This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote since1953 at 15 Sep 2015 12.44pm
After promising refuge to 800K immigrants in the first year,Germany has closed its border with Austria after taking in a fraction (40K?) . They are now proposing a financial penalty for those EU countries not wishing to take a proportion. Dream on. See this makes sense to me. They proposed taking 800,000 refugees, not 800,000 immigrants. Effectively the best solution is to restrict borders, and take refugees primarily from the camps, thus preventing people trying to get into countries 'illicitly' and claiming independent asylum. Realistically, the solution to the problem is better resolved on an European wide basis, than individual nationalities - Such as the suspension Free Movement going forwards which would reduce UK Immigration by 42% in the coming year, and easily allow for a significant contribution to Refugee placements (well in excess of the 4,000 a year we have agreed on, over five years).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote sickboy at 15 Sep 2015 12.10pm
Quote Kermit8 at 14 Sep 2015 7.27am
Quote sickboy at 14 Sep 2015 7.01am
Quote oldcodger at 13 Sep 2015 11.07pm
Quote sickboy at 13 Sep 2015 10.41pm
Quote Kermit8 at 13 Sep 2015 9.50pm
Uu Quote sickboy at 13 Sep 2015 3.52pm
Quote since1953 at 13 Sep 2015 2.06pm
I agree entirely sickboy, but what is the chance of them returning to Syria/Afghanistan etc once the fighting has finished? Very slim I would suggest. Tracking them down and processing them for deportation would be expensive and almost impossible. Realistically then, once you have taken them in you will have to accept them as potentially new citizens. This may suit Germany and Sweden for economic reasons but I find the prospect unattractive.
Edited by Kermit8 (13 Sep 2015 9.51pm)
If you're in a war zone, where does this idea come from that the only viable option is to move to the next country over from the war zone. Of course many do that, but those who don't may do so for a multitude of reasons, perceived safety being one of them - not only 'financial reasons'.
The scrub and mass camps of the neighbouring countries can't offer them a normal life or positive future. Edited by Kermit8 (14 Sep 2015 7.31am)
I'm not sure they do. We have a pretty low figure for accepting Asylum cases, and even lower for approving them. Actual migration to the UK by Asylum is generally very low, around 5% of the total figure. Most migration into the UK is through the EU Freedom of Movement (42%), student visas and from Non-EU countries for work (43%). About half a million people come to the UK long term each year, and 255,000 leave the UK long term each year, of which about 155,000 are British Citizens. About 25,000 people in an average year are granted Asylum.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote Ouzo Dan at 15 Sep 2015 1.41pm
Germany's action's have been a disgrace, you cannot open your borders the way they have done creating a once in a lifetime mad dash that we will never see again & then shut the door. How many more have died because of Merkel's frankly mental plan? she should be arrested & tried at court. Germany have pissed off half of Europe, have left thousands upon thousands of refugees & economic chancers stuck in limbo & despite their pitiful U-turn & breaking their own rules twice have the nerve threaten other nations to take more. This is the biggest blow to the European union to date one which the EU will not recover from & it was all caused by the one Nation that stands to lose the most from it. It's all just so f***ing mental.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote since1953 at 15 Sep 2015 1.03pm
I see your point but: The refugees that are taken on will eventually apply for full citizenship. No way will they want to return to Syria/Afghanistan etc after the fighting. As I have said before tracking them down and deporting them will be expensive and difficult. That isn't represented in the data sets though, it seems that the UK migration rate is about 300,000 or so more than the UK emigration rates each year. I'd see this as unsustainable, as any kind of long term strategy, especially given the impact it has had on wages in the UK (here the demand makes sense, given the strength of the pound against the Euro). Whilst I'm left wing, I see the use of the Free Movement as a means by which cheap labour has been shifted around the EU and has driven down wages for the working class and upper working classes (and to a lesser extent middle classes of the UK). Refugees on the other hand traditionally do generally end up becoming long term citizens, I don't see a case where by they will be able to return to Syria, so the prospect of them becoming a cheap labour force that drives down wages doesn't exist. Admitedly, they'll have longer term costs in terms of health care, but also greater based UK spending and long term engagement, as well as providing a potential boon for the intelligence services - an influx of people who speak both English and Arabic, many of who have been driven out by groups such as IS. As a rule Refugees have a great history of integration and loyalty in their first two generations The spike in Syrian refugees as boat migrants, has been driven particularly from the Syrian middle classes, which means that many potentially have useful skills and educational backgrounds.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Sep 2015 2.22pm
Quote since1953 at 15 Sep 2015 1.03pm
I see your point but: The refugees that are taken on will eventually apply for full citizenship. No way will they want to return to Syria/Afghanistan etc after the fighting. As I have said before tracking them down and deporting them will be expensive and difficult. That isn't represented in the data sets though, it seems that the UK migration rate is about 300,000 or so more than the UK emigration rates each year. I'd see this as unsustainable, as any kind of long term strategy, especially given the impact it has had on wages in the UK (here the demand makes sense, given the strength of the pound against the Euro). Whilst I'm left wing, I see the use of the Free Movement as a means by which cheap labour has been shifted around the EU and has driven down wages for the working class and upper working classes (and to a lesser extent middle classes of the UK). Refugees on the other hand traditionally do generally end up becoming long term citizens, I don't see a case where by they will be able to return to Syria, so the prospect of them becoming a cheap labour force that drives down wages doesn't exist. Admitedly, they'll have longer term costs in terms of health care, but also greater based UK spending and long term engagement, as well as providing a potential boon for the intelligence services - an influx of people who speak both English and Arabic, many of who have been driven out by groups such as IS. As a rule Refugees have a great history of integration and loyalty in their first two generations The spike in Syrian refugees as boat migrants, has been driven particularly from the Syrian middle classes, which means that many potentially have useful skills and educational backgrounds.
And even now it's lower than our rate. How it used to be before:
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 16 Sep 2015 11.00am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Sep 2015 2.22pm
Quote since1953 at 15 Sep 2015 1.03pm
I see your point but: The refugees that are taken on will eventually apply for full citizenship. No way will they want to return to Syria/Afghanistan etc after the fighting. As I have said before tracking them down and deporting them will be expensive and difficult. That isn't represented in the data sets though, it seems that the UK migration rate is about 300,000 or so more than the UK emigration rates each year. I'd see this as unsustainable, as any kind of long term strategy, especially given the impact it has had on wages in the UK (here the demand makes sense, given the strength of the pound against the Euro). Whilst I'm left wing, I see the use of the Free Movement as a means by which cheap labour has been shifted around the EU and has driven down wages for the working class and upper working classes (and to a lesser extent middle classes of the UK). Refugees on the other hand traditionally do generally end up becoming long term citizens, I don't see a case where by they will be able to return to Syria, so the prospect of them becoming a cheap labour force that drives down wages doesn't exist. Admitedly, they'll have longer term costs in terms of health care, but also greater based UK spending and long term engagement, as well as providing a potential boon for the intelligence services - an influx of people who speak both English and Arabic, many of who have been driven out by groups such as IS. As a rule Refugees have a great history of integration and loyalty in their first two generations The spike in Syrian refugees as boat migrants, has been driven particularly from the Syrian middle classes, which means that many potentially have useful skills and educational backgrounds.
After an initial annoyance I think that Cameron has pretty much played the right card in this situation. We should respect our long standing position on refugees. However, this country is in dire straits in terms of housing even its own inhabitants and national policies need to take account of realities on the ground. No country will operate policies that are significantly against there own self interest. So do the Conservatives have a policy that is going to redress the housing crisis and ridiculously inflated prices of rents and property prices? Neither them or Labour really did anything about this during the last 17 years (when prices were rising into the 'absurdly' high). I don't for a minute think the Conservatives are going to shoot themselves in the foot by introducing Rent Caps or build sufficient low cost council maintained properties to tackle the market demand.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 16 Sep 2015 11.00am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Sep 2015 2.22pm
Quote since1953 at 15 Sep 2015 1.03pm
I see your point but: The refugees that are taken on will eventually apply for full citizenship. No way will they want to return to Syria/Afghanistan etc after the fighting. As I have said before tracking them down and deporting them will be expensive and difficult. That isn't represented in the data sets though, it seems that the UK migration rate is about 300,000 or so more than the UK emigration rates each year. I'd see this as unsustainable, as any kind of long term strategy, especially given the impact it has had on wages in the UK (here the demand makes sense, given the strength of the pound against the Euro). Whilst I'm left wing, I see the use of the Free Movement as a means by which cheap labour has been shifted around the EU and has driven down wages for the working class and upper working classes (and to a lesser extent middle classes of the UK). Refugees on the other hand traditionally do generally end up becoming long term citizens, I don't see a case where by they will be able to return to Syria, so the prospect of them becoming a cheap labour force that drives down wages doesn't exist. Admitedly, they'll have longer term costs in terms of health care, but also greater based UK spending and long term engagement, as well as providing a potential boon for the intelligence services - an influx of people who speak both English and Arabic, many of who have been driven out by groups such as IS. As a rule Refugees have a great history of integration and loyalty in their first two generations The spike in Syrian refugees as boat migrants, has been driven particularly from the Syrian middle classes, which means that many potentially have useful skills and educational backgrounds.
After an initial annoyance I think that Cameron has pretty much played the right card in this situation. We should respect our long standing position on refugees. However, this country is in dire straits in terms of housing even its own inhabitants and national policies need to take account of realities on the ground. Germany's population is going down......They need migrants but......after a couple of idealistic comments they are now obviously aware of the potential for swamping. No country will operate policies that are significantly against there own self interest. I think Germany is happy to take 800,000 Refugees, I think its less keen on the idea of taking 800,000 new migrants - which is why they want to take them from camps. A consequence of the Syrian and Libyan refugees moving freely, is that they make a great means by which illegal migrants and economic migrants can also move country.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.