You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > An immigrant speaks..
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

An immigrant speaks..


Page 5 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
TheJudge Flag 09 Apr 15 12.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2015 10.18am

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 11.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Apr 2015 10.55pm

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 10.37pm

Meaning if the majority are black then whites suffer the brunt of racism and vice versa? Yes I'd agree with that. Minorities are often at a disadvantage. In that scenario you were the minority. Evidently you got out.

Of course the lesson to be learned is to treat those 'up against it' with empathy and fairness, rather than attack or laud over minorities. Easier said than done when people are in an advantageous position, like those on the estate, or sometimes those who get out of such situations. Often the abused becomes the abuser. An easy trap to fall into.


Edited by imbored (08 Apr 2015 10.45pm)

Yup, I'd say that's about right. It also is true that it's normally a minority of people who actually are the problem.....Most people are fine and just getting on with their lives.

Still, the impact of a few nasty incidents can be quite significant upon an individual and cause them to become insular....Which just makes integration even harder.

Still, if you choose to re-locate to a country then you should know to expect that some people are going to be arseholes.....It's essentially the same most places if you are in a minority.

Swings and roundabouts.


Similar with the police in the States for instance. There are a minority of nutters in badges who drag the reputation of them all down and create friction between communities. From a different vantage point the police would claim that they have to be tough on crime because of the problems in those communities. So it ends up being something of a slippery slope with no easy answers.


I disagree with this. The problem with the Police in the US isn't with racism, per se, it just that the black community of the US has in place a number of groups that have a history of racial campaigning. Looking at the statistics the US police shoot and kill a staggering amount of unarmed people and resort to leathal force remarkably quickly. Its not just with black people, its just that the black community having experienced racism in the past from racist police forces have the capacity for successful protest.

A lot of poor white people get shot in exactly the same circumstances but the capacity of 'resistance' to that doesn't exist. It remains localised rather than nationalised news (where as Black and Hispanic communities have 'effective mechanisms of resistance to racism'.

The US Police have a very liberal approch to the use of lethal force in poorer communities, and are typically defended by a law that presents a very liberal attitude to the use of firearms prevelent in US Society. Certainly a very large amount of US police killings would be considered murder in the UK.

The race card. How about that.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 09 Apr 15 12.47pm

Quote TheJudge at 09 Apr 2015 12.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2015 10.18am

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 11.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Apr 2015 10.55pm

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 10.37pm

Meaning if the majority are black then whites suffer the brunt of racism and vice versa? Yes I'd agree with that. Minorities are often at a disadvantage. In that scenario you were the minority. Evidently you got out.

Of course the lesson to be learned is to treat those 'up against it' with empathy and fairness, rather than attack or laud over minorities. Easier said than done when people are in an advantageous position, like those on the estate, or sometimes those who get out of such situations. Often the abused becomes the abuser. An easy trap to fall into.


Edited by imbored (08 Apr 2015 10.45pm)

Yup, I'd say that's about right. It also is true that it's normally a minority of people who actually are the problem.....Most people are fine and just getting on with their lives.

Still, the impact of a few nasty incidents can be quite significant upon an individual and cause them to become insular....Which just makes integration even harder.

Still, if you choose to re-locate to a country then you should know to expect that some people are going to be arseholes.....It's essentially the same most places if you are in a minority.

Swings and roundabouts.


Similar with the police in the States for instance. There are a minority of nutters in badges who drag the reputation of them all down and create friction between communities. From a different vantage point the police would claim that they have to be tough on crime because of the problems in those communities. So it ends up being something of a slippery slope with no easy answers.


I disagree with this. The problem with the Police in the US isn't with racism, per se, it just that the black community of the US has in place a number of groups that have a history of racial campaigning. Looking at the statistics the US police shoot and kill a staggering amount of unarmed people and resort to leathal force remarkably quickly. Its not just with black people, its just that the black community having experienced racism in the past from racist police forces have the capacity for successful protest.

A lot of poor white people get shot in exactly the same circumstances but the capacity of 'resistance' to that doesn't exist. It remains localised rather than nationalised news (where as Black and Hispanic communities have 'effective mechanisms of resistance to racism'.

The US Police have a very liberal approch to the use of lethal force in poorer communities, and are typically defended by a law that presents a very liberal attitude to the use of firearms prevelent in US Society. Certainly a very large amount of US police killings would be considered murder in the UK.

The race card. How about that.

To state a truism about the historical situation, status and social position, especially when in relation to the police, of Black America and the subsequent groups which have evolved from the 60's civil rights movements which today challenge perceived racist policing in a more organised fashion than White America does for white suspects being shot) isn't playing any race card - its a fact.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 09 Apr 15 2.18pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Apr 2015 10.10pm

Quote iheartcpfc at 08 Apr 2015 10.03pm

Quote TUX at 08 Apr 2015 9.51pm

Quote iheartcpfc at 08 Apr 2015 8.38pm

Quote TUX at 08 Apr 2015 7.47pm

Quote iheartcpfc at 08 Apr 2015 6.49pm

This is a great post. I find the scapegoating of immigrants disgusting. UKIP in particular have a lot to answer for. I'm ashamed that there are people who speak to others like this in our country, minority or otherwise.

This is faaaaaaaaaar from a great post. It's pathetic.

An immigrant came here to earn strong money, fairplay.
But to then whine about 2 xenophobic instances is boll-x!

Edited by TUX (08 Apr 2015 8.16pm)


Shouldn't you be trolling the Guardian's comment sections with the rest of your "not racist, honest" 'kipper mates? I'd prefer these things aren't brushed under the carpet because they hit too close to home for some in this country.

Shouldn't you be in bed by now?

I too (along with my family) have been a tax paying immigrant in the past (8yrs, not 4.5) and I could mention way more than 2 examples. That was a monthly occurrence tbh. So I speak from experience.
If you read carefully, the author of this thread has done nothing more than made himself look like a tool imo and playing the 'immigrant card'. If he does have English friends then i'm sure they would have told him to ignore the idiots. Why wouldn't they as I would. Wouldn't you?
In essence, all he's posted is 'I came here to earn more money............and have faced the reality of being a stranger in a strange land a couple of times'.

Oh well. These things happen.

Never will understand immigrants who pull up the drawbridge behind them

He isn't suggesting the drawbridge should be pulled up.

You don't appear to have understood his post at all.

What you do appear to be doing is insulting people who don't agree with you and being generally unpleasant.

Perhaps your yellow card is well earned.


whatever mate, this site is full of UKIP filth anyway. oh no, I got a yellow card for pulling people up for slagging people off who dare to complain about receiving unsolicited abuse

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 09 Apr 15 2.51pm

Quote iheartcpfc at 09 Apr 2015 2.18pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Apr 2015 10.10pm

Quote iheartcpfc at 08 Apr 2015 10.03pm

Quote TUX at 08 Apr 2015 9.51pm

Quote iheartcpfc at 08 Apr 2015 8.38pm

Quote TUX at 08 Apr 2015 7.47pm

Quote iheartcpfc at 08 Apr 2015 6.49pm

This is a great post. I find the scapegoating of immigrants disgusting. UKIP in particular have a lot to answer for. I'm ashamed that there are people who speak to others like this in our country, minority or otherwise.

This is faaaaaaaaaar from a great post. It's pathetic.

An immigrant came here to earn strong money, fairplay.
But to then whine about 2 xenophobic instances is boll-x!

Edited by TUX (08 Apr 2015 8.16pm)


Shouldn't you be trolling the Guardian's comment sections with the rest of your "not racist, honest" 'kipper mates? I'd prefer these things aren't brushed under the carpet because they hit too close to home for some in this country.

Shouldn't you be in bed by now?

I too (along with my family) have been a tax paying immigrant in the past (8yrs, not 4.5) and I could mention way more than 2 examples. That was a monthly occurrence tbh. So I speak from experience.
If you read carefully, the author of this thread has done nothing more than made himself look like a tool imo and playing the 'immigrant card'. If he does have English friends then i'm sure they would have told him to ignore the idiots. Why wouldn't they as I would. Wouldn't you?
In essence, all he's posted is 'I came here to earn more money............and have faced the reality of being a stranger in a strange land a couple of times'.

Oh well. These things happen.

Never will understand immigrants who pull up the drawbridge behind them

He isn't suggesting the drawbridge should be pulled up.

You don't appear to have understood his post at all.

What you do appear to be doing is insulting people who don't agree with you and being generally unpleasant.

Perhaps your yellow card is well earned.


whatever mate, this site is full of UKIP filth anyway. oh no, I got a yellow card for pulling people up for slagging people off who dare to complain about receiving unsolicited abuse


You mad bro??

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

TheJudge Flag 09 Apr 15 2.56pm

Quote The Sash at 09 Apr 2015 12.47pm

Quote TheJudge at 09 Apr 2015 12.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2015 10.18am

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 11.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Apr 2015 10.55pm

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 10.37pm

Meaning if the majority are black then whites suffer the brunt of racism and vice versa? Yes I'd agree with that. Minorities are often at a disadvantage. In that scenario you were the minority. Evidently you got out.

Of course the lesson to be learned is to treat those 'up against it' with empathy and fairness, rather than attack or laud over minorities. Easier said than done when people are in an advantageous position, like those on the estate, or sometimes those who get out of such situations. Often the abused becomes the abuser. An easy trap to fall into.


Edited by imbored (08 Apr 2015 10.45pm)

Yup, I'd say that's about right. It also is true that it's normally a minority of people who actually are the problem.....Most people are fine and just getting on with their lives.

Still, the impact of a few nasty incidents can be quite significant upon an individual and cause them to become insular....Which just makes integration even harder.

Still, if you choose to re-locate to a country then you should know to expect that some people are going to be arseholes.....It's essentially the same most places if you are in a minority.

Swings and roundabouts.


Similar with the police in the States for instance. There are a minority of nutters in badges who drag the reputation of them all down and create friction between communities. From a different vantage point the police would claim that they have to be tough on crime because of the problems in those communities. So it ends up being something of a slippery slope with no easy answers.


I disagree with this. The problem with the Police in the US isn't with racism, per se, it just that the black community of the US has in place a number of groups that have a history of racial campaigning. Looking at the statistics the US police shoot and kill a staggering amount of unarmed people and resort to leathal force remarkably quickly. Its not just with black people, its just that the black community having experienced racism in the past from racist police forces have the capacity for successful protest.

A lot of poor white people get shot in exactly the same circumstances but the capacity of 'resistance' to that doesn't exist. It remains localised rather than nationalised news (where as Black and Hispanic communities have 'effective mechanisms of resistance to racism'.

The US Police have a very liberal approch to the use of lethal force in poorer communities, and are typically defended by a law that presents a very liberal attitude to the use of firearms prevelent in US Society. Certainly a very large amount of US police killings would be considered murder in the UK.

The race card. How about that.

To state a truism about the historical situation, status and social position, especially when in relation to the police, of Black America and the subsequent groups which have evolved from the 60's civil rights movements which today challenge perceived racist policing in a more organised fashion than White America does for white suspects being shot) isn't playing any race card - its a fact.


Indeed.
I wasn't referring to your post, I was referring to the behaviour you describe. I actually agree with your observations to a large degree.


 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Apr 15 3.51pm

Quote TheJudge at 09 Apr 2015 12.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2015 10.18am

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 11.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Apr 2015 10.55pm

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 10.37pm

Meaning if the majority are black then whites suffer the brunt of racism and vice versa? Yes I'd agree with that. Minorities are often at a disadvantage. In that scenario you were the minority. Evidently you got out.

Of course the lesson to be learned is to treat those 'up against it' with empathy and fairness, rather than attack or laud over minorities. Easier said than done when people are in an advantageous position, like those on the estate, or sometimes those who get out of such situations. Often the abused becomes the abuser. An easy trap to fall into.


Edited by imbored (08 Apr 2015 10.45pm)

Yup, I'd say that's about right. It also is true that it's normally a minority of people who actually are the problem.....Most people are fine and just getting on with their lives.

Still, the impact of a few nasty incidents can be quite significant upon an individual and cause them to become insular....Which just makes integration even harder.

Still, if you choose to re-locate to a country then you should know to expect that some people are going to be arseholes.....It's essentially the same most places if you are in a minority.

Swings and roundabouts.


Similar with the police in the States for instance. There are a minority of nutters in badges who drag the reputation of them all down and create friction between communities. From a different vantage point the police would claim that they have to be tough on crime because of the problems in those communities. So it ends up being something of a slippery slope with no easy answers.


I disagree with this. The problem with the Police in the US isn't with racism, per se, it just that the black community of the US has in place a number of groups that have a history of racial campaigning. Looking at the statistics the US police shoot and kill a staggering amount of unarmed people and resort to leathal force remarkably quickly. Its not just with black people, its just that the black community having experienced racism in the past from racist police forces have the capacity for successful protest.

A lot of poor white people get shot in exactly the same circumstances but the capacity of 'resistance' to that doesn't exist. It remains localised rather than nationalised news (where as Black and Hispanic communities have 'effective mechanisms of resistance to racism'.

The US Police have a very liberal approch to the use of lethal force in poorer communities, and are typically defended by a law that presents a very liberal attitude to the use of firearms prevelent in US Society. Certainly a very large amount of US police killings would be considered murder in the UK.

The race card. How about that.

I don't think its playing the race card, its more having the apparatus in place to raise an issue, protest and promote it, because of a history of racism and prejudice in the US, which is still present and active today. As such, black America has the social political institutions to esclate issues.

I wouldn't necessarily rule out racism as a factor, in some cases, but that the greater reality is that a greater social phenomena is at stake. The police in the US kill 400 people a year (not including deaths in custody). However no accurate centralised collection of statistics is kept (yep, the US Police aren't required to report statistics on the number of people they shoot or kill)

There are no records for the number of non-fatal shootings by US police.

In 2012 409 People in the US were shot and killed by the police out of 410 people killed by the police. The british police fired three shots in the same time frame and killed no one.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 09 Apr 15 4.02pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2015 3.51pm

Quote TheJudge at 09 Apr 2015 12.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Apr 2015 10.18am

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 11.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Apr 2015 10.55pm

Quote imbored at 08 Apr 2015 10.37pm

Meaning if the majority are black then whites suffer the brunt of racism and vice versa? Yes I'd agree with that. Minorities are often at a disadvantage. In that scenario you were the minority. Evidently you got out.

Of course the lesson to be learned is to treat those 'up against it' with empathy and fairness, rather than attack or laud over minorities. Easier said than done when people are in an advantageous position, like those on the estate, or sometimes those who get out of such situations. Often the abused becomes the abuser. An easy trap to fall into.


Edited by imbored (08 Apr 2015 10.45pm)

Yup, I'd say that's about right. It also is true that it's normally a minority of people who actually are the problem.....Most people are fine and just getting on with their lives.

Still, the impact of a few nasty incidents can be quite significant upon an individual and cause them to become insular....Which just makes integration even harder.

Still, if you choose to re-locate to a country then you should know to expect that some people are going to be arseholes.....It's essentially the same most places if you are in a minority.

Swings and roundabouts.


Similar with the police in the States for instance. There are a minority of nutters in badges who drag the reputation of them all down and create friction between communities. From a different vantage point the police would claim that they have to be tough on crime because of the problems in those communities. So it ends up being something of a slippery slope with no easy answers.


I disagree with this. The problem with the Police in the US isn't with racism, per se, it just that the black community of the US has in place a number of groups that have a history of racial campaigning. Looking at the statistics the US police shoot and kill a staggering amount of unarmed people and resort to leathal force remarkably quickly. Its not just with black people, its just that the black community having experienced racism in the past from racist police forces have the capacity for successful protest.

A lot of poor white people get shot in exactly the same circumstances but the capacity of 'resistance' to that doesn't exist. It remains localised rather than nationalised news (where as Black and Hispanic communities have 'effective mechanisms of resistance to racism'.

The US Police have a very liberal approch to the use of lethal force in poorer communities, and are typically defended by a law that presents a very liberal attitude to the use of firearms prevelent in US Society. Certainly a very large amount of US police killings would be considered murder in the UK.

The race card. How about that.

I don't think its playing the race card, its more having the apparatus in place to raise an issue, protest and promote it, because of a history of racism and prejudice in the US, which is still present and active today. As such, black America has the social political institutions to esclate issues.

I wouldn't necessarily rule out racism as a factor, in some cases, but that the greater reality is that a greater social phenomena is at stake. The police in the US kill 400 people a year (not including deaths in custody). However no accurate centralised collection of statistics is kept (yep, the US Police aren't required to report statistics on the number of people they shoot or kill)

There are no records for the number of non-fatal shootings by US police.

In 2012 409 People in the US were shot and killed by the police out of 410 people killed by the police. The british police fired three shots in the same time frame and killed no one.


I agree with this. Racism could be one factor but a disproportionate number of non whites being involved in crime and their attitude toward the police could be another. The difference is, no one wants to hear the latter because it does not fit with the quasi religious liberalism that exists in the media and with the self interests groups that help promote it.

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Apr 15 5.24pm

Quote TheJudge at 09 Apr 2015 4.02pm

I agree with this. Racism could be one factor but a disproportionate number of non whites being involved in crime and their attitude toward the police could be another. The difference is, no one wants to hear the latter because it does not fit with the quasi religious liberalism that exists in the media and with the self interests groups that help promote it.

...................................................
Racism only "could" be "a factor"???!

Perhaps "no one" also likes to care to hear (or remember that) when balancing different potential factors institutionalised racism was pervasive (including denying the right to vote) well within living memory.Couple this with institutionalised economic and racial discrimination.

Hardly any wonder if people of colour in the US still show up ahead of the average when it comes to crime statistics and attitudes towards the police, and the bit you left out,attitudes of some in the police towards them ...

It takes more than a generation or so to wipe out two hundred years and fifty plus of ingrained racism. My experience of visiting small town/rural areas in the deep South (not typical of the whole country but still illuminating) was that such attitudes were very much still alive towards the black population.The most vivid example I saw being on a saturday afternoon when a group of whites who had been drinking affably with us in a bar in deepest Louisiana,saw a black guy having the nerve to wear his US Army uniform (while back on leave) on Main Street and elected to go out and threaten him with guns for this seemingly unforgivable act!Calling the police wouldn't have been much use;one of the the main protagonists was a member of the local force!

A few days later,talking to an English woman in Walker,Louisiana,who had moved there as a GI Bride,and hearing her shock at seeing black people strung up from trees in town after facing "kangaroo" vigilante courts.Very much in living memory.

It all points back to a bit more than "could be a factor".More like, is an important factor,especially in a country where police recourse to arms is plainly completely OTT in the first place.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 5.42pm)

 

TheJudge Flag 09 Apr 15 6.39pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 Apr 2015 5.24pm

Quote TheJudge at 09 Apr 2015 4.02pm

I agree with this. Racism could be one factor but a disproportionate number of non whites being involved in crime and their attitude toward the police could be another. The difference is, no one wants to hear the latter because it does not fit with the quasi religious liberalism that exists in the media and with the self interests groups that help promote it.

...................................................
Racism only "could" be "a factor"???!

Perhaps "no one" also likes to care to hear (or remember that) when balancing different potential factors institutionalised racism was pervasive (including denying the right to vote) well within living memory.Couple this with institutionalised economic and racial discrimination.

Hardly any wonder if people of colour in the US still show up ahead of the average when it comes to crime statistics and attitudes towards the police, and the bit you left out,attitudes of some in the police towards them ...

It takes more than a generation or so to wipe out two hundred years and fifty plus of ingrained racism. My experience of visiting small town/rural areas in the deep South (not typical of the whole country but still illuminating) was that such attitudes were very much still alive towards the black population.The most vivid example I saw being on a saturday afternoon when a group of whites who had been drinking affably with us in a bar in deepest Louisiana,saw a black guy having the nerve to wear his US Army uniform (while back on leave) on Main Street and elected to go out and threaten him with guns for this seemingly unforgivable act!Calling the police wouldn't have been much use;one of the the main protagonists was a member of the local force!

A few days later,talking to an English woman in Walker,Louisiana,who had moved there as a GI Bride,and hearing her shock at seeing black people strung up from trees in town after facing "kangaroo" vigilante courts.Very much in living memory.

It all points back to a bit more than "could be a factor".More like, is an important factor,especially in a country where police recourse to arms is plainly completely OTT in the first place.
=======================================================

I think we can all agree that racism is disgusting but the past must be left there where it belongs.
There has always been a greater antagonism between races in the U.S. and it is an ugly sight, but we cannot simply excuse away everything by crying racist at every opportunity. Of course racist attitudes prevail among some in the States but every black man who ever got shot by the police or put in prison can blame racism. Sometimes the only person they can blame is themselves. Remember, that country has a black President, so maybe racism is not a defining factor for black people after all.

[


Edited by TheJudge (09 Apr 2015 6.44pm)

Edited by TheJudge (09 Apr 2015 6.45pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Apr 15 7.04pm

And maybe,just maybe,it results in somewhat more black people being shot dead by police even nowadays than should be the case,or would otherwise be the case.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 7.05pm)

 

OldFella Flag London 09 Apr 15 7.37pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 Apr 2015 7.04pm

And maybe,just maybe,it results in somewhat more black people being shot dead by police even nowadays than should be the case,or would otherwise be the case.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 7.05pm)

Have you always started arguments in empty rooms?


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

TheJudge Flag 09 Apr 15 7.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 Apr 2015 7.04pm

And maybe,just maybe,it results in somewhat more black people being shot dead by police even nowadays than should be the case,or would otherwise be the case.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 7.05pm)


Well I would like to see you in the shoes of those policemen and see how you would react.
You are not revealing a big secret by suggesting there are some bad cops,and some bad racist cops but to somehow imply that all non whites, or even a significant proportion, are shot because of racism is another matter. That is an easy headline grabbing line which you have not supported with facts.

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Apr 15 7.54pm

..

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 7.55pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Apr 15 7.55pm

Quote OldFella at 09 Apr 2015 7.37pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 Apr 2015 7.04pm

And maybe,just maybe,it results in somewhat more black people being shot dead by police even nowadays than should be the case,or would otherwise be the case.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 7.05pm)

Have you always started arguments in empty rooms?



Hello sunshine man.Lovely to hear from you again

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 7.57pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Apr 15 8.08pm

Quote TheJudge at 09 Apr 2015 7.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 Apr 2015 7.04pm

And maybe,just maybe,it results in somewhat more black people being shot dead by police even nowadays than should be the case,or would otherwise be the case.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 7.05pm)


Well I would like to see you in the shoes of those policemen and see how you would react.
You are not revealing a big secret by suggesting there are some bad cops,and some bad racist cops but to somehow imply that all non whites, or even a significant proportion, are shot because of racism is another matter. That is an easy headline grabbing line which you have not supported with facts.


You are perfectly entitled to your opinion.I didn't think for a nano second I was revealing any big secrets.

The implication that "all non whites are shot because of racism"is not one I implied,other than in your mind. I did put forward the view that racism was a "significant factor" in accounting for the phenomenon.I also referred to the "gun craziness" of cops in the USA.

Yes,its purely an opinion not a fact.Its known as posting in general talk on HOL. I hope you don't take such postings as fact,any more than anyone should take your own postings in such a way.

Judging by your posts,I don't know about me,but I would not like to see you in the shoes of those policemen

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 8.09pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Apr 15 8.49pm

Oh and by the way legal...the term 'institutional racism' is a meaningless unprovable phrase that has done more harm than good.

Everytime I hear it, it makes me shudder.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 09 Apr 15 9.06pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Apr 2015 8.49pm

Oh and by the way legal...the term 'institutional racism' is a meaningless unprovable phrase that has done more harm than good.

Everytime I hear it, it makes me shudder.

Totally agree, as I said on the UKIP thread, it was purely away to "justify" or at least "remove responsibility" from an individual's racism.

It is the same with "reverse-racism" and the denial of those who practice the abhorrence.

It is all just racism.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

legaleagle Flag 09 Apr 15 9.28pm

I should perhaps have said "institutionalised racism"-a slip of the keyboard ,for which apologies.But one perfectly appropriate IMHO to describe the situation in many parts of the USA up until the mid/late 60's (with some only to be expected still lingering consequences thereafter) where,for example, the racism was institutionalised into laws allowing for discrimination in access to facilities,transport, jobs and voting.

The Cambridge Dictionary defines it as when someone is treated unfairly because of their race and that has become part of the normal behaviour of people within an organization.

In the South,substitute "society" for organisation.

Hard to see IMO that wasn't the case until the Civil Rights movement managed to achieve some progress.But no one could expect to see 250 years of such pervasive discrimination (including the thought patterns accompanying it) eradicated totally in a few decades.

If you disagree,no problem

As for reverse racism,I agree its an abhorrence and I experienced it for myself when at a party in the USA accompanied by a black woman. Racism is racism,whether its the USA,here or in China,where in Cantonese speaking areas,as I found out, its not unusual to be referred to as a Gweilo: "white devil".


Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 10.44pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Apr 15 10.42pm

Quote legaleagle at 09 Apr 2015 9.28pm

I should perhaps have said "institutionalised racism"-a slip of the keyboard ,for which apologies.But one perfectly appropriate IMHO to describe the situation in many parts of the USA up until the mid/late 60's (with some only to be expected still lingering consequences thereafter) where,for example, the racism was institutionalised into laws allowing for discrimination in access to facilities,transport, jobs and voting.

The Cambridge Dictionary defines it as when someone is treated unfairly because of their race and that has become part of the normal behaviour of people within an organization.

In the South,substitute "society" for organisation.

Hard to see IMO that wasn't the case until the Civil Rights movement managed to achieve some progress.But no one could expect to see 250 years of such pervasive discrimination (including the thought patterns accompanying it) eradicated totally in a few decades.

If you disagree,no problem

As for reverse racism,I agree its an abhorrence and I experienced it for myself when at a party in the USA accompanied by a black woman. Racism is racism,whether is the USA,here or in China,where in Cantonese speaking areas,as I found out, its not unusual to be referred to as a Gweilo: "white devil".


Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 9.40pm)


You will get no argument from me that the South had 'institutionalized racism' set down in its law books before ultimately common sense and humanity eventually prevailed.

MLK jr was far from a saint but he was certainly one of my heroes growing up.

I was referring instead to that great bug bear of mine and many others the 'institutionalized racism' phrase first used within the Macpherson report resulting from the Stephen Lawrence mess.

Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Apr 2015 11.42pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 09 Apr 15 10.46pm

Well,Stephen Lawrence,his murder,the Met and the report is a separate topic for another day. Sir William Macpherson may have used the phrase in his report but he was far from the being the originator of it.

But your post was in response to posts made solely about the USA...we weren't debating the UK...

Edited by legaleagle (09 Apr 2015 10.52pm)

 

Page 5 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > An immigrant speaks..