|
quote]leggedstruggle at 18 Aug 2015 5.50pm
The USA started from a 'clean sheet', did not have established race, language, religion and culture - apart from the indigenous population who were more of less 'ethnically cleansed' (you would have thought they would have welcomed the vibrant diversity of the immigrants wouldn't you?) The USA does indeed have communities of different races etc. They get on well don't they? No suggestion of racial tensions, riots etc? Also, each nationality revels in their particular 'heritage' - ask the American Irish or Italians what nationality they identify with.
The USA started from a 'clean sheet', did not have established race, language, religion and culture - apart from the indigenous population who were more of less 'ethnically cleansed' (you would have thought they would have welcomed the vibrant diversity of the immigrants wouldn't you?) The USA does indeed have communities of different races etc. They get on well don't they? No suggestion of racial tensions, riots etc? Also, each nationality revels in their particular 'heritage' - ask the American Irish or Italians what nationality they identify with.
Canada? The English speaking Canadians get on really well with the French speakers don't they? No calls for an independent French state within Canada is there?
Australia of course ethnically cleansed its indigenous population and is now experiencing the usual problems of mass immigration of people of different race, religion, language and culture.
British Empire ended peacefully? What apart from America, Canada, Ireland, South Africa, India, Malaya, Cyprus, Kenya, Southern Rhodesia, Palestine, etc
....................................................
USA? started from a clean sheet?Yes a clean sheet of existing established cultures and languages and religions,largely geographically separate.
Very established Spanish culture and language in the South West and California. French culture established in Louisiana (Louisiana law based on French law to this day).British on the east cost
Race issues are very much due to the perversity of slavery and its lingering effects.Not the artificial creation of the USA based on people of differing ethnicities,language and religion per se.
As for present -day Canada? No,I'd say generally now a belief in a united Canada as the way forward.A main reason? policy of multiculturalism.Also,another generally stunning example of immigration from, all over the place within the past 60 years and policies of multi culturalism.
Have you lived in Australia?I have.Its also generally a stunning example of successful mass immigration over the past 60 years of people from all over the place.
Of course there were violent uprisings within the British Empire.I took issue with your statement that such was largely the outcome.And even your list of "insurrections" is wrong.Take S Africa.Empire didn't end because of an insurrection.Rather a conscious decision decades later to grant dominion status and later a revulsion following the introduction post 1948-1950's of apartheid. Your other example of the USA is misplaced.The origins of that"insurrection" were about tax not nationalism.
Edited by legaleagle (18 Aug 2015 6.11pm)
|