You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stoke fan in Peace.
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Stoke fan in Peace.


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
1steino Flag Stoke 18 Mar 14 4.02pm

First of all, good luck for the rest of the season. I really do like a lot of Stoke supporters hope Palace stay up. I was wondering what your opinions on Tony Pulis are now hes gone past the honeymoon period. Are you happy with the decision your board made?

Im genuinly interested in your thoughts.

Thanks

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 18 Mar 14 4.06pm

You've probably posted this at the worst possible time, as there's a lot of doom and gloom on here at the moment (for some reason).

Personally, I think Pulis is doing what he has to to make our inadequate squad competitive. He's on course to keep us up, which would be a phenomenal achievement, and then hopefully work on improving the squad over the summer and push on from there.

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 18 Mar 14 4.07pm

I like him and I think he is and was the best man for the job in our circumstances
He is here to do a job which is to keep us up,for which he is getting well paid.
As for his type of football its not my style but hey ho,if he keeps us up that will do me.

 

Hoof Hearted 18 Mar 14 4.10pm

If we go down it won't be Pulis' fault.

To be honest he's given us a fighting chance but that is all.

I think we would be already relegated, but for him.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 18 Mar 14 4.14pm

Terrible to watch, but given what he has to work with, I don't think he has much option.

If we stay up, it's going to need a massive investment to make us competitive next term

 

songsta Flag New Addington 18 Mar 14 4.46pm

Depends what your individual take on it is son.

If you watch Football as a source of entertainment like going to the movies or going to a comedy club and happy to pay £25 odd quid to be royaly entertained then as you know TP is not the compare/Host you want to hire.

If however you want to brag to your Milwall or Charlton or in my case Brighton chums too that we are premier league then and get all the shizzle that comes with being premier league, then, well maybe he is the man.

Let me turn the question on you, how do you now feel since your board sacked him for playing boring negative robotic football over a long period of time in favour of exciting creative moving forward dynamic football ?

 

beer man Flag Kent 18 Mar 14 4.48pm

There's an 'Away Fans' area so why don't you post on there; there's always a few ar$e lickers who'll talk to anyone.

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 18 Mar 14 4.56pm

Is the Hughes style of football that much different from Pulis? From when I saw Stoke at Palace it seems it was just pass the ball around the back 4 a bit, then either a defender of N'Zonzi humps it forward, Crouch knocks it down and you play for second balls. Didn't seem this 'progressive' new football that Hughes was trying to implement that I'd heard about.

Probably doesn't help that I think Mark Hughes is an arrogant pr*ck

But in answer to your question, I'm happy with Pulis. Done a great job with some very limited players. His style is frustrating at times but seems to be working, although he does seem to be getting more and more cautious.

Edited by victor43 (18 Mar 2014 5.13pm)

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 18 Mar 14 5.12pm

Quote beer man at 18 Mar 2014 4.48pm

There's an 'Away Fans' area so why don't you post on there; there's always a few ar$e lickers who'll talk to anyone.


Unnecessary. The OP posted a polite and civil question; perhaps you could respond in kind and if not, don't bother to respond at all.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

williamrufus Flag London 18 Mar 14 5.18pm

Quote 1steino at 18 Mar 2014 4.02pm

First of all, good luck for the rest of the season. I really do like a lot of Stoke supporters hope Palace stay up. I was wondering what your opinions on Tony Pulis are now hes gone past the honeymoon period. Are you happy with the decision your board made?

Im genuinly interested in your thoughts.

Thanks

He was the best possible choice under the cirumstances and came just in the nick of time to give us a fighting chance of staying up. He knows his business and is honest as well as being good with the media.

 


We must find a way. Or we will make one. - Hannibal Barca

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Mar 14 5.20pm

Quote beer man at 18 Mar 2014 4.48pm

There's an 'Away Fans' area so why don't you post on there; there's always a few ar$e lickers who'll talk to anyone.


One of the more interesting posts on here and you have to knock it. If you have nothing positive, interesting or half considered to say, why bother posting?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Mar 14 5.22pm

Let me turn the question on you, how do you now feel since your board sacked him for playing boring negative robotic football over a long period of time in favour of exciting creative moving forward dynamic football ?


----------------------------------------------

Yes, I would be really interested in this answer. Because at the moment the style of play feels like a necessary evil to buy us time and therein revenue. But in two or three years we would like some entertainment, do you think we will get it with TP?

Edited by Mapletree (18 Mar 2014 5.23pm)

 

paulose17 Flag Sutton 18 Mar 14 5.32pm

The football when he came in was decent it's only the last 3/4ish games that have been dross. I think he was the right man for the job but I think he could try some of our more (rare) flair players we have in the squad and not keep using his mediocre favourites.

 


Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.

dg1937 Flag 18 Mar 14 5.52pm

If the job was to keep Palace in the Prem (it was) then Pulis was the best man for it. I don't like Fat Sam but I think he gives West Ham an edge in a relegation battle; same with Pulis, his experience is worth a few points compared to the guy West Brom appointed. I don't especially enjoy the football I'm seeing at the moment but I didn't particularly enjoy getting 4 points from the first 11 games either. Under TP we have a chance of staying up, I'd have taken that in November.

 

est1905 Flag 18 Mar 14 5.59pm

Quote npn at 18 Mar 2014 4.14pm

Terrible to watch, but given what he has to work with, I don't think he has much option.

If we stay up, it's going to need a massive investment to make us competitive next term

Much less terrible to watch than Freedman's 'park the bus and hope to nick a 1 0' philosophy. It aint pretty at times but what do people want? with the squad and resources we have in this division competitive is all we can hope for. if we stay up a couple of years we'll be able to introduce a bit more quality and flair and kick on in terms of league position and performances.
Right now we don't have that luxury. I just don't understand how people can possibly think otherwise.
All this 'I'd rather be in the Championship and playing attractive football' tripe is so small minded. I've got a newsflash, we weren't that entertaining in the second tier either!


 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 18 Mar 14 6.23pm

Quote est1905 at 18 Mar 2014 5.59pm

Much less terrible to watch than Freedman's 'park the bus and hope to nick a 1 0' philosophy. It aint pretty at times but what do people want? with the squad and resources we have in this division competitive is all we can hope for. if we stay up a couple of years we'll be able to introduce a bit more quality and flair and kick on in terms of league position and performances.
Right now we don't have that luxury. I just don't understand how people can possibly think otherwise.
All this 'I'd rather be in the Championship and playing attractive football' tripe is so small minded. I've got a newsflash, we weren't that entertaining in the second tier either!



Seems to me to be pretty similar to DF's philosophy tbh.

Agree with the rest of your post though. Given what TP has to work with and the position we were in when he came, it's a miracle we've got any chance whatsoever of staying up. If we do, hopefully he'll have the time and money over the summer to rebuild the squad and make is into a more attractive side to watch.

Edited by Seth (18 Mar 2014 6.23pm)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

maxipalace Flag in a box 18 Mar 14 6.48pm

Quote Seth at 18 Mar 2014 6.23pm

Quote est1905 at 18 Mar 2014 5.59pm

Much less terrible to watch than Freedman's 'park the bus and hope to nick a 1 0' philosophy. It aint pretty at times but what do people want? with the squad and resources we have in this division competitive is all we can hope for. if we stay up a couple of years we'll be able to introduce a bit more quality and flair and kick on in terms of league position and performances.
Right now we don't have that luxury. I just don't understand how people can possibly think otherwise.
All this 'I'd rather be in the Championship and playing attractive football' tripe is so small minded. I've got a newsflash, we weren't that entertaining in the second tier either!



Seems to me to be pretty similar to DF's philosophy tbh.

Agree with the rest of your post though. Given what TP has to work with and the position we were in when he came, it's a miracle we've got any chance whatsoever of staying up. If we do, hopefully he'll have the time and money over the summer to rebuild the squad and make is into a more attractive side to watch.

Edited by Seth (18 Mar 2014 6.23pm)


its a miracle, he is the messiah!

Edited by maxipalace (18 Mar 2014 6.49pm)

 

MPE Flag Maidstone 18 Mar 14 6.56pm

Very impressed with him, made us a solid and organised unit, does not play the clown to the media, tells you how it is. As said before TP is setting up the past few games to not lose need to be abit more brave, want to see the performances we saw away to Man City, Spurs and Chelsea, where we were actually creating chances and looking a threat.

If he keeps us up, he deserves the chance to build his own team over the summer, and give it another crack, would also be happy to have him in the championship, but think he would be snapped up, if we went down!

 


Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in

goodersgold Flag Hastings 18 Mar 14 7.07pm

Quote Mapletree at 18 Mar 2014 5.20pm

Quote beer man at 18 Mar 2014 4.48pm

There's an 'Away Fans' area so why don't you post on there; there's always a few ar$e lickers who'll talk to anyone.


One of the more interesting posts on here and you have to knock it. If you have nothing positive, interesting or half considered to say, why bother posting?


Why should he?
There is loads of negative whiners on here I think talk utter bollocks,but we are constantly told it's just someone's differing opinion.
Why should Beer man be any different ?

 


The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!

1steino Flag Stoke 18 Mar 14 8.15pm

Tp is great playing the underdog, it's when the emphasis is on his team he struggles. If he keeps you up this year then you won't be in danger of relegation for as long as he's there. After so long though you will want more and grow frustrated. He does try and the intention is there to integrate a different kind of player than what he knows. We had eidur gudjohnsson, tuncay and Michael Owen and he hardly ever played any of them. Don't what ever you do expect flair, it's not in tones game. Midfielders won't shoot from distance or ever get in the box as he integrates a 'cage' for them to play in (his words) He will play people out of position and not pick people on form. We went 7 years without a left back which drove everyone mad. What aggravated people is his interviews can be as if he's watched a different game, he will say his team should of got this or that even tho they were awful.

The main thing is he plays not to lose not to win. He always said if we draw every game we would get enough points to stay up knowing he would always be in the chance of sneaking a win if drawing the game.

He will however always get 100% commitment out of your players which to keep you up you need.

Our game against palace was probably our worst performance of the season, we still have resilience if tones team but yeh to win every game playing god football with a lot more flair.

Tp will always be appreciated in stoke it was a situation where he really took us as far as he could and change was needed.

We all watch from up here with interest. I hope he does well with you n learns from mistakes he made at stoke.

Time will tell. Good luck 👍

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stoke fan in Peace.