This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
1. Why would he undermine public trust in media that backs him? And calling it 'free' by the way is inaccurate as they are mouthpieces for their owners. 2. A distinction with no serious difference. 3. And the evidence it is always their parents is? This policy was fine with Democrats before Trump. Hi stirlingsays, thanks for your reply. I'm not trying to get into a trump vs biden discussion, I just wanted to point out what a terribly written article this was. 1. That doesnt contradict my point. The article is saying the Biden and trump have treated the media the same but they havent. Trump tried to undermine a press that was critical of him, hence the comparison to nzism. Biden hasn't done that which is why no one is calling him one. I understand your point about free media, a discussion for another day when I've got a beer to hand! 2. There is a moral argument there eg the conditions for a 'just war' etc, but again, maybe another time! Since neither action is closely related to nazzism, this is a red herring in the original article. That should have been my original criticism of it but there were so many to choose from! 3. I dont know if that's true but either way it doesnt contradict my point. The article is a comparison of President Trump vs president Biden not president trump vs pre-2016 Democrats. Regarding if it is their parents or not, even if some of the children weren't with their own real parents, the point still stands. The other children were forcibly separated from their own real parents. And that is why trump was compared to Hitler and co, and biden wasn't.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Seagles
Hi stirlingsays, thanks for your reply. I'm not trying to get into a trump vs biden discussion, I just wanted to point out what a terribly written article this was. 1. That doesnt contradict my point. The article is saying the Biden and trump have treated the media the same but they havent. Trump tried to undermine a press that was critical of him, hence the comparison to nzism. Biden hasn't done that which is why no one is calling him one. I understand your point about free media, a discussion for another day when I've got a beer to hand! I explained why Biden hasn't treated the press the same and myself I think that's kind of relevant as a difference between the two. Anyone who called Trump a Nazi was always an idiot...especially considering his main donors were Jews. Originally posted by Seagles
2. There is a moral argument there eg the conditions for a 'just war' etc, but again, maybe another time! Since neither action is closely related to nazzism, this is a red herring in the original article. That should have been my original criticism of it but there were so many to choose from! Fair enough. Originally posted by Seagles
3. I dont know if that's true but either way it doesnt contradict my point. The article is a comparison of President Trump vs president Biden not president trump vs pre-2016 Democrats. Regarding if it is their parents or not, even if some of the children weren't with their own real parents, the point still stands. The other children were forcibly separated from their own real parents. And that is why trump was compared to Hitler and co, and biden wasn't. As Biden was vice president all the way through these years where the exact same policy was enacted so I view it as relevant myself. And sorry I don't think the point still stands and in cases of child abuse and sexual exploitation, which often come with Stockholm syndrome. It's a very serious issue. This separation wasn't done for jokes but because of realities on the ground that many don't wish to recognise. Also, any comparison to Hitler that anyone made with this is pure hyperbole. Hitler would have had them all shot and probably anyone of lower rank who complained about it. If Hitler had been the US president the illegal immigrant situation would have quickly and brutally resolved in a fashion none of us would have supported.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As Biden was vice president all the way through these years where the exact same policy was enacted so I view it as relevant myself. And sorry I don't think the point still stands and in cases of child abuse and sexual exploitation, which often come with Stockholm syndrome. It's a very serious issue. This separation wasn't done for jokes but because of realities on the ground that many don't wish to recognise. Also, any comparison to Hitler that anyone made with this is pure hyperbole. Hitler would have had them all shot and probably anyone of lower rank who complained about it. If Hitler had been the US president the illegal immigrant situation would have quickly and brutally resolved in a fashion none of us would have supported. It's a bit useless complaining about the nazi comparisons as that is literally what the article is about. I didn't know if what you said previously about the democrats immigration policy was true or not and since you have brought it up again I looked into it - it isn't. I am sure there were some families separated some times, but it was the trump administration that made it policy to separate children from their families. Trump's attorney general Jeff sessions said, "I have put in place a “zero tolerance” policy for illegal entry on our Southwest border. If you cross this border unlawfully, then we will prosecute you. It’s that simple... If you are smuggling a child, then we will prosecute you and that child will be separated from you" [Link] This is completely different from the previous administrataions policy when family detention centres were purpose built to avoid it, [Link] and indeed the current one's as acknowledged in the article being discussed So back to my original point which is that the author of the article is deliberatly misleading the readers when he attempts to equate the two.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
Fellow posters, a little advice, if you don't mind. I've not used italics before. Which one of these is most appropriate? a) That's not Biden b) That's not Biden or c) That's not Biden Personally I really like "a" and "b" is a corker too. My feeling is "c" isn't quite right. But that's just me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Seagles
It's a bit useless complaining about the nazi comparisons as that is literally what the article is about. I didn't know if what you said previously about the democrats immigration policy was true or not and since you have brought it up again I looked into it - it isn't. I am sure there were some families separated some times, but it was the trump administration that made it policy to separate children from their families. Trump's attorney general Jeff sessions said, "I have put in place a “zero tolerance” policy for illegal entry on our Southwest border. If you cross this border unlawfully, then we will prosecute you. It’s that simple... If you are smuggling a child, then we will prosecute you and that child will be separated from you" [Link] This is completely different from the previous administrataions policy when family detention centres were purpose built to avoid it, [Link] and indeed the current one's as acknowledged in the article being discussed So back to my original point which is that the author of the article is deliberatly misleading the readers when he attempts to equate the two. I must admit it's probably a personal failing that I didn't read the article in question.....I just wanted to argue some points. Still, you seem a well meaning fellow who made some reasonable points which you bothered to research.....So I tip my hat sir.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Absolute clusterf*** of US foreign policy the past few days, namely against China, Russia and North Korea. Russia: Biden goads Putin. Putin recalls ambassador, wishes Biden "the best of health" (code: we know you're senile). Then challenges him to a 1-on-1 debade, no censors, live. Checkmate China: Outright body-bags amateur Blinken in the Alaska meeting. Blinken had no response (nor did the purple-haired woman in the background) and no counter to their statements. Made to look feeble and weak, and utterly outclassed. Who the hell appointed this muppet? North Korea: despite attempts to open dialogue with the leadership there, Biden has been rebuffed. Rocket Man doesn't respond to weaklings. Refuses to have any contact with the US lines of communication. ...and as if to underscore the whole sorry state of affairs, Biden... well... apart from the "President Harris" goof... well, he did this, right as Russia and China are lauging at how weak he is: [Tweet Link]
Weak. We need a strong US. We have a feeble shell of a president that is clearly being handled. But yeah, Orange Man bad.
|
|
|
China will be looking at Biden across the table and leaving him in no doubt that the USA position is not one of strength anymore.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Biden always looked like he's wearing someone elses teeth, now he's got someone elses feet too.
|
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Absolute clusterf*** of US foreign policy the past few days, namely against China, Russia and North Korea. Russia: Biden goads Putin. Putin recalls ambassador, wishes Biden "the best of health" (code: we know you're senile). Then challenges him to a 1-on-1 debade, no censors, live. Checkmate China: Outright body-bags amateur Blinken in the Alaska meeting. Blinken had no response (nor did the purple-haired woman in the background) and no counter to their statements. Made to look feeble and weak, and utterly outclassed. Who the hell appointed this muppet? North Korea: despite attempts to open dialogue with the leadership there, Biden has been rebuffed. Rocket Man doesn't respond to weaklings. Refuses to have any contact with the US lines of communication. ...and as if to underscore the whole sorry state of affairs, Biden... well... apart from the "President Harris" goof... well, he did this, right as Russia and China are lauging at how weak he is: [Tweet Link]
Weak. We need a strong US. We have a feeble shell of a president that is clearly being handled. But yeah, Orange Man bad. Yep, it's an absolute clusterfeck. This is the guy they preferred and what happens from it is on them. Still, no mean tweets, so....you know, thank god for that.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
On Wednesday, his press secretary Jen Psaki announced that Biden would finally hold a press conference on 25th March. The ABC interview will not have reassured his advisors. Stephanopoulus pitched the gentlest of underarm lobs – “You think he’s a killer?” – and Biden swung and missed: “Uh-huh. I do.” When Stephanopoulos asked how Biden would make Putin “pay”, Biden floundered. The transcript reads like a man trying to remove his foot from his mouth. “The price he's gonna pay we'll – you'll see shortly. I'm not gonna – there's – by the way, we oughta be able that ol' – that trite expression ‘walk and chew gum at the same time’, there're places where it's in our mutual interest to work together.” If Trump had said that then can you imagine the stick he'd be getting. Unbelievable.....you tell a leader like Putin he's 'gonna pay' and then you say you're going to work together on issues of mutual interest. What a fecking idiot.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
On Wednesday, his press secretary Jen Psaki announced that Biden would finally hold a press conference on 25th March. The ABC interview will not have reassured his advisors. Stephanopoulus pitched the gentlest of underarm lobs – “You think he’s a killer?” – and Biden swung and missed: “Uh-huh. I do.” When Stephanopoulos asked how Biden would make Putin “pay”, Biden floundered. The transcript reads like a man trying to remove his foot from his mouth. “The price he's gonna pay we'll – you'll see shortly. I'm not gonna – there's – by the way, we oughta be able that ol' – that trite expression ‘walk and chew gum at the same time’, there're places where it's in our mutual interest to work together.” A lovely birthday present for me then.
|
|
|
I called it while back - President Harris by Christmas.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nead1
And the alternative view is that he has made a very good start and arguably the best "first 100 days" of any President for a very long time; got his stimulus bill through Congress, rightly called out the behaviour of so called strong men around the world, displays a strong/informed world view and perhaps most importantly is a steady hand on both Government and the associated judgements required.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by nead1
Re the stimulus, it begs the question why Trump did not get on and do it rather than spending his time peddling endless theories about rigged election results. The rather obvious answer to that is that the Democrats stopped him....you obviously don't really follow US politics that closely.....Nancy Pelosi put up a number of barriers with the obvious intent of delaying until after the election. Originally posted by nead1
As to calling out the tyrants of the world - especially Putin - he has been working against the US and the West more generally for years. Just look at the cyber attack on the Pentagon, again trying to interfere in the electoral process and the numerous murders of opponents both within and outside Russia. For a really good background read, I would refer you to "Putin's people - how the KGB took back Russia and then took on the west" by Catherine Belton. Also includes a very insightful chapter on "the network and Trump". Well, I wouldn't disagree with you on aspects of Putin....However, while Russia is a major power we mustn't forget that it also has the economy of California. The far more important threat is China. On all the aspects you mention, cyber attacks, human rights it makes Russia pale into insignificance. Also economically it has the power to corrupt and invest into infrastructure which you rely upon...and hence blackmail and bully countries....Russia also has this ability with piped gas (which needs to change). However, China is investing and gaining influence in multiple continents and it's decidedly anti western. Yet you just swallow the Democrat's line, because corrupt people like Biden have had ties to China and other corrupt countries for decades. One of his first acts in, what you regard as a good 100 days was to allow China back into US infrastructure. As for election interference....didn't the Democrats spend tens of millions on that trying to impeach Trump for years...wasting valuable state time, only to end up with nothing but 'orange man bad'. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Mar 2021 1.02pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by nead1
Actually, you are quite wrong - I do follow/have studied US politics closely and I don't "just swallow Democrat lines". My views are my own formed ones and I certainly don't share your comment re Biden being corrupt - pretty rich given the behaviour of his predecessor!
As for reading leftist books on Trump, it would have to be a leftist I respect and while I disagreed with him I did that with Bob Woodward's book. In terms of interference I can only direct you to my previous comments....tens of millions spent and years of state time for no result. I've had the leftist perspective up to here and it's been in control for decades so I see the ruinous damage it does everyday. So forgive me but I'll take a pass. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Mar 2021 2.55pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.