You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Red Nose Day
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Red Nose Day


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Hoof Hearted 15 Mar 15 5.17pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 Mar 2015 11.19am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 15 Mar 2015 10.20am

Interesting... you've sort of tried to "top trump me" with your MA studies...LOL

I still feel the way I do though.

I remember the time when the white farmers were driven out of their homes/farms to be taken over by the black farm workers and that wasn't good.

They slaughtered the dairy herd for a quick steak dinner, then didn't utilise the expertise shown to them for decades... animal husbandry, crop efficiency etc... most farms failed and then the famine started.

The likes of Robert Mugabe were allowed to flourish backed by vicious gangs and corrupt officials.

I'm not buying that they were worse off before liberation.

Most of the aid we send ends up as Private Jets, Limousines and flash Palaces sadly.


Yes,I thought about whether I should mention the MA studies since it would just be seen as trying to trump you. But, what is a constant in your posts is your lack of knowledge of the situation of the locals under settler rule in Southern Rhodesia under our "benign" watch.. So, all you do is look at bad things happening now,and contrast them with your general view of "order" under British rule and conclude the locals must be worse off than they were.

I can't and don't defend Mugabe or his henchpeople and support the struggle of the Movement for Democratic Change.But that is a struggle by a populace against repression,just like in Belarus,or Uzbekistan or in Poland pre-1990.What it is emphatically not is a struggle against "black rule" of the country, a consequence of blacks ruling rather than whites,or an example of innate white superiority.

But,just to take the topic of land...how exactly did the white farmers get this land,Hoof? Did they visit the estate agent,make an offer and pay market rate in an "ordered" way?.No,the settlers simply threw the locals off all the best land whether they wanted to move or not,with no compensation,and introduced a legal system giving them "ownership" of it."We" set a great example...just like we did with our introduction of detention without trial because people called for democracy.

As a result of this "stitch up",the land allocated to black people was not only the "worst"land in agriculturally but as of 1969 had a population density of 67 people per sq mile,whereas the white reserved land had a density of 3 people per square mile. It is hopeless to try to evaluate anything that happened about land post independence unless you are aware of what "we" created and the legacy left.

It was overall certainly worse than what happened when some white farmers were thrown off.

As for the "aid" going to the elite,contrast this with almost all the "aid" going to the old elite,the settlers resulting in "limousines" and "flash palaces".;it was worse then in terms of "trickle down".

If we just look at education as an example.

1930:compulsory education for whites.By 1975,education for blacks still not compulsory.In 1964,only 64% of blacks of the relevant age group went to primary school.

As of 1971 the average educational spend per black kid was £16.60 whereas it was £160.70 for each white kid.

Nowadays,Zimbabwe has one of the best adult literacy rates in Africa.

Would the locals think educational opportunity,for all the current economic woes, was better or worse now?Would the locals in Zimbabwe like to bring back the "good old days"? I doubt it.

Edited by legaleagle (15 Mar 2015 11.55am)


Again I don't dispute how the white farmers came about their farms was probably illegal, but they were better farmers and produced more crops, dairy and beef than ever has been the case under the black tenure. That's incompetence dealt with.

You've agreed with me about Mugabe's regime so that's corruption and greed dealt with.

I think the locals in Zimbabwe keep pretty quiet these days and will do until Mugabe's tyranny is at an end.

 

legaleagle Flag 15 Mar 15 9.10pm

Hoof,we haven't agreed about anything unfortunately.You think black people are inherently less capable of running their own country than white people running it instead;I very strongly don't.Let's move on rather than banging heads against a brick wall.

Edited by legaleagle (15 Mar 2015 9.14pm)

 

Boooo Flag 15 Mar 15 9.41pm

Quote MileFan at 13 Mar 2015 7.47pm

I hate this red nose day/comic relief crap - we give so much money/aid/support etc to africa and it never makes a blind bit of difference in the long term.

total waste of time money and effort imo

If someone has said it, apologies, i've not read the entire thread.
£1b and 'they' are still drinking dirty water! Someone is making shed loads from this and it isn'tt he kids in the villages.
I think it's almost run it's course now, we have food banks in this country ffs. We have our own 'foreign aid' needed on our doorstep.

 


I refuse to believe there are that many people out there that can't spell. Too f**king lazy, that's what I think.

imbored Flag UK 15 Mar 15 10.53pm

Quote Boooo at 15 Mar 2015 9.41pm

Quote MileFan at 13 Mar 2015 7.47pm

I hate this red nose day/comic relief crap - we give so much money/aid/support etc to africa and it never makes a blind bit of difference in the long term.

total waste of time money and effort imo

If someone has said it, apologies, i've not read the entire thread.
£1b and 'they' are still drinking dirty water! Someone is making shed loads from this and it isn'tt he kids in the villages.
I think it's almost run it's course now, we have food banks in this country ffs. We have our own 'foreign aid' needed on our doorstep.

Huge numbers of people have gained access to clean water over the last 20 years - 2 billion in fact - due to global efforts. If you're one of those 2 billion people I'm guessing you're happy about it, and would be averse to the argument that "'they' are still drinking dirty water" as an argument to pull the plug.

Granted not all of the money reaches the right places, but clearly some of it does and it makes a difference to a staggering number of lives. Specifically the 1 billion pounds you highlight is money donated by the public. If you don't want to directly contribute then don't. I donate to food banks too by the way. If you help one person up, you're not obliged to kick another down.


Edited by imbored (15 Mar 2015 10.55pm)

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 16 Mar 15 1.03am

The thing is that IMO you will never be shown anything positive in the media when it comes to Africa. They are too used to showing hungry children with European doctors doing there best to help.

Africa is a huge and diverse continent, even on world maps it is made too look smaller than it really is even though it is the second biggest continent in the world, it is always shown as just slightly bigger than South America despite being twice the size.

It is made up of many, many different countries, with many different cultures and people of many different races and languages and shades of skin colour but it is all just lumped together.

As a continent, many of it's countries are some of the best places in the world to invest. With growth rates for some, three times that of any European country, and many with growth rates higher than China but you would never know it. The reason why China invests so heavily in many African countries is that it is a good investment for them for many reasons, although not all good IMO.

When you think of the benefits that many European countries have gained from the slave trade, echos of which can still be felt today in Africa and here, it is no wonder that we are able to call ourselves a developed country. All those pretty buildings you see when you go to Brugge were built on African blood and rubber, in an absolutely horrific manner.

I remember reading a report a few years ago where a top London accountancy firm were asked to calculate the financial benefits of the slave trade. That figure came back as around 700 trillion dollars, more than ten times greater than global GDP.

That is what African blood, sweat and tears has given to us and on this thread people moan about aid and debate why some and I say some Africa countries are poor.

It's like beating someone and stealing their clothes and then arguing over whether to give them back a shoe.

Edited by Mr Palaceman (16 Mar 2015 1.09am)

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 9.25am

Quote matt_himself at 15 Mar 2015 5.07pm

May I play Devils Advocate and ask what is the point of having the best literacy rate in Africa if your country is one of the most corrupt places on Earth, where ownership of property is dictated by the whim of the ruling junta and where said activities have driven the economy and society into the ground?

I don't support minority rule in any country. However, i support the concept of a meritocracy and blaming all the woes of a country or people on colonialism seems to be a kop out. Look at Singapore? They have been independent as long as many African States and have created wealth, employment and a system that rejects corruption. You seem to blame everything on whitey. Why do you do that when there are credible examples of former colonies throwing off the yoke of oppression and embracing change? Zimbabwe hasn't and won't until it faces some brutal, home truths.

If you look,you will see I condemned Mugabe's "junta".I can't stand the guy and his "problems" certainly can't all be blamed on colonialism.But,I wasn't doing so.Equally,there is no reason not to recognise some achievements there in the past 30 years,such as in relation to adult literacy which helps give rise to conditions allowing for more of a meritocracy when Mugabe goes,laudable regardless of what Mugabe's regime has become.

In terms of the economy, obviously its been badly affected by sanctions (which I supported overall) in place by the EU and others.In the case of the EU until December 2014.The whole point of the sanctions was to put economic pressure on the regime to change from outside,but the economy has suffered as a result so that needs to be taken into account when people suggest the state of the economy means blacks can't adequately run things in Zimbabwe.

My comments were in a context of responding to a poster who suggested blacks are inherently not capable of ruling a country as well as whites. I was writing solely about central Africa only since that was the specific example he had used and he was focusing on the supposed inadequacies of black people in Africa.I was not making the point that anything associated with white people's actions was inherently bad and the sole cause of any issues today.Rather that it was wrong to conclude from Zimbabwe's situation today that things were better overall in the "good old days" there and thus that white people were inherently better than blacks at running the country.

Singapore is indeed an interesting example.Very high economic growth and lack of overt corruption.But a small clique (simplistically put,the family and close associates of Lee Kuan Yew) having run the country in a very authoritarian closed way for 50 years with tactics such as using the libel laws inappropriately to bankrupt opposition leaders and clamp down on any meaningful opposition to their one party rule.I had a case involving a senior figure there and the use of libel laws against mild criticism of the elite. The basic advice from the local lawyer was just give in and pay up since there was no chance that the defence available as a matter of law would have any hope of being upheld by the local courts if this would displease the ruling party...

Illegal there to buy or use chewing gum unless obtained with a prescription!

The Singapore example shows that it would be facile to argue that the locals can't "rule" their country/city state as well/better than the colonialists by definition because of their race.Also,that the negative undemocratic aspects of present rule in a country/city state,don't change that underlying proposition.

Edited by Moose (17 Mar 2015 9.56am)

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 16 Mar 15 9.27am

Quote Mr Palaceman at 16 Mar 2015 1.03am


Africa is a huge and diverse continent, even on world maps it is made too look smaller than it really is even though it is the second biggest continent in the world, it is always shown as just slightly bigger than South America despite being twice the size.
]

You'll approve of the Peters World Map then.

[Link]

Edited by Johnny Eagles (16 Mar 2015 9.29am)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 9.45am

The Aussie map of the world can also be interesting in terms of a different perspective from the traditional Euro-centric way of seeing the world,with Europe is a central position..

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.46am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Mar 15 11.08am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 9.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 14 Mar 2015 11.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Mar 2015 10.40am

You just have to look at places like Zimbabwe.

When it was colonial Rhodesia it prospered by exporting copper and had a great railway system.

Now the railway is fcuked both financially and physically and only survives on handouts from China (in return for the major slice of the copper no doubt).

It may have been un PC by the poster to suggest "blacks" always fcuk up... but the state of Africa kind of backs this statement up unfortunately... corruption, greed, incompetence..... -.-'


Um Hoof,two points (only two because the proposition that black people screw up as a result of being black whereas white people don't since they are white,advanced on his thread,is too too insane to get further engaged with).

1.The copper was/is in the British colony of Northern Rhodesia now known as Zambia,as opposed to the British territory of Southern Rhodesia now known as Zimbabwe,so at least try to have a basic grasp of facts if you are going to advance an argument tending towards a proposition of inherent racial inferiority.

2.Take a look at places like Moldova,Uzbekistan. Note the health of the economies,their corruption etc,the extent to which their rulers f-up. and then take a look at the colour of the skin of the people that rule in those states.Poverty,corruption and repression do not stem from skin colour/race.The logic of your proposition is that we shouldn't vote for black politicians here due to inherent racial lesser ability to "govern" than those of a superior at governing white race.We are indeed headed back to the dark ages (no pun intended).


Edited by legaleagle (14 Mar 2015 4.45pm)


Zambia/Zimbabwe........ North/South Rhodesia....

Makes little difference - it was an example of a major fcuk up that wouldn't have occurred under colonial rule.

I don't think all black people are inferior but in Africa there are a lot of greedy/corrupt/incompetent people (who just happen to be black) now running most countries and sadly running them into the ground.

The worst of the lot is Mugabe.

As for your last point I'd rather vote for that Chukka fella than Balls/Miliband or Prescott.

But he's had the benefit of our education system.

Arguably colonialism was just a different form of corrupt rule, in which a foreign nation exploited the resources of a third world nation towards its own profits and ends.

The problem, is often as not, those that overthrow aren't any more altruistic than those they replace and come to power having to make 'suicide' economic policy.

As seen in South Africa and Zimbabwe, the implementation of 'prejudice' policy to replace prejudiced policy, simply results in a consequential exodus of your 'skilled and knowledged' workers that are essential to your economic well being.

Sudden changes rarely end well. They need to be graduated and controlled towards a goal, social engineering isn't something you can manage if you just jenga out whole sections of society.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

reborn 16 Mar 15 12.49pm

At least they are doing something, more than 99% of people on this board, including the OP?

I'd gladly be disproved of that by the way.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

imbored Flag UK 16 Mar 15 1.21pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.49pm

At least they are doing something, more than 99% of people on this board, including the OP?

I'd gladly be disproved of that by the way.

Exactly. I've worked with charities and it's never those doing charity work that slag off people raising money for other causes. So you wind up with those not helping their neighbour or anyone elses for that matter, moaning about amazing and often life saving efforts.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 Mar 15 3.43pm

Jamie... [Link]

 

Stuk Flag Top half 16 Mar 15 4.02pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.45am

The Aussie map of the world can also be interesting in terms of a different perspective from the traditional Euro-centric way of seeing the world,with Europe is a central position..

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.46am)


It's not Europe that's central, it's Britain, and the reason is the Prime meridian.

 


Optimistic as ever

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 16 Mar 15 4.19pm

Quote Stuk at 16 Mar 2015 4.02pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.45am

The Aussie map of the world can also be interesting in terms of a different perspective from the traditional Euro-centric way of seeing the world,with Europe is a central position..

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.46am)


It's not Europe that's central, it's Britain, and the reason is the Prime meridian.


Is that the ruling that the Enterprise can't meddle in other alien civilisations (except where it suits the plot?)

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 16 Mar 15 4.26pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Mar 2015 4.19pm

Quote Stuk at 16 Mar 2015 4.02pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.45am

The Aussie map of the world can also be interesting in terms of a different perspective from the traditional Euro-centric way of seeing the world,with Europe is a central position..

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.46am)


It's not Europe that's central, it's Britain, and the reason is the Prime meridian.


Is that the ruling that the Enterprise can't meddle in other alien civilisations (except where it suits the plot?)


It never stopped Captain Kirk!

 


Optimistic as ever

sitdownstandup Flag 16 Mar 15 8.12pm

Quote Mr Palaceman at 16 Mar 2015 1.03am

The thing is that IMO you will never be shown anything positive in the media when it comes to Africa. They are too used to showing hungry children with European doctors doing there best to help.

Africa is a huge and diverse continent, even on world maps it is made too look smaller than it really is even though it is the second biggest continent in the world, it is always shown as just slightly bigger than South America despite being twice the size.

It is made up of many, many different countries, with many different cultures and people of many different races and languages and shades of skin colour but it is all just lumped together.

As a continent, many of it's countries are some of the best places in the world to invest. With growth rates for some, three times that of any European country, and many with growth rates higher than China but you would never know it. The reason why China invests so heavily in many African countries is that it is a good investment for them for many reasons, although not all good IMO.

When you think of the benefits that many European countries have gained from the slave trade, echos of which can still be felt today in Africa and here, it is no wonder that we are able to call ourselves a developed country. All those pretty buildings you see when you go to Brugge were built on African blood and rubber, in an absolutely horrific manner.

I remember reading a report a few years ago where a top London accountancy firm were asked to calculate the financial benefits of the slave trade. That figure came back as around 700 trillion dollars, more than ten times greater than global GDP.

That is what African blood, sweat and tears has given to us and on this thread people moan about aid and debate why some and I say some Africa countries are poor.

It's like beating someone and stealing their clothes and then arguing over whether to give them back a shoe.

Edited by Mr Palaceman (16 Mar 2015 1.09am)


A well written, thoughtful and insightful post. Well done palaceman.

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 9.26pm

Quote Stuk at 16 Mar 2015 4.02pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.45am

The Aussie map of the world can also be interesting in terms of a different perspective from the traditional Euro-centric way of seeing the world,with Europe is a central position..

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.46am)


It's not Europe that's central, it's Britain, and the reason is the Prime meridian.


Yes,and that was because at the time we were the dominant world power and took the view the centre of things was here as the natural order of things...ie all time based around variations of GMT,GMT being the standard reference point,and not because scientifically it had to be...

 

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 9.30pm

Quote imbored at 16 Mar 2015 1.21pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.49pm

At least they are doing something, more than 99% of people on this board, including the OP?

I'd gladly be disproved of that by the way.

Exactly. I've worked with charities and it's never those doing charity work that slag off people raising money for other causes. So you wind up with those not helping their neighbour or anyone elses for that matter, moaning about amazing and often life saving efforts.

I've worked for a charity as a full time employee and some people seem to think that should also involve working full-time for nothing.The reality is,yes admin and staff costs eat up part of donations but most charity workers work for less than equivalent jobs in the private sector or even in the state sector.

 

imbored Flag UK 16 Mar 15 10.25pm

Quote sitdownstandup at 16 Mar 2015 8.12pm

Quote Mr Palaceman at 16 Mar 2015 1.03am

The thing is that IMO you will never be shown anything positive in the media when it comes to Africa. They are too used to showing hungry children with European doctors doing there best to help.

Africa is a huge and diverse continent, even on world maps it is made too look smaller than it really is even though it is the second biggest continent in the world, it is always shown as just slightly bigger than South America despite being twice the size.

It is made up of many, many different countries, with many different cultures and people of many different races and languages and shades of skin colour but it is all just lumped together.

As a continent, many of it's countries are some of the best places in the world to invest. With growth rates for some, three times that of any European country, and many with growth rates higher than China but you would never know it. The reason why China invests so heavily in many African countries is that it is a good investment for them for many reasons, although not all good IMO.

When you think of the benefits that many European countries have gained from the slave trade, echos of which can still be felt today in Africa and here, it is no wonder that we are able to call ourselves a developed country. All those pretty buildings you see when you go to Brugge were built on African blood and rubber, in an absolutely horrific manner.

I remember reading a report a few years ago where a top London accountancy firm were asked to calculate the financial benefits of the slave trade. That figure came back as around 700 trillion dollars, more than ten times greater than global GDP.

That is what African blood, sweat and tears has given to us and on this thread people moan about aid and debate why some and I say some Africa countries are poor.

It's like beating someone and stealing their clothes and then arguing over whether to give them back a shoe.

Edited by Mr Palaceman (16 Mar 2015 1.09am)


A well written, thoughtful and insightful post. Well done palaceman.


Agreed.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Mar 15 10.32pm

Quote imbored at 16 Mar 2015 10.25pm

Quote sitdownstandup at 16 Mar 2015 8.12pm

Quote Mr Palaceman at 16 Mar 2015 1.03am

The thing is that IMO you will never be shown anything positive in the media when it comes to Africa. They are too used to showing hungry children with European doctors doing there best to help.

Africa is a huge and diverse continent, even on world maps it is made too look smaller than it really is even though it is the second biggest continent in the world, it is always shown as just slightly bigger than South America despite being twice the size.

It is made up of many, many different countries, with many different cultures and people of many different races and languages and shades of skin colour but it is all just lumped together.

As a continent, many of it's countries are some of the best places in the world to invest. With growth rates for some, three times that of any European country, and many with growth rates higher than China but you would never know it. The reason why China invests so heavily in many African countries is that it is a good investment for them for many reasons, although not all good IMO.

When you think of the benefits that many European countries have gained from the slave trade, echos of which can still be felt today in Africa and here, it is no wonder that we are able to call ourselves a developed country. All those pretty buildings you see when you go to Brugge were built on African blood and rubber, in an absolutely horrific manner.

I remember reading a report a few years ago where a top London accountancy firm were asked to calculate the financial benefits of the slave trade. That figure came back as around 700 trillion dollars, more than ten times greater than global GDP.

That is what African blood, sweat and tears has given to us and on this thread people moan about aid and debate why some and I say some Africa countries are poor.

It's like beating someone and stealing their clothes and then arguing over whether to give them back a shoe.

Edited by Mr Palaceman (16 Mar 2015 1.09am)


A well written, thoughtful and insightful post. Well done palaceman.


Agreed.


Na.....It reads like he's just watched, 'Soulman' on Blu-ray.

If the slave trade had never existed the situation would still be the same.....People conveniently forget all the black slavers as well.

Also the slave trade is a long long time ago. In the modern world it doesn't excuse the underlying problems within Africa societies.

Africa is coming....It's developing but it's still held back by core cultural problems related to institutional weakness, corruption and exploitation....Both internal and external.

Just like the famous shag scene in Soulman, referring back to historical wrongs as a cause for the present is just an illusion.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Mar 2015 10.41pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Red Nose Day