You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Greens
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Greens


Page 5 of 21 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Stuk Flag Top half 09 Dec 14 4.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 3.26pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 3.12pm

Most efficient using what criteria? Do you mind posting it again or tell me exactly where I can find it?

The NHS does lots of good stuff but I find the efficiency claim very surprising, given how centralised it is.

The European Health Consumer Index is a regularly produced report by one of the leading providers of information about international healthcare.

I used to work in healthcare marketing by the way. Before you think I'm sad enough to spend my free time reading these sorts of reports.


Here's the link again: [Link]

I'm no expert and you obviously have a professional interest in this subject, but I do find it irritating when the NHS is attacked from the right, especially when the people doing the attacking have a vested interest in privatising our system because they want to make a profit from it. I'm not tarring you with that brush by the way and wonder what you make of the Commonwealth Fund report, if you can be sad enough to read another one

Edited by Seth (09 Dec 2014 3.27pm)

It's not as transparent in terms of how it generated the scores. Or what data it used. Which makes it hard to judge.

It seems that the UK's high score for "efficiency" stems from the fact that Britain spends less per capita than other countries. Which it does, certainly compared to the US. Not sure if that automatically means it's the "best" system though.

Some of the categories seem a bit woolly. Eg, 'Equity'. What does that mean?

And Britain comes first on "patient-centred care". Which sounds good, but what does it mean and how do they measure it?

I find it remarkable that the UK comes first on virtually everything while countries which perform a lot better in other studies (Germany, Netherlands, Norway) all do comparatively so poorly. Is the NHS really that wonderful!?

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

Glad to hear I'm not being tarred with any brushes.

It's understandable that people are wary of privatisation. But the NHS is completely intertwined with the private sector anyway. And the US system is hardly a pure free market. Medicare and Medicaid are huge state-funded programmes. It's not as simple as reducing "privatisation bad, nationalisation good."

It crossed my mind while reading it too.

 


Optimistic as ever

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

It crossed my mind while reading it too.


I had a similar thought with Johnny's linked report, although from the opposite political perspective.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 4.26pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 3.26pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 3.12pm

Most efficient using what criteria? Do you mind posting it again or tell me exactly where I can find it?

The NHS does lots of good stuff but I find the efficiency claim very surprising, given how centralised it is.

The European Health Consumer Index is a regularly produced report by one of the leading providers of information about international healthcare.

I used to work in healthcare marketing by the way. Before you think I'm sad enough to spend my free time reading these sorts of reports.


Here's the link again: [Link]

I'm no expert and you obviously have a professional interest in this subject, but I do find it irritating when the NHS is attacked from the right, especially when the people doing the attacking have a vested interest in privatising our system because they want to make a profit from it. I'm not tarring you with that brush by the way and wonder what you make of the Commonwealth Fund report, if you can be sad enough to read another one

Edited by Seth (09 Dec 2014 3.27pm)

It's not as transparent in terms of how it generated the scores. Or what data it used. Which makes it hard to judge.

It seems that the UK's high score for "efficiency" stems from the fact that Britain spends less per capita than other countries. Which it does, certainly compared to the US. Not sure if that automatically means it's the "best" system though.

Some of the categories seem a bit woolly. Eg, 'Equity'. What does that mean?

And Britain comes first on "patient-centred care". Which sounds good, but what does it mean and how do they measure it?

I find it remarkable that the UK comes first on virtually everything while countries which perform a lot better in other studies (Germany, Netherlands, Norway) all do comparatively so poorly. Is the NHS really that wonderful!?

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

Glad to hear I'm not being tarred with any brushes.

It's understandable that people are wary of privatisation. But the NHS is completely intertwined with the private sector anyway. And the US system is hardly a pure free market. Medicare and Medicaid are huge state-funded programmes. It's not as simple as reducing "privatisation bad, nationalisation good."

I can't answer all your points but am satisfied that the NHS represents very good value for money, especially compared with other country's health systems.

No service will be perfect but, with proper funding, we can be proud of what we have in the NHS.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Dec 14 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Dec 14 4.43pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

It crossed my mind while reading it too.


I had a similar thought with Johnny's linked report, although from the opposite political perspective.

We were talking about a country, not a political perspective.

Who do think that report is out to bash, and why?

 


Optimistic as ever

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 4.50pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

My experience is that GP services have deteriorated dramatically over the last few years and the funding cuts over the same timescale are no coincidence.

The report I linked to agrees and I'm inclined to believe the GP's.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 09 Dec 14 4.52pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

I'm not a unthinking defender of the NHS (and have been in work-related private healthcare schemes for about 10 years now) but I can always get to see my GP the same day for a shorter 5 minute consultation if it is an urgent case and can get an appointment within a maximum of 48 hours if not.

The only thing that prevents me being able to see them within that period is my own inflexibility trying to get around work. And even then they offer limited weekday appointments starting at 07:30 for working people to facilitate.

I suspect it is a case of good and bad GP surgeries exist.

As someone with 2 small children they have been massively helpful to me and I can have very little complaint about the quality of care provided.

Edited by OknotOK (09 Dec 2014 4.53pm)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 4.53pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.43pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

It crossed my mind while reading it too.


I had a similar thought with Johnny's linked report, although from the opposite political perspective.

We were talking about a country, not a political perspective.

Who do think that report is out to bash, and why?


I merely wondered if the report Johnny quoted was politically motivated to bash the NHS. Johnny says it's by one of the "leading providers of information about international healthcare" and I've accepted that. I was just saying I had my doubts when it was first posted, that's all.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Dec 14 4.54pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

Arguably that's funding, if they're aren't enough GPs to go around and increasingly less incentives to work in the NHS as a GP.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 4.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Dec 2014 4.54pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

Arguably that's funding, if they're aren't enough GPs to go around and increasingly less incentives to work in the NHS as a GP.

Indeed. If more people want to see their GP and they can't it's because there's not enough funding for more GP's.

My daughter is at med school and is not inclined to become a GP because of the ever-increasing workload and huge cuts in their funding.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Dec 14 5.04pm

GP's are a lottery. First you generally can't book an appointment, or if you can its for about a week in advance, then it can be a total crap shoot who you'll see and what time you'll get into see them.

Then comes to the fun of trying to persuade them that you actually are ill

Invariably then you get the fun of coming back because either the treatment was useless, or because you were right all along, that it wasn't something like a cold (who the f**k goes to the GP for a cold unless its persisting).

Plus all the fun of contracting something else in the 30-40 minute wait, despite being five minutes early for the appointment time.

Eventually, after a few visits, they'll pass you onto a specialist and you just have to hope that it wasn't something really serious.

After six months of complaining to her GP about pains in her side that was intermitant, my mother finally got diagnosed with clear cell cancer in her kidney, only because she'd gone in for breathing complaint which turned out to be a pulmonary embolism from the cancer.

Sadly, by that point it had metasticised to her Spine and lungs, and removing the Kidney only bought her more time, where as had they scanned her for the pain, rather than going for cheap painkiller options, she'd have had a 90% chance of survival once the kidney was removed.

Pressure on GPs is not to refer, and to hit budgets totals. Invariably that gets people killed.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Dec 14 5.12pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.50pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

My experience is that GP services have deteriorated dramatically over the last few years and the funding cuts over the same timescale are no coincidence.

The report I linked to agrees and I'm inclined to believe the GP's.

Mine has actually improved in the last couple of years, thanks to a new and larger practice but getting same day or next day appointments are still almost impossible. (That's with 100% patient flexibility OKnotOK.)

I'm always less inclined to fully believe a report done by someone with a heavily vested interest in a certain outcome, rather than an independently found conclusion.

 


Optimistic as ever

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 09 Dec 14 5.14pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

It crossed my mind while reading it too.


I had a similar thought with Johnny's linked report, although from the opposite political perspective.

What opposite political perspective is that then?

The rabidly free-market Dutch and Danish healthcare industry?!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Dec 14 5.14pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.53pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.43pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

It crossed my mind while reading it too.


I had a similar thought with Johnny's linked report, although from the opposite political perspective.

We were talking about a country, not a political perspective.

Who do think that report is out to bash, and why?


I merely wondered if the report Johnny quoted was politically motivated to bash the NHS. Johnny says it's by one of the "leading providers of information about international healthcare" and I've accepted that. I was just saying I had my doubts when it was first posted, that's all.


Fair dos. I didn't see it as out to promote or bash any of the systems it reported on.

The other one does seemingly lean towards it though.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Dec 14 5.14pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Dec 2014 3.27pm

Quote Stuk at 08 Dec 2014 5.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 Dec 2014 5.01pm

Quote matt_himself at 08 Dec 2014 4.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 Dec 2014 4.46pm

I don't think people are against the idea of paying tax, rather they're more against the way in which its spent (or wasted) on things like vanity projects and political egotism.


Tax payers money is not just wasted on vanity projects and political egotism. It is wasted by those running public services. It has been proven that reducing public spending reduces waste and the waste that departments makes is criminal. Look at the recent news about the amount spent by the NHS on paracetamol. It was something like £5 a packet. Outrageous.

I am not for the dismantling of public services but I think a dosage of private sector keeping costs down management will be of benefit to all concerned.

How many paracetamol in the packet, what size and what strength? Is that the cost of the drugs, or the cost of dispensing the drug to patients in A+E or hospitals (when you figure in other costs).

The private sector isn't as efficient as people tend to think either, and in many cases are a reason why government costs can be much higher.

Government services will always cost more than the private counter parts, because the public will insist on higher standards in regards to operations and responsibility, which results in greater expenditure.


I don't agree. Firstly the public, for the most part, wouldn't have a clue about quality or standards. The costs are higher because there's a chain of people/departments and pointless procedures invovled to do anything, which all add to costs. Whereas the private sector have to compete against others normally, resulting in lower costs.

Not to mention being far more efficient, at anything.

Personal experience. I've worked in contracts to government and private sector, private sector work has a lot less in the way of requirements, compared to government sector work.

For example, there when providing IT into government sectors you have all manner of health and safety requirements that you just don't see in the private sector (such as RSI systems, Special Needs Software, higher data protection requirements, security protocols are higher, environmental systems requirements, more resilient DR and fallback plans, restricted infrastructure requirements are higher etc). You'll need to security clear staff to just be on site, which you almost never will for private sector contracts. Chances are you'll have restricted hardware limitations as well.

Even requirements in regards to development, testing and QA is much higher when you're working with governments, as is auditing requirements.

Defense is even more extreme in its standards and requirements.

It all has to be recouped somehow, and invariably it costs more.

It costs about 750-1000 per end user to provide a workstation to a government worker. Its about 500-750 in private sector.



And the private sector worker will still have the better equipment at the end of the day.

As I said it's the chain of pointless procedures and box ticking that means you pay more, for lower rather than higher standards. Not to mention the additional costs of someone else, ordering it, unwrapping it, setting it up etc.

Not really, the two aren't really comparable. I remember being called into consult on a Lloyds project which was regularly blue screening users. They had the cheapest kit, worst processes and paid for the lowest quality service - because ultimately as long as they didn't lose the ATMs and basic service they didn't have a real problem (they could even resort to back ups).

You don't get the same flexibility with a Government systems.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Dec 14 5.15pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Dec 2014 4.54pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

Arguably that's funding, if they're aren't enough GPs to go around and increasingly less incentives to work in the NHS as a GP.

Arguably it's also population increase and population density.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Dec 14 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Dec 2014 5.14pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Dec 2014 3.27pm

Quote Stuk at 08 Dec 2014 5.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 Dec 2014 5.01pm

Quote matt_himself at 08 Dec 2014 4.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 Dec 2014 4.46pm

I don't think people are against the idea of paying tax, rather they're more against the way in which its spent (or wasted) on things like vanity projects and political egotism.


Tax payers money is not just wasted on vanity projects and political egotism. It is wasted by those running public services. It has been proven that reducing public spending reduces waste and the waste that departments makes is criminal. Look at the recent news about the amount spent by the NHS on paracetamol. It was something like £5 a packet. Outrageous.

I am not for the dismantling of public services but I think a dosage of private sector keeping costs down management will be of benefit to all concerned.

How many paracetamol in the packet, what size and what strength? Is that the cost of the drugs, or the cost of dispensing the drug to patients in A+E or hospitals (when you figure in other costs).

The private sector isn't as efficient as people tend to think either, and in many cases are a reason why government costs can be much higher.

Government services will always cost more than the private counter parts, because the public will insist on higher standards in regards to operations and responsibility, which results in greater expenditure.


I don't agree. Firstly the public, for the most part, wouldn't have a clue about quality or standards. The costs are higher because there's a chain of people/departments and pointless procedures invovled to do anything, which all add to costs. Whereas the private sector have to compete against others normally, resulting in lower costs.

Not to mention being far more efficient, at anything.

Personal experience. I've worked in contracts to government and private sector, private sector work has a lot less in the way of requirements, compared to government sector work.

For example, there when providing IT into government sectors you have all manner of health and safety requirements that you just don't see in the private sector (such as RSI systems, Special Needs Software, higher data protection requirements, security protocols are higher, environmental systems requirements, more resilient DR and fallback plans, restricted infrastructure requirements are higher etc). You'll need to security clear staff to just be on site, which you almost never will for private sector contracts. Chances are you'll have restricted hardware limitations as well.

Even requirements in regards to development, testing and QA is much higher when you're working with governments, as is auditing requirements.

Defense is even more extreme in its standards and requirements.

It all has to be recouped somehow, and invariably it costs more.

It costs about 750-1000 per end user to provide a workstation to a government worker. Its about 500-750 in private sector.



And the private sector worker will still have the better equipment at the end of the day.

As I said it's the chain of pointless procedures and box ticking that means you pay more, for lower rather than higher standards. Not to mention the additional costs of someone else, ordering it, unwrapping it, setting it up etc.

Not really, the two aren't really comparable. I remember being called into consult on a Lloyds project which was regularly blue screening users. They had the cheapest kit, worst processes and paid for the lowest quality service - because ultimately as long as they didn't lose the ATMs and basic service they didn't have a real problem (they could even resort to back ups).

You don't get the same flexibility with a Government systems.



You what?

Large private sector can be easily as wasteful as public.

Let's put it this way. An out of the box iPad, for example, will cost the public sector more per unit (with all associated costs) than it would in the private sector.

 


Optimistic as ever

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 5.29pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 5.12pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.50pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.40pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.23pm

Quote Superfly at 09 Dec 2014 4.15pm

The NHS, im my very very recent experience, is in a shocking state & getting worse.

I phoned to see my GP yesterday & was told they no longer take same day appointments. There is a same day walk in clinic from 2pm but they'll only see the first 18 people. I arrived at 1pm and the queue was out the door. I called again this morning to book a future appointment - the earliest they can book me in is the 24th December.

My group practice has 9 GP's and I'm willing to see any of them.

I'm going to have to join my work private health care. An action I despise as I don't see why I should when we have the NHS - but a 15 day wait for a doctors appointment is unacceptable.


My GP practice is similar and cuts to GP's funding are to blame. This report is from last year so it's probably even worse than then:

The GP system in England is facing a "catastrophe" because of cuts in funding, doctors' leaders are warning.

Analysis by the Royal College of GPs suggests that over the past three years, investment in general practice has fallen by £400m in real terms.

That is equivalent to a 7% cut in spending per patient, it says.

[Link]


It's been like this at GP surgeries for at least a decade. They have become so pointless that you need to second guess your illness in advance to see a GP.

It's not funding, it's the ratio of doctors and surgeries to people, which gets worse by the day.

My experience is that GP services have deteriorated dramatically over the last few years and the funding cuts over the same timescale are no coincidence.

The report I linked to agrees and I'm inclined to believe the GP's.

Mine has actually improved in the last couple of years, thanks to a new and larger practice but getting same day or next day appointments are still almost impossible. (That's with 100% patient flexibility OKnotOK.)

I'm always less inclined to fully believe a report done by someone with a heavily vested interest in a certain outcome, rather than an independently found conclusion.


Glad yours has improved. Mine hasn't, although they're making some changes just now which are meant to make things better. We'll see.

You say vested interests, I say experience and expertise. Let's call the whole thing off.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Dec 14 5.31pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 5.14pm

Quote Seth at 09 Dec 2014 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2014 4.21pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 4.19pm

The cynic in me makes me wonder if the people behind this study were keen on using it to bash the American healthcare system, which is a bit of a political hot potato over there.

It crossed my mind while reading it too.


I had a similar thought with Johnny's linked report, although from the opposite political perspective.

What opposite political perspective is that then?

The rabidly free-market Dutch and Danish healthcare industry?!

I obviously didn't make myself clear. To repeat what I said to Stuk, I merely wondered if the report you quoted was politically motivated to bash the NHS. You say it's by one of the "leading providers of information about international healthcare" and I've accepted that. I was just saying I had my doubts when it was first posted, that's all.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Page 5 of 21 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Greens