This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Personally, I'd prefer a Labour Party leader that represented the core of the Labour Party. Similarly for the Lib Dems and Conservatives (respectively). The moment you're talking about most likely to win you've missed the point of representative democracy. Its bad enough we have a country where a party that wins 8% of the votes, gets dramatically more seats than one who wins 13% of the vote. Reducing politics into a popularity contest, aimed at winning over fringe voters is the real poison that's killing politics in this country. And Blair can f**k off.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Jul 2015 11.31am
Quote OknotOK at 22 Jul 2015 11.21am
I actually think Tom Watson would have been less electable than Jeremy Corbyn. We want politicians who actually believe in things. In the UK almost all our options are image conscious, identikit politicians, who don't actually come out and say what they mean. Or if they do it's too bland to actually care about. But there is plenty of evidence that this is unelectable. Labour lost the election because it wasn't left wing enough in Scotland. But also because it wasn't seen as credible and right-wing enough to win back floating Tory-Labour voters in England. And given even if Labour had won every Scottish seat they'd still have lost the election, it's easy to see which would seem to be the priority. The question I suppose is whether there are genuinely enough disillusioned natural Labour voters who didn't vote, or who voted for UKIP. Because if so then Jeremy Corbyn could - in theory - be able to win an election. If that's not the case, then he would look like a disaster waiting to happen for the party. And actually for the country - because the country needs credible and competent opposition partis to try and curtail the government of the day.
Corbyn as the elected PM would see money rush out of this country quicker than Russell Brand can get his pants down.......But if that was the will of the electorate then that's democracy in action......It would be highly unlikely but interesting to see if someone like Corbyn could get the vast amount of untapped left votes in the country to actually vote for him. I have to admit, that's what I prefer in an MP personal conviction and a capacity to present a reasoned argument. Conviction, pragmatism and a willingness to be persuaded by the argument, not just the issue, even if its unpopular. I quite like Tom Watson. He was instrumental in protecting the UK Video Games industry, involved in the expenses issue and one of the few MP's pushing on the 'pedophile protection' issue.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote OknotOK at 22 Jul 2015 11.21am
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Jul 2015 11.10am
Quote npn at 22 Jul 2015 10.20am
Quote nickgusset at 22 Jul 2015 10.14am
Latest polls show Corbyn on course to win. I'm not sure why his opponents are just saying how awful it would be if he won rather than unpicking his policies with a cogent argument.
On the one hand, it will be nice to see Labour move left to give genuine alternatives to the kind of 'conservative-lite' they've become in the search for votes from the middle ground. On the other hand, any government needs a strong opposition to keep it in check, and I suspect a Corbyn-led Labour party will fall back quite a long way before any comeback and the next election (at least) would be something of a landslide.
I want parties to represent their grass roots....Not treat them with contempt.....Which is what happens with both the Tories and Labour. Blair and Blairites are Labour's right and are the minority amongst the membership.....They shouldn't feel that they have a right to own the leadership of the party. I'm not saying this because of some desire to see Labour stay in opposition for ages.....I'm genuinely saying it as an appeal to democracy in representation. I'm a right winger but while I'd never vote for Corbyn/CND I could see myself voting for a slightly moderated version of old Labour as a counter to the Tories if......As they probably will this version of rich boy Tories go too far in increasing the class/social divide in this country. But I don't think voting for another Blair/Cameron Labour clone like Burnham wouldn't interest me or many others. Tom Watson would have been a more sensible choice perhaps. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2015 11.12am) I actually think Tom Watson would have been less electable than Jeremy Corbyn. We want politicians who actually believe in things. In the UK almost all our options are image conscious, identikit politicians, who don't actually come out and say what they mean. Or if they do it's too bland to actually care about. But there is plenty of evidence that this is unelectable. Labour lost the election because it wasn't left wing enough in Scotland. But also because it wasn't seen as credible and right-wing enough to win back floating Tory-Labour voters in England. And given even if Labour had won every Scottish seat they'd still have lost the election, it's easy to see which would seem to be the priority. The question I suppose is whether there are genuinely enough disillusioned natural Labour voters who didn't vote, or who voted for UKIP. Because if so then Jeremy Corbyn could - in theory - be able to win an election. If that's not the case, then he would look like a disaster waiting to happen for the party. And actually for the country - because the country needs credible and competent opposition partis to try and curtail the government of the day. If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 22 Jul 2015 12.46pm
At the risk of getting shot at from all sides, I have to stick up (a bit) for "identikit" politicians. We have them for one big reason: they win elections. It's a bit short-sighted to blame them for being "careerist". Blame the electorate for believing that Cameron (IMO an utter charlatan who wouldn't know a principle if it crawled up his leg and bit him) is somehow more "prime ministerial" (whatever that means) than Ed Miliband. Also, given some of the frankly scary guff you hear from the politicians on the fringes (ie, the ones you don't agree with, in my case anyone from the Greens) maybe the centrist, anodyne stuff is not such a bad thing. What I'm trying to say is that, in my ideal world, we'd have Attila the Hun as prime minister with that marine bloke off Celebrity Fit Club as Chancellor. Nick Gusset would want Fidel Castro and Arthur Scargill. Maybe these think-tank groomed special adviser sorts are, for all their flaws, at least a happy medium between the two. I think Castro is busy. Generally these days, UK Prime Minister is kind of like a President, a c**t in a suit, that takes flack, but actually has less power than they make out and generally toes the party line. The problem with everyone being centrist, is that ultimately its a pointless exercise. You need the fringes to be represented in government, even if they only have one or two MPs, to throw some of the unpopular, but often important, issues into the ring for debate. Sometimes, you need those people who 'are on the outside' to throw something into the mix. The Greens, might only have 1 MP, they might come across as crazy ladies who keep sparrows in their hair, but they do have quite an important issue that may very well need to be addressed, which no other party really gave a f**k about.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Which is to say, that it might be scary stuff, but there is pretty decent evidence that suggests that the ecological future of the UK and world (and Humanity) isn't looking too good.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.