Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Mar 2015 6.25pm
Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm
I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.
I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.
But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.
I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.
Hang on a minute. Let's go back to your original post:
Quote serial thriller
Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?
Now we can argue about what constitutes "living essentials" but, having been challenged, you're now talking about having "little disposable income" and having to "compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure".
So what exactly is the issue that your clarion call about "poverty" would have us address? Is it "essentials" or "disposable income"?
I repeat: I'm not saying inequality is not a problem. I'm not saying "essentials" are a bowl of rice a day.
I am trying to give a bit of perspective when people start talking about developed world problems (as lefties are wont to do) in emotive language, trying to make out that we're faced with shanty towns and rickets, not advanced healthcare and an established system of income redistribution.
Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Mar 2015 6.26pm)
I think the point I highlighted in red is a crucial one (sorry, having been on this site nearly half a decade I still can't figure out how to do that fancy quote thing you and White Horse do). In a developed nation, living essentials are generally seen to extend beyond those of the bare necessities to survive, and tend to prefigure a relatively acceptable standard of living. No one on 'the left' (which is as broad and heteregoeneous a church as 'the right' or the even more excruciating 'centre' that I am aware of is claiming we are 'faces with shanty towns and rickets': what many are legitimately raising as a cause for concern is that we live in the 5th most developed nation on the planet, with growth supposedly outstripping all of our similar economies, we are being bombarded with propaganda from our government telling us how many jobs are being created and how our standards of living are so much improved and blah blah blah. And yet. AND YET, we are seeing social ills on a fairly large scale which totally contradict that rhetoric.
Now what you or I define as poverty is clearly totally different. Relative poverty as defined by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, a politically neutral organisation, not some far-left thinktank, suggests around 10 million people live in this situation in the UK, figures that have barely shifted in the past few years where growth has been supposedly good. Whatever you describe to define this as: relative poverty, low income households, poor plebs, whatever, it means that despite all of Osbourne's nonsense about growth, there are still millions who live in a position of financial insecurity that is incredibly uncomfortable, particularly if you're trying to raise a family.
And this is perpetuated by government policy. What we are seeing in society at the moment is the gradual erosion of the systems and institutions which benefit the poorest in society. Welfare is being cut, and will undoubtedly be savagely hit again regardless of who wins in May. As I have said, the majority of jobs being created are low paid, while the hardening of anti-union laws and emergence of zero-hours contracts (700 000 in the UK) means that, regardless on whether you see them as positive or negative, job security is incredibly low and far more dictated by the employer than the employee.
And at an even lower level, what you may see as a sub-level of society, it's even more terrifying. Asylum seekers, refugees and other people who are being deprived citizenship are being sexually abused, tortured and sent back to countries where many await death, because our government is depriving them of citizenship. Society has, in the main, decided to wash its hands of this issue which I find sickening, yet I can't help but see it as fundamentally connected to the inequality which causes the previous issues I've spoken about.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|