You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?
November 16 2026 12.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?


Page 5 of 25 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 15 Apr 14 4.26pm

Quote The Dolphin at 15 Apr 2014 3.51pm

It is only a worry if there was something in their contract with Ian Moody.
However - he got the push I believe so it unlikely he had to sign anything unless he got a big pay-off.
If he signed something then it is more likely to be an employment issue than something concerning the Premier League.
I suspect this is Cardiff not only clutching at straws but also trying to unsettle a Team above them.
If they knew this happened before the game then they should have reported it then - not now.
I can't see us having points deducted somehow.
It is a side show which Palace seem to be avoiding joining in which is a good sign.

Other than us HOLERS.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Apr 14 4.56pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 15 Apr 2014 3.58pm

Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 12.38pm

I guess it is likely that Moody had a confidentiality clause in his contract.

If he breached it, he can be sued.

If the club encouraged that breach, or could have prevented it but did not, then it also could be sued.

Presumably it would be sued for damages, so Cardiff would have to prove the damages. If Cardiff goes down but would have stayed up had it had three more points this could - in theory - become a problem.

Mind you, if Moody was unfairly dismissed that may impact upon this. I am guessing there was a Settlement Agreement in place, it would be interesting to know what it had to say on confidentiality but likely it reinforced the requirement.

Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 12.38pm)

No, he was dismissed pretty unceremoniously so that contract is no longer valid, as Tan is in breach of contract.


But assuming the Guardian is correct he signed a Settlement Agreement. So yes, the confidentiality clauses are almost certainly re-validated.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 15 Apr 14 5.17pm

Quote PalacePhotoMan at 15 Apr 2014 2.09pm

2 days before the game, Ole Gunnar wotsit said in the paper that he had told Wilf to celebrate if he scored a goal.

That suggests to me that OGS told the World that Wilf would be playing.

So is Tan sueing OGS too?



He said "when", not "if". He was wrong and this is pure bollocks.

We've done nothing and nothing can or will happen to us.

 


Optimistic as ever

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 15 Apr 14 5.24pm

Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 4.56pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 15 Apr 2014 3.58pm

Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 12.38pm

I guess it is likely that Moody had a confidentiality clause in his contract.

If he breached it, he can be sued.

If the club encouraged that breach, or could have prevented it but did not, then it also could be sued.

Presumably it would be sued for damages, so Cardiff would have to prove the damages. If Cardiff goes down but would have stayed up had it had three more points this could - in theory - become a problem.

Mind you, if Moody was unfairly dismissed that may impact upon this. I am guessing there was a Settlement Agreement in place, it would be interesting to know what it had to say on confidentiality but likely it reinforced the requirement.

Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 12.38pm)

No, he was dismissed pretty unceremoniously so that contract is no longer valid, as Tan is in breach of contract.


But assuming the Guardian is correct he signed a Settlement Agreement. So yes, the confidentiality clauses are almost certainly re-validated.

As I understand it Moody's dismissal is the subject of an unfair dismissal claim, if so he's hardly likely to have signed any contract of silence.

 

Hoof Hearted 15 Apr 14 5.31pm

I just think Tan is a bit Moody.

This will blow over without any fines, deductions or warnings.

We've played the same starting XI for 3 weeks FFS.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Apr 14 5.31pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 15 Apr 2014 5.24pm

Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 4.56pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 15 Apr 2014 3.58pm

Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 12.38pm

I guess it is likely that Moody had a confidentiality clause in his contract.

If he breached it, he can be sued.

If the club encouraged that breach, or could have prevented it but did not, then it also could be sued.

Presumably it would be sued for damages, so Cardiff would have to prove the damages. If Cardiff goes down but would have stayed up had it had three more points this could - in theory - become a problem.

Mind you, if Moody was unfairly dismissed that may impact upon this. I am guessing there was a Settlement Agreement in place, it would be interesting to know what it had to say on confidentiality but likely it reinforced the requirement.

Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 12.38pm)

No, he was dismissed pretty unceremoniously so that contract is no longer valid, as Tan is in breach of contract.


But assuming the Guardian is correct he signed a Settlement Agreement. So yes, the confidentiality clauses are almost certainly re-validated.

As I understand it Moody's dismissal is the subject of an unfair dismissal claim, if so he's hardly likely to have signed any contract of silence.


I can't find anything to that effect. All I can find is that he signed an agreement when he left, quoted in the Guardian.

If he did you would think it was a Settlement Agreement in which case there is no possibility of an Employment Tribunal. Maybe it was some kind of interim agreement though. Where did you see this was the subject of an unfair dismissal claim?

 

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 15 Apr 14 6.00pm

The only possible way we could be in trouble is if we coerced the information using torture or paid for it...can't believe we paid for it so that one's ruled out. :-)

In any case if the Premier League takes any action I'm personnaly going to counter with my own lawsuit claiming unlawful possible withdrawl from a sporting competition and citing either pure incompetence or corruption or both.

 

muffinbrucie Flag london 15 Apr 14 7.51pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Cardiff leaks' by SloveniaDave

Surely this is a non story. I could name palaces team days before we play as I'm sure most fans could with their teams. Formations may change to stifle the opposition but this can be Sussex and changed with subs if it's really necessary. On the day they were crap and we weren't .

 


its a town full of losers, i,m pulling outta here to win

muffinbrucie Flag london 15 Apr 14 7.52pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Cardiff leaks' by SloveniaDave

That's sussed not Sussex, I should have checked,doh

 


its a town full of losers, i,m pulling outta here to win

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Apr 14 8.02pm

No, he was dismissed pretty unceremoniously so that contract is no longer valid, as Tan is in breach of contract.


But assuming the Guardian is correct he signed a Settlement Agreement. So yes, the confidentiality clauses are almost certainly re-validated.

As I understand it Moody's dismissal is the subject of an unfair dismissal claim, if so he's hardly likely to have signed any contract of silence.


I can't find anything to that effect. All I can find is that he signed an agreement when he left, quoted in the Guardian.

If he did you would think it was a Settlement Agreement in which case there is no possibility of an Employment Tribunal. Maybe it was some kind of interim agreement though. Where did you see this was the subject of an unfair dismissal claim?


--------------------------------------------------
Ah, found it:

<<Mackay has not agreed a settlement with the club since his departure and is involved wrongful dismissal claim.>>

In that case Tan stands little chance of making any confidentiality clause stick, although it is still possible.

You can tell it's the Guardian from the missing words!

Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 8.02pm)

Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 8.04pm)

 

Everlast Flag Isle of Wight 15 Apr 14 8.27pm

This is a complete waste of everyone's time. As Caulker said, this is an issue that has been going on at Cardiff all season.

 

Everlast Flag Isle of Wight 15 Apr 14 8.31pm

Quote The Dolphin at 15 Apr 2014 3.51pm

It is only a worry if there was something in their contract with Ian Moody.
However - he got the push I believe so it unlikely he had to sign anything unless he got a big pay-off.
If he signed something then it is more likely to be an employment issue than something concerning the Premier League.
I suspect this is Cardiff not only clutching at straws but also trying to unsettle a Team above them.
If they knew this happened before the game then they should have reported it then - not now.
I can't see us having points deducted somehow.
It is a side show which Palace seem to be avoiding joining in which is a good sign.

Hit the nail on the head. This is nothing more than Cardiff desperately trying any tact they can to stay in the PL.


 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Apr 14 8.32pm

Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 8.02pm

No, he was dismissed pretty unceremoniously so that contract is no longer valid, as Tan is in breach of contract.


But assuming the Guardian is correct he signed a Settlement Agreement. So yes, the confidentiality clauses are almost certainly re-validated.

As I understand it Moody's dismissal is the subject of an unfair dismissal claim, if so he's hardly likely to have signed any contract of silence.


I can't find anything to that effect. All I can find is that he signed an agreement when he left, quoted in the Guardian.

If he did you would think it was a Settlement Agreement in which case there is no possibility of an Employment Tribunal. Maybe it was some kind of interim agreement though. Where did you see this was the subject of an unfair dismissal claim?


--------------------------------------------------
Ah, found it:

<<Mackay has not agreed a settlement with the club since his departure and is involved wrongful dismissal claim.>>

In that case Tan stands little chance of making any confidentiality clause stick, although it is still possible.

You can tell it's the Guardian from the missing words!
--------------------------------------------------
Oops, that is Mackay. Silly me.

So back to my point, if Moody had signed an agreement there could indeed be a problem.

Edited by Mapletree (15 Apr 2014 8.32pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 15 Apr 14 8.37pm

Right, now found out that Moody was paid off and did sign a Settlement Agreement.

That's a bit of a pity......

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 15 Apr 14 8.39pm

Surely the problem is at Cardiff's end.
Even if Moody spoke to somebody at Cardiff about details, that information was given willingly, I doubt he got the thumbscrews out, therefore Tan's gripe is with HIS employee. Perhaps he needs to try and find out who's not quite so loyal.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 15 Apr 14 8.50pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Cardiff leaks' by SloveniaDave

Quote muffinbrucie at 15 Apr 2014 7.52pm

That's sussed not Sussex, I should have checked,doh


You didn't check if there was already a thread about this, either.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 15 Apr 14 8.55pm

The folks I feel for are the abused Cardiff City FC "Bluebirds" supporters. They get this guy in as owner who totally trashes the club's identity, undermines and then fires the best manager they've ever had and allows the architect of that side to leave and then, when things go predictably wrong, chooses to blame everyone else instead of taking a good hard look in the mirror. Tan makes Venkys look positively enlightened. If someone knows how to get in touch with their Supporters Club, suggest that they take a page out of Blackburn's book and find the appropriate barnyard animal to let loose at the next home match.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 15 Apr 14 9.15pm

Who's more likely to be telling the truth?
Parish and Moody who run a proper football club and run it well, or Vincent Tan with his stupid high trousers, crap ethos, retraction of the player bonus, due to NOT KNOWING THE RULES and someone who doesn't know what the offside rule is?

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 15 Apr 14 9.17pm

Quote Mapletree at 15 Apr 2014 8.37pm

Right, now found out that Moody was paid off and did sign a Settlement Agreement.

That's a bit of a pity......


Not an expert but I would guess that the agreement would refer to knowledge already held although it might have a non contact clause too, but then would just be a civil case (although still enough for the FA to act). West Ham had two players purchased illegally and still survived, I think the Fa generally acts in a big club small club way so I am a little worried about this even though theoretically it SHOULD only cost us 3 points.


 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

glazedallover Flag Allier 15 Apr 14 9.21pm

So basically nobody here knows if we should be worried or not.

How soon are the FA likely to rule on any possible penalties financial or otherwise?

 

Page 5 of 25 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?