You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Sorloth thread


Page 49 of 54 < 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 27 Feb 20 7.31pm

Originally posted by ger20

The Turkish league is a piss poor league. Everton payed £27 million for Tosun and look how that ended.

Tosun looks like he could be OK for us. He's even scored.

 


Red and Blue Army!

dg1937 Flag 27 Feb 20 9.11pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Err, the ones hes made already on about 3 posts.

Try reading the thread properly, just saying.

I think he has implied that we should never have let Sorloth go because he is banging in goals in the Turkish league.

I think he has suggested that because scoring goals is all about confidence, RH should have shown more confidence in him. But it has been pointed out that Maine Eagle himself described Sorloth as a dreadful signing.

I think he has implied that because Sorloth showed little sign of improving during his time here RH must not have coached him properly. But he himself has said that Ayew is a much improved player this season. I'm curious to know what Maine Eagle thinks lies behind this transformation.

My main complaint is that people who slagged Sorloth off at the time (I was one of them) are on dodgy ground if they now complain that we should have kept him.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 28 Feb 20 6.43am

Originally posted by dg1937

I think he has implied that we should never have let Sorloth go because he is banging in goals in the Turkish league.

I think he has suggested that because scoring goals is all about confidence, RH should have shown more confidence in him. But it has been pointed out that Maine Eagle himself described Sorloth as a dreadful signing.

I think he has implied that because Sorloth showed little sign of improving during his time here RH must not have coached him properly. But he himself has said that Ayew is a much improved player this season. I'm curious to know what Maine Eagle thinks lies behind this transformation.

My main complaint is that people who slagged Sorloth off at the time (I was one of them) are on dodgy ground if they now complain that we should have kept him.

Sorloth still hasn't proved himself, not really. But I think there's been a failure among football fans at large to appreciate how hard it can be for some young players to come into English football at its highest tier and impose themselves with limited, stop-start minutes, the glaring judgment of fans, battling for a place against incumbent player who might be inferior but knows the ropes.

Sorloth's body language wasn't right, he never moved like a player who belonged, and always looked uneasy.

To my eye, it always seemed worth a proper look. The difficulty is that when you're battling relegation, when a single place in the PL is worth so much £££, it's nigh impossible to take the long view.

If the club really has ballsed up his loan (and effectively sold him), I would be disappointed but understanding. There's a litany of better players than Sorloth who've done this. Sometimes a player clicks, sometimes not.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Feb 20 7.49am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

The person in charge of these things is one Mr D Freedmam. He is where this whole fiasco started and should end with him being sacked for gross incompetence.

OK send the guy on loan and OK maybe offer an option to but but to do a 2 year loan where we have no right of recall or indeed any rights at all is just negligent.

This fiasco has also probably tainted all other transfer dealings as people must look at us whenever we want to buy or sell and think you don't know what you are doing

Mind you we prove that again and again in the market.


How do you know Dougie did this deal? Even if he lined it up I’m assuming it will have been sanctioned by SP and probably RH. very unlikely he makes decisions on how much we sell a player for,length of loan etc. I would suspect he lines up the deals and then gets them approved. However, if you are right, then the whole transfer policy needs looking at. Having said that, at the time who would have questioned the deal? Maybe we could have got a percentage of any sell on, but I doubt it and who would have questioned the sale price?
Conversely, look at Ayew. What would he fetch now. Again I’m assuming his transfer fee was approved by minimum SP.
I find it frustrating Palace don’t publish better clearer detail to the fans on transfer deals. They love skinning us lot, so how about upping the gold membership fee and offering gold members a clear concise uptdate of done deals every quarter?
( and offering some decent more expensive food inthe kiosks. I’m sure the players don’t get fed the crap on offernow)


Edited by dreamwaverider (28 Feb 2020 7.57am)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 29 Feb 20 1.08pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

It matters not a jot whether he is scoring for fun or not as he is not our player. He is on loan with an option to purchase at a fixed price. There is no return clause unless of course they wish to return him. So all that will happen is that they buy him from us at a figure that has been mooted at around 6m Euro and sell him at a massive profit. There is nothing that can be done about it.

Could you explain in more depth how you know such detail to be true? Genuine question, as there’s just so much talk of this but little detail or substance and I am intrigued to know more of the details of the loan deal.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 29 Feb 20 1.29pm

Massive difference in standard from the Turkish League to the EPL or La Liga

He was utter toilet for us and I just don’t buy the ‘he wasn't given a chance‘ stuff! He looked AWFUL yet was still given Eight starts and Twelve substitute appearances. We persevered with him far longer than we should’ve done, he was that poor!

Neil Warnock sums it up perfectly with this piece from Soccer Saturday today...absolutely priceless!

Video link attached below...

He’s clearly spoken to people in the know about him (from Palace) and they obviously didn’t rate him and I can see why!

He is shocking and nowhere near good enough for top flight football. I don’t ever want him back but it would be nice to get the full transfer fee for him rather than just the left overs after Trabzonspor flog him!


Edited by Phil’s Barber (29 Feb 2020 1.36pm)

Attachment: trim.54BDDD90-0542-4C46-B37B-89A08AF61167.MOV (15,151.96Kb)

 

Jacey Flag 03 Mar 20 2.55pm

Unbelievable, if media reports are true.
Being reported that scouts from Bayen,Man U and many others are planning to watch his scoring exploits this coming weekend.
Never judged a book by it's cover.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 03 Mar 20 4.07pm

What people never point out is how very hard it is for a centre forward in a Palace shirt to score.

If you are a defensive team with few, if any, providers able to place a pass it is hellishly difficult.

Ask Murray, Gayle, Bamford (!) Benteke, Ayew and Tosun.

If we were to persist with someone who can hold and pass the ball (e.g Max Meyer) the true talent of Sorloth might have been revealed.

If he eventually makes it good in the PL our loaning out policy for him will look ludricous and expensive.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 03 Mar 20 5.05pm

Pogba, Dr Bruyne, Salah...sometimes players crap out only for it to dawn that they are worldies...it happens...

Even Collymore back in the day...

People just find a place where they feel right and that's when you see what they are capable of

No shame in it, just a pity

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Mar 20 6.37pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Pogba, Dr Bruyne, Salah...sometimes players crap out only for it to dawn that they are worldies...it happens...

Even Collymore back in the day...

People just find a place where they feel right and that's when you see what they are capable of

No shame in it, just a pity

True but we have f***ed up big time with our loan policy. Surely you loan out players to give them game time and monitor their progress, a 2 year loan with no recall option beggars belief

 

harleygrove Flag Uckfield, East Sussex 03 Mar 20 6.51pm

He is at it again tonight. Can't stop scoring. Should have given him a proper go at Palace

 

Robk Flag 03 Mar 20 7.25pm

Can't believe we've done such a stupid deal....thought our Chairman was smart... Just shows you he wasn't given a proper chance and some people are going to end up having egg on their face 's here....I feel we have similar players here ... Jairo and Max ... Just hope they don't make the same error....

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Mar 20 8.06am

Originally posted by Uphill

What people never point out is how very hard it is for a centre forward in a Palace shirt to score.

If you are a defensive team with few, if any, providers able to place a pass it is hellishly difficult.


We do have "providers able to place a pass" but unfortunately they tend not to make the playing 11

 

Jaha Flag 05 Mar 20 5.53pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sorloth to man united ' by becky

Just read this article with a statement from his agent saying we have agreed a right to buy with the Turkish club he plays for. Been smashing them in this year for them. It’s an undisclosed fee. Does anyone know if we now have to accept their money and sell him if they want Him now? Bet the fee is too low!

Begs the question though, has freedman actually found a worldwide here and is hodgson at fault for not utilising him correctly? Or is it just the league he’s in and all these rumours linking him to bigger clubs are a load of agent chat?


[Link]

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 05 Mar 20 6.28pm

More evidence of our clownish transfer approach. We should be recalling our most in-form striker right now to replace Tosun. Except we can't because some idiot didn't put a contract clause in.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Mar 20 6.33pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

More evidence of our clownish transfer approach. We should be recalling our most in-form striker right now to replace Tosun. Except we can't because some idiot didn't put a contract clause in.

No, but we could extend and seriously improve his deal and price out competition.

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 05 Mar 20 6.40pm

so sorloth has gone from a donkey to a world beater because he is playing in a crap league??

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 Mar 20 7.08pm

Originally posted by chris123

No, but we could extend and seriously improve his deal and price out competition.

How does that work then.
I thought 2 year loan and no recall.
Can we really extend it, and does that trump a buy out clause at the end?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Mar 20 7.24pm

Originally posted by cryrst

How does that work then.
I thought 2 year loan and no recall.
Can we really extend it, and does that trump a buy out clause at the end?

Shouldn't affect his contract with us. The buyout must be an option the player wants too, so seriously enhance his current deal and price out competition.

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 05 Mar 20 8.26pm

If the Turkish team have an option to buy (€6k I believe) they could buy him and sell him on for a hefty profit -assuming he keeps scoring for them - and nothing we could do - except ask him nicely to ignore that and come on back!

 

Page 49 of 54 < 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread