You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Jeremy Clarkson
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jeremy Clarkson


Page 5 of 17 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Stuk Flag Top half 11 Mar 15 9.49pm

Quote imbored at 11 Mar 2015 9.23pm

Quote TUX at 11 Mar 2015 9.17pm

Quote imbored at 11 Mar 2015 9.03pm

Shouldn't what has actually happened here hold some sway over whether he should be back on our screens? If he's actually physically assaulted someone, just because we find him entertaining that's not the be all and end all. The BBC already have a reputation for letting all kinds of behaviour slide on account of their stars popularity. It's not a management style that's served them well.

Let's detach this from "PC" on one side and "team clarkson" on the other. If it turns out this was a nothing incident, he should definitely keep his job. If he essentially lamped someone for no good reason then he shouldn't.

Edited by imbored (11 Mar 2015 9.05pm)

That's Jedinak on the dole queue then. No more TV appearances for him too I guess as he also 'became angry' while at work.


Edited by TUX (11 Mar 2015 9.19pm)

Incidents in a contact sport are perhaps a bit different from hitting someone because your dinner is late, if it turns out that's actually what happened. If you disagree, I wouldn't want to be your missus, haha. Joke.



It's actually a good juxtaposition I think.

Jedinak's, I hope, moment of madness, would be what most would call a "cheap shot". Whether this was similar, or a dust up as James May described it, who knows.

 


Optimistic as ever

imbored Flag UK 11 Mar 15 9.58pm

Quote TUX at 11 Mar 2015 9.38pm

Quote imbored at 11 Mar 2015 9.23pm

Quote TUX at 11 Mar 2015 9.17pm

Quote imbored at 11 Mar 2015 9.03pm

Shouldn't what has actually happened here hold some sway over whether he should be back on our screens? If he's actually physically assaulted someone, just because we find him entertaining that's not the be all and end all. The BBC already have a reputation for letting all kinds of behaviour slide on account of their stars popularity. It's not a management style that's served them well.

Let's detach this from "PC" on one side and "team clarkson" on the other. If it turns out this was a nothing incident, he should definitely keep his job. If he essentially lamped someone for no good reason then he shouldn't.

Edited by imbored (11 Mar 2015 9.05pm)

That's Jedinak on the dole queue then. No more TV appearances for him too I guess as he also 'became angry' while at work.


Edited by TUX (11 Mar 2015 9.19pm)

Incidents in a contact sport are perhaps a bit different from hitting someone because your dinner is late, if it turns out that's actually what happened. If you disagree, I wouldn't want to be your missus, haha. Joke.


So elbowing someone unexpectedly is far less of a 'crime' than having an alleged face off.......then things happen to go further?
Hmmmm.......i'll rise above and leave your good lady out of this.


My good lady is more likely to give me a back hander for my woeful attempts at cooking!

As for the other point, I'm stating that within contact sports, a degree of physical aggression is expected and punished within the culture of that sport. As such, a ten second brawl in rugby is unlikely to see them all banned from the sport, but a brawl in a boardroom is likely to see people fired.

Edited by imbored (11 Mar 2015 10.04pm)

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 11 Mar 15 10.55pm

Je suis Clarkson

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 11 Mar 15 11.06pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 Mar 2015 10.55pm

Je suis Clarkson

...il est Jezza!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

legaleagle Flag 11 Mar 15 11.43pm

Quote Percy of Peckham at 11 Mar 2015 11.06pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 Mar 2015 10.55pm

Je suis Clarkson

...il est Jezza!

Je suis un producer


Edited by legaleagle (11 Mar 2015 11.45pm)

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 11 Mar 15 11.54pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.53am

Quote Ian J at 11 Mar 2015 10.45am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.31am

Quote bexleydave at 10 Mar 2015 11.44pm

The problem for the BBC is that JC and his executive producer own 50% of the production company that make TG (the BBC own the other 50%). It won't continue if the two parties can't come to an agreement and with a worldwide audience of 300m and the BBC earning £4.5m from the programme last year, it will be a huge decision for the Beeb.

According to Radio 4 news this morning they quoted TG earning £200M from overseas syndication and that Clarkson sold his existing stake ages ago.

It will still be a huge cock up by the Beeb if they let him go.

The BBC are in a very difficult position as they have given Clarkson plenty of warnings and made the point last time that it was his last warning so what are they supposed to do now. It wasn't a case of mumbling something inaudible under his breath or insulting a race by using a derogatory term that most of us had never heard of as this time if the stories are to be believed he physically assaulted one of the staff which for any other person in any other company is a sacking offence.

If the BBC let him carry on as normal where does it stop?


Well Jimmy Saville had a Get Out Of Jail Free card!

If he has punched someone at work or threatened to punch someone at work no one can seriously expect that he can be allowed to carry on in his job.

All the BBC bashing on this is just a load of hypocrites sounding off. One of the issues about Jimmy Saville is that he was too powerful to touch. You are just saying that Clarkson is also too powerful to touch.

(Touch is probably an uncomfortable word to use in the same sentence as Jimmy Saville but you know what I mean).


Edited by Bert the Head (11 Mar 2015 11.56pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 12 Mar 15 12.21am

Quote Bert the Head at 11 Mar 2015 11.54pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.53am

Quote Ian J at 11 Mar 2015 10.45am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.31am

Quote bexleydave at 10 Mar 2015 11.44pm

The problem for the BBC is that JC and his executive producer own 50% of the production company that make TG (the BBC own the other 50%). It won't continue if the two parties can't come to an agreement and with a worldwide audience of 300m and the BBC earning £4.5m from the programme last year, it will be a huge decision for the Beeb.

According to Radio 4 news this morning they quoted TG earning £200M from overseas syndication and that Clarkson sold his existing stake ages ago.

It will still be a huge cock up by the Beeb if they let him go.

The BBC are in a very difficult position as they have given Clarkson plenty of warnings and made the point last time that it was his last warning so what are they supposed to do now. It wasn't a case of mumbling something inaudible under his breath or insulting a race by using a derogatory term that most of us had never heard of as this time if the stories are to be believed he physically assaulted one of the staff which for any other person in any other company is a sacking offence.

If the BBC let him carry on as normal where does it stop?


Well Jimmy Saville had a Get Out Of Jail Free card!

If he has punched someone at work or threatened to punch someone at work no one can seriously expect that he can be allowed to carry on in his job.

All the BBC bashing on this is just a load of hypocrites sounding off. One of the issues about Jimmy Saville is that he was too powerful to touch. You are just saying that Clarkson is also too powerful to touch.

(Touch is probably an uncomfortable word to use in the same sentence as Jimmy Saville but you know what I mean).


Edited by Bert the Head (11 Mar 2015 11.56pm)

Particularly if it were,for example,(allegedly) for punching someone in the face when Sir's refreshments were not up to Sir's expectations after filming had finished and Sir went off on a rant. I couldn't possibly say if that's (allegedly) what happened but it might be what someone who was there has (allegedly) said happened.


Edited by legaleagle (12 Mar 2015 12.23am)

 

imbored Flag UK 12 Mar 15 1.13am

Quote Bert the Head at 11 Mar 2015 11.54pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.53am

Quote Ian J at 11 Mar 2015 10.45am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.31am

Quote bexleydave at 10 Mar 2015 11.44pm

The problem for the BBC is that JC and his executive producer own 50% of the production company that make TG (the BBC own the other 50%). It won't continue if the two parties can't come to an agreement and with a worldwide audience of 300m and the BBC earning £4.5m from the programme last year, it will be a huge decision for the Beeb.

According to Radio 4 news this morning they quoted TG earning £200M from overseas syndication and that Clarkson sold his existing stake ages ago.

It will still be a huge cock up by the Beeb if they let him go.

The BBC are in a very difficult position as they have given Clarkson plenty of warnings and made the point last time that it was his last warning so what are they supposed to do now. It wasn't a case of mumbling something inaudible under his breath or insulting a race by using a derogatory term that most of us had never heard of as this time if the stories are to be believed he physically assaulted one of the staff which for any other person in any other company is a sacking offence.

If the BBC let him carry on as normal where does it stop?


Well Jimmy Saville had a Get Out Of Jail Free card!

If he has punched someone at work or threatened to punch someone at work no one can seriously expect that he can be allowed to carry on in his job.

All the BBC bashing on this is just a load of hypocrites sounding off. One of the issues about Jimmy Saville is that he was too powerful to touch. You are just saying that Clarkson is also too powerful to touch.

(Touch is probably an uncomfortable word to use in the same sentence as Jimmy Saville but you know what I mean).


Edited by Bert the Head (11 Mar 2015 11.56pm)

I wonder how many already adamant that Clarkson should stay were certain that Brand should gone? I must have missed the bit where he lamped Andrew Sachs.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 12 Mar 15 6.11am

Quote imbored at 12 Mar 2015 1.13am

Quote Bert the Head at 11 Mar 2015 11.54pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.53am

Quote Ian J at 11 Mar 2015 10.45am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.31am

Quote bexleydave at 10 Mar 2015 11.44pm

The problem for the BBC is that JC and his executive producer own 50% of the production company that make TG (the BBC own the other 50%). It won't continue if the two parties can't come to an agreement and with a worldwide audience of 300m and the BBC earning £4.5m from the programme last year, it will be a huge decision for the Beeb.

According to Radio 4 news this morning they quoted TG earning £200M from overseas syndication and that Clarkson sold his existing stake ages ago.

It will still be a huge cock up by the Beeb if they let him go.

The BBC are in a very difficult position as they have given Clarkson plenty of warnings and made the point last time that it was his last warning so what are they supposed to do now. It wasn't a case of mumbling something inaudible under his breath or insulting a race by using a derogatory term that most of us had never heard of as this time if the stories are to be believed he physically assaulted one of the staff which for any other person in any other company is a sacking offence.

If the BBC let him carry on as normal where does it stop?


Well Jimmy Saville had a Get Out Of Jail Free card!

If he has punched someone at work or threatened to punch someone at work no one can seriously expect that he can be allowed to carry on in his job.

All the BBC bashing on this is just a load of hypocrites sounding off. One of the issues about Jimmy Saville is that he was too powerful to touch. You are just saying that Clarkson is also too powerful to touch.

(Touch is probably an uncomfortable word to use in the same sentence as Jimmy Saville but you know what I mean).


Edited by Bert the Head (11 Mar 2015 11.56pm)

I wonder how many already adamant that Clarkson should stay were certain that Brand should gone? I must have missed the bit where he lamped Andrew Sachs.


Russell Brand should just be ignored.

The World needs people like Clarkson. Without his like, insipid liberals have one less thing to moan about and Blokes going through a mid life crisis have no role models.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

imbored Flag UK 12 Mar 15 6.18am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Mar 2015 6.11am

Quote imbored at 12 Mar 2015 1.13am

Quote Bert the Head at 11 Mar 2015 11.54pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.53am

Quote Ian J at 11 Mar 2015 10.45am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.31am

Quote bexleydave at 10 Mar 2015 11.44pm

The problem for the BBC is that JC and his executive producer own 50% of the production company that make TG (the BBC own the other 50%). It won't continue if the two parties can't come to an agreement and with a worldwide audience of 300m and the BBC earning £4.5m from the programme last year, it will be a huge decision for the Beeb.

According to Radio 4 news this morning they quoted TG earning £200M from overseas syndication and that Clarkson sold his existing stake ages ago.

It will still be a huge cock up by the Beeb if they let him go.

The BBC are in a very difficult position as they have given Clarkson plenty of warnings and made the point last time that it was his last warning so what are they supposed to do now. It wasn't a case of mumbling something inaudible under his breath or insulting a race by using a derogatory term that most of us had never heard of as this time if the stories are to be believed he physically assaulted one of the staff which for any other person in any other company is a sacking offence.

If the BBC let him carry on as normal where does it stop?


Well Jimmy Saville had a Get Out Of Jail Free card!

If he has punched someone at work or threatened to punch someone at work no one can seriously expect that he can be allowed to carry on in his job.

All the BBC bashing on this is just a load of hypocrites sounding off. One of the issues about Jimmy Saville is that he was too powerful to touch. You are just saying that Clarkson is also too powerful to touch.

(Touch is probably an uncomfortable word to use in the same sentence as Jimmy Saville but you know what I mean).


Edited by Bert the Head (11 Mar 2015 11.56pm)

I wonder how many already adamant that Clarkson should stay were certain that Brand should gone? I must have missed the bit where he lamped Andrew Sachs.


Russell Brand should just be ignored.

The World needs people like Clarkson. Without his like, insipid liberals have one less thing to moan about and Blokes going through a mid life crisis have no role models.


Plenty of liberals like Clarkson. He is after all hugely pro EU. He plays up to a character and ticks boxes with various crowds. It'll be interested to see how this all pans out.


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Mar 15 6.46am

Quote imbored at 12 Mar 2015 6.18am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Mar 2015 6.11am

Quote imbored at 12 Mar 2015 1.13am

Quote Bert the Head at 11 Mar 2015 11.54pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.53am

Quote Ian J at 11 Mar 2015 10.45am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.31am

Quote bexleydave at 10 Mar 2015 11.44pm

The problem for the BBC is that JC and his executive producer own 50% of the production company that make TG (the BBC own the other 50%). It won't continue if the two parties can't come to an agreement and with a worldwide audience of 300m and the BBC earning £4.5m from the programme last year, it will be a huge decision for the Beeb.

According to Radio 4 news this morning they quoted TG earning £200M from overseas syndication and that Clarkson sold his existing stake ages ago.

It will still be a huge cock up by the Beeb if they let him go.

The BBC are in a very difficult position as they have given Clarkson plenty of warnings and made the point last time that it was his last warning so what are they supposed to do now. It wasn't a case of mumbling something inaudible under his breath or insulting a race by using a derogatory term that most of us had never heard of as this time if the stories are to be believed he physically assaulted one of the staff which for any other person in any other company is a sacking offence.

If the BBC let him carry on as normal where does it stop?


Well Jimmy Saville had a Get Out Of Jail Free card!

If he has punched someone at work or threatened to punch someone at work no one can seriously expect that he can be allowed to carry on in his job.

All the BBC bashing on this is just a load of hypocrites sounding off. One of the issues about Jimmy Saville is that he was too powerful to touch. You are just saying that Clarkson is also too powerful to touch.

(Touch is probably an uncomfortable word to use in the same sentence as Jimmy Saville but you know what I mean).


Edited by Bert the Head (11 Mar 2015 11.56pm)

I wonder how many already adamant that Clarkson should stay were certain that Brand should gone? I must have missed the bit where he lamped Andrew Sachs.


Russell Brand should just be ignored.

The World needs people like Clarkson. Without his like, insipid liberals have one less thing to moan about and Blokes going through a mid life crisis have no role models.


Plenty of liberals like Clarkson. He is after all hugely pro EU. He plays up to a character and ticks boxes with various crowds. It'll be interested to see how this all pans out.



I think Clarkson is great. Plays his persona very well.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Mar 15 8.22am

Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Mar 2015 8.38pm

Quote The Sash at 11 Mar 2015 12.59pm

Clarkson plays his cartoon character very well (and very profitably) - that of fat, balding out of condition middle Englander who's dress sense doesn't stretch beyond Next catalogue.

He's cultivated a persona as a cardboard cut out, stereotypical unapologetic xenophobe trading on cardboard cut out stereotypes of everyone and everything else.

Edited by The Sash (11 Mar 2015 1.01pm)

If possession of this dubious set of attributes is sufficient to qualify one to be described as "talented" then I can only say God help the entertainment industry.


I didn't say he was talented did I now Syd ??

Although I do find him funny and irritating in equal measure.

What he is is different from the acres of beige woodchip on legs that seems to be the world of Television presenting..he's a cartoon and a cultivated persona and I find it quite funny that people get taken in by that

A television world totally inhabited by Phillip Schofields is to horrific to contemplate, whether you love or loathe Clarkson

Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 8.44am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 12 Mar 15 9.10am

Quote The Sash at 12 Mar 2015 8.22am

Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Mar 2015 8.38pm

Quote The Sash at 11 Mar 2015 12.59pm

Clarkson plays his cartoon character very well (and very profitably) - that of fat, balding out of condition middle Englander who's dress sense doesn't stretch beyond Next catalogue.

He's cultivated a persona as a cardboard cut out, stereotypical unapologetic xenophobe trading on cardboard cut out stereotypes of everyone and everything else.

Edited by The Sash (11 Mar 2015 1.01pm)

If possession of this dubious set of attributes is sufficient to qualify one to be described as "talented" then I can only say God help the entertainment industry.


I didn't say he was talented did I now Syd ??

Although I do find him funny and irritating in equal measure.

What he is is different from the acres of beige woodchip on legs that seems to be the world of Television presenting..he's a cartoon and a cultivated persona and I find it quite funny that people get taken in by that

A television world totally inhabited by Phillip Schofields is to horrific to contemplate, whether you love or loathe Clarkson
Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 8.44am)


Best and most sensible post in this entire thread. He is after all an entertainer, and he is (according to the viewing figures for top gear) very good at it.

As an aside, I know how much it takes for me to want to lamp someone, (quite a lot contrary to popular opinion, unless you live in Sussex and support a team who's kit is not unlike a TESCO carrier bag.) So although resulting to violence is not the answer... blah....blah.... blah. This producer bloke may well have deserved a slap for being an utter tool, the fact is we dont know why it happened, it may have been unprovoked, I doubt it, my opoinion is two blokes had a square up so what.

Should they both be sacked, no. Should they be fined and told to grow up? Yes.

Should Top gear fans be punished becaus of it, Hell no, but the PC brigade at the Beeb have been just itching for an excuse to gag Clarkson as he doesnt fit into thier etho-centrical cleansed world.

For me Clarksons on sccreen Personna is a beacon of light in what is a drab see of safe watching paint dry boring sanitised Beeb presenters who are scred of thier own shadow.

BBC Bring Back Clarkson.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

fledgling Flag Beckenham 12 Mar 15 9.53am

Quote The Sash at 12 Mar 2015 8.22am

Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Mar 2015 8.38pm

Quote The Sash at 11 Mar 2015 12.59pm

Clarkson plays his cartoon character very well (and very profitably) - that of fat, balding out of condition middle Englander who's dress sense doesn't stretch beyond Next catalogue.

He's cultivated a persona as a cardboard cut out, stereotypical unapologetic xenophobe trading on cardboard cut out stereotypes of everyone and everything else.

Edited by The Sash (11 Mar 2015 1.01pm)

If possession of this dubious set of attributes is sufficient to qualify one to be described as "talented" then I can only say God help the entertainment industry.


I didn't say he was talented did I now Syd ??

Although I do find him funny and irritating in equal measure.

What he is is different from the acres of beige woodchip on legs that seems to be the world of Television presenting..he's a cartoon and a cultivated persona and I find it quite funny that people get taken in by that

A television world totally inhabited by Phillip Schofields is to horrific to contemplate, whether you love or loathe Clarkson

Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 8.44am)

The main problem I have is with the man himself. I agree that you should have personalities that challenge and provoke discussion and that's always going to be divisive.

For your Pip Schofield I have Matt Baker....so when his saccharine grinning face looms I just turnover. I understand you have to have these shows as they do have an appeal to many as does Top Gear. No interest personally. A car gets me from A to B, some faster and in more comfort than others.

But Clarkson's a snide. If you've got something to say to the Argentinians about the Falklands then stand up and say it. If you want to take the piss out of a Burmese man for being Burmese then do it so we can all understand it. Underhand, cowardly and juvenile.


 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 12 Mar 15 9.57am

Modern society seems to create bland TV people so the likes of Clarkson are important but you cannot go around punching people.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Hoof Hearted 12 Mar 15 10.00am

Latest News.....

The BBC will be showing an hour long episode of "Miranda" at 8pm on BBC2 Sunday in place of Top Gear.

Be careful what you wish for......

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Mar 15 10.07am

Quote fledgling at 12 Mar 2015 9.53am

Quote The Sash at 12 Mar 2015 8.22am

Quote sydtheeagle at 11 Mar 2015 8.38pm

Quote The Sash at 11 Mar 2015 12.59pm

Clarkson plays his cartoon character very well (and very profitably) - that of fat, balding out of condition middle Englander who's dress sense doesn't stretch beyond Next catalogue.

He's cultivated a persona as a cardboard cut out, stereotypical unapologetic xenophobe trading on cardboard cut out stereotypes of everyone and everything else.

Edited by The Sash (11 Mar 2015 1.01pm)

If possession of this dubious set of attributes is sufficient to qualify one to be described as "talented" then I can only say God help the entertainment industry.


I didn't say he was talented did I now Syd ??

Although I do find him funny and irritating in equal measure.

What he is is different from the acres of beige woodchip on legs that seems to be the world of Television presenting..he's a cartoon and a cultivated persona and I find it quite funny that people get taken in by that

A television world totally inhabited by Phillip Schofields is to horrific to contemplate, whether you love or loathe Clarkson

Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 8.44am)

The main problem I have is with the man himself. I agree that you should have personalities that challenge and provoke discussion and that's always going to be divisive.

For your Pip Schofield I have Matt Baker....so when his saccharine grinning face looms I just turnover. I understand you have to have these shows as they do have an appeal to many as does Top Gear. No interest personally. A car gets me from A to B, some faster and in more comfort than others.

But Clarkson's a snide. If you've got something to say to the Argentinians about the Falklands then stand up and say it. If you want to take the piss out of a Burmese man for being Burmese then do it so we can all understand it. Underhand, cowardly and juvenile.


He does though doesn't he.

I have seen and read far worse from Clarkson than his 'slope' dig (I knew what it meant). Everything from the Chinese as having no souls to Jade Goody being a 'racist waste of organs' to 'America: 250 million w****rs living in a country with no word for w****r'

Nobody jumped up and down then. Why now ?

So he's a snide - so what ??

Like I said - no flag here for Clarkson but the (faux?) outrage he seems to provoke bemuses me.


Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 10.10am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

fledgling Flag Beckenham 12 Mar 15 10.34am

Quote The Sash at 12 Mar 2015 10.07am

/quote]

He does though doesn't he.

I have seen and read far worse from Clarkson than his 'slope' dig (I knew what it meant). Everything from the Chinese as having no souls to Jade Goody being a 'racist waste of organs' to 'America: 250 million w****rs living in a country with no word for w****r'

Nobody jumped up and down then. Why now ?

So he's a snide - so what ??

Like I said - no flag here for Clarkson but the (faux?) outrage he seems to provoke bemuses me.


Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 10.10am)

Does he? Did he call an American who could answer back a w****r or insult Jade in person etc Or did he do it on camera to be aired at a later date or write it in a book? I genuinely don't know.

For the record I'm not outraged at all. I think he should lose his job if it turns out the only provocation for clumping the bloke was that he served a cold platter of deli meats rather than an Argentinian steak.

If he stays on I'll turn off as I always have and continue to dislike him from afar. No skin off his nose nor mine.

As for not liking snides, I suppose it's my own character flaw. I like 'stand up' people.


 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Mar 15 10.49am

Quote fledgling at 12 Mar 2015 10.34am

Quote The Sash at 12 Mar 2015 10.07am

/quote]

He does though doesn't he.

I have seen and read far worse from Clarkson than his 'slope' dig (I knew what it meant). Everything from the Chinese as having no souls to Jade Goody being a 'racist waste of organs' to 'America: 250 million w****rs living in a country with no word for w****r'

Nobody jumped up and down then. Why now ?

So he's a snide - so what ??

Like I said - no flag here for Clarkson but the (faux?) outrage he seems to provoke bemuses me.


Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 10.10am)

Does he? Did he call an American who could answer back a w****r or insult Jade in person etc Or did he do it on camera to be aired at a later date or write it in a book? I genuinely don't know.

For the record I'm not outraged at all. I think he should lose his job if it turns out the only provocation for clumping the bloke was that he served a cold platter of deli meats rather than an Argentinian steak.

If he stays on I'll turn off as I always have and continue to dislike him from afar. No skin off his nose nor mine.

As for not liking snides, I suppose it's my own character flaw. I like 'stand up' people.


Well no, that's all to camera or in print, but that's not going to make him unique is it ?? Or should people with opinion, regardless of what it is only make them 'face to face'?

I have a theory that a bit like Thatcher - Clarkson has become a bit of a litmus test for some of peoples 'right-on' ness quotient and that to like him categorises someone as a UKIP supporting misty eyed nostalgic loon and to dislike him is as trendy as a George VI bearded Hoxton hipster.

The rest of us seem just to go meh...life is to short to worry about the flaws and virtues of the TV presenting classes personality traits...they only have one prerogative and that's to be entertaining - and there are precious few who do it well.


Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 11.04am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

legaleagle Flag 12 Mar 15 11.07am

Plenty of people thought Saville and Rolf Harris were,as entertainers,entertaining...

Edited by legaleagle (12 Mar 2015 11.08am)

 

Page 5 of 17 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Jeremy Clarkson