This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote Master Coin at 22 Jan 2014 12.59pm
Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jan 2014 11.57am
To answer your questions: 1. Do you not think that IM in particular is involved in our txfr dealings? I'd like to think he's involved as that's his area of responsibility. However, the fact that our owners seem to handle media briefings on this subject rather than the executive in charge of it worries me. Maybe it doesn't worry you, but to me it's an early sign of a dysfunctional organisation. Not sure why IM not handling the media briefings on transfer dealings worries you. IM is a negotiations / player personnel guy not necessarily a 'media' guy. Is media even in his job description? To my knowledge he didn't do the media bit at Cardiff and nor do a lot of DoF's. Whether or not leaving SP to basically handle all media responsibilities is the right thing for the club is a different question (which I'm not gonna answer) but IM not doing the media is not an indicator of a disfunctional board room. I could similarly argue that them sitting next to each other at home games is an indicator of a functional relationship - either way would be reading too much into something that might not be there. 2. Do you not think they are trying their best? Absolutely I do. That, however, does not mean they are doing the right things. It's very easy to put 101% into the wrong action, especially when you're running a company. See the first point in my earlier post, which you ignored. When you start doing other people's jobs outside of your own area of expertise, you can work very hard and care a lot, but still end up making the wrong choices. You can.... you might not be. One transfer window aside (the most recent one) there aren't any real indicators of 'cock-up'. We've come from recent administration and Championship relegation battles to the PL in a short space of time so some of the football decisions (pre-IM) must have been good ones. 3. Every year under CPFC 2010's stewardship our club improves, whether it be infrastructure, ability to generate revenue, permanent staff, playing staff. Agreed. And this proves completely my earlier point. In the areas of the club that our owners have proven expertise in (catering, infrastructure, marketing, etc.) they have moved us forwards leaps and bounds. They have done brilliantly. In the areas of the club where they have no expertise but insist on being heavily involved (like the transfer market), we have not performed well at all. This is what is frustrating TP. You could not have made my point for me more clearly. SHUT UP AND LET THE EXPERTS DO THEIR JOBS. Do you think TP tells Browett what wines to select for the club bars? It doesn't 'completely' prove your point at all. It may 'partly' prove your point but think you're reading too much into it again. To suggest we haven't performed well at all in the transfer market is a bit of an overstatement - basically our whole team is signings post-adminstration so that can't be true. At best you can argue that the Summer was a bit of a catastrophe (which it was) but even the summer had some silver linings (Guediora, Bannan and I think Gayle / Campana may come good long term). Also, to your earlier point, you have NO IDEA about whether or not SP is a good negotiator (for example). All you know is that he ran a good marketing business - what underlines that (marketing nouse, negotiation skills, recruitment etc) is unknown to you. I know somebody who worked under SP at TAG who said that, whilst they thought he was a bit of an arse, he was an excellent negotiator and man motivator. Greg Dyke is currently the CEO of the FA. I doubt they employed him because the BBC (his former CEO role) used to show MotD weekly or because he could spot that Sherlock would be a winner on a Saturday night - its probably more to do with his all-round intangible skillset. 4. Financial prudence is everything im afraid, even if it means us dropping back down for a season as we continue to develop. Agreed. But prudence does not mean "take no risks". It means take calculated risks, and have a very good mechanism for judging which to take and which to walk away from. Agreed
I agree with a lot of Ian's / Syd's comments - SP does like the sound of his own voice too much and we absolutely should be entitled to challenge views of the owner / manager (I've been vocal about TP strategy on multiple occasions including his casting aside of young / small talent). With that said I do disagree with a fair bit of it too (see above). I suspect its somewhere between the two polarising opinions in this thread.
Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link] Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.