This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
was that the best refereeing performance we've see
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
hastingseagle67 13 Apr 14 8.19am |
|
|
don't get me wrong, I very much dislike Howard Webb and feel that he has cost us in the previous 2 games that he has officiated, but are we big enough to admit that he put in a pretty good performance yesterday. How many times have we seen him try to make it the Howard Webb show, but yesterday he pointed to the penalty spot, then on advice from the linesman, correctly reversed the decision. I would usually expect him to stand there posturing saying "I am Howard Webb, and if I say its a penalty, its a penalty". But yesterday, he seemed to be a little more understated, and gave a fair amount of what I felt were correct decisions for both sides. I really don't like doing it, but feel you probably have to give credit where its due.
has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!
|
selecta Land of Fleet 13 Apr 14 8.33am |
|
|
By awarding the penalty initially clearly showed that he just guessed it. He should have consulted the lino first rather than looking like a fool afterwards.
Mr Kirk's nightmare
|
hastingseagle67 13 Apr 14 8.42am |
|
|
you could say he guessed the penalty decision, or you could say he made a decision on what he thought he saw, and was then prepared to reverse the decision after consultation with the lino.
has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!
|
Sg Bilko Deurne Holland 13 Apr 14 8.43am |
|
Quote selecta at 13 Apr 2014 8.33am
By awarding the penalty initially clearly showed that he just guessed it. He should have consulted the lino first rather than looking like a fool afterwards.
No, he gave what he thought he saw, the player definitely moved his body to the ball and contact was made, in normal play time that could have looked like an arm made contact with the ball, and he had the commonsense to consult the linesman.
He got that one spot on, and the one with Bolasies less than graceful theatrics 100% correct, neither were penalties.
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 13 Apr 14 8.51am |
|
|
He was better yesterday although,there was one instance when a Villa defender flew into a tackle, got hurt himself from that we were bearing down on goal and he blew up to get the Villa player some attention.
Then when play started up again he gave Guzan (Villa Keeper) the ball to start play off.
But apart from that he was good.
|
peterg Anerley 13 Apr 14 8.58am |
|
|
He missed a pen in the Guzan clash with Jedi. Guzan ran into Jedi and knocked him to the ground, which probably wasn't a pen, and Webb indicated as such. But Guzan aimed a kick at Jedi as he went down, which should have been a pen and even a red card. Webb missed it because he was walking away from Guzan and Jedi after signalling no pen. That was shown on the Sky recording of the game at 10pm. It wasn't shown on MoD. PS It was also analysed on Goals on Sunday and Roberto Martinez said it was a pen and a sending-off - if Webb had seen it.
Edited by peterg (13 Apr 2014 12.22pm)
The right place at the right time
|
bodge 13 Apr 14 9.00am |
|
|
He done the right thing with the handball. The Bolasie one is close but if you can not tell on a replay if there was contact then no way can he give a pen so no errors well done Mr Webb.
|
west eagle 13 Apr 14 9.01am |
|
|
this is a joke yes??
|
braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 13 Apr 14 9.03am |
|
|
yes good performance...his only mistake in my eyes was missing the jedi/guzan incident.
on the whole, a good performance.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
|
goodersgold Hastings 13 Apr 14 9.06am |
|
|
He still owes us one after the Bolasie incident against Soton . I can't stand him and think he is a crap referee,then again I think they are all crap
The world was a mess but his hair was perfect!
|
west eagle 13 Apr 14 9.10am |
|
|
so when the villa player goes down in the first half and he doesn't blow and plays on, Ward takes the shot, Webb calls for the physio and then proceeds to give a free kick????????
doesn't book the villa player for deliberately kick the ball away, and the player gets booked in the 2nd half so should have been his second?????????
gives a foul against Jedi when Guzan takes him out.
and that's just the few that spring to mind!
Edited by west eagle (13 Apr 2014 9.10am)
Edited by west eagle (13 Apr 2014 9.15am)
|
woahwoahwoah 13 Apr 14 9.17am |
|
|
The keeper actually kicked out at Jedinak, not even a yellow card for him, but a free kick for Villa? Stupid decision.
|
brownsugar 13 Apr 14 9.26am |
|
|
Totally disagree! A clear penalty. But not as far as Webb is concerned. A great set piece which really caught them out. Holt catches Yannick's standing foot as he is about to strike and he goes down. Also watch the reaction of all our nearby players. Don't often see a protest like that. In addition, Guzan barged Jedi down in the box which to me is a foul and therefore a penalty (not shown on motd). Ok, Webb looking away at the time, but linesman could have helped out as he did to correct the penalty decision he did give. Another great team performance and a desrved win - really proud of them!!
|
james03 Bangkok 13 Apr 14 9.27am |
|
|
I thought is was a truly dreadful performance by Mr. Webb.
I lost count of the number of times he simply turned his back on where the ball was and sprinted up the pitch thus missing what was actually going on. Once such example being Guzman's 'assault' on Murray.
It staggers me that match officials remain as inept today as they were when I first went to matches in 1959.
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx
|
| Hoof Hearted 13 Apr 14 9.30am |
|
Quote Sg Bilko at 13 Apr 2014 8.43am
Quote selecta at 13 Apr 2014 8.33am
By awarding the penalty initially clearly showed that he just guessed it. He should have consulted the lino first rather than looking like a fool afterwards.
No, he gave what he thought he saw, the player definitely moved his body to the ball and contact was made, in normal play time that could have looked like an arm made contact with the ball, and he had the commonsense to consult the linesman.
He got that one spot on, and the one with Bolasies less than graceful theatrics 100% correct, neither were penalties.
In actual fact Webb reacted to the linesman pointing to his chest which normally indicates a penalty, but on discussion the lineo was saying the ball hit the player's chest.
I still think Webb missed things and would not be happy with him refereeing us every week.
He completely ignored the challenge on Bolasie which I believe was a pen (why would he go down with the goal at his mercy?) and didn't even see Guzan take out Jedinak.
|
The Heath Eagle Thornton Heath 13 Apr 14 9.38am |
|
|
He got a massive Howard Webb is a w***er chant, I thought we would end up paying for that
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 13 Apr 14 9.46am |
|
|
Yeah, a bit dangerous from the crowd, but HE IS a w...er! An arrogant one as well!!
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 13 Apr 14 9.51am |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Apr 2014 9.30am
Quote Sg Bilko at 13 Apr 2014 8.43am
Quote selecta at 13 Apr 2014 8.33am
By awarding the penalty initially clearly showed that he just guessed it. He should have consulted the lino first rather than looking like a fool afterwards.
No, he gave what he thought he saw, the player definitely moved his body to the ball and contact was made, in normal play time that could have looked like an arm made contact with the ball, and he had the commonsense to consult the linesman.
He got that one spot on, and the one with Bolasies less than graceful theatrics 100% correct, neither were penalties.
In actual fact Webb reacted to the linesman pointing to his chest which normally indicates a penalty, but on discussion the lineo was saying the ball hit the player's chest.
I still think Webb missed things and would not be happy with him refereeing us every week.
He completely ignored the challenge on Bolasie which I believe was a pen (why would he go down with the goal at his mercy?) and didn't even see Guzan take out Jedinak.
Is the CORRECT answer.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
hastingseagle67 13 Apr 14 9.54am |
|
|
There have been some truly dreadful refereeing performances in our games this season and Webb has been culpable in two of them which has angered a lot of Palace fans. This obviously leads to a lot of anti webb feeling, but the point I think I was trying to make was that because of that bad feeling do we always pre judge him and accuse him for every game, or are we big enough to judge each performance individually. Yes there were mistakes yesterday, but you will get mistakes in every game. None of them were catastrophic. I'd still prefer him not to ref us, cos I believe he still thinks its all about him, but I am prepared to say that previous performances annoy me, but yesterday, he was alright.
has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!
|
Lucas Oliver Miles away 13 Apr 14 10.03am |
|
Quote alaneagle1 at 13 Apr 2014 9.51am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Apr 2014 9.30am
Quote Sg Bilko at 13 Apr 2014 8.43am
Quote selecta at 13 Apr 2014 8.33am
By awarding the penalty initially clearly showed that he just guessed it. He should have consulted the lino first rather than looking like a fool afterwards.
No, he gave what he thought he saw, the player definitely moved his body to the ball and contact was made, in normal play time that could have looked like an arm made contact with the ball, and he had the commonsense to consult the linesman.
He got that one spot on, and the one with Bolasies less than graceful theatrics 100% correct, neither were penalties.
In actual fact Webb reacted to the linesman pointing to his chest which normally indicates a penalty, but on discussion the lineo was saying the ball hit the player's chest.
I still think Webb missed things and would not be happy with him refereeing us every week.
He completely ignored the challenge on Bolasie which I believe was a pen (why would he go down with the goal at his mercy?) and didn't even see Guzan take out Jedinak.
Is the CORRECT answer.
That is correct - but where was our corner to restart play? Bolaisie chop down when villa player injured himself was another. Refs get decisions wrong all the time but rarely in applying the laws
Nope it's not my name
|