You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Moody have such a good rep?
November 16 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why does Moody have such a good rep?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 25 Jan 14 1.23pm

Honest question, why does Ian Moody have such a good reputation in the game?

I didn't know much about him before he signed and well obviously the transfer window isn't done but it hasn't exactly been great has it?

At Cardiff he was involved with signing Cornelius for £10million who hasn't scored yet.Numerous other players such as Odemwingie and Medel haven't been great either. Especially when you consider what they paid/are paying.

Interesting article about him in the DM in Dec here:

[Link]

Can anyone share some of his success stories? Because I don't really know of any?

Edited by Crazy_Eagle (25 Jan 2014 1.24pm)

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

jimmyc Flag 25 Jan 14 1.33pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.23pm

Honest question, why does Ian Moody have such a good reputation in the game?

I didn't know much about him before he signed and well obviously the transfer window isn't done but it hasn't exactly been great has it?

At Cardiff he was involved with signing Cornelius for £10million who hasn't scored yet.Numerous other players such as Odemwingie and Medel haven't been great either. Especially when you consider what they paid/are paying.

Interesting article about him in the DM in Dec here:

[Link]

Can anyone share some of his success stories? Because I don't really know of any?

Edited by Crazy_Eagle (25 Jan 2014 1.24pm)

So what you're saying is you know basically nothing about the guy but the tiny tiny bit you do know you got from the f*€king Daily Mail!?! Jesus, let him at least complete a window before you start these idiotic threads.

 

redpalace91 Flag Bromley 25 Jan 14 1.39pm

I would rather have one excellent signing this January than 5 average players. We have quite a large squad already. Transfer window isn't closed yet - things can still happen.

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 25 Jan 14 1.41pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.33pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.23pm

Honest question, why does Ian Moody have such a good reputation in the game?

I didn't know much about him before he signed and well obviously the transfer window isn't done but it hasn't exactly been great has it?

At Cardiff he was involved with signing Cornelius for £10million who hasn't scored yet.Numerous other players such as Odemwingie and Medel haven't been great either. Especially when you consider what they paid/are paying.

Interesting article about him in the DM in Dec here:

[Link]

Can anyone share some of his success stories? Because I don't really know of any?

Edited by Crazy_Eagle (25 Jan 2014 1.24pm)

So what you're saying is you know basically nothing about the guy but the tiny tiny bit you do know you got from the f*€king Daily Mail!?! Jesus, let him at least complete a window before you start these idiotic threads.

Yeah I'm saying I know basically nothing about him and would like to know more. Wasn't my post clear?

I clearly wasn't making a judgement on him, I was asking about it

You should read more carefully.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

jimmyc Flag 25 Jan 14 1.48pm

And you should do your own research. Although you did a good job at finding the negative garbage the Mail spews out and posting it.

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 25 Jan 14 1.54pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.48pm

And you should do your own research. Although you did a good job at finding the negative garbage the Mail spews out and posting it.


Heartfelt apologies Mrs Moody, I thought this was a discussion board. That article I happened to read on the train on the day and it stuck with me.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

andrewravesax Flag cowbridge 25 Jan 14 1.57pm

Medel is OK, but not sure whether Cornelius can actually run.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Jan 14 2.02pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.23pm

why does Ian Moody have such a good reputation in the game?

Does he have a good reputation in the game though?

Malky Mackay obviously thought highly of him and Steve Parish was obviously impressed sufficiently to offer him a job but does his reputation spread any wider than those two?


Edited by Ian J (25 Jan 2014 2.04pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Jan 14 2.03pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.54pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.48pm

And you should do your own research. Although you did a good job at finding the negative garbage the Mail spews out and posting it.


Heartfelt apologies Mrs Moody, I thought this was a discussion board. That article I happened to read on the train on the day and it stuck with me.

Don't worry about him. Some people are happy to toe the party line and are unable to think for themselves

 

jimmyc Flag 25 Jan 14 2.06pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.54pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.48pm

And you should do your own research. Although you did a good job at finding the negative garbage the Mail spews out and posting it.


Heartfelt apologies Mrs Moody, I thought this was a discussion board. That article I happened to read on the train on the day and it stuck with me.

It is a discussion board, but yet another obviously negative thread about our transfer action based on no knowledge about what is going on or the people involved is just boorish

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 25 Jan 14 2.09pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 2.06pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.54pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.48pm

And you should do your own research. Although you did a good job at finding the negative garbage the Mail spews out and posting it.


Heartfelt apologies Mrs Moody, I thought this was a discussion board. That article I happened to read on the train on the day and it stuck with me.

It is a discussion board, but yet another obviously negative thread about our transfer action based on no knowledge about what is going on or the people involved is just boorish


I think you've completely missed the point. Of course it is based on no knowledge, that's the whole reason for the post. I was asking for HOL to give their opinions.

Shame that the HOL suffers from prickly posters such as you.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 25 Jan 14 2.09pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.33pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.23pm

Honest question, why does Ian Moody have such a good reputation in the game?

I didn't know much about him before he signed and well obviously the transfer window isn't done but it hasn't exactly been great has it?

At Cardiff he was involved with signing Cornelius for £10million who hasn't scored yet.Numerous other players such as Odemwingie and Medel haven't been great either. Especially when you consider what they paid/are paying.

Interesting article about him in the DM in Dec here:

[Link]

Can anyone share some of his success stories? Because I don't really know of any?

Edited by Crazy_Eagle (25 Jan 2014 1.24pm)

So what you're saying is you know basically nothing about the guy but the tiny tiny bit you do know you got from the f*€king Daily Mail!?! Jesus, let him at least complete a window before you start these idiotic threads.

Calm down mate,the bloke asked a fair question which I wouldn't mind knowing the answer cos I know nothing about him either

 

jimmyc Flag 25 Jan 14 2.11pm


Edited by jimmyc (25 Jan 2014 2.16pm)

 

bertshead Flag Castlederg 25 Jan 14 2.13pm

Quote andrewravesax at 25 Jan 2014 1.57pm

Medel is OK, but not sure whether Cornelius can actually run.


Cornelius got a bad ankle injury shortly after signing for them so the jury's out on him.
Medel's alright and Caulker is a good signing,also Moody has a goog knowledge of the European scene apparently.
January is a notoriously hard time to buy decent players so he should at least be given time and a summer window to judge the bloke on properly.

 

Keni Flag Brighton 25 Jan 14 2.14pm

I thought the tgread opened with a pretty fair question. Can't say that I've seen much to make me feel Mr. M is an integral part of the club? Or maybe thete is no one worth buying out there. I cant believe that T.P came into the job without the reassurance that he would be able to strengthen the squad he inherited. It is frustrating watching the teams around us buying players that might solve their problems. There are players in the league that have scored mord than our entire team! There is a need to imptovd thd forward line with a player who has experience of helping those around him find the goal more often. It seems every player who we are linked with sems to be signing for rival team? Is thst a good testimony for Mr. Moody. I for one would like to see a frw results of his supposed skills. Sooner rather than later so players had time to fit in with the team. Think a few more will soon be asking this question? Including T.P. maybe?

 

jimmyc Flag 25 Jan 14 2.16pm

Haha, ok, apologies I guess, maybe be I need coffee or something.

Edited by jimmyc (25 Jan 2014 2.20pm)

 

lindz Flag kent 25 Jan 14 2.33pm

Quote aquickgame2 at 25 Jan 2014 2.09pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.33pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.23pm

Honest question, why does Ian Moody have such a good reputation in the game?

I didn't know much about him before he signed and well obviously the transfer window isn't done but it hasn't exactly been great has it?

At Cardiff he was involved with signing Cornelius for £10million who hasn't scored yet.Numerous other players such as Odemwingie and Medel haven't been great either. Especially when you consider what they paid/are paying.

Interesting article about him in the DM in Dec here:

[Link]

Can anyone share some of his success stories? Because I don't really know of any?

Edited by Crazy_Eagle (25 Jan 2014 1.24pm)

So what you're saying is you know basically nothing about the guy but the tiny tiny bit you do know you got from the f*€king Daily Mail!?! Jesus, let him at least complete a window before you start these idiotic threads.

Calm down mate,the bloke asked a fair question which I wouldn't mind knowing the answer cos I know nothing about him either

^^^^This too. All I know Is he used to be part of Cardiffs recruitment and he has a list of if I remember correctly all the premier league players ever with stats on which I believe I heard somewhere but can't remember exactly .

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 25 Jan 14 2.35pm

Until he was sacked by/left Cardiff, I'd never heard of the bloke.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Jan 14 3.34pm

At Cardiff he was able to offer wages of 30k a week in the championship. At Palace you try attracting people with £17:50 and a part time shelf stacking job in Sainsbury's.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

est1905 Flag 25 Jan 14 3.36pm

Quote jimmyc at 25 Jan 2014 1.33pm

Quote Crazy_Eagle at 25 Jan 2014 1.23pm

Honest question, why does Ian Moody have such a good reputation in the game?

I didn't know much about him before he signed and well obviously the transfer window isn't done but it hasn't exactly been great has it?

At Cardiff he was involved with signing Cornelius for £10million who hasn't scored yet.Numerous other players such as Odemwingie and Medel haven't been great either. Especially when you consider what they paid/are paying.

Interesting article about him in the DM in Dec here:

[Link]

Can anyone share some of his success stories? Because I don't really know of any?

Edited by Crazy_Eagle (25 Jan 2014 1.24pm)

So what you're saying is you know basically nothing about the guy but the tiny tiny bit you do know you got from the f*€king Daily Mail!?! Jesus, let him at least complete a window before you start these idiotic threads.


Blimey mate, don't wet your knickers over it! He only asked what people know about the bloke.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Moody have such a good rep?