This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 05 May 2015 5.00pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 May 2015 4.10pm
Quote dannyh at 05 May 2015 3.30pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 May 2015 2.25pm
Quote dannyh at 05 May 2015 1.59pm
Quote npn at 05 May 2015 1.46pm
I'm not voting UKIP. I am amazed, however, that a lot of people I know (particularly left-leaning ones, to be fair) seem totally disgusted by them. I had to step into one of those pointless Facebook battles when someone posted that UKIP and their supporters are a disgrace. It seems everyone is in favour of free speech, provided the person speaking agrees with their views. If you don't like UKIP, don't vote for them. Pretty simple. Shouting them down and referring to them as a disgrace, and even trying to associate them with the BNP because of some spurious, vague, and not even verified, assertion that Griffin will be voting for them (he's a far-right person, natural he's going to vote for the furthest right candidate, surely? Just like Mao would probably vote TUSC because they are the closest aligned to his own ideal, not because those ideals are the same) is surely a very poor effort at debate.
As far as I can see: he wants out of Europe ( no bad thing ) Have I missed the bit where he wants burning crosses at the end of every street where Johnny Foreigner lives. Some people on here are so up them selves they can literally lick their own tonsils.
This perception interests me, as its not actually entirely accurate. Both the Conservatives and previous Labour governments pursued and implemented policy restrictions on immigration and citizenship that were tough, and arguably very close to restrictive. The problem is really with temporary EU migrant workers - and really only after the economic downturn (prior to that no one really cared that the woman making sandwiches in the canteen had Masters and was from Poland). The issue, is of course that a large part of the UK economy is entirely dependent on a) foreign investment b) a cheap EU labour force. UKIP can promise to end all that, because they don't have to ever do it. If Labour or the Conservatives make the same promise and win, then they actually have to shoot the UK economy in the head, over an issue that's really more 'ideological' due to the current economic situation, than anything else. Taking the migrant labour out of the question means jobs either go abroad, or the wages rise, which means costs rise, which results people being worse off, overall, and the government getting the blame. And then if growth does recover to a pre-2010 level, they'd need to rediscover that labour. If your UKIP (or the Greens) you can promise to do all manner of things that are economic suicide, but are popular, because you'll never get called on it. Unless of course you're the Lib Dems, who promised all kinds of things at the last election, and then got crucified by their own supporters for compromising them to form a coalition government (and now are likely to take more of a battering than a member of the Barrymore swim club). Tighter controls on immagration is not fiscal suicide at all, Australia seem to be doing fine. And there also not part of the Euro Disaster. Thing is JM I'm not going to get booged down in a financial debate, it is long winded and boring, but your above post is just "scare mongering" as anything printed by the mail, or the Grauniad. I will say this though on finances, the next country to go bust in the Eurozone (Spain most likely)will get the last of the bale out money, then what ? Greece have basically all but said f*** you to the Germans. Thank christ the Tories kept the pound, or we'd be in just as big a pile of shyte as Germany who are owed billions with no chance of getting it back. Australia also isn't in a position where its actively pursuing policy that would essentially mean a large part of the work force would be 'ineligible to work in the UK' which UKIP is pushing. Not it is not, that is just made up bollicks, what UKIP ARE saying is that they want british jobs for British people, no matter what ethinicity you are. And for your information the Ozzies are far tougher on immagration than we are. Some of UKIPs policies I agree with. I want to see the removal of imported competition for low skilled work, but I also want to see those jobs filled by workers, on a decent living wage. That is the floor in the European free market, people with low standards of living in countries like Poland and Romania come to the UK work for Peanuts, send the money home, keeping the low wage down if there wasnt the people to pay low wages too, then the wage would go up, simple supply and demand economics. The NHS 'tourism' issue is something that should be addressed, providing the costs of doing so aren't restrictive (the NHS isn't really set up to do this - and the last attempt to set the NHS up for that level of infrastructure management was a disaster). Only because there are to many managers instigated by Labour who went Quango mad on the NHS, the management ( I use the term losely) needs gutting, and with NI numbers the Government already has the info it needs to start issuing NHS cards as photo ID. The cost would be negligable against the amount that would be saved. It may even stop people turning up at AE departments with a f***ing cold for christ sake, if they think they have to admit who they are first. UKIP are like the Lib Dems, it was easy when they didn't have to deliver to their supporters. Once they did, they failed because they'd promised 'impossible dreams'. And just how has UKIP failed by becoming (according to most poles) the third biggest party in local elections, I agree in the Kilroy Silk days they were seen as a bit of a joke, not so much these days, with the Tories seemingly open to a coalition to gain a majority. I'm not against a private NHS, Germany and France, both have a Private Health Care System, which is more effective and efficient than our own - Its about how you do it. No it is not. I lived in Germany for 4 years and the waiting times are bloody horrendous, I waited in an empty waiting room for 3 hours with my young daughter in agony with a dislocated elbow. The NHS should be a shinning beacon to the rest of the world, but it is chronically understaffed and has been mis-managed by a bunch of f***tards for at least the last twenty to thirty years. That said, I've got no idea who I'm going to vote for. Probably it'll be Green on the basis of their drug policy. You'd have to be a crack head to vote for those eco nutters
I'm all for the idea of jobs for the British, what I haven't really seen is actually how UKIP plan to make that work, without it either resulting in a hike in wages (and thus costs to the consumer) or cost to the taxpayer in relocating people to fill the presumed vacancies. A governments first duty should always be to the people it represents. However it should also be pragmatic and responsible in how it goes about it - and UPFRONT about how its going to achieve it. More importantly, in UKIPs case, that in doing so it won't actually result in greater problems. Ideals are all well and good, but pragmatism is essential. Radical changes rarely end well. UKIP, like the Greens, are attracting supporters because they're protest votes. Neither are even remotely capable of delivering on their manifesto without sinking the nation into a pit of financial catastrophe. But they don't have to be. They won't have to deliver.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote The Sash at 06 May 2015 12.36pm
Quote npn at 05 May 2015 1.46pm
I'm not voting UKIP. I am amazed, however, that a lot of people I know (particularly left-leaning ones, to be fair) seem totally disgusted by them. I had to step into one of those pointless Facebook battles when someone posted that UKIP and their supporters are a disgrace. It seems everyone is in favour of free speech, provided the person speaking agrees with their views. If you don't like UKIP, don't vote for them. Pretty simple. Shouting them down and referring to them as a disgrace, and even trying to associate them with the BNP because of some spurious, vague, and not even verified, assertion that Griffin will be voting for them (he's a far-right person, natural he's going to vote for the furthest right candidate, surely? Just like Mao would probably vote TUSC because they are the closest aligned to his own ideal, not because those ideals are the same) is surely a very poor effort at debate. Exactamundo Always amazes me that people who shout down those they oppose and accuse them of intolerance (and in this case threaten as result) seem to have a massive 'whoosh' at the disclosure of their own intolerance of people who hold a political view counter to their own. Its not even debate - its simply Wolfie Smith Polytechnic level 'right on-ness' white noise.. Edited by The Sash (06 May 2015 12.38pm) In the end, those shouting loudest, usually prosper, because they're easy to shout louder at. I mean who cares if UKIP's employment policy or economic models are feasible, when you can shout Nazi. Said it when Griffin was on Question Time, that going on about the BNP and race is pointless, they're prepared for that, get them on the economics and practicality of policy, and they'll hang themselves. Nothing wrong with being a Neo-Nazi, that's your right, but the trick is making them look stupid, not yourself. I don't really like UKIP, but I think the media love them (they're unspin, full of gaffs and interesting) compared to the mainstream (similarly the Greens). Realistically, they're being presented really as a deflection from the fact that none of the mainstream parties have much to say other than slagging off the others.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 06 May 2015 2.08pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 May 2015 12.45pm
Quote Stuk at 05 May 2015 4.17pm
Wouldn't be hard to make NI cards (which we all have) into photo ID for the NHS. National ID cards, worked out so well the last time that was proposed. You should have an NHS ID number anyway, the problem isn't really with the treatment, its with the infrastructure and systems by which they're recorded, invoiced to the host nation and funds are collected (based on the assorted insurance schemes of those nations or health care programs). If it was as easy as sending an invoice to Accounts Payable, Nigeria. Its a minefield. Yeah but these wouldn't be mandatory. I'm pretty sure the uptake wouild be high though if it meant no NHS access. I'm talking accidents only. Long term illness you can go home and get treated. Not invoicing nations either, it would be the individuals. Which they won't pay, because they'll realize that the time and effort of taking them to court and then enforcing that via international law is ludicrously difficult and expensive. Enforcement would be almost impossible to achieve. Its hard enough to get your money back through civil claims against someone in the UK, let alone someone in another country. And I don't imagine too many foreign countries would be overly enthusiastic in pursuing their nationals for the money. It might be possible if you could arrange payment via medical insurance companies. Realistically, the only way it could work is an undertaking between nations to pay for health care of nationals abroad that are not paying local taxation and national insurance.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Taylors Lovechild........hehehehehehehehe
Bleed Claret & Blue THEN Red & Blue!!!!! |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 06 May 2015 2.32pm
Quote Stuk at 06 May 2015 2.08pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 May 2015 12.45pm
Quote Stuk at 05 May 2015 4.17pm
Wouldn't be hard to make NI cards (which we all have) into photo ID for the NHS. National ID cards, worked out so well the last time that was proposed. You should have an NHS ID number anyway, the problem isn't really with the treatment, its with the infrastructure and systems by which they're recorded, invoiced to the host nation and funds are collected (based on the assorted insurance schemes of those nations or health care programs). If it was as easy as sending an invoice to Accounts Payable, Nigeria. Its a minefield. Yeah but these wouldn't be mandatory. I'm pretty sure the uptake wouild be high though if it meant no NHS access. I'm talking accidents only. Long term illness you can go home and get treated. Not invoicing nations either, it would be the individuals. I understand the sentiment of treating sick people come what may and in emergencey type situations. However if I was to say bust my leg skiing in Austria, unless I had adequate Health cover, the cost of getting me down the mountain, and into plaster is fecking mahhosive, so what do we do, we pay throughthe nose for insurance., or dont go skiing its that simple. As an NHS Patient you're legally entitled to treatment in any EEA state, and automatically entitled to emergency health care under the EIHC. You can in fact travel abroad for all manner of health care which the NHS will pay for (and its your legal right to do so, although pre-approval may be required). Without pre-approval the expectation of the EU Directive is that you will be expected to pay for the treatment, and then reclaim it from the NHS. In reality, of course, no one is going to stop you from leaving, and you probably don't have 40k kicking around to pay for the treatment anyhow.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Mapletree at 06 May 2015 2.47pm
Really don't recommend letting your p*ss boil, you will be hospitalised AND WE WILL HAVE TO PAY!. Apparently twice as many 'health tourists' pay than don't pay, and they pay lots. Cost to treat free-loaders £60m to £80m, income from paying visitors appears to be way more but nobody can count it. Overall the UK is a net exporter of patients, with 63,000 travelling abroad for treatment. Don't know how many paid, those with an EHIC shouldn't have had to. I suggest a foley catheter and some nice cooling balm. None of them, in the EEA. EIHC doesn't cover non-emergency care - the NHS takes care of that.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 06 May 2015 3.50pm
Bollocks to all that, you pay or you lose all your possesions and go to a deportation centre until settled. No civil claims or relying on foreign institutes to chase payment or reclaim costs. It'll work as it does for us when abroad, as dannyh eluded to, and anyone who wants to try it on can go to deportation centre/jail. Our debts don't even get written off at death, they go to the next of kin, so why shouldn't it be a two way street? How do people get out of the detention center, if they can't pay the bills (which will be 10s or 100s of thousands of pounds). Its not like they going to earn more money then. I'm sure the UK tourism industry would welcome such a draconian measure such as indefinite imprisonment of foreign nationals, without trial for having the temerity to be injured or get sick whilst in the UK and require medical care. Pretty sure it doesn't work that way for us either, certainly isn't my experience, although that was Europe and minor (my girlfriend broke her ankle in Spain, it costs her absolutely nothing). Bound to be popular with other nations as well, the whole kidknapping their nationals etc. All seems like a lot of effort, expense and disasterous embracing of totalitarianism over a few 100m or so.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.