You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Jews
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace Jews


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Jan 14 8.54pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 8.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Greenham Common? Reading Uni? Blimey SE9 you must be nearly 50.

Steady on chap - you'll have a hearty.

I am 50 but still the scourge of the left!Problem with people like Syd n Seth(sounds like a lovely couple!)is that cant see a wind up.Im quite happy to say the most extreme things to get them wetting the bed tonight!Im still on the right and make no apologies for that.


I think you let the cat out of the bag too early...
Still a right wing nutjob is a right wing nutjob

 

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 9.03pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Jan 2014 8.54pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 8.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Greenham Common? Reading Uni? Blimey SE9 you must be nearly 50.

Steady on chap - you'll have a hearty.

I am 50 but still the scourge of the left!Problem with people like Syd n Seth(sounds like a lovely couple!)is that cant see a wind up.Im quite happy to say the most extreme things to get them wetting the bed tonight!Im still on the right and make no apologies for that.


I think you let the cat out of the bag too early...
Still a right wing nutjob is a right wing nutjob

You lot dont like a few home truths do you?Once your arguments and brittle humour fall apart Im a w#####r,nutjob etc.Make your own mind up about things rather than following the herd and get a sense of humour.Anyway isnt it about time you started a thread about more muslims at Palace-maybe a reading of the Koran at half time rather than the Crystals!

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 21 Jan 14 9.03pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 7.37am

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am

When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.

Unbelievable

[/quo
Think ths just goes to clarify my point,in the importance of intention and recieving the message. The whole post was actually saying the if the non Jewish Spurs fans feel they should defend the Jewish spurs fans from Anti-Semtic abuse calling themselfes Yid Army I've no problem with it as long as the Jewish Spurs fans haven't got a problem with that. The line you have taken is out of context of the whole post and implies I think singng songs abou gas chambers is honourable which I clearly don't.
Sorry I'll try to make that clearer next time but it seemed fairly obvious in the context of the whole post.
I'm hoping it has been a misunderstanding otherwise it implies you find defending people from abuse is unbelievable.
In addition and being properly PC I do accept that Jewish Spurs fans do not rely on Non Jewish Spurs to defend their honour.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 14 9.03pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 8.03pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 6.40pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jan 2014 6.35pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 5.58pm

A spirited rant, but what's it got to do with what I asked?

Well, Seth, you generously invited him to make a complete fool of himself and it appears that he has speedily accepted your invitation. Words fail me, but I think if you were looking for a cogent response, you may be waiting a while.

I make you right syd. There may be just a little too much froth in his mouth to allow him to speak coherently.


Been to the gym if thats OK.Anyway Ive always enjoyed winding up people like you.Reminds me of my days at Reading University when we use to travel out to Greenham Common to taunt the verminous lesbians who were posing as CND peace women.Ah happy days and a much worthier foe than the pair of you.....

Janitor or gardener?

 

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 9.08pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 9.03pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 8.03pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 6.40pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jan 2014 6.35pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 5.58pm

A spirited rant, but what's it got to do with what I asked?

Well, Seth, you generously invited him to make a complete fool of himself and it appears that he has speedily accepted your invitation. Words fail me, but I think if you were looking for a cogent response, you may be waiting a while.

I make you right syd. There may be just a little too much froth in his mouth to allow him to speak coherently.


Been to the gym if thats OK.Anyway Ive always enjoyed winding up people like you.Reminds me of my days at Reading University when we use to travel out to Greenham Common to taunt the verminous lesbians who were posing as CND peace women.Ah happy days and a much worthier foe than the pair of you.....

Janitor or gardener?


Second class division one degree in medieval history as it happens.They wanted to give me a First but were concerned about my obsession with Genghis Khan and frequent absences to watch Palace away games midweek.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Jan 14 9.13pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.03pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Jan 2014 8.54pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 8.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Greenham Common? Reading Uni? Blimey SE9 you must be nearly 50.

Steady on chap - you'll have a hearty.

I am 50 but still the scourge of the left!Problem with people like Syd n Seth(sounds like a lovely couple!)is that cant see a wind up.Im quite happy to say the most extreme things to get them wetting the bed tonight!Im still on the right and make no apologies for that.


I think you let the cat out of the bag too early...
Still a right wing nutjob is a right wing nutjob

You lot dont like a few home truths do you?Once your arguments and brittle humour fall apart Im a w#####r,nutjob etc.Make your own mind up about things rather than following the herd and get a sense of humour.Anyway isnt it about time you started a thread about more muslims at Palace-maybe a reading of the Koran at half time rather than the Crystals!

I just thought I'd join in with yer cliches.
Home truths? More like ignorant half truths.
Still nice that Dwelboy has been replaced. Are the mods fulfilling quotas? 1 out, 1 in

 

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 9.20pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Jan 2014 9.13pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.03pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Jan 2014 8.54pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 8.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 21 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Greenham Common? Reading Uni? Blimey SE9 you must be nearly 50.

Steady on chap - you'll have a hearty.

I am 50 but still the scourge of the left!Problem with people like Syd n Seth(sounds like a lovely couple!)is that cant see a wind up.Im quite happy to say the most extreme things to get them wetting the bed tonight!Im still on the right and make no apologies for that.


I think you let the cat out of the bag too early...
Still a right wing nutjob is a right wing nutjob

You lot dont like a few home truths do you?Once your arguments and brittle humour fall apart Im a w#####r,nutjob etc.Make your own mind up about things rather than following the herd and get a sense of humour.Anyway isnt it about time you started a thread about more muslims at Palace-maybe a reading of the Koran at half time rather than the Crystals!

I just thought I'd join in with yer cliches.
Home truths? More like ignorant half truths.
Still nice that Dwelboy has been replaced. Are the mods fulfilling quotas? 1 out, 1 in


You would love that wouldnt you?Silence any dissent and I thought we lived in a democracy...

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 21 Jan 14 9.20pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jan 2014 8.58am

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am

It's in the intention and how it is recieved, the intention is that Jewish and non Jewish Spurs fans are supporting the Jewish spurs fans. When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.
However, if the Jewish Spurs Fans are uncomfortable with it, then however honourable the intentions it is misguided.

What the hell do they sing Ketteridge? Some kind of 'we won't forget them' type song?

Sounds like leaning into a punch, setting up opposition fans for some very nasty responses.

And if you really would shout something like 'gas them' EaglesMad then you have a childlike conception of what is acceptable and a complete inability to grasp the shame of our grandparents' generation.

Sorry that misses the wider point of what I was saying. If Spurs fans are singing 'Yid Army' to set up opposition fans for nasty response then the intention is not honourable and therefore not acceptable. The point being that any action is judged by intention and how it received by the recipient and society in general.
Anelka claims he did intended to offend Jew but used the a gesture in support of a friend the general feeling is that the gesture was anti-Semitic and offence.

We also need to stop the thinking that Anti-Semitism, Racism etc is of our grandparents generation but an on going problem.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 9.26pm

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 9.20pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jan 2014 8.58am

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am

It's in the intention and how it is recieved, the intention is that Jewish and non Jewish Spurs fans are supporting the Jewish spurs fans. When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.
However, if the Jewish Spurs Fans are uncomfortable with it, then however honourable the intentions it is misguided.

What the hell do they sing Ketteridge? Some kind of 'we won't forget them' type song?

Sounds like leaning into a punch, setting up opposition fans for some very nasty responses.

And if you really would shout something like 'gas them' EaglesMad then you have a childlike conception of what is acceptable and a complete inability to grasp the shame of our grandparents' generation.

Sorry that misses the wider point of what I was saying. If Spurs fans are singing 'Yid Army' to set up opposition fans for nasty response then the intention is not honourable and therefore not acceptable. The point being that any action is judged by intention and how it received by the recipient and society in general.
Anelka claims he did intended to offend Jew but used the a gesture in support of a friend the general feeling is that the gesture was anti-Semitic and offence.

We also need to stop the thinking that Anti-Semitism, Racism etc is of our grandparents generation but an on going problem.


What was the last time you saw anything racist or anti semitic at Palace?A lot of its in your head.I cant remember one occasion in the last decade at least and maybe longer than that...

 

moaner Flag Westerham 21 Jan 14 9.29pm

Quote Elpis at 20 Jan 2014 10.47pm

No , Im saying nobody gives a monkies


That's not fair on monkeys!

 


Everyone is entitled to my opinions

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 21 Jan 14 9.42pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.26pm

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 9.20pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jan 2014 8.58am

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am

It's in the intention and how it is recieved, the intention is that Jewish and non Jewish Spurs fans are supporting the Jewish spurs fans. When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.
However, if the Jewish Spurs Fans are uncomfortable with it, then however honourable the intentions it is misguided.

What the hell do they sing Ketteridge? Some kind of 'we won't forget them' type song?

Sounds like leaning into a punch, setting up opposition fans for some very nasty responses.

And if you really would shout something like 'gas them' EaglesMad then you have a childlike conception of what is acceptable and a complete inability to grasp the shame of our grandparents' generation.

Sorry that misses the wider point of what I was saying. If Spurs fans are singing 'Yid Army' to set up opposition fans for nasty response then the intention is not honourable and therefore not acceptable. The point being that any action is judged by intention and how it received by the recipient and society in general.
Anelka claims he did intended to offend Jew but used the a gesture in support of a friend the general feeling is that the gesture was anti-Semitic and offence.

We also need to stop the thinking that Anti-Semitism, Racism etc is of our grandparents generation but an on going problem.


What was the last time you saw anything racist or anti semitic at Palace?A lot of its in your head.I cant remember one occasion in the last decade at least and maybe longer than that...

Probably more valid to ask the question to some one who is n't a white bloke but actually I'm not talking about Palace or football but a the general impression that racism or anti semitism stopped with our Grandad's generation. Wish it was in my head but unfortunatley it is not,

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 9.44pm

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 9.42pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.26pm

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 9.20pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jan 2014 8.58am

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am

It's in the intention and how it is recieved, the intention is that Jewish and non Jewish Spurs fans are supporting the Jewish spurs fans. When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.
However, if the Jewish Spurs Fans are uncomfortable with it, then however honourable the intentions it is misguided.

What the hell do they sing Ketteridge? Some kind of 'we won't forget them' type song?

Sounds like leaning into a punch, setting up opposition fans for some very nasty responses.

And if you really would shout something like 'gas them' EaglesMad then you have a childlike conception of what is acceptable and a complete inability to grasp the shame of our grandparents' generation.

Sorry that misses the wider point of what I was saying. If Spurs fans are singing 'Yid Army' to set up opposition fans for nasty response then the intention is not honourable and therefore not acceptable. The point being that any action is judged by intention and how it received by the recipient and society in general.
Anelka claims he did intended to offend Jew but used the a gesture in support of a friend the general feeling is that the gesture was anti-Semitic and offence.

We also need to stop the thinking that Anti-Semitism, Racism etc is of our grandparents generation but an on going problem.


What was the last time you saw anything racist or anti semitic at Palace?A lot of its in your head.I cant remember one occasion in the last decade at least and maybe longer than that...

Probably more valid to ask the question to some one who is n't a white bloke but actually I'm not talking about Palace or football but a the general impression that racism or anti semitism stopped with our Grandad's generation. Wish it was in my head but unfortunatley it is not,

Maybe your crusade doesnt belong on PALACE TALK?

 

thebob Flag Tatebayashi (from Croydon) 21 Jan 14 9.55pm

I think this all boils down to intent. In the case of chanting "Yid army" that is very difficult to establish.

The chant is meant to self identify a group of supporters, not to cast aspersions on a racial/religious group. As such, intent is missing

It is similar to people calling each other "My ******". There are times when the word ****** is a racial taunt and those where it is used in a group for self identification. Yid army is the latter case in my opinion.

Prejudice can't exist without intent, and in this case the intent is to foster group identity, not to promote racial hatred.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 21 Jan 14 9.55pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.44pm

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 9.42pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.26pm

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 9.20pm

Quote Mapletree at 21 Jan 2014 8.58am

Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am

It's in the intention and how it is recieved, the intention is that Jewish and non Jewish Spurs fans are supporting the Jewish spurs fans. When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.
However, if the Jewish Spurs Fans are uncomfortable with it, then however honourable the intentions it is misguided.

What the hell do they sing Ketteridge? Some kind of 'we won't forget them' type song?

Sounds like leaning into a punch, setting up opposition fans for some very nasty responses.

And if you really would shout something like 'gas them' EaglesMad then you have a childlike conception of what is acceptable and a complete inability to grasp the shame of our grandparents' generation.

Sorry that misses the wider point of what I was saying. If Spurs fans are singing 'Yid Army' to set up opposition fans for nasty response then the intention is not honourable and therefore not acceptable. The point being that any action is judged by intention and how it received by the recipient and society in general.
Anelka claims he did intended to offend Jew but used the a gesture in support of a friend the general feeling is that the gesture was anti-Semitic and offence.

We also need to stop the thinking that Anti-Semitism, Racism etc is of our grandparents generation but an on going problem.


What was the last time you saw anything racist or anti semitic at Palace?A lot of its in your head.I cant remember one occasion in the last decade at least and maybe longer than that...

Probably more valid to ask the question to some one who is n't a white bloke but actually I'm not talking about Palace or football but a the general impression that racism or anti semitism stopped with our Grandad's generation. Wish it was in my head but unfortunatley it is not,

Maybe your crusade doesnt belong on PALACE TALK?


The whole thread has only a loosest connection to Palace talk but that is where it is so that's where I'll respond.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 21 Jan 14 9.56pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.08pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 9.03pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 8.03pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 6.40pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jan 2014 6.35pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 5.58pm

A spirited rant, but what's it got to do with what I asked?

Well, Seth, you generously invited him to make a complete fool of himself and it appears that he has speedily accepted your invitation. Words fail me, but I think if you were looking for a cogent response, you may be waiting a while.

I make you right syd. There may be just a little too much froth in his mouth to allow him to speak coherently.


Been to the gym if thats OK.Anyway Ive always enjoyed winding up people like you.Reminds me of my days at Reading University when we use to travel out to Greenham Common to taunt the verminous lesbians who were posing as CND peace women.Ah happy days and a much worthier foe than the pair of you.....

Janitor or gardener?


Second class division one degree in medieval history as it happens.They wanted to give me a First but were concerned about my obsession with Genghis Khan and frequent absences to watch Palace away games midweek.

Medieval history.

The irony.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

Eagles-Mad Flag Romford Essex 21 Jan 14 9.58pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 5.24pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 5.14pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 5.07pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 5.05pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 21 Jan 2014 5.00pm

The amount of Politically Correct do gooders in this country is unbearable.


And Im afraid we have got more than our fair share at Palace.I would actually feel sorry for them if their views werent so corrosive to our national interest....

I suppose that's about par for the course from someone who feels like you do:-

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 20 Jan 2014 5.11pm

Nothing else in any other sport compares to a goal either for or against.And the there is the singing,extreme language and punch ups!


That was posted tongue in cheek but of course a po faced leftie like you would not appreciate that would you?


Given the choice I would rather be a po faced leftie than a right wing thug

I would rather be a right wing thug then a left wing arse lick snob but thats just me.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 21 Jan 14 10.04pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.20pm

You would love that wouldnt you?Silence any dissent and I thought we lived in a democracy...

Another idiot in search of a village.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 10.25pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 21 Jan 2014 9.58pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 5.24pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 5.14pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 5.07pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 5.05pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 21 Jan 2014 5.00pm

The amount of Politically Correct do gooders in this country is unbearable.


And Im afraid we have got more than our fair share at Palace.I would actually feel sorry for them if their views werent so corrosive to our national interest....

I suppose that's about par for the course from someone who feels like you do:-

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 20 Jan 2014 5.11pm

Nothing else in any other sport compares to a goal either for or against.And the there is the singing,extreme language and punch ups!


That was posted tongue in cheek but of course a po faced leftie like you would not appreciate that would you?


Given the choice I would rather be a po faced leftie than a right wing thug

I would rather be a right wing thug then a left wing arse lick snob but thats just me.

Amazing-someone on here with some balls!Well said fella.

 

SE9 EAGLE Flag 21 Jan 14 10.27pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Jan 2014 10.04pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 9.20pm

You would love that wouldnt you?Silence any dissent and I thought we lived in a democracy...

Another idiot in search of a village.

Rather than you being in search of the village people?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jan 14 10.38pm

Quote SE9 EAGLE at 21 Jan 2014 5.52pm

Quote Seth at 21 Jan 2014 5.33pm

Quote TomThePalaceFanatic at 21 Jan 2014 5.11pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 2.20pm

Quote Frickin Saweet at 21 Jan 2014 1.35pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jan 2014 6.32am

Quote Elpis at 20 Jan 2014 10.29pm

Anyone in football would know that clubs have their own ways , chants and 'terms of endearment' that those outside of the game endeavour to find offensive . The fans of the hotspurs from Tottingham are no exception .
Your friends should maybe go and support a club that is inclusive of minority and odd jobs and those who make a living of being offended . The poofters at Brighton may be their calling .

The word yid is as offensive to Jews as the word ****** is to black people. As we have a number of black players and supporters at Palace would you think it's acceptable that we refer to ourselves as ******s then - as a term of endearment of course

Unless you're a Yid or black (or both, a 'blid' you're not really in a position to know whether that's true or not. I have heard anecdotes from Spurs supporting friends of Jewish people that are not in the slightest bit offended by the term when used at their ground. It's about context. As much as the N word is used by some black people.

Some of the comments in this thread get more and more unbelievable

It's true though. People are offended on other peoples behalf


I keep seeing this phrase and don't get it.

Were white people who campaigned against slavery "offended on other people's behalf"?

Were men who fought for votes for women "offended on other people's behalf"?

Were non-Jews who fought the Nazis "offended on other people's behalf"?

Are adults who campaign against child abuse "offended on other people's behalf"?

Please explain why, if someone perceives an action as wrong, why they cannot speak up against it, whoever they are?

Edited by Seth (21 Jan 2014 5.34pm)

The problem with you people is that slaves,Muslims,blacks,the disabled,women,gays,hermaphrodites and indeed all minorities(and that includes foreign rapists we cant deport because of their rights and terrorists)all have full civil rights and probably more rights than the rest of us.But you still need the idea of prejudice to soothe your misguided consciencies.And if loving my country and being concerned with untrammeled immigration and crime makes me right wing I make no apology for that.I am not a thug though....

Well argued, that won me over. Jesus...

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Jews