That was my point really. Anyway, enough from me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Where people are uncompromising, whatever they believe it is an ill fitting mix for people who prefer a more reasonable exchange of views. There is much talk of activists, it may help for people to realise when they are one. You're right, people have a choice about posting or not. Realistically I don't think it would be helpful for anyone to be banned no matter how much they wind each other up. That was my point really. Anyway, enough from me. Criticism of opinions we don't like is of course free speech itself and if that's the extent of it then we are in agreement. If Hol decided today to ban Hrolf, me, you, Wisbech or anyone for whatever reason then as a private site I accept that as their freedom....I might not agree, but that's the point. I don't like the bbs for example, but that doesn't extend to the point that I think it shouldn't be allowed its own rules. What is important is that the state allows speech to exist with as low a bar as possible, which requires a certain level of interpretation. It also requires a level of protection for what some might view as unpopular speech. Of course I realise that the direction of travel by the state isn't along these lines and that it's only a matter of time before speech of whatever type is restricted....this will allow a multitude of sins to rush in but it's like complaining about the waves of the ocean. I think it is a dimming of freedom in these lands but I've long realised that darkness is part of our future. However, while I can still criticise the decisions that led to that I will. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Nov 2021 3.32pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Nov 2021 3.31pm) I agree. Not really a left or right thing though really. It certainly happens in societies that you may view to be a better model, or seek to emulate and it happens in ours. I wonder how quick the freedom of speech love would dial down in a society that more reflected your racial interests (as in for all our faults China, Russia, Hungary etc don't seem all that hot on individual freedoms or voices in how they govern). In any case, many proposed laws hijack both the sensibilities of the perceived left (cancel culture) and right attributes (groundless stop and search, often anti protest - well until covid) to contort into laws that impact all. They breeze past on account of side stepping the left and right Punch and Judy show that they rely on to sneak in authoritarian laws
Edited by BlueJay (27 Nov 2021 3.57pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I agree. Not really a left or right thing though really. It certainly happens in societies that you may view to be a better model, or seek to emulate and it happens in ours. I wonder how quick the freedom of speech love would dial down in a society that more reflected your racial interests (as in for all our faults China, Russia, Hungary etc don't seem all that hot on individual freedoms or voices in how they govern). In any case, many proposed laws hijack both the sensibilities of the perceived left (cancel culture) and right attributes (groundless stop and search, often anti protest - well until covid) to contort into laws that impact all. They breeze past on account of side stepping the left and right Punch and Judy show that they rely on to sneak in authoritarian laws
Edited by BlueJay (27 Nov 2021 3.57pm) I think you make good points here. I'm a bit pushed for time for a bit but at a later point I'd like to extend some of these points as some of your criticisms are indeed valid.....I just think it's all inevitable. I'm saying that so often now I could put it on my gravestone....it still works there as well.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't think it's true to say that mainstream opinions aren't found on Hol. I don't even think that interpretation is close. Also, If people choose not to post, that is the operation of choice, and so that isn't an attack on free speech. Hol does quite well in terms of posts compared to some other sites. I have always defended free speech (as have you, though perhaps not so much recently) however I also agree that a private site has the right to make its own interpretations of its own rules. I see that continually attacked by people who have the choice to attend sites that much more closely resemble their desire for restricted opinions. I think that is a point worth making.
Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Nov 2021 2.58pm) I am very glad to know you now support the right of Facebook, Twitter etc to ban the likes of Alex Jones and, of course, Donald Trump. Welcome to the club. The only people who I see attacking that principal are those who themselves have the right to go and support the likes of "Gab". My own view is that there is little point in participating in an echo chamber of similar views, unless your only purpose is to confirm your biases. That some do here is unfortunate, and I would urge them all to also post their views elsewhere. You won't change minds unless you engage with them. I abhor extreme right attitudes and don't want to see them ever gaining any traction in my country. I cannot impact that much, but if all I did was complain in an echo chamber, I wouldn't do anything at all. So I reject the concept, often expressed here, that people like me aren't welcome and should go somewhere else, like the BBS where, apparently, my views are commonplace. That feels like the antithesis of free speech.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
If you want to see a balanced, fair- minded article on this subject, then get hold of Monty Panesar’s article in ‘The Daily Telegraph’ today.
|
|
|
Originally posted by soapbox
If you want to see a balanced, fair- minded article on this subject, then get hold of Monty Panesar’s article in ‘The Daily Telegraph’ today. Here is something from Wisden:
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The silicon valley companies were given both public funds at start up and laws were changed to allow them to operate. They aren't private operations in the same way Hol is. A very important second point to make here is on monopolies. In a free marketplace, I have no issues with companies having rules on their platforms which would see people they don't like banned (though this is done in a very underhand and dishonest fashion). However, the point should also be made that the kind of restrictions they now use were not in place when they started up. Only once they reached powerful positions have they started to exclude people...directly going back on their original free speech beginnings....However, all that is what it is...what I very much more opposed to are those same companies have conspired to limit new competing platforms that differ from them politically because of their monopoly power.....they have conspired together because they have the same politics and it's very unethical. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Nov 2021 10.08pm) Silicon valley was designed to be a base for start-up tech companies, so it's hardly surprising that start-up tech companies set up there. That means zilch in terms of their ownership being private and the rules being their rules. No different at all to the Hol, other than in scale. None are monopolies. They all have competition. That they can reach the same conclusions is a sign that they are all trying to find a balance between allowing freedom of expression and ensuring that their sites are not used to promote dangerous misinformation, or calls for violence. Something that unmoderated sites, like Gab fail badly at doing. My view, which seems to be shared by many these days, is that they don't go nearly far enough. It has nothing at all to do with whether someone is "liked" or not. It's how they behave and what they post. You can find some pretty outrageous stuff on all the social media sites. Unedited untruths that would never get past a lawyer on the regular media. Some might like that, because it's "free speech", but when it's irresponsible speech that can cause actual harm, we need them to take action. Of course, as they have grown, oversight arrangements have had to evolve to suit their new environment. That happens to every business, in every sector. They need to evolve faster, though, because their environment is ever-changing. The idea that these companies must, by default, have political motivations behind their decisions is untrue. It is an excuse to justify the antagonism. Removals and bans happen because of the posting of lies and dangerous calls for unlawful actions, and not because of any particular viewpoint of the poster. They can easily be avoided, simply by staying within the rules and not posting things known to be untrue.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
This is spot on Originally posted by soapbox
If you want to see a balanced, fair- minded article on this subject, then get hold of Monty Panesar’s article in ‘The Daily Telegraph’ today.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am very glad to know you now support the right of Facebook, Twitter etc to ban the likes of Alex Jones and, of course, Donald Trump. Welcome to the club. The only people who I see attacking that principal are those who themselves have the right to go and support the likes of "Gab". My own view is that there is little point in participating in an echo chamber of similar views, unless your only purpose is to confirm your biases. That some do here is unfortunate, and I would urge them all to also post their views elsewhere. You won't change minds unless you engage with them. I abhor extreme right attitudes and don't want to see them ever gaining any traction in my country. I cannot impact that much, but if all I did was complain in an echo chamber, I wouldn't do anything at all. So I reject the concept, often expressed here, that people like me aren't welcome and should go somewhere else, like the BBS where, apparently, my views are commonplace. That feels like the antithesis of free speech. How many minds have you changed on HOL? The various posters on here are as malleable as anyone else so your success rate must be pretty high.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
How many minds have you changed on HOL? The various posters on here are as malleable as anyone else so your success rate must be pretty high. I have no idea, although a complete change, probably none. On a few matters, maybe some. We won't know because they are very unlikely to admit it. It's not the only reason for doing it. You need to feel comfortable with yourself. Not trying isn't an option for me. I disagree though about the posters here having malleable minds. Some might, but there are others whose minds haven't moved an inch in the last 50 years.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I have no idea, although a complete change, probably none. On a few matters, maybe some. We won't know because they are very unlikely to admit it. It's not the only reason for doing it. You need to feel comfortable with yourself. Not trying isn't an option for me. I disagree though about the posters here having malleable minds. Some might, but there are others whose minds haven't moved an inch in the last 50 years. And on which subjects has your opinion been changed?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.