This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by chris123
The science surely is overwhelming clear that, properly worn and maintained, masks work stopping the spread of infection. Where is this science that people keep banging on about. There is more evidence it causes problems than there is it stops transmission of anything. I don’t want to see a government instruction I want to see scientific evidence and I never have.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
It’s also science that they don’t reduce oxygen intake. ‘’It’s droplets, it’s aerosols, it’s it’s it’s better than nothing, it might make 1% difference.’’ Give it up, unless you’re wearing a proper mask it’s garbage and can actually make more of a problem. Notice parts of Britain that prove you wrong. Social distancing is fine, this one cloth measure is false hope and often not needed. It’s been virtually no issue whatsoever for shop workers. People actually start believing masks make them safe and stop the distancing. I’ve seen lots of it, while wearing a cloth that could make as little as 3% difference and as much as 20%, if you had it on so tight you couldn’t speak or even breathe and probably about 3 of them. Edited by Rudi Hedman (10 Dec 2020 11.38am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Where is this science that people keep banging on about. There is more evidence it causes problems than there is it stops transmission of anything. I don’t want to see a government instruction I want to see scientific evidence and I never have. The science is everywhere and constant, how are you missing it?
|
|
|
The science wasn’t used much here.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
Despicable. My child gets forced to wear a mask over my dead body. Why point the finger at others? They're just breathing. You're a human too, aren't you? Christ. People like this actually exist
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
No that's ministers not science.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
‘’It’s droplets, it’s aerosols, it’s it’s it’s better than nothing, it might make 1% difference.’’ Give it up, unless you’re wearing a proper mask it’s garbage and can actually make more of a problem. Notice parts of Britain that prove you wrong. Social distancing is fine, this one cloth measure is false hope and often not needed. It’s been virtually no issue whatsoever for shop workers. People actually start believing masks make them safe and stop the distancing. I’ve seen lots of it, while wearing a cloth that could make as little as 3% difference and as much as 20%, if you had it on so tight you couldn’t speak or even breathe and probably about 3 of them. Edited by Rudi Hedman (10 Dec 2020 11.38am) This is more or less correct. Cloth masks do sod all. Other than give the wearer a false sense of security – not to mention the fact that most people won't wash them after every use, so even more useless. However, this doesn't mean that wearing a proper multilayered one is ineffective, far from it. As for oxygen levels – clearly any covering over your face restricts breathing even if it is a negligible amount. Medical grade masks such as the proper n95 variety that effectively seal around your face would probably cause an issue if you wore them for extended amounts of time. But do you actually need one? Probably not. A half decent mask and multi layer filter with some form of anti-microbial coating should be enough – not fool proof, but far better to you and more importantly others than simply wheezing all over the place. It's not about protecting yourself, so much, as being socially considerate. Again, asian countries have done this for decades to protect others when feeling ill, out of courtesy. It's not exactly orwellian FFS. For those whining about it, get over yourself and stop being so selfish. And ditch the cotton mask you've fashioned out of some old shirt. Useless. Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Dec 2020 5.35pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
Despicable. My child gets forced to wear a mask over my dead body. Why point the finger at others? They're just breathing. You're a human too, aren't you?
What might a face mask do? There has been discussion that a face mask might add to anatomical dead space by extending it beyond the mouth area. If everything else stays the same, an extra 20 ml say, of dead space, theoretically will reduce the percentage of oxygen at the alveolus, but the effect is very small, meaning that blood still would stay fully saturated with oxygen. Oxygen in the blood equilibrates with oxygen in our alveoli. Blood is maximally saturated with oxygen when alveolar oxygen is 13-15%. This means this means that all the all the oxygen binding sites on haemoglobin (which makes our blood red) are occupied. So even if more oxygen were available, blood saturation with oxygen does not increase. Furthermore, the relationship between % oxygen and blood saturation is not linear, oxygen levels would need to halve to reduce saturation to 90%. What might a face mask do? There has been discussion that a face mask might add to anatomical dead space by extending it beyond the mouth area. If everything else stays the same, an extra 20 ml say, of dead space, theoretically will reduce the percentage of oxygen at the alveolus, but the effect is very small, meaning that blood still would stay fully saturated with oxygen. Think about how many people go swimming with snorkels, how much dead space this adds and how it has remarkably little effect on our activities. So, does a face mask restrict flow of air into the lungs? The bottom line is, if used correctly, it does not. If airflow is restricted, less millilitres of oxygen get to the alveoli, and less carbon dioxide is exhaled. While this reduces the percentage of oxygen in our lungs, and increases carbon dioxide, the body senses these changes in the lungs and stimulates breathing.' However as mentioned, cloth masks are useless. Multi-layered/filter based, anti-microbial fabric masks are the way to go. Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Dec 2020 5.47pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
My 85 year old Uncle had his first vaccination today! Another one on January 6th. All good. Good luck to him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
My 85 year old Uncle had his first vaccination today! Another one on January 6th. All good. Best wishes to him
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
My 85 year old Uncle had his first vaccination today! Another one on January 6th. All good. Well done to the old chap. I'm sure he will feel a whole lot more secure although early posts on here may have read 'what's the point, hes 85 and goner die soon anyway'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Well done to the old chap. I'm sure he will feel a whole lot more secure although early posts on here may have read 'what's the point, hes 85 and goner die soon anyway'. My old chap could do with an injection. Are they still available on the nhs?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
My old chap could do with an injection. Are they still available on the nhs? The blue pill could be a less painful way to go unless you want botox
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
My old chap could do with an injection. Are they still available on the nhs? Apparently it’s just a little p***k
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
What might a face mask do? There has been discussion that a face mask might add to anatomical dead space by extending it beyond the mouth area. If everything else stays the same, an extra 20 ml say, of dead space, theoretically will reduce the percentage of oxygen at the alveolus, but the effect is very small, meaning that blood still would stay fully saturated with oxygen. Oxygen in the blood equilibrates with oxygen in our alveoli. Blood is maximally saturated with oxygen when alveolar oxygen is 13-15%. This means this means that all the all the oxygen binding sites on haemoglobin (which makes our blood red) are occupied. So even if more oxygen were available, blood saturation with oxygen does not increase. Furthermore, the relationship between % oxygen and blood saturation is not linear, oxygen levels would need to halve to reduce saturation to 90%. What might a face mask do? There has been discussion that a face mask might add to anatomical dead space by extending it beyond the mouth area. If everything else stays the same, an extra 20 ml say, of dead space, theoretically will reduce the percentage of oxygen at the alveolus, but the effect is very small, meaning that blood still would stay fully saturated with oxygen. Think about how many people go swimming with snorkels, how much dead space this adds and how it has remarkably little effect on our activities. So, does a face mask restrict flow of air into the lungs? The bottom line is, if used correctly, it does not. If airflow is restricted, less millilitres of oxygen get to the alveoli, and less carbon dioxide is exhaled. While this reduces the percentage of oxygen in our lungs, and increases carbon dioxide, the body senses these changes in the lungs and stimulates breathing.' However as mentioned, cloth masks are useless. Multi-layered/filter based, anti-microbial fabric masks are the way to go. Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Dec 2020 5.47pm) Good evening.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
‘’It’s droplets, it’s aerosols, it’s it’s it’s better than nothing, it might make 1% difference.’’ Give it up, unless you’re wearing a proper mask it’s garbage and can actually make more of a problem. Notice parts of Britain that prove you wrong. Social distancing is fine, this one cloth measure is false hope and often not needed. It’s been virtually no issue whatsoever for shop workers. People actually start believing masks make them safe and stop the distancing. I’ve seen lots of it, while wearing a cloth that could make as little as 3% difference and as much as 20%, if you had it on so tight you couldn’t speak or even breathe and probably about 3 of them. Edited by Rudi Hedman (10 Dec 2020 11.38am) Why are you still peddling this nonsense? We dealt with this pages ago. Wearing a mask is NOT, repeat NOT, done to protect YOU. It is to protect others FROM you. If everyone does it, everyone is protected. Not perfectly but sufficiently to make it a sensible part of the precautions we all need to take. People that have a medical problem can gain dispensation but most of us manage perfectly well.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
Good evening. Yep. Looks like you knocked that up yourself in Microsoft Word Decent effort TBF Further - point 19, which I assume is what you’ve chosen to zero in on without debating the rest of the context in the post, refers to a driver who was wearing an n95 medical mask for prolonged periods of time. Not a cloth mask. Not a multilayered fabric mask. Not a type of mask that most people will be wearing on a day to day basis. If you actually read my post, I specifically mention medical grade, tightly sealed masks as being problematic. They’re not necessary for general use and are not designed for everyday wear. Also the lack of specifics in that barrage of points renders it mostly useless. ‘A mask’. Because of course, all masks are identical. If you’re going to quote research at least be specific about the variables. How ironic that something supposed to be scientific is actually incredibly unscientific. Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Dec 2020 10.28pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Why are you still peddling this nonsense? We dealt with this pages ago. Wearing a mask is NOT, repeat NOT, done to protect YOU. It is to protect others FROM you. If everyone does it, everyone is protected. Not perfectly but sufficiently to make it a sensible part of the precautions we all need to take. People that have a medical problem can gain dispensation but most of us manage perfectly well. He is right re. Single sheet homemade cloth masks. They’re completely useless. Not sure the argument is all masks bad Just those ones are pointless
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
My 85 year old Uncle had his first vaccination today! Another one on January 6th. All good. Amazing. All the best to him. Hope you get to see him soon.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.