This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Puncheon
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
bubble wrap Carparks in South East London 08 Mar 14 8.37pm |
|
|
Silly mistake today yes but he has gained us a few vital points this season. My point is that I find him very frustrating, he seems to think he has loads of time on the ball and is very casual with his touches and passing
|
curlyeagle crowborough 08 Mar 14 8.41pm |
|
|
In the position we are in you cant keep selecting a player like Puncheon who one week wants it and the next just cant be naffed.
Not the kind of player that will have the guts to keep us up.
Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days
|
Dangermouse Hastings 08 Mar 14 8.49pm |
|
|
That is the big problem with Punch. When he's up for it he is a valuable player, but today he had one of his can't be arsed days, which we can't afford.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
woodlemoo Worthing 08 Mar 14 9.28pm |
|
|
Bannan anyone?
|
premier fan BR4 08 Mar 14 9.34pm |
|
Quote woodlemoo at 08 Mar 2014 9.28pm
Bannan anyone?
Yes I think he deserves a recall.
|
Palace_denizen filed under " time wasters " 08 Mar 14 11.00pm |
|
|
does Puncheon really believe he can walk it when so many spectators are watching him ?
Laughing at Charlton - Every London Clyub's fourth or fifth most hated team - [Link]
|
goodersgold Hastings 08 Mar 14 11.04pm |
|
Quote bubble wrap at 08 Mar 2014 8.37pm
Silly mistake today yes but he has gained us a few vital points this season. My point is that I find him very frustrating, he seems to think he has loads of time on the ball and is very casual with his touches and passing
Ex Soton player gifting Soton a goal , Dubious c-nt and was poor today piss poor
Edited by goodersgold (08 Mar 2014 11.05pm)
The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!
|
merganser 09 Mar 14 12.05am |
|
|
Unfair to blame puncheon for soton goal. He was entitled to expect better cover behind him. Where was the rest of the defence?
Wouldn't blame Jules either. He was a fractional inch away from making what would have been the best tackle ever made at selhurst park
IMO, Jules did well to make the challenge without getting himself sent off.
Disagree entirely with fowler 's motd comment.
But what does TP think? Will he use the incident as an excuse to replace speroni with Hennessy?
|
gazzagoalie 09 Mar 14 12.32am |
|
|
really poor from punch today. the goal was entirely his fault, p1$$ poor header, and I think he could have chased it down after it was past speroni. the ball wasnt moving that fast.
|
kennet croydon 09 Mar 14 1.54am |
|
|
I don't rate him one little bit, he's just not consistent enough for what we need at this point in our season!! Yea he can pop up with something good every now and again but I'd defo bring bannan back into the frame!! It might even liven punch up if he was dropped for bannan, bannan put 100% in every game he played and looked good but since punch got his contract he hasn't performed 1 little bit!! I'd drop to liven him up
|
south coast eagle Rustington West Sussex 09 Mar 14 5.45am |
|
|
What are these good games Puncheon has had ????
How he get s a start most weeks is beyond me, as much as i think Bannon is better in CM he is definitely better than Puncheon out wide.
Forever Palace
|
tjc47380 09 Mar 14 6.44am |
|
|
Two main problems with Puncheon : 1) his first instinct when he gets the ball is to turn inside or backwards - this slows attacks down; 2) he has periods in games where he looks like he can't be bothered (avoiding 50/50 tackles etc) - this is not an attitude that goes down well with supporters of any team. I'm not sure why (especially at home) you would start him ahead of Ince.
|
Andy_G Wimbledon 09 Mar 14 7.17am |
|
|
He's what I call a comfort player, if he is feeling good and at ease he'll be great but if not he'll go missing. Yesterday he went missing.
The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years
|
antipodeagle Wellington 09 Mar 14 7.43am |
|
Quote south coast eagle at 09 Mar 2014 5.45am
What are these good games Puncheon has had ????
How he get s a start most weeks is beyond me, as much as i think Bannon is better in CM he is definitely better than Puncheon out wide.
I don't like to bag current players, but I have been surprised all season every time JP is in the starting line-up.
That said, I didn't think Ince made that much of an impact when he came on this week: JT had the biggest positive impact and I'm not normally a fan of his.
|
phillanth London 09 Mar 14 9.08am |
|
Quote merganser at 09 Mar 2014 12.05am Unfair to blame puncheon for soton goal. He was entitled to expect better cover behind him. Where was the rest of the defence?
Wouldn't blame Jules either. He was a fractional inch away from making what would have been the best tackle ever made at selhurst park
IMO, Jules did well to make the challenge without getting himself sent off.
Disagree entirely with fowler 's motd comment.
But what does TP think? Will he use the incident as an excuse to replace speroni with Hennessy?
I agree with Fowler. Watching the game live I thought Jules was going to get to the ball first. Having just seen it again on MoTD I think that not only should he have got to the ball first but once he got there, he should have made sure he won it rather than making a powder puff challenge which left Rodrigues with an empty net to aim at. Unfair to blame Puncheon solely for the goal in my opinion.
|
goodersgold Hastings 09 Mar 14 9.12am |
|
Quote phillanth at 09 Mar 2014 9.08am
Quote merganser at 09 Mar 2014 12.05am Unfair to blame puncheon for soton goal. He was entitled to expect better cover behind him. Where was the rest of the defence?
Wouldn't blame Jules either. He was a fractional inch away from making what would have been the best tackle ever made at selhurst park
IMO, Jules did well to make the challenge without getting himself sent off.
Disagree entirely with fowler 's motd comment.
But what does TP think? Will he use the incident as an excuse to replace speroni with Hennessy?
I agree with Fowler. Watching the game live I thought Jules was going to get to the ball first. Having just seen it again on MoTD I think that not only should he have got to the ball first but once he got there, he should have made sure he won it rather than making a powder puff challenge which left Rodrigues with an empty net to aim at. Unfair to blame Puncheon solely for the goal in my opinion.
That's how I saw it too ,once Jules has come he has get there
The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!
|
merganser 09 Mar 14 9.20am |
|
|
The last time puncheon was so heavily slagged off (the penalty miss v spurs), he scored the winner in the next game.
Roll on Saturday!
|
gazzagoalie 09 Mar 14 2.35pm |
|
Quote goodersgold at 09 Mar 2014 9.12am
Quote phillanth at 09 Mar 2014 9.08am
Quote merganser at 09 Mar 2014 12.05am Unfair to blame puncheon for soton goal. He was entitled to expect better cover behind him. Where was the rest of the defence?
Wouldn't blame Jules either. He was a fractional inch away from making what would have been the best tackle ever made at selhurst park
IMO, Jules did well to make the challenge without getting himself sent off.
Disagree entirely with fowler 's motd comment.
But what does TP think? Will he use the incident as an excuse to replace speroni with Hennessy?
I agree with Fowler. Watching the game live I thought Jules was going to get to the ball first. Having just seen it again on MoTD I think that not only should he have got to the ball first but once he got there, he should have made sure he won it rather than making a powder puff challenge which left Rodrigues with an empty net to aim at. Unfair to blame Puncheon solely for the goal in my opinion.
That's how I saw it too ,once Jules has come he has get there
Not speronis fault imo. Maybe would have been better to stay in his area so he could use his hands, but the challenge could easily have gone wrong and he would have walked.
|
Crazy_Eagle South London 09 Mar 14 2.49pm |
|
Quote antipodeagle at 09 Mar 2014 7.43am
Quote south coast eagle at 09 Mar 2014 5.45am
What are these good games Puncheon has had ????
How he get s a start most weeks is beyond me, as much as i think Bannon is better in CM he is definitely better than Puncheon out wide.
I don't like to bag current players, but I have been surprised all season every time JP is in the starting line-up.
That said, I didn't think Ince made that much of an impact when he came on this week: JT had the biggest positive impact and I'm not normally a fan of his.
I'm not a fan of JT but his crossing was miles better than anyones
R.I.P. DJ Hardline
CPFC2010
|
Dangermouse Hastings 09 Mar 14 2.50pm |
|
|
Neither Speroni or Moxey could go in full pelt because a red card was waiting for one of them depending on how Rodriguez would of gone down. Puncheon sold Moxey down the river, but he didn't do it on purpose, so I forgive him, although I find him incredibly frustrating to watch. What I did notice today was that Southampton left no one up at defensive corners and even though that happens you still leave two players back, one deeper than the other, but two in order to cover a break down either side. Pulis only left back Moxey and sorry but that is far too big an area for one player to cover and the goal came from our corner. An extra player back would of mopped up the clearance or fouled Rodriguez in his own half and obviously wouldn't of been the last man, Moxey was and couldn't risk it.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|