You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 2015 budget
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

2015 budget


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Hoof Hearted 21 Mar 15 10.39am

Quote Jimenez at 20 Mar 2015 11.32pm

.......are you in 'downtown' Epsom Bertram?

He's probably helping the Epsom Popular Peoples Front running the soup kitchens in Banstead!

Power to the People!


-.-'

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 21 Mar 15 10.54am

Quote Bert the Head at 20 Mar 2015 11.51pm

Quote Jimenez at 20 Mar 2015 11.32pm

Quote Bert the Head at 20 Mar 2015 11.22pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Mar 2015 10.51am

Quote OknotOK at 20 Mar 2015 10.37am

Quote Willo at 20 Mar 2015 9.55am

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 2.48pm

In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs.

Total and utter bilge, the likes of which we heard from Miliband after the Budget.

I could trot out a load of statistics which would bore all and sundry on here so I shall refrain from doing so.

All I will say is that it has been a terrific success story but of course there is more to be done.
Over to you chaps ! I will only raise all your hackles if I get on my political "Soapbox" so I shall stick to the football and not get embroiled in the political debate!!!!


Ummmm except you just did "get embroiled in a political debate".

And you're still wrong. I'm not judging George Osborne on anything other than his own targets and his own guidance. And the only measure he can point to as a success on that basis is job creation. Everything else he has massively missed his own targets/expectations.

Like I said, you don't have to think he is culpable for that. Feel free to think he has done a splendid job based upon horrific conditions and the Eurozone collapsing around him. But by his own criteria - set out when he had been in office for several months - he has failed to live up to expectations.

And for the record I won't be voting (and haven't ever voted) for Labour at a general election.

You could judge Osborne by how he has performed versus the previous Labour chancellors and conclude that he has managed to clear up a lot of their mess.

I note you distance yourself from Labour, and by deduction you won't be voting Tory I guess?

Who are you voting for?


did you mean to say:


You could judge posh Tory boy in term of how well he has benefited the public school set versus ordinary working people because he has managed to make sure the wealthy haven’t really experienced a recession and has wallpapered over the neo-liberal economic mess without really changing anything?



.......are you in 'downtown' Epsom Bertram?

Honestly, I'd love to say "what a witty response" and when you manage I will, I promise. Really, I will. In the meantime P**s of* back to your Beans and Cornbread.

Because that's the height of wit.

Beyond loftily dismissing everyone else as blinded by propaganda (when, by the way, will you be revealing to us the source of the wisdom you profess to have but seldom display?) you steer clear of actual debate and have very little to contribute.

I wonder whether you are as well-endowed with critical faculties as you like to think you are.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 21 Mar 15 11.51am

I wish they'd vary the rate of VAT for different areas.
I've just lost a 15K decorating job because the other firm is non VAt reg.
If it was,say 5% on building works it would even the playing field & if not give me the option of paying the 5% myself,out of my price if it suited me to win the work.
charging 20% for the privilege of maintenance on your property is plain daft.
Remember it only be around 8% in the 80's and bloody thatcher doubled it to 15%.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

chris123 Flag hove actually 21 Mar 15 12.00pm

Quote OknotOK at 20 Mar 2015 10.37am

Quote Willo at 20 Mar 2015 9.55am

Quote OknotOK at 19 Mar 2015 2.48pm

In terms of delivering as a chancellor, the only measure he can be seen to have been a success is on jobs.

Total and utter bilge, the likes of which we heard from Miliband after the Budget.

I could trot out a load of statistics which would bore all and sundry on here so I shall refrain from doing so.

All I will say is that it has been a terrific success story but of course there is more to be done.
Over to you chaps ! I will only raise all your hackles if I get on my political "Soapbox" so I shall stick to the football and not get embroiled in the political debate!!!!


Ummmm except you just did "get embroiled in a political debate".

And you're still wrong. I'm not judging George Osborne on anything other than his own targets and his own guidance. And the only measure he can point to as a success on that basis is job creation. Everything else he has massively missed his own targets/expectations.

Like I said, you don't have to think he is culpable for that. Feel free to think he has done a splendid job based upon horrific conditions and the Eurozone collapsing around him. But by his own criteria - set out when he had been in office for several months - he has failed to live up to expectations.

And for the record I won't be voting (and haven't ever voted) for Labour at a general election.

The economic forecasts come from the OBR.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 21 Mar 15 12.22pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 10.19pm

Quote elgrande at 20 Mar 2015 10.05pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.


Surely that's an oxymoron


An organic free-range chicken is about three times the price of a KFC bargain bucket.


What utter crap.Organic free range chicken,sorry tescos or any other supermarket or even better butchers sell chicken for a lot less,buy in bulk save money.


Or is it just pure laziness.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Mar 15 1.15pm

Quote elgrande at 21 Mar 2015 12.22pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 10.19pm

Quote elgrande at 20 Mar 2015 10.05pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.


Surely that's an oxymoron


An organic free-range chicken is about three times the price of a KFC bargain bucket.


What utter crap.Organic free range chicken,sorry tescos or any other supermarket or even better butchers sell chicken for a lot less,buy in bulk save money.


Or is it just pure laziness.

Buying in bulk's great if you can afford it.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 21 Mar 15 6.25pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.

Hang on a minute. Let's go back to your original post:

Quote serial thriller

Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?

Now we can argue about what constitutes "living essentials" but, having been challenged, you're now talking about having "little disposable income" and having to "compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure".

So what exactly is the issue that your clarion call about "poverty" would have us address? Is it "essentials" or "disposable income"?

I repeat: I'm not saying inequality is not a problem. I'm not saying "essentials" are a bowl of rice a day.

I am trying to give a bit of perspective when people start talking about developed world problems (as lefties are wont to do) in emotive language, trying to make out that we're faced with shanty towns and rickets, not advanced healthcare and an established system of income redistribution.


Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Mar 2015 6.26pm)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

chris123 Flag hove actually 21 Mar 15 8.38pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Mar 2015 6.25pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.

Hang on a minute. Let's go back to your original post:

Quote serial thriller

Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?

Now we can argue about what constitutes "living essentials" but, having been challenged, you're now talking about having "little disposable income" and having to "compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure".

So what exactly is the issue that your clarion call about "poverty" would have us address? Is it "essentials" or "disposable income"?

I repeat: I'm not saying inequality is not a problem. I'm not saying "essentials" are a bowl of rice a day.

I am trying to give a bit of perspective when people start talking about developed world problems (as lefties are wont to do) in emotive language, trying to make out that we're faced with shanty towns and rickets, not advanced healthcare and an established system of income redistribution.


Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Mar 2015 6.26pm)


Often you see the poverty line described as those on less than 60% of median income which in 2012/13 was £264 a week before housing costs and for all individuals and children. But where you live makes a huge difference - I was working in Manchester before Christmas and all the beers were 50p less than down here and renting differentials are massive - so it really does depend on where you live too.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 22 Mar 15 11.13am

Quote nickgusset at 21 Mar 2015 1.15pm

Quote elgrande at 21 Mar 2015 12.22pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 10.19pm

Quote elgrande at 20 Mar 2015 10.05pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.


Surely that's an oxymoron


An organic free-range chicken is about three times the price of a KFC bargain bucket.


What utter crap.Organic free range chicken,sorry tescos or any other supermarket or even better butchers sell chicken for a lot less,buy in bulk save money.


Or is it just pure laziness.

Buying in bulk's great if you can afford it.


Its cheaper than takeaways.which is the point.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Mar 15 4.01pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 21 Mar 2015 6.25pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.

Hang on a minute. Let's go back to your original post:

Quote serial thriller

Over half of the people in poverty are in work - that is an astonishing statistic. It's all well and good creating more jobs than the rest of the EU, but what's the point if people are still unable to pay for living essentials?

Now we can argue about what constitutes "living essentials" but, having been challenged, you're now talking about having "little disposable income" and having to "compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure".

So what exactly is the issue that your clarion call about "poverty" would have us address? Is it "essentials" or "disposable income"?

I repeat: I'm not saying inequality is not a problem. I'm not saying "essentials" are a bowl of rice a day.

I am trying to give a bit of perspective when people start talking about developed world problems (as lefties are wont to do) in emotive language, trying to make out that we're faced with shanty towns and rickets, not advanced healthcare and an established system of income redistribution.


Edited by Johnny Eagles (21 Mar 2015 6.26pm)


I think the point I highlighted in red is a crucial one (sorry, having been on this site nearly half a decade I still can't figure out how to do that fancy quote thing you and White Horse do). In a developed nation, living essentials are generally seen to extend beyond those of the bare necessities to survive, and tend to prefigure a relatively acceptable standard of living. No one on 'the left' (which is as broad and heteregoeneous a church as 'the right' or the even more excruciating 'centre' that I am aware of is claiming we are 'faces with shanty towns and rickets': what many are legitimately raising as a cause for concern is that we live in the 5th most developed nation on the planet, with growth supposedly outstripping all of our similar economies, we are being bombarded with propaganda from our government telling us how many jobs are being created and how our standards of living are so much improved and blah blah blah. And yet. AND YET, we are seeing social ills on a fairly large scale which totally contradict that rhetoric.

Now what you or I define as poverty is clearly totally different. Relative poverty as defined by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, a politically neutral organisation, not some far-left thinktank, suggests around 10 million people live in this situation in the UK, figures that have barely shifted in the past few years where growth has been supposedly good. Whatever you describe to define this as: relative poverty, low income households, poor plebs, whatever, it means that despite all of Osbourne's nonsense about growth, there are still millions who live in a position of financial insecurity that is incredibly uncomfortable, particularly if you're trying to raise a family.

And this is perpetuated by government policy. What we are seeing in society at the moment is the gradual erosion of the systems and institutions which benefit the poorest in society. Welfare is being cut, and will undoubtedly be savagely hit again regardless of who wins in May. As I have said, the majority of jobs being created are low paid, while the hardening of anti-union laws and emergence of zero-hours contracts (700 000 in the UK) means that, regardless on whether you see them as positive or negative, job security is incredibly low and far more dictated by the employer than the employee.

And at an even lower level, what you may see as a sub-level of society, it's even more terrifying. Asylum seekers, refugees and other people who are being deprived citizenship are being sexually abused, tortured and sent back to countries where many await death, because our government is depriving them of citizenship. Society has, in the main, decided to wash its hands of this issue which I find sickening, yet I can't help but see it as fundamentally connected to the inequality which causes the previous issues I've spoken about.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 22 Mar 15 10.06pm

That's the thing about relative poverty, ST, it's relative. It depends for meaning on what you compare it with.

If you compare someone on 1300 quid a month with some Ferrari driving, coke-snorting banker, then the difference seems egregious. But if you compare the lot of - to use the standard lefty definition (and the Rowntree lot are completely left-wing BTW) - those on 60% of median income with the same set of people 50, 100 or 150 years ago, then they are much better off on pretty much any measure you care to mention. Health, infant mortality, life expectancy, literacy, you name it.

You mention "refugees". Obviously there are loads of people with horrendous lives compared to your average middle-class Brit. But again, go back 50 or 100 years and literally hundreds of millions of people across the world are much, much better off than people in those countries were in the past.

I put it to you that you are obsessed by an egalitarian ideology. It blinds you to the advances made in recent history because you are blinkered by a mythical dreamworld (pre-1979) of social mobility and meritocracy. You would love, if you had the power, to impose equality on the world, even if it was destructive. Because of your obsession you are so offended by the very idea of inequality, and especially by those with extreme amounts of wealth, that you would impose large-scale wealth distribution in order to bring them down a peg or two even if it meant that the poorest in the world were worse off in the long term.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 23 Mar 15 12.33am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 22 Mar 2015 10.06pm

That's the thing about relative poverty, ST, it's relative. It depends for meaning on what you compare it with.

If you compare someone on 1300 quid a month with some Ferrari driving, coke-snorting banker, then the difference seems egregious. But if you compare the lot of - to use the standard lefty definition (and the Rowntree lot are completely left-wing BTW) - those on 60% of median income with the same set of people 50, 100 or 150 years ago, then they are much better off on pretty much any measure you care to mention. Health, infant mortality, life expectancy, literacy, you name it.

You mention "refugees". Obviously there are loads of people with horrendous lives compared to your average middle-class Brit. But again, go back 50 or 100 years and literally hundreds of millions of people across the world are much, much better off than people in those countries were in the past.

I put it to you that you are obsessed by an egalitarian ideology. It blinds you to the advances made in recent history because you are blinkered by a mythical dreamworld (pre-1979) of social mobility and meritocracy. You would love, if you had the power, to impose equality on the world, even if it was destructive. Because of your obsession you are so offended by the very idea of inequality, and especially by those with extreme amounts of wealth, that you would impose large-scale wealth distribution in order to bring them down a peg or two even if it meant that the poorest in the world were worse off in the long term.


My ideology isn't focused on the very top exclusively. It isn't even just situated in some idealised working class movement. I have just as much antipathy with most left wing movements (The Soviet Union, Cuba, pre-New Labour left) as I do with most Right-wingers.

I think the recent 'progressions' of third world countries which you list (access to drinking water, healthy livestock, even clean sanitation) are the benefits of an increase of globalised awareness, via technology and infrastructure improvements. But is the reason those people were in that position in the first place solved? No, of course not. Africa, South America or wherever there was/is absolute poverty are still corrupt to the core, still exploited by now transnational companies and puppet regimes, and thus millions, even billions, still live miserable lives and die young.

But those progressions do show that with modern capabilities, legitimate redistribution could far more realistically happen on a global scale, leaving 80, maybe 90% of the global population better off (including people in Britain!). So a few bankers or whatever have to compromise their own living standards, based on the exploitation of labour which reinforces the refinement of wealth, I can live with that.

Your point about refugees as well, yeah maybe you don't have so many people fleeing starvation because of Aid programmes. But you have just as many fleeing warzones and discriminatory tyrants. The West is still breeding conflict for self-gain. DR Congo is oil-rich, sold it's oil to the West and is now one of the fastest developing nations on the planet. Yet 50% of its people don't have access to drinking water. Strange. My overrall point though was we in this country treat asylum seekers woefully, and there really is no need to.

Edited by serial thriller (23 Mar 2015 12.36am)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

matt_himself Flag Matataland 23 Mar 15 6.59am

Quote serial thriller at 23 Mar 2015 12.33am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 22 Mar 2015 10.06pm

That's the thing about relative poverty, ST, it's relative. It depends for meaning on what you compare it with.

If you compare someone on 1300 quid a month with some Ferrari driving, coke-snorting banker, then the difference seems egregious. But if you compare the lot of - to use the standard lefty definition (and the Rowntree lot are completely left-wing BTW) - those on 60% of median income with the same set of people 50, 100 or 150 years ago, then they are much better off on pretty much any measure you care to mention. Health, infant mortality, life expectancy, literacy, you name it.

You mention "refugees". Obviously there are loads of people with horrendous lives compared to your average middle-class Brit. But again, go back 50 or 100 years and literally hundreds of millions of people across the world are much, much better off than people in those countries were in the past.

I put it to you that you are obsessed by an egalitarian ideology. It blinds you to the advances made in recent history because you are blinkered by a mythical dreamworld (pre-1979) of social mobility and meritocracy. You would love, if you had the power, to impose equality on the world, even if it was destructive. Because of your obsession you are so offended by the very idea of inequality, and especially by those with extreme amounts of wealth, that you would impose large-scale wealth distribution in order to bring them down a peg or two even if it meant that the poorest in the world were worse off in the long term.


My ideology isn't focused on the very top exclusively. It isn't even just situated in some idealised working class movement. I have just as much antipathy with most left wing movements (The Soviet Union, Cuba, pre-New Labour left) as I do with most Right-wingers.

I think the recent 'progressions' of third world countries which you list (access to drinking water, healthy livestock, even clean sanitation) are the benefits of an increase of globalised awareness, via technology and infrastructure improvements. But is the reason those people were in that position in the first place solved? No, of course not. Africa, South America or wherever there was/is absolute poverty are still corrupt to the core, still exploited by now transnational companies and puppet regimes, and thus millions, even billions, still live miserable lives and die young.

But those progressions do show that with modern capabilities, legitimate redistribution could far more realistically happen on a global scale, leaving 80, maybe 90% of the global population better off (including people in Britain!). So a few bankers or whatever have to compromise their own living standards, based on the exploitation of labour which reinforces the refinement of wealth, I can live with that.

Your point about refugees as well, yeah maybe you don't have so many people fleeing starvation because of Aid programmes. But you have just as many fleeing warzones and discriminatory tyrants. The West is still breeding conflict for self-gain. DR Congo is oil-rich, sold it's oil to the West and is now one of the fastest developing nations on the planet. Yet 50% of its people don't have access to drinking water. Strange. My overrall point though was we in this country treat asylum seekers woefully, and there really is no need to.

Edited by serial thriller (23 Mar 2015 12.36am)

This post is wonderful. It sums up to me why the lefties will never gain power.

1. They all hate each other in a comedic 'Judean People's Front' manner;
2. They espouse a loose selection of 'causes' and jump from one to the other wih no order or sense;
3. They are brainwashed by the mythical enemy - be that bankers or trans national globals - and pursue the mythical enemy rather than the people they claim to want to empower.

Thanks ST. Leftism hasn't changed since I was a teenager and doesn't look like moving forward anytime soon.


Edited by matt_himself (23 Mar 2015 6.59am)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 23 Mar 15 11.28am

I think what's needed is a 'poverty basket' to see what items you should be able to afford before being recognised as being below the poverty line...you know akin to the 'shopping basket' to determine how inflation is doing.

Clearly, cars, Tv's and mobiles shouldn't be in this basket as they're luxury items / discretionary spend if you will.

So what essentials would you all have in the 'poverty basket' that everyone should be able to afford?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Mar 15 1.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Mar 2015 1.15pm

Quote elgrande at 21 Mar 2015 12.22pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 10.19pm

Quote elgrande at 20 Mar 2015 10.05pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.


Surely that's an oxymoron


An organic free-range chicken is about three times the price of a KFC bargain bucket.


What utter crap.Organic free range chicken,sorry tescos or any other supermarket or even better butchers sell chicken for a lot less,buy in bulk save money.


Or is it just pure laziness.

Buying in bulk's great if you can afford it.


You don't need to. It's just utter bollocks in the first place.

6 piece bargain bucket will cost you more than a £10 (but it does come with about 50p's worth of chips admittedly).

An organic, free range chicken which has 8 pieces, will cost you £7-8. A free range, corn fed one will cost you even less.

 


Optimistic as ever

ghosteagle Flag 23 Mar 15 2.20pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Mar 2015 1.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Mar 2015 1.15pm

Quote elgrande at 21 Mar 2015 12.22pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 10.19pm

Quote elgrande at 20 Mar 2015 10.05pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.


Surely that's an oxymoron


An organic free-range chicken is about three times the price of a KFC bargain bucket.


What utter crap.Organic free range chicken,sorry tescos or any other supermarket or even better butchers sell chicken for a lot less,buy in bulk save money.


Or is it just pure laziness.

Buying in bulk's great if you can afford it.


You don't need to. It's just utter bollocks in the first place.

6 piece bargain bucket will cost you more than a £10 (but it does come with about 50p's worth of chips admittedly).

An organic, free range chicken which has 8 pieces, will cost you £7-8. A free range, corn fed one will cost you even less.

But how much would you have to pay for the Colonel's secret recipe?

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 23 Mar 15 2.36pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Mar 2015 2.20pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Mar 2015 1.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Mar 2015 1.15pm

Quote elgrande at 21 Mar 2015 12.22pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 10.19pm

Quote elgrande at 20 Mar 2015 10.05pm

Quote serial thriller at 20 Mar 2015 9.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 20 Mar 2015 2.54pm

I'm not saying inequality isn't a problem. And I'm not saying that we should all live on a bowl of rice and a day so we can "compete" in a globalised world.

I'm just pointing out that when people (lefties) start banging on about "poverty" being "astonishing" (I knew the words "food bank" wouldn't be far behind) that it's useful to know exactly what we're talking about.

But it is astonishing. I mean on a purely economic basis, what is the benefit of having a workforce that has so little disposable income? If you live on your own in London, work on the minimum wage, and rent, about 2/3rds of your expenditure is on housing, which invariably means you're going to have to compromise on things like food, clothing and leisure. No wonder social problems like obesity and depression are soaring, and it is a reality which so many youngsters have to face nowadays.

I actually think defining it as poverty is important because, like absolute poverty, it is so intrinsically based around economic inequality, and given that we have entered what will apparently be the most economically unequal century in human history it is no surprise that poverty is rising with it. If the Tories are to boast about job creation, I feel like they should at least have the guts to admit that the vast majority of these jobs are totally undignified and unedifying. I call it statistic chasing: they know it sounds good to create jobs, so they cut corners in order to do so, thus compromising on the standard of living and the poorest's relative social position.


Surely that's an oxymoron


An organic free-range chicken is about three times the price of a KFC bargain bucket.


What utter crap.Organic free range chicken,sorry tescos or any other supermarket or even better butchers sell chicken for a lot less,buy in bulk save money.


Or is it just pure laziness.

Buying in bulk's great if you can afford it.


You don't need to. It's just utter bollocks in the first place.

6 piece bargain bucket will cost you more than a £10 (but it does come with about 50p's worth of chips admittedly).

An organic, free range chicken which has 8 pieces, will cost you £7-8. A free range, corn fed one will cost you even less.

But how much would you have to pay for the Colonel's secret recipe?

As a KFC sponsored athlete please see the recipe below:

1 teaspoon ground oregano
1 teaspoon chilli powder
1 teaspoon ground sage
1 teaspoon dried basil
1 teaspoon dried marjoram
1 teaspoon pepper
2 teaspoons salt
1 teaspoon paprika
1 teaspoon onion salt
1 teaspoon garlic powder
2 tablespoons Accent (MSG)

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 23 Mar 15 5.20pm

Quote serial thriller at 23 Mar 2015 12.33am

My overrall point though was we in this country treat asylum seekers woefully, and there really is no need to.

I thought your overall point was that half of people in "poverty" are in work?

You didn't actually respond to what I put to you. You said, "my ideology isn't focused on the very top exclusively" but that wasn't what I said. I said I think you are obsessed with equality as an ideal and that you would, given the chance, impose equality on everyone even if it meant that people in aggregate were worse off.

You also said:

"But those progressions [in the 'Third World'] show that with modern capabilities, legitimate redistribution could far more realistically happen on a global scale, leaving 80, maybe 90% of the global population better off (including people in Britain!). So a few bankers or whatever have to compromise their own living standards, based on the exploitation of labour which reinforces the refinement of wealth, I can live with that."

I disagree strongly that the "progressions" in the developing world are an argument for "legitimate redistribution".

On the contrary, they are an argument for enterprise, entreprenuerialism and the market. Ask your average Chinese or Nigerian what he'd rather: hand-wringing handouts from well-intentioned Westerners with a guilty conscience or a level playing field to try and make the most of himself?

Your comments about "a few bankers or whatever" reveals either your prejudice or your naivete, I'm not sure which.

Edited by Johnny Eagles (23 Mar 2015 5.22pm)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 23 Mar 15 6.28pm

Quote matt_himself at 23 Mar 2015 6.59am


1. They all hate each other in a comedic 'Judean People's Front' manner; be it UKIP, the BNP, the EDL, the Tories, the English Democrats etc.
2. They espouse a loose selection of 'causes' (from outsourcing public assets, to supporting Israel, to funding military programmes, to protecting Christian moral values, to fawning over the royal family) and jump from one to the other wih no order or sense;
3. They are brainwashed by the mythical enemy - be that immigrants or benefit scroungers - and pursue the mythical enemy rather than the realising who actually holds power.

Edited by matt_himself (23 Mar 2015 6.59am)


Edited to get your blood boiling that bit more, rather than make any particular serotype of the right.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

imbored Flag UK 23 Mar 15 6.48pm

People prattle on about the left or right being in power, but the reality is that the extremes of both ideologies cancel each other out thankfully, so there is at least some left and right influence at all times, just to varying degrees.

People are tribal. Most here would be lost without the comfort they find in frothing at the mouth at opposing ideology.


Edited by imbored (23 Mar 2015 6.52pm)

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 2015 budget