You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 49 of 71 < 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 >
Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 21 Nov 18 12.19pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

This doesn't suprise me. They're not going to want to be at the back of the stand . Imagine what's going to happen when we score and the players run behind the goal to celebrate with them. There's going to be an almighty crush as the HF run down to the front.
Just waiting for the announcement that the new singing section will actually be a narrower section running from front to back ....

My guess is that the HF are not happy about how it's been handled and want to make sure those effected are properly compensated. Either a better deal from the club for those who have been told to move, or still pushing for the full lower tier reset (which is a fairer option for the long standing ST holders). I know there is a certain perception of the HF on here, but I know them to be considerate and genuinely trying to do whats best for the club and not just themselves. They will want to minimise any ill feeling so that all Palace fans are with them.

To suggest they will run down 20 rows to celebrate with the players and cause a crush is nonsense, a wind up. The back of the stand has better acoustics with the overhanging roof (similar to the AW) which will generate more noise. they will also be standing for 90 minutes (seperate debate, but it happens at all grounds, just accept it) and standing at the front will cause problems for those who would want to sit behind them. Standing at the front of block B has never been an issue as block B has always been a 'standing area' even before the HF were there.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Nov 18 12.29pm

Originally posted by Painter

From your posts you are obviously very passionate about the issue, but there are some points your missing.
The only way we will stop being a small South London clubs is to win football matches, it’s that simple. Nobody cares how much noise the crowd makes, as it is irrelevant, it’s results that matter.
Crowds fluctuate from year to year, so no point hanging your hat on a small group of supporters, who can disappear at any time. Which they appear to have done already.
The majority of supporters go the a football match to watch the game, whether it’s in the Premier or non league. Being told your no longer wanted as you don’t sing enough, just sounds crazy.

They haven’t been told they’re not wanted because they don’t sing and that and it isn’t the case. They’re being moved seats. They and it have been handled badly but I don’t think it’s intended or because they aren’t valued. I think it’s because CPFC, with whatever year is named after it have always been poor with anything more than the basic, they haven’t handled any of this well from the start remember, and Parish isn’t as multi skilled as some think, and it comes across as him not giving a fvck, when really it’s because he doesn’t have the skills to handle it or anyone employed to either.

 


COYP

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 21 Nov 18 12.39pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

This doesn't suprise me. They're not going to want to be at the back of the stand . Imagine what's going to happen when we score and the players run behind the goal to celebrate with them. There's going to be an almighty crush as the HF run down to the front.
Just waiting for the announcement that the new singing section will actually be a narrower section running from front to back ....

Initially there was a stated desire to emulate what was so impactful at Wembley for the Semi & Final. On both occasions they were located at the rear of the lower tier yet were still very visible.

Being at the back minimises the impact on fans in blocks either side & might actually avoid the entire LH having to stand up for extended periods.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 21 Nov 18 12.43pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

FFS

It's Hampton, OK?

What a load of old pony. Have a butcher's at a fish hook or ask a Julius Caesar my old manhole cover.

Edited by Mapletree (20 Nov 2018 6.02pm)

Hampton is prick.

(Hampton Wick)

 


All good. Nothing bad.

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 21 Nov 18 12.58pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It wouldn’t be a bad move to do that. You could put the current front half of E at the back of B and the current back of B at the back of E which will effectively be a B block move into E block.

On yer bike.

Why should I move from the back of B?

 


All good. Nothing bad.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Nov 18 12.58pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

My guess is that the HF are not happy about how it's been handled and want to make sure those effected are properly compensated. Either a better deal from the club for those who have been told to move, or still pushing for the full lower tier reset (which is a fairer option for the long standing ST holders). I know there is a certain perception of the HF on here, but I know them to be considerate and genuinely trying to do whats best for the club and not just themselves. They will want to minimise any ill feeling so that all Palace fans are with them.

To suggest they will run down 20 rows to celebrate with the players and cause a crush is nonsense, a wind up. The back of the stand has better acoustics with the overhanging roof (similar to the AW) which will generate more noise. they will also be standing for 90 minutes (seperate debate, but it happens at all grounds, just accept it) and standing at the front will cause problems for those who would want to sit behind them. Standing at the front of block B has never been an issue as block B has always been a 'standing area' even before the HF were there.

There’s already standing at the front of block E.

 


COYP

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 21 Nov 18 12.59pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Relegtion will solve all the poblems re seats being available. The HF wil have half of Selhurst Park to choose fromalthough doubt what atmosphere there will be wont be much wih only 10000 or so in the ground for most macthe' Parish should stop farting around with this singing section and concentrate all his efforts on the football side of things ie the scouting set up etc and the January window to enure we sty in the PL.

The atmosphere was good when we were in the Championship, most would actually say better then in the PL.

Attendances were usually higher than 10,000 then, not sure why you think that they would drop that dramatically.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Nov 18 1.01pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

Initially there was a stated desire to emulate what was so impactful at Wembley for the Semi & Final. On both occasions they were located at the rear of the lower tier yet were still very visible.

Being at the back minimises the impact on fans in blocks either side & might actually avoid the entire LH having to stand up for extended periods.

There’s already standing at the front of E. As things stand there’ll be standing behind them. I don’t know if there’ll be some sitting in between. It wouldn’t surprise me.

 


COYP

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 21 Nov 18 1.09pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There’s already standing at the front of E. As things stand there’ll be standing behind them. I don’t know if there’ll be some sitting in between. It wouldn’t surprise me.

I didn't think it was all game though? Doesn't seem to be from where I am.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

bicycle repair man 21 Nov 18 1.16pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Relegtion will solve all the poblems re seats being available. The HF wil have half of Selhurst Park to choose fromalthough doubt what atmosphere there will be wont be much wih only 10000 or so in the ground for most macthe' Parish should stop farting around with this singing section and concentrate all his efforts on the football side of things ie the scouting set up etc and the January window to enure we sty in the PL.

Absolutely,well said.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Nov 18 1.24pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

I didn't think it was all game though? Doesn't seem to be from where I am.

No. Occasional standing and only on the right side as you look at the pitch

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Nov 18 1.26pm

Originally posted by turbohorsebox

Hampton is prick.

(Hampton Wick)

Can you say that word on this site?

That is the correct rhyming slang for the male appendage being discussed, yes.

An alternative is Corn on the Cob. Don't hear that very often.

 

Pompyeagle Flag Gosport Hants 21 Nov 18 3.34pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Can you say that word on this site?

That is the correct rhyming slang for the male appendage being discussed, yes.

An alternative is Corn on the Cob. Don't hear that very often.

What a load of "Pony" this thread is

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Nov 18 4.26pm

Originally posted by topcat

The atmosphere was good when we were in the Championship, most would actually say better then in the PL.

Attendances were usually higher than 10,000 then, not sure why you think that they would drop that dramatically.

In the Championship we tended to do far better at home than we have done in the PL of late.

In our last season in the Championship we only lost 2 Home league games out of 23 matches,the season before that we lost 5 at Home and the season before that we lost 6 at home.The team haven't given us too much to get excited about at home of late !

 

est1905 Flag 21 Nov 18 5.31pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

My guess is that the HF are not happy about how it's been handled and want to make sure those effected are properly compensated. Either a better deal from the club for those who have been told to move, or still pushing for the full lower tier reset (which is a fairer option for the long standing ST holders). I know there is a certain perception of the HF on here, but I know them to be considerate and genuinely trying to do whats best for the club and not just themselves. They will want to minimise any ill feeling so that all Palace fans are with them.

To suggest they will run down 20 rows to celebrate with the players and cause a crush is nonsense, a wind up. The back of the stand has better acoustics with the overhanging roof (similar to the AW) which will generate more noise. they will also be standing for 90 minutes (seperate debate, but it happens at all grounds, just accept it) and standing at the front will cause problems for those who would want to sit behind them. Standing at the front of block B has never been an issue as block B has always been a 'standing area' even before the HF were there.

They dont seem overly bothered about taking over their seats so I'd seriously doubt they give a damn about 'proper compensation'

 

Glazed Over Flag Sevenoaks 21 Nov 18 5.49pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

To allow the singing section to grow and to emulate the Ultra's of some of the European teams, remember how it looked at sounded at Wembley ? imagine that at every home game.

To Improve on the atmosphere at Selhurst getting it back to how it used to be and moving on to make it even better.

To generate revenue for the club in HF Merchandise, Whether you agree or like them is immaterial the HF could well be a valuable marketable commodity for the club to exploit, paying members etc etc all good stuff.

They have been around 13 years and are a very established part of our support that are very Vocal and put there hands in their own pockets for displays etc that we all enjoy and are proud of. Surely the hard work they put in for Match days gives them some credence over Your average supporter (myself included).

But the main reason, is that it will be for the good and benefit for the club as whole, yes some people such as the people on here who refuse to debate and just insult me , may have to move seats, and personally I see that as a small price to pay for improving the atmosphere making it the best in the premiership and the envy of every other club in the UK.

And I am sorry to say the small mindedness of a few on here is exactly why we will always be a small club in South London if they had their way. It's almost as if because they've been going for a number of years it gives them some higher power and importance over other fans who actually dig deep for the club, which is exactly what they accuse the HF of.

The HF could be a very marketable brand for the club and I think SP is well aware of that, and in this premiership era money talks loudest of all.

I really feel for George and Mildred who have sat there for years and been (quiet) loyal supporters, but times change, things move on and standing in the way of progress is a very inward way of looking at things.

Incidentally I would move in a heart beat before you ask. I also have been going to Palace since I was about 6 so been supporting the mighty Palace for 40 odd years, so just as long in tooth as some of the people on here who think SP should hang his head in shame (LOL) but I'm not adverse to change especially if it improves the atmosphere at our club, which currently is flatter than a witches tit.

Thanks for an clear and honest response of your opinions.

Just think we'll have to disagree about the 'marketable brand' that is the HF. I think they'll struggle to find 400 singers prepared to commit to a ST in Block E. I also believe their 'Ultras' viewpoint is a million miles away from the vast majority of English football fans in the Premier League era.

But then again, I could be wrong!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Nov 18 6.24pm

Originally posted by Glazed Over

Thanks for an clear and honest response of your opinions.

Just think we'll have to disagree about the 'marketable brand' that is the HF. I think they'll struggle to find 400 singers prepared to commit to a ST in Block E. I also believe their 'Ultras' viewpoint is a million miles away from the vast majority of English football fans in the Premier League era.

But then again, I could be wrong!

Respectfully I have to disagree

There will be a 200 person waiting list once they've filled the 400. Probably many people not really suited to it but this is the new sexy.

And I reckon this will be the future for many copycat clubs. Watch Huddersfield and Watford. Leicester has been desperate to do this for ages. Whoever shows the way, there will be many on their tails.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Nov 2018 6.26pm)

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 21 Nov 18 7.20pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Respectfully I have to disagree

There will be a 200 person waiting list once they've filled the 400. Probably many people not really suited to it but this is the new sexy.

And I reckon this will be the future for many copycat clubs. Watch Huddersfield and Watford. Leicester has been desperate to do this for ages. Whoever shows the way, there will be many on their tails.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Nov 2018 6.26pm)


I have you right on that. I see other Premier League clubs copying Palace on this pretty quickly as they have done previously.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Nov 18 8.33pm

Originally posted by turbohorsebox

On yer bike.

Why should I move from the back of B?

To the back of E. So a better view. Okay?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Nov 18 8.41pm

Originally posted by Glazed Over

Thanks for an clear and honest response of your opinions.

Just think we'll have to disagree about the 'marketable brand' that is the HF. I think they'll struggle to find 400 singers prepared to commit to a ST in Block E. I also believe their 'Ultras' viewpoint is a million miles away from the vast majority of English football fans in the Premier League era.

But then again, I could be wrong!

As already said, you are wrong. This kind of thing is popular with younger age groups and older fans who want to sing will only want to and have to be on the edges. Being on the edges at Wembley was perfect. Unfortunately there’s no option for that. There’ll be 400 singers surrounded by silent sitters in F,G,H and silent standers in D and most of C. You’d easily fill 3 blocks and some of it was done properly but I understand why Parish may not feel comfortable doing it, although I suspect it could be because he and the club don’t want to or can’t be bothered.

 


COYP

Page 49 of 71 < 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic