You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 43 of 44 < 39 40 41 42 43 44 >
7mins Flag In the bush 05 Feb 17 10.30am

Originally posted by matt_himself

It appears from the outside that Southern has divided and conquered.

Not knowing the negotiations, but from what I have read, it appears that the RMT is bitter about ASLEF agreeing a deal on their own.

It's hard to jointly negotiate with two different unions that have separate aims. I think ASLEF has probably won on points.

 

Hoof Hearted 05 Feb 17 10.35am

I find it amusingly ironic that we have two separate threads going concurrently on this topic!

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 05 Feb 17 10.45am

Originally posted by 7mins

It's hard to jointly negotiate with two different unions that have separate aims. I think ASLEF has probably won on points.

[Link]

I thought their aims were the same. Passenger safety was held up as the reason for the strike from both unions.

I find it strange that this is the outcome given that stance by both unions.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

gambler Flag Kent 05 Feb 17 11.58am

Aslef havent agreed a deal. They've simply agreed to put something to a vote of their members. The members are the ones who need to agree.

Aslef members will be voting on this deal. It won't be accepted. No way.

Anyone saying that the staff have been divided and conquered you need to hold fire on that I'm afraid.

Sadly for the long suffering passengers this thing is far from over.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 05 Feb 17 1.18pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

[Link]

I thought their aims were the same. Passenger safety was held up as the reason for the strike from both unions.

I find it strange that this is the outcome given that stance by both unions.

You can't have RMT discussion driver indemnity insurance, upgrading of in cab cctv, relocation deals and subsequent training of freight train drivers and the rewriting of drivers employment contracts (DRI)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 05 Feb 17 1.24pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

[Link]

I thought their aims were the same. Passenger safety was held up as the reason for the strike from both unions.

I find it strange that this is the outcome given that stance by both unions.

Do you not think the agreement with ASLEF is all about passenger safety? To me... it totally vindicates their actions. They have refused £££ that Southern have offered them, and secured a deal that protests passenger safety, while not benefiting financially at all. Southern have come out of this bad. They accepted the deal that was offered before the strikes. Southern had the power to avoid the strikes by accepting this deal when first offered.

Drivers have lost thousands to secure this deal. They have been rewarded with safer working practices not extra money.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 05 Feb 17 7.21pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Do you not think the agreement with ASLEF is all about passenger safety? To me... it totally vindicates their actions. They have refused £££ that Southern have offered them, and secured a deal that protests passenger safety, while not benefiting financially at all. Southern have come out of this bad. They accepted the deal that was offered before the strikes. Southern had the power to avoid the strikes by accepting this deal when first offered.

Drivers have lost thousands to secure this deal. They have been rewarded with safer working practices not extra money.

Then why would the RMT state that the ASLEF deal will lead to reduction of staff levels which was the core issue of the dispute?

Here is another story stating this:

[Link]


Edited by matt_himself (05 Feb 2017 7.26pm)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Feb 17 9.43pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

Then why would the RMT state that the ASLEF deal will lead to reduction of staff levels which was the core issue of the dispute?

Here is another story stating this:

[Link]


Edited by matt_himself (05 Feb 2017 7.26pm)

Do Aslef drivers not have the choice of refusing to drive a train if they think it is unsafe without an onboard staff member as part of the deal? I may be mistaken.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 06 Feb 17 2.26am

Originally posted by matt_himself

Then why would the RMT state that the ASLEF deal will lead to reduction of staff levels which was the core issue of the dispute?

Here is another story stating this:

[Link]


Edited by matt_himself (05 Feb 2017 7.26pm)

RMT think Southern will reneg on the deal. If ASLEF get it in DRI (drivers employment contract) southern can't go back on their word. It all hinges on what Southern put in drivers new contracts. If ASLEF have taken Southern just on their word, they are foolish. Southern have a long history of lying. If ASLEF get the OBS role written in to the new contract, it will be hard for Southern to go back on their word.
Personally... I would get new DRI written up then ask members to vote.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 06 Feb 17 6.53am

Originally posted by 7mins

RMT think Southern will reneg on the deal. If ASLEF get it in DRI (drivers employment contract) southern can't go back on their word. It all hinges on what Southern put in drivers new contracts. If ASLEF have taken Southern just on their word, they are foolish. Southern have a long history of lying. If ASLEF get the OBS role written in to the new contract, it will be hard for Southern to go back on their word.
Personally... I would get new DRI written up then ask members to vote.

I don't doubt your intel but from the outside, something's smells about this deal.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

7mins Flag In the bush 06 Feb 17 7.44am

Originally posted by matt_himself

I don't doubt your intel but from the outside, something's smells about this deal.

I think this deal might not even get through. The exceptional circumstances clause is too vague, and requires trust from drivers for Southern to honour it. Considering how Southern have lied to drivers recently (they put in writing that they wouldn't extend DOO without consulting unions, then extended it without consultation). I can't see there being the trust there to split the vote. You can't blame the drivers for not trusting a company that has continually lied to its staff and customers.

If drivers get the OBS stuff in to DRI. I think they will agree it.
Rewriting DRI will cost Southern. The union will use it to get parity with other drivers in the industry.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 06 Feb 17 8.25am

Originally posted by 7mins

I think this deal might not even get through. The exceptional circumstances clause is too vague, and requires trust from drivers for Southern to honour it. Considering how Southern have lied to drivers recently (they put in writing that they wouldn't extend DOO without consulting unions, then extended it without consultation). I can't see there being the trust there to split the vote. You can't blame the drivers for not trusting a company that has continually lied to its staff and customers.

If drivers get the OBS stuff in to DRI. I think they will agree it.
Rewriting DRI will cost Southern. The union will use it to get parity with other drivers in the industry.

This is the bit I am struggling with, if the deal is likely unacceptable to drivers why would ASLEF recommend it? It would put ASLEF in a weak position to recommend a deal which drivers subsequent vote down. Also why would ASLEF cut the RMT out of the deal, given their supposed shared aims of 'safety'?

This smells rotten.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 06 Feb 17 9.24am

Originally posted by matt_himself

This is the bit I am struggling with, if the deal is likely unacceptable to drivers why would ASLEF recommend it? It would put ASLEF in a weak position to recommend a deal which drivers subsequent vote down. Also why would ASLEF cut the RMT out of the deal, given their supposed shared aims of 'safety'?

This smells rotten.

The reason RMT weren't involved has been explained 3 times on this thread. Why do you keep asking?


I think it's all down to trust. The union negotiators are putting faith in Southern to provide 2nd crew members in all but a few services. Drivers however want a guarantee, after being lied to by southern so often and so long I can see why there is no trust. That's why the RMT said it was something of a capitulation by Aslef.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 06 Feb 17 9.55am

It says in the Guardian that ASLEF have conceded to Southern that drivers will operate doors:

[Link]

There will be an 'onboard supervisor' but they appear not be guards and will have different responsibilities and training.

This appears to be the reason why the RMT was excluded from the deal.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 06 Feb 17 6.13pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Do you not think the agreement with ASLEF is all about passenger safety? To me... it totally vindicates their actions. They have refused £££ that Southern have offered them, and secured a deal that protests passenger safety, while not benefiting financially at all. Southern have come out of this bad. They accepted the deal that was offered before the strikes. Southern had the power to avoid the strikes by accepting this deal when first offered.

Drivers have lost thousands to secure this deal. They have been rewarded with safer working practices not extra money.

Are they not going to be on the same scale as Thameslink and South Eastern which is better for them as part of the deal?

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 06 Feb 17 6.57pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Are they not going to be on the same scale as Thameslink and South Eastern which is better for them as part of the deal?

And I feel the need to intervene by way of posters' previous summation as to the contribution of Secretary for Transport, Chris Grayling, upon the basis that you contribute via your taxes towards his salary and expected working output that is conducive to elected party manifesto promises.

[Link]

 

7mins Flag In the bush 06 Feb 17 7.56pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Are they not going to be on the same scale as Thameslink and South Eastern which is better for them as part of the deal?

Southern will get parity with Thameslink. Southeastern have conductors and Sunday in the working week, different rest day pattern.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 06 Feb 17 7.58pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

It says in the Guardian that ASLEF have conceded to Southern that drivers will operate doors:

[Link]

There will be an 'onboard supervisor' but they appear not be guards and will have different responsibilities and training.

This appears to be the reason why the RMT was excluded from the deal.

ASLEF have got safety critical training for OBS's. Spoke to a Southern manager this morning. They think the deal will be accepted by metro but rejected by coastal drivers.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 06 Feb 17 8.06pm

Originally posted by 7mins

ASLEF have got safety critical training for OBS's. Spoke to a Southern manager this morning. They think the deal will be accepted by metro but rejected by coastal drivers.

But it says on here, the ASLEF strike was intended to remove Southern's plans to remove 'safety trained guards' from trains:

[Link]

I am sorry but it really looks from the outside that ASLEF has capitulated to Southern and sold out the RMT. This is from the BBC, which appears to reflect this view:

[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

7mins Flag In the bush 06 Feb 17 9.32pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

But it says on here, the ASLEF strike was intended to remove Southern's plans to remove 'safety trained guards' from trains:

[Link]

I am sorry but it really looks from the outside that ASLEF has capitulated to Southern and sold out the RMT. This is from the BBC, which appears to reflect this view:

[Link]

I think both sides have negotiated. This is the deal offered by ASLEF 3 months ago. ASLEF have to represent their members. RMT represent their members. Sympathy strikes are illegal.

Edited by 7mins (06 Feb 2017 9.37pm)

 

Page 43 of 44 < 39 40 41 42 43 44 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong