You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end


Page 5 of 25 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 09 Nov 14 1.53am

Quote The White Horse at 09 Nov 2014 1.43am

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 9.10am

Anyone who says that these things shouldn't happen are derided and ridiculed. The greens are anti austerity so they're not being included in televised election debates because Murdoch and his mates stand to lose the most. If the greens are so wrong, let them in on the debate anyway and let Joe public see the arguments for and against. Could it be the anti austerity groups have a point? The establishment are scared of the alternative arguments, so they sweep it under the carpet and deride it. Brand has a point, but instead of arguing why he is wrong, he's ridiculed.

Current polling average (during a good period for the Greens), with the number of MPs in brackets:

Labour - 33 (257)
Tories - 32 (303)
UKIP - 16 (1)
Lib Dem - 8 (56)
Greens - 5 (1)

At the last general election, they got 0.9% of the vote and out of 310 seats I think they kept their deposit in about 5. It's not a conspiracy to keep certain views out of the debate, there simply has to be a line drawn somewhere and a party almost always failing to keep its deposit shouldn't be surprised to find itself on the wrong side of the line.

You're right that few people actually discuss his politics (a lot of playing the man and not the ball as has been mentioned), but he doesn't actually represent a politics that many people vote for. Why doesn't he just tell people to vote green? That's surely what his politics is closest to. There are 15 million people who don't vote up for grabs; if UKIP can attract millions of them, it can't be that hard.


True to a degree, but when no-one in the mainstream media has even touched upon an alternative to austerity, even to rubbish it, or that the current hegemony is completely f***ed up and screwed is it no surprise that not many people question the current status quo.
Would UKIP have had as many votes had they not had all the media coverage initially?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Nov 14 9.09am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 08 Nov 2014 2.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 Nov 2014 8.28am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Nov 2014 11.22pm

The man is a complete cock.

The capitalism he "hates" has allowed him to have a very comfy lifestyle including a rather lavish wedding by anyone's standards never mind a "revolutionary" and also fund his upcoming film.

The reality is that capitalism ultimately works because it fits in with human nature far better than any other well meaning "we are all equal" rhetoric

Doesn't exist, its a convenient phrase that's used to justify something as being an necessary truth, without the presentation of evidence - despite the fact that there is absolutely no real evidence of anything being classed as human nature outside of certain physiological reactions. To class a hypothetical concept as human nature is a poor rhetoric trick that is a secularised version of gods will or the right of kings etc.

The excellent [Link] is a good starting point for understanding the complexity of human nature as a subject (note that this has since been expanded to include twelve different perspective theories about human nature).



Jamie, we as in humans have progressed / regressed depending on your stance due to "human nature". We are animals, nothing more and nothing less.

Is capitalism perfect? No of course not and wanton greed cannot be allowed at the detriment of everyone else. However socialism never truly exists because even in socialist states someone is still getting f***ed over to make someone else richer.

The problem here is that you're redefining capitalism and socialism to mean something that they not, their economic systems of distribution, both have advantages and disadvantages. Capitalism didn't invent the idea of profit, just as Socialism didn't invent the idea of redistribution.

As to the first part, yes and no, we are biological entities and fundamentally animals, but our utilisation of biological determinism to simplify nature to easily reducible common shared factors. I'd present the same argument as applicable to 'dog nature' or 'gorilla' nature - in that certainly in most mammals, individual personality defines behaviour far more than biological nature and mammals learn their behaviours far more than they are born with them.

This is especially true in higher mammals when the necessity for competitive survival has been removed (ie domesticated animals). That's before you add the complexities of language into the functionality and formation of individuals.

Capitalism itself originated out of the production of the middle classes, through merchants and the rise of yeomanry, prior to which the concept of wealth as a characteristic of the individual was somewhat more constrained (wealth existed for what you could do with it, rather than as a means in and of itself, it was a tool to an end, rather than an end in its own right).

Capitalism is simply a progression from previous systems that will be surplanted by others, as it replaced others before it (indeed Capitalism of the earlier eras has itself been replaced by different forms of capitalism).

Capitalism was entirely dependent on five major factors. The rise of protestatism, the publication of 'Summa de arithmetica, geometria', industrialisation and the works of Adam Smith and the emergence of the merchant classes (and ultimately the middle classes).

It has no relationship really to human nature, beyond being developed by humans to suit the needs of thoe with power and status. As the emergent middle classes gained increasing social power, society changed more to reflect their interests (with power being ceded by the aristocratic land owners).

Prior to the rise of capitalism, the dominant system wasn't profit, it was land ownership.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Nov 14 9.12am

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Nov 2014 9.59am

Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 07 Nov 2014 8.25pm

Quote nickgusset at 07 Nov 2014 7.13pm
It's easier to take the piss out of the messenger than answer the questions / issues he brings up.


The message? The questions? Russell Brand's take on things - in my humble opinion, is akin to revolutionary tourettes. What is his message? I'm not sure even he knows, to be honest. It's so verbosely contrived that he actually talks himself around in a circle half the time.

Also, he's very keen to point out the failures of society without offering viable non-uptopian, practical solutions, reasonable alternatives or even just a consistent approach to any one issue.

Half the time it sounds like he's swallowed a thesaurus, vomited it back up and proceeded to sit and eat it, whilst discussing its merits. Most of what he says is a confused nonsense of pseudo-political, revolutionary rhetoric with no cognisant use in modern day socio-economic practices.

See, he has me at it now. PARKLIFE!


You just summed him up completely for me Mongo (Jim'll).


It's the modern day socia economic practices that he is arguing against, so of course it wouldn't. His main tenet is there has to be a better way, but that the establishment are unwilling to look for one as it doesn't favour them.

Also he isn't an economist. He's just a bloke highlighting that social injustice.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 09 Nov 14 9.59am

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2014 1.26am

Whatever you think of Brand and his politics, the fact he gets the eye-swivelling, frothy-mouthed loony green-ink brigade pissing their pants at the very sight and sound of him makes him good value for money in my book.


Very much like Clarkson then eh Seth?

 

Hoof Hearted 09 Nov 14 10.03am

Quote nickgusset at 09 Nov 2014 1.53am

Quote The White Horse at 09 Nov 2014 1.43am

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 9.10am

Anyone who says that these things shouldn't happen are derided and ridiculed. The greens are anti austerity so they're not being included in televised election debates because Murdoch and his mates stand to lose the most. If the greens are so wrong, let them in on the debate anyway and let Joe public see the arguments for and against. Could it be the anti austerity groups have a point? The establishment are scared of the alternative arguments, so they sweep it under the carpet and deride it. Brand has a point, but instead of arguing why he is wrong, he's ridiculed.

Current polling average (during a good period for the Greens), with the number of MPs in brackets:

Labour - 33 (257)
Tories - 32 (303)
UKIP - 16 (1)
Lib Dem - 8 (56)
Greens - 5 (1)

At the last general election, they got 0.9% of the vote and out of 310 seats I think they kept their deposit in about 5. It's not a conspiracy to keep certain views out of the debate, there simply has to be a line drawn somewhere and a party almost always failing to keep its deposit shouldn't be surprised to find itself on the wrong side of the line.

You're right that few people actually discuss his politics (a lot of playing the man and not the ball as has been mentioned), but he doesn't actually represent a politics that many people vote for. Why doesn't he just tell people to vote green? That's surely what his politics is closest to. There are 15 million people who don't vote up for grabs; if UKIP can attract millions of them, it can't be that hard.


True to a degree, but when no-one in the mainstream media has even touched upon an alternative to austerity, even to rubbish it, or that the current hegemony is completely f***ed up and screwed is it no surprise that not many people question the current status quo.
Would UKIP have had as many votes had they not had all the media coverage initially?


That's your fault nick.... you keep mentioning them and people take notice mate!

 

Hoof Hearted 09 Nov 14 10.06am

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.27am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Nov 2014 10.03am

Quote Percy of Peckham at 08 Nov 2014 9.28am

Whilst I wouldn't disagree with everything he says ...it should not detract from the fact he is incredibly irritating and at times obnoxious. I've never really been sure where his "talent" lies or why he is regarded as a celebrity. He is certainly not a warrior because he'd have to be someone I'd look up to - he'd probably make a great politician or a bell end as they are very similar in my book.


Agreed... he certainly lost any respect he might of had when he did that stunt on air with Woss taking the p1ss out of 'Manuel' and his grand-daughter.

Something that he has apologised for and profusely regrets.


That's okay then..... we can let Clarkson off for his gaffes which "he has apologised for and profusely regrets"

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 09 Nov 14 10.12am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Nov 2014 10.03am

Quote nickgusset at 09 Nov 2014 1.53am

Quote The White Horse at 09 Nov 2014 1.43am

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 9.10am

Anyone who says that these things shouldn't happen are derided and ridiculed. The greens are anti austerity so they're not being included in televised election debates because Murdoch and his mates stand to lose the most. If the greens are so wrong, let them in on the debate anyway and let Joe public see the arguments for and against. Could it be the anti austerity groups have a point? The establishment are scared of the alternative arguments, so they sweep it under the carpet and deride it. Brand has a point, but instead of arguing why he is wrong, he's ridiculed.

Current polling average (during a good period for the Greens), with the number of MPs in brackets:

Labour - 33 (257)
Tories - 32 (303)
UKIP - 16 (1)
Lib Dem - 8 (56)
Greens - 5 (1)

At the last general election, they got 0.9% of the vote and out of 310 seats I think they kept their deposit in about 5. It's not a conspiracy to keep certain views out of the debate, there simply has to be a line drawn somewhere and a party almost always failing to keep its deposit shouldn't be surprised to find itself on the wrong side of the line.

You're right that few people actually discuss his politics (a lot of playing the man and not the ball as has been mentioned), but he doesn't actually represent a politics that many people vote for. Why doesn't he just tell people to vote green? That's surely what his politics is closest to. There are 15 million people who don't vote up for grabs; if UKIP can attract millions of them, it can't be that hard.


True to a degree, but when no-one in the mainstream media has even touched upon an alternative to austerity, even to rubbish it, or that the current hegemony is completely f***ed up and screwed is it no surprise that not many people question the current status quo.
Would UKIP have had as many votes had they not had all the media coverage initially?


That's your fault nick.... you keep mentioning them and people take notice mate!


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 09 Nov 14 10.13am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Nov 2014 10.06am

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.27am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Nov 2014 10.03am

Quote Percy of Peckham at 08 Nov 2014 9.28am

Whilst I wouldn't disagree with everything he says ...it should not detract from the fact he is incredibly irritating and at times obnoxious. I've never really been sure where his "talent" lies or why he is regarded as a celebrity. He is certainly not a warrior because he'd have to be someone I'd look up to - he'd probably make a great politician or a bell end as they are very similar in my book.


Agreed... he certainly lost any respect he might of had when he did that stunt on air with Woss taking the p1ss out of 'Manuel' and his grand-daughter.

Something that he has apologised for and profusely regrets.


That's okay then..... we can let Clarkson off for his gaffes which "he has apologised for and profusely regrets"

Got no problem with Clarkson.

 

The White Horse Flag 09 Nov 14 1.20pm

Quote nickgusset at 09 Nov 2014 1.53am

True to a degree, but when no-one in the mainstream media has even touched upon an alternative to austerity, even to rubbish it

Is Owen Jones not in the mainstream media? I'd imagine he's on telly and radio at least daily? Is Russell Brand not getting a fairly decent airing at the moment? I'd say the Greens get at least their 5% of political media coverage (certainly 1%).

Presumably you define 'austerity' as any political ideology that suggests spending cuts are necessary? If the Greens (and a handful of tinpot parties) are the only ones against it, then at the last general election, 99% of people voted for 'pro-austerity parties'.

Quote nickgusset at 09 Nov 2014 1.53am

or that the current hegemony is completely f***ed up and screwed is it no surprise that not many people question the current status quo.

Loads of people do. There's been a long-term decline in support for Labour and the Tories, there was a poll the other day where the other parties had 40% of the vote.

Quote nickgusset at 09 Nov 2014 1.53am

Would UKIP have had as many votes had they not had all the media coverage initially?

Perhaps not, but they'd have at least twice as many votes as the Greens, because they represent something that many people already believe, rather than trying to convince people to believe something different.

The mistake the Greens make is that they assume people will 'come round' to their way of thinking because they're largely right. That's not how politics works, particularly under first past the post.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Nov 14 2.02pm

Quote The White Horse at 09 Nov 2014 1.20pm

Perhaps not, but they'd have at least twice as many votes as the Greens, because they represent something that many people already believe, rather than trying to convince people to believe something different.

The mistake the Greens make is that they assume people will 'come round' to their way of thinking because they're largely right. That's not how politics works, particularly under first past the post.


Though it pains me to type it.....That's largely right.

Other than the bit about the Greens being 'largely right'.

The world that the Greens would recast us in isn't realistic nor practically achievable. The Greens have some sensible points but as a whole their policies are unrealistic.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 14 7.40pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Nov 2014 9.59am

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2014 1.26am

Whatever you think of Brand and his politics, the fact he gets the eye-swivelling, frothy-mouthed loony green-ink brigade pissing their pants at the very sight and sound of him makes him good value for money in my book.


Very much like Clarkson then eh Seth?

You betcha Hoofy

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 09 Nov 14 10.31pm

Rarely heard someone hit the nail on the head as completely as this: [Link]

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

The White Horse Flag 09 Nov 14 11.54pm

Quote serial thriller at 09 Nov 2014 10.31pm

Rarely heard someone hit the nail on the head as completely as this: [Link]

Summarised, doesn't that basically boil down to "there's more to life than basic human desires, humanity should aspire to something better, be nice and chill out a bit".

Hard to disagree with, but it's such a broad suggestion that it doesn't really inspire anything in particular. And most people wouldn't have both the patience and vocabulary to listen to him.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Stuk Flag Top half 10 Nov 14 2.59pm

Nick. See France for the alternative to austerity, giving Le Pen a serious shout at the next election.

Russell Brand doesn't live here, doesn't vote and just talks in soundbites in order to flog his book.

He's also a terrible actor.

 


Optimistic as ever

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 10 Nov 14 3.49pm

Quote serial thriller at 09 Nov 2014 10.31pm

Rarely heard someone hit the nail on the head as completely as this: [Link]

Whatever message in that was lost amongst him waffling on about Spirituality & religion.
He may have found some inner peace through meditation and believing in works of fiction & thats great for him but it doesnt stop him being consumed by his own illusion.

I prefer to see the beauty in the things we don't make up in our heads, from the collisions of Quarks (the first building blocks of everything) to the chemical reactions in Cells are all infinitely more beautiful than God.

“If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe.”
Carl Sagan

Edited by Ouzo Dan (10 Nov 2014 3.50pm)

Edited by Ouzo Dan (10 Nov 2014 3.50pm)

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 10 Nov 14 3.58pm

Just in case it wasn't clear from my earlier post, I would like to re-iterate my position that he is a complete bell end.

I cannot stress enough the extent to which I believe this to be the case.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

derby eagle Flag Derby 10 Nov 14 5.07pm

Worse than a bellend. My dog is called Bellaend and I'm piping up on her behalf as she would never want to be associated with such a total tool.

 

Mongo Like Clunge Flag Bumfuck City, Texas 10 Nov 14 5.44pm

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.26am
It's the modern day socia economic practices that he is arguing against


I meant framework, but it's a fair point either way considering how far out some of his views are. My biggest beef with him - and what I was trying to outline there, is his willingness to take potshots, but unwillingness to even attempt to effect change from within.

Cowardice or reticence?

 


WORRIED that your teeth will be stained after a heavy night drinking red wine? Fear not; drink a bottle of white wine before going to bed, to remove the stains.

TUX Flag redhill 10 Nov 14 8.14pm

Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 10 Nov 2014 5.44pm

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.26am
It's the modern day socia economic practices that he is arguing against


I meant framework, but it's a fair point either way considering how far out some of his views are. My biggest beef with him - and what I was trying to outline there, is his willingness to take potshots, but unwillingness to even attempt to effect change from within.

Cowardice or reticence?

All he can do is spread 'the truth' and hope that many follow. The bigger the following the brighter the future for many.
But sadly it'll never happen.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Nov 14 8.23pm

Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 10 Nov 2014 5.44pm

Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.26am
It's the modern day socia economic practices that he is arguing against


I meant framework, but it's a fair point either way considering how far out some of his views are. My biggest beef with him - and what I was trying to outline there, is his willingness to take potshots, but unwillingness to even attempt to effect change from within.

Cowardice or reticence?


Slowly getting through the book... He does say that he is trying to effect change from within himself.
Also said that it would have been easier to just write 'Booky wook 3' make money from that and save the hassle of vast swathes of the media turning against him.

 

Page 5 of 25 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end