You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hiroshima
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hiroshima


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Aug 15 9.36am

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Aug 2015 8.28am

Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Aug 2015 2.30am

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 10.51pm

It was a very close thing until the last moment(whatever Halifax might have said later).I am talking about May 1940,after Hitler had already smashed through the French army.You are entitled to your opinion,but in my view there was a not uninfluential lobby on "the right"for peace in 1940. Not anything like a majority.But not uninfluential. Churchill did not really establish any overwhelming dominance in such quarters until later in 1940.

Below,only wikipedia (sorry no time to dig up something more authoritative),but reflects my reading on the topic:

"The May 1940 War Cabinet Crisis was a confrontation between Winston Churchill, newly appointed as the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, and Viscount Halifax, the Foreign Secretary...Halifax believed that in view of the successful German invasion of France and the encirclement of British forces at Dunkirk the United Kingdom should try to negotiate a peace settlement with Adolf Hitler.... Churchill disagreed."

Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 11.19pm)


You are wrong to dismiss the very words of Halifax himself.....I mean?...

Neville Chamberlain's position became untenable on 10 May 1940 because May the tenth was the day Hitler's forces attacked via pushing through the Ardennes......Chamberlain only resigned because it had become evident that appeasement had failed.

Chamberlain couldn't realistically have successfully continued appeasement at that point.....Like Halifax says himself....It just wasn't going to work.

If Halifax had been selected PM....A post he had declined from Chamberlain who didn't favour Churchill, then what is obvious is that Halifax would have continued fighting.

The danger of a deal with Hitler didn't require Halifax being PM...Which wasn't going to happen anyway......No the danger of that was once Hitler had successfully beaten France and had effective control over the European continent.

At that point during cabinet Halifax pushed for a deal. He ultimately lost the argument though once Churchill had appealed to cabinet with words like, 'If this long island story of ours is to end at last, let it end only when each one of us lies choking in his own blood upon the ground.' Churchill's cabinet backed him and that was that.

However if we hadn't managed the evacuation at Dunkirk....Then maybe Churchill's words wouldn't have carried the day.

Dunkirk was the close run thing....Without those 330 thousand men...Halifax would have probably won the argument.

Still, ultimately a hawkish nationalist with a small 'n' saved this nation from German hegemony at least and full scale direct German rule at most.

Hell, by not having to fight on two fronts Hitler would have been able to invade the USSR earlier and ultimately have won the war and.....Well, you legal would probably not have been born into the same kind of world.....You probably wouldn't have been raised in a liberalised environment.....legal the right winger perhaps.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2015 2.32am)


I have a question for both of you, legal and Stirling.

Hitler's admiration for the British, and particularly the Empire, is well documented through Mein Kampf and other sources - he placed immense emphasis on the importance of some kind of alliance with Britain. Had he achieved such an alliance, would he have kept to it?

Whilst it's true that his track record on treaty observance was pretty piss poor, notably with the Soviet Union, he stuck with Mussolini to the end. Would he have viewed his alliance with Britain as a matter of temporary expediency or would he genuinely have stuck to it? He wanted Europe as his own fiefdom but he seemed to believe that Britain and her Empire was a vital cog in supporting his own particular version of the new world order .

Would eventual conflict have always been inevitable? Or would Britain and Germany genuinely have walked hand in hand off into the sunset together?

I've read some interesting arguments on both sides as to how it might have panned out - what do you lads think?

The Nazi's would have preferred most of the European nation as allies I think, especially the British, and would likely have stuck with any alliances they made with those countries, if they politically had moved towards National Socialism or Fascism over time (even if never fully embracing those ideologies).

Conflict was inevitable, because of the British and French, maybe more than the German and their allies. Ultimately it would be them who declared war, in response to invasion of Poland.

The Germans also stuck by the Spanish, and never really pressured them to enter the war.

As for the Soviets, about the only person who was surprised by the German breaking the pact, was Stalin it seems, most of the Russian command structure seemed to have some expectation and Hitler and the Nazi's view of the Slavs and communists pretty made the pact one of temporary convenience.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 07 Aug 15 9.47am

Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Aug 2015 5.56am

[
No modern day American is responsible for the bomb.....Truman and those who supported the unconditional terms given to the Japanese are.


It is worth remembering Stirling that Churchill did not demur from the decision to use the bomb (though being more of a wheeler dealer type of politician he had doubts about the unconditional surrender strategy).

We had assisted the US to develop the bomb and in Triumph and Tragedy,Churchill later wrote of feeling at Potsdam after the decision had been made in principle to use it, that he had a vision, "fair and bright indeed it seemed"... "of the end of the whole war in one or two violent shocks."

So,not sure you can simply pin any historical moral culpability (if that's what you are going) on Truman and leave Churchill completely out of the equation.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Aug 15 9.58am

Worth noting that Churchill didn't want war crimes trials, he was all for just shooting them as they found them, he would later admit he was wrong, and glad that they went down the war crimes route, but I suspect by 1945, Churchill like most of the UK, just wanted it done with.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Aug 15 10.04am

Quote Stirlingsays at 06 Aug 2015 10.02pm

Quote silvertop at 06 Aug 2015 10.01pm

I can actually see the sense in dropping the bomb. My problem is the need to drop it on a city. The U.S. Had complete air supremacy and could have dropped it anywhere they liked. At least start with a more isolated island.


I wonder if this was considered.

I suspect it was, but civilian annihilation was flavour of the month in Europe. I suspect they did not have dozens of those bombs to give the luxury of starting somewhere safe and then grading up. And the Japanese were proving somewhat entrenched in the concept of fight to the last man. U.S. servicemen were winning but the body count was huge. Nevertheless, we know they had at least 2. And the first could have not been a city. With the second coming maybe a couple of weeks later. Not in the same week.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 Aug 15 10.09am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Aug 2015 9.58am

Worth noting that Churchill didn't want war crimes trials, he was all for just shooting them as they found them, he would later admit he was wrong, and glad that they went down the war crimes route, but I suspect by 1945, Churchill like most of the UK, just wanted it done with.


Curiously, it was the Soviets who were the keenest to put them on trial, albeit with an inevitable outcome. WC was indeed lukewarm at best and the Yanks needed a bit of persuasion as well.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

legaleagle Flag 07 Aug 15 10.12am

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Aug 2015 8.28am

I have a question for both of you, legal and Stirling.

Hitler's admiration for the British, and particularly the Empire, is well documented through Mein Kampf and other sources - he placed immense emphasis on the importance of some kind of alliance with Britain. Had he achieved such an alliance, would he have kept to it?

Whilst it's true that his track record on treaty observance was pretty piss poor, notably with the Soviet Union, he stuck with Mussolini to the end. Would he have viewed his alliance with Britain as a matter of temporary expediency or would he genuinely have stuck to it? He wanted Europe as his own fiefdom but he seemed to believe that Britain and her Empire was a vital cog in supporting his own particular version of the new world order .

Would eventual conflict have always been inevitable? Or would Britain and Germany genuinely have walked hand in hand off into the sunset together?

I've read some interesting arguments on both sides as to how it might have panned out - what do you lads think?

That's a big question! with a huge amount of "ifs"

Can I answer part of it this way?

Had there been a deal in Summer 1940,I think it would have been one with the UK very much the weaker partner.It would have led to a new government in the UK of an very appeasement ilk and I think every chance of us drifting slowly into a Vichy-like regime,nominally independent but of a quite distasteful hue in its own right.

It would have opened the way for Hitler to turn on the USSR earlier (which might even have been supported by the UK) and made it less likely Hitler would lose on the Eastern front (though quite possible war would have gone on for many years in the inner depths of the Soviet Union and an endless possible stalemate,with Japan having invaded from Manchuria too).

In terms of the Empire,I think Hitler would have wanted an "in" on equal economic terms to UK (and the restoration of the colonies taken away from Germany after WW1 and put under British mandate) to the natural resources and this would have created strong tensions.

The UK would have been in a v weak position to do anything about it had the "partnership" with Germany begun to seem like not such a good idea,other than negotiate the best it could from a subservient position.

With the UK not as close to the US,I think once things kicked off in Asia (as I think they would have anyway between the US and Japan),I'm not sure the British possessions in the F East would have ended up coming back to the UK .THE US had no interest in the resumption of the British Empire (and attendant economic benefits)n there.

I think Canada would have likely become much more in the US orbit quicker (with the US acting solely in US interests),and Australia would have either become very close to the US in the same way or might even have been invaded by Japan.

Japan might have succeeded in pushing more into India. Interesting thought the extent to which an alliance with Japan might have topped keeping the UK happy for Hitler,once the UK could be no threat in Europe and was very much subservient to Germany on any meaningful areas of difference.

Would Hitler have kept to the deal?I think likely not,unless the UK morphed inexorably into a Vichy type satellite.Hitler's track record on deals,say the Munich Agreement re Czechoslovakia and his treaty with the USSR indicates he was not a great deal keeper.I think his "looking after" of Mussolini was as much from self-interest as anything else.

I also think in such a situation (given the degree of latent anti-semitism with some establishment circles) and the likely permeation of Nazi propaganda given Germany would have become our "partner",there could well have also been a drift towards anti-semitic laws along the lines of those in Germany in the 1930's being introduced.

I don't think we would have walked into the sunset in a way (with hindsight) we might say was desirable and the sunset might rather have been a horrible big storm.

The novel,"Dominion" by CJ Sansom is one take on how things might have panned out in the UK following such a deal in 1940.


Edited by legaleagle (07 Aug 2015 10.18am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Aug 15 11.24am

Quote silvertop at 07 Aug 2015 10.04am

Quote Stirlingsays at 06 Aug 2015 10.02pm

Quote silvertop at 06 Aug 2015 10.01pm

I can actually see the sense in dropping the bomb. My problem is the need to drop it on a city. The U.S. Had complete air supremacy and could have dropped it anywhere they liked. At least start with a more isolated island.


I wonder if this was considered.

I suspect it was, but civilian annihilation was flavour of the month in Europe. I suspect they did not have dozens of those bombs to give the luxury of starting somewhere safe and then grading up. And the Japanese were proving somewhat entrenched in the concept of fight to the last man. U.S. servicemen were winning but the body count was huge. Nevertheless, we know they had at least 2. And the first could have not been a city. With the second coming maybe a couple of weeks later. Not in the same week.

They had two, ready to go, and another that would be operational by the 19th of August, and enough material to produce six more by the end of October.

The US didn't have to invade the mainland of Japan, they could just as easily taken a few remaining Islands and settled in for a siege, backed by total air superiority and near total naval superiority, hitting infrastructure targets that remained until Japan was incapable of any kind of sustainability and surrendered. Of course, they also had the capacity to force an enemy to surrender (the nuclear option) or the military option (Invasion). Of the three, the nuclear option makes sense in terms of a war, because its the most cost efficient (plus it needed field testing).

Hiroshima, was a target because it had been largely unscathed by US bombing runs, and as such retained a lot of infrastructure, about 20% of the casualties were military at Hiroshima. So it was as far as air bombing operations went a logical target, as even if Japan didn't surrender, it would effectively destroy one of its few remaining intact cities and industry zones.

Nagasaki, was more the warning shot, because it wasn't even the target. Kyoto was the initial target, however due to weather conditions over Kyoto, Nagasaki was selected for the second nuclear bomb.

Japan also didn't surrender immediately after Nagasaki, it would be another five days, on the 13th the US decided to cease the production of the third atomic bomb, probably highlighting when the US was convinced an Unconditional Surrrender was coming.

Ironically the US could only have deployed one more nuclear weapon before the end of September.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 07 Aug 15 12.09pm

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 11.12pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 10.28pm

Quote legaleagle at 06 Aug 2015 10.14pm

Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 10.10pm

Well certainly Fascism wasn't frowned upon, pre war, by everyone for sure and certainly Hitler had many admirers over here. But the the truth is that ideology came a distant second to national and personal security when the war started and the Right soon realised that Hitler was a megalomaniac.

Unfortunately, the left, the unions and all the usual suspects were not so keen to roll their sleeves up. Same old same old.

Of course I'm speaking in generalities but I'm happy to engage you on detail if you really want to.


No need.But thank goodness people like Ernie Bevan and Attlee "rolled their sleeves" up as opposed to appeasers on the right like Lord Halifax who,had he taken over from Chamberlain in May 1940 (and it was a close thing), would no doubt have done the deal with Adolf even quicker than you would take another historically biased and inaccurate potshot at "the left".

Edited by legaleagle (06 Aug 2015 10.15pm)

But the point dear legal is that they were onside when the war began. The might have had ideological sympathies but that was secondary.

You might be interested in this proud assertion.

[Link]


In relation to Halifax,dear chap, the point was my point was about him still harbouring appeasement tendencies and being in favour of a deal in May 1940,well after war had been declared.

Of course most of "the right" did their bit after war was declared,just like most on the left.I was focusing on your lack of balance in posting about "the left",and as if "the left" is/was one unified grouping

To illustrate that the right was not free of appeasers etc after war was declared ,note that Mosley, certainly of the wider "right" apropos your references to "the left", and 740 followers were interned in May 1940, war having started 8 months earlier, as a potential fifth column.

The "Establishment" was far from free of appeasers post outbreak of war either.Take the Duke of Buccleuch, Lord ­Steward of the Royal Household.He was opposed to any war with the Nazis and when it did break out in 1939, he joined the Peace Aims Group and urged a truce based on Germany keeping all the lands Hitler had stolen in Europe. Even after the bombing started, he continued to defend Hitler.

The Duke of Westminster,an admirer of Hitler,spent the first year of the war demanding, to whomever would listen, that peace be made with Germany.

Another interned was Admiral Sir Barry Domville.In June 1940 his mistress, Mrs. Olive Baker, was arrested for distributing leaflets promoting Reichssender Hamburg.

Take Archibald Maule Ramsay,Scottish Unionist MP. On 20 March 1940, he asked a question in parliament about a propaganda radio station set up by Germany which gave its precise wavelength, which was suspected by both his allies and opponents as a subtle way of advertising it.

Just saying...


Someone has been spending too much time on Wiki.

You have named a few deluded individuals, but I'm talking about a large numbers of people. Yes to use epithets like left and right is simple minded of course but the fact is that the left/union mentality still resisted the war effort in many cases because they put their own interests before the nations. The link I provided which you conveniently ignored just demonstrates that the same attitudes still prevails. The left always trying to claim the moral high ground but ultimately always the spanner in the works.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Aug 15 12.26pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Aug 2015 9.25am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 7.51am

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 10.16pm

Quote matt_himself at 06 Aug 2015 8.19pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.

The Japanese, due to their belief that their Emperor was a God, we're not going to surrender.

Bear in mind that up until 1974 there were Japanese soldiers in places like Micronesia still fighting the war and when they were found by locals, they persisted in killing them as they had not had instruction to down weapons.

Plus the Japanese human rights record in the war was barbaric. They tortured and raped at will. Chinese, Koreans, Malay, Singaporean, etc., they didn't care. POW's were treated as sub human scum.

Additionally, the Japanese weren't afraid to sacrifice hundreds of thousands of their own.

The use of nuclear weapons was the last resort but in a situation like that, where you have an enemy who is so intractable, what do you do?

Talk and provide humanitarian aid in the hope they bow down?


Edited by matt_himself (06 Aug 2015 8.20pm)


I don't disagree with the use of the bomb at that particular time but strongly disagree with the actual geographical targets. Mass murder, basically. Those 140,000 civilians young and old weren't the ones trying to kill US soldiers so don't really get the narrative that it was done in order to save lives.

My old library master had been tortured by the Japs and couldn't speak save for a desperate rasp. They had been brutalized into savagery akin to the Hitler Youth being brainwashed with 'strength through joy' and other zeitgeist phrases.

read about the power the Emperor had over the Japanese. The bombs were dropped to save lives as the Emperor employed a scorched earth policy and would rather see his country and people wiped out than surrender.

However the bombs changed opinion.

Not nice, hope we never have to use them again but ultimately the correct course of action.

The US had essentially beaten Japan back to the mainland, its navy was almost incapable of operation and total air superiority could have been achieved within a few days. The US had other options, but it did have a super weapon, that had cost a massive fortune to produce, that no one else in the world possessed.

I don't really think the decision was taken for the good of POWs, Japans future, negating the necessity of an invasion, but because it would effectively demonstrate the capability of the US militarily, probably force an unconditional surrender (that was only a matter of time - Japan would probably have accepted a conditional surrender).

If Japan was truly committed to a everyman to the death, for the glory of the Emperor, scorched earth policy, then Nagasaki and Hiroshima would have made no difference to that. The US were also quite keen on covering up the full effects of radiation poisioning after the war, and the consequences to those affected by the bombs.

I think its hard to escape the conclusion that it remains one of the single most horrific acts of war targeted at a mostly civilian population.

I don't think you can really ever get away from the fact that it really was a war crime by any stretch of the imagination; it worked out for the best, probably, all told, but its hard to really justify any situation in which a country deliberately targets and kills at least 80,000 in a single indiscriminate attack.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (07 Aug 2015 9.29am)

I think you can get away from the 'fact' that it was a 'war crime' because it wasn't.

It was an act of war brought about by the circumstances of the time.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Aug 15 12.49pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 12.26pm
I think you can get away from the 'fact' that it was a 'war crime' because it wasn't.

It was an act of war brought about by the circumstances of the time.

What you actually mean is, because the US was on the winning side, it wasn't a war crime. Whilst with Hiroshima a loose argument can be made for a military legitimacy, 20% of the 80,000 dead were military, Nagasaki certainly wasn't.

If deliberately targeting and killing tens of thousands of civilians in a single attack isn't a war crime, we probably shouldn't bother with the concept.

That said, it was probably with hindsight the right decision, and I suspect I'd have made the same decision. Just if your going to have the idea of war crimes, nuking cities pretty much tops the list. A lot of war criminals were punished for far less serious offences.

But that is the way it works, the cost of losing a war, is being held accountable.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Aug 15 12.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Aug 2015 12.49pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 12.26pm
I think you can get away from the 'fact' that it was a 'war crime' because it wasn't.

It was an act of war brought about by the circumstances of the time.

What you actually mean is, because the US was on the winning side, it wasn't a war crime. Whilst with Hiroshima a loose argument can be made for a military legitimacy, 20% of the 80,000 dead were military, Nagasaki certainly wasn't.

If deliberately targeting and killing tens of thousands of civilians in a single attack isn't a war crime, we probably shouldn't bother with the concept.

That said, it was probably with hindsight the right decision, and I suspect I'd have made the same decision. Just if your going to have the idea of war crimes, nuking cities pretty much tops the list. A lot of war criminals were punished for far less serious offences.

But that is the way it works, the cost of losing a war, is being held accountable.


I don't mean that at all. I believe that it was the right course of action and that you and sundry can judge the situation through revisionist glasses all you like, however, the reality of the situation was that it had to happen.

Freeing the Japanese people from the Emperor and ending the war by use of atomic weapons was the right course of action.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 07 Aug 15 1.18pm

Quote legaleagle at 07 Aug 2015 10.12am

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Aug 2015 8.28am

I have a question for both of you, legal and Stirling.

Hitler's admiration for the British, and particularly the Empire, is well documented through Mein Kampf and other sources - he placed immense emphasis on the importance of some kind of alliance with Britain. Had he achieved such an alliance, would he have kept to it?

Whilst it's true that his track record on treaty observance was pretty piss poor, notably with the Soviet Union, he stuck with Mussolini to the end. Would he have viewed his alliance with Britain as a matter of temporary expediency or would he genuinely have stuck to it? He wanted Europe as his own fiefdom but he seemed to believe that Britain and her Empire was a vital cog in supporting his own particular version of the new world order .

Would eventual conflict have always been inevitable? Or would Britain and Germany genuinely have walked hand in hand off into the sunset together?

I've read some interesting arguments on both sides as to how it might have panned out - what do you lads think?

That's a big question! with a huge amount of "ifs"

Can I answer part of it this way?

Had there been a deal in Summer 1940,I think it would have been one with the UK very much the weaker partner.It would have led to a new government in the UK of an very appeasement ilk and I think every chance of us drifting slowly into a Vichy-like regime,nominally independent but of a quite distasteful hue in its own right.

It would have opened the way for Hitler to turn on the USSR earlier (which might even have been supported by the UK) and made it less likely Hitler would lose on the Eastern front (though quite possible war would have gone on for many years in the inner depths of the Soviet Union and an endless possible stalemate,with Japan having invaded from Manchuria too).

In terms of the Empire,I think Hitler would have wanted an "in" on equal economic terms to UK (and the restoration of the colonies taken away from Germany after WW1 and put under British mandate) to the natural resources and this would have created strong tensions.

The UK would have been in a v weak position to do anything about it had the "partnership" with Germany begun to seem like not such a good idea,other than negotiate the best it could from a subservient position.

With the UK not as close to the US,I think once things kicked off in Asia (as I think they would have anyway between the US and Japan),I'm not sure the British possessions in the F East would have ended up coming back to the UK .THE US had no interest in the resumption of the British Empire (and attendant economic benefits)n there.

I think Canada would have likely become much more in the US orbit quicker (with the US acting solely in US interests),and Australia would have either become very close to the US in the same way or might even have been invaded by Japan.

Japan might have succeeded in pushing more into India. Interesting thought the extent to which an alliance with Japan might have topped keeping the UK happy for Hitler,once the UK could be no threat in Europe and was very much subservient to Germany on any meaningful areas of difference.

Would Hitler have kept to the deal?I think likely not,unless the UK morphed inexorably into a Vichy type satellite.Hitler's track record on deals,say the Munich Agreement re Czechoslovakia and his treaty with the USSR indicates he was not a great deal keeper.I think his "looking after" of Mussolini was as much from self-interest as anything else.

I also think in such a situation (given the degree of latent anti-semitism with some establishment circles) and the likely permeation of Nazi propaganda given Germany would have become our "partner",there could well have also been a drift towards anti-semitic laws along the lines of those in Germany in the 1930's being introduced.

I don't think we would have walked into the sunset in a way (with hindsight) we might say was desirable and the sunset might rather have been a horrible big storm.

The novel,"Dominion" by CJ Sansom is one take on how things might have panned out in the UK following such a deal in 1940.


Edited by legaleagle (07 Aug 2015 10.18am)

This is an interesting topic the US strategic thought was against GB's global interests rather than Japan. Rather as China is seen as a strategic threat nowadays.

A war was inevitable but the sides might have been different if Hitler played his cards with more finesse.


Edited by pefwin (07 Aug 2015 1.26pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Aug 15 1.26pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 12.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Aug 2015 12.49pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 12.26pm
I think you can get away from the 'fact' that it was a 'war crime' because it wasn't.

It was an act of war brought about by the circumstances of the time.

What you actually mean is, because the US was on the winning side, it wasn't a war crime. Whilst with Hiroshima a loose argument can be made for a military legitimacy, 20% of the 80,000 dead were military, Nagasaki certainly wasn't.

If deliberately targeting and killing tens of thousands of civilians in a single attack isn't a war crime, we probably shouldn't bother with the concept.

That said, it was probably with hindsight the right decision, and I suspect I'd have made the same decision. Just if your going to have the idea of war crimes, nuking cities pretty much tops the list. A lot of war criminals were punished for far less serious offences.

But that is the way it works, the cost of losing a war, is being held accountable.


I don't mean that at all. I believe that it was the right course of action and that you and sundry can judge the situation through revisionist glasses all you like, however, the reality of the situation was that it had to happen.

Freeing the Japanese people from the Emperor and ending the war by use of atomic weapons was the right course of action.

Yes, because that's entirely what the motivation was in vaporizing two whole cities.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Aug 15 1.41pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Aug 2015 8.28am

I have a question for both of you, legal and Stirling.

Hitler's admiration for the British, and particularly the Empire, is well documented through Mein Kampf and other sources - he placed immense emphasis on the importance of some kind of alliance with Britain. Had he achieved such an alliance, would he have kept to it?

Whilst it's true that his track record on treaty observance was pretty piss poor, notably with the Soviet Union, he stuck with Mussolini to the end. Would he have viewed his alliance with Britain as a matter of temporary expediency or would he genuinely have stuck to it? He wanted Europe as his own fiefdom but he seemed to believe that Britain and her Empire was a vital cog in supporting his own particular version of the new world order .

Would eventual conflict have always been inevitable? Or would Britain and Germany genuinely have walked hand in hand off into the sunset together?

I've read some interesting arguments on both sides as to how it might have panned out - what do you lads think?

Hitler wanted a Europe/world ruled by Germany.......I'd say if it wasn't so downbeat the modern day outcome is almost amusing.

If Germany had beaten the USSR and come to some arrangement with the US (the US being beaten wasn't realistic with the bomb)....Probably involving the Axis ditching Japan and the war in the pacific....though their involvement was limited.

It's possible that Germany could have come back to just fighting on one front.

I think Churchill could have been over-ruled
Then Britain would have at the least have had a government similar to the Vichy government.

If Britain had still choosen to fight then it was a war of attrition.....But one we couldn't without American help and control of the air..... once air superiority was won Germany would still have had an army of around half a million to defeat.

Hitler would have preferred installing a Vicky style government rather than defeating it......He would have been more concerned with controlling the newly defeated USSR.

With a Vicky style government Churchill and others would have probably operated a resistance....and in time been done away with.

Essentially all defeated nations were regarded in arian terms by Hitler....All subservient to Germany. In comparison to the Poles and slavs the British would have been treated reasonably well.....God help the Jewish population here though.

The same kind of revisionism that teaches that the atom bomb was justifiable would have been used to teach young British children that the British defeat was necessary for a united Europe......A kind of....All roads lead to Berlin....The only difference was the route taken.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 07 Aug 15 1.46pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Aug 2015 8.28am

I have a question for both of you, legal and Stirling.

Hitler's admiration for the British, and particularly the Empire, is well documented through Mein Kampf and other sources - he placed immense emphasis on the importance of some kind of alliance with Britain. Had he achieved such an alliance, would he have kept to it?

Whilst it's true that his track record on treaty observance was pretty piss poor, notably with the Soviet Union, he stuck with Mussolini to the end. Would he have viewed his alliance with Britain as a matter of temporary expediency or would he genuinely have stuck to it? He wanted Europe as his own fiefdom but he seemed to believe that Britain and her Empire was a vital cog in supporting his own particular version of the new world order .

Would eventual conflict have always been inevitable? Or would Britain and Germany genuinely have walked hand in hand off into the sunset together?

I've read some interesting arguments on both sides as to how it might have panned out - what do you lads think?

Hitler wanted a Europe/world ruled by Germany.......I'd say if it wasn't so downbeat the modern day outcome is almost amusing.

If Germany had beaten the USSR and come to some arrangement with the US (the US being beaten wasn't realistic with the bomb)....Probably involving the Axis ditching Japan and the war in the pacific....though their involvement was limited.

It's possible that Germany could have come back to just fighting on one front.

I think Churchill could have been over-ruled
Then Britain would have at the least have had a government similar to the Vichy government.

If Britain had still choosen to fight then it was a war of attrition.....But one we couldn't without American help and control of the air..... once air superiority was won Germany would still have had an army of around half a million to defeat.

Hitler would have preferred installing a Vicky style government rather than defeating it......He would have been more concerned with controlling the newly defeated USSR.

With a Vicky style government Churchill and others would have probably operated a resistance....and in time been done away with.

Essentially all defeated nations were regarded in arian terms by Hitler....All subservient to Germany. In comparison to the Poles and slavs the British would have been treated reasonably well.....God help the Jewish population here though.

The same kind of revisionism that teaches that the atom bomb was justifiable would have been used to teach young British children that the British defeat was necessary for a united Europe......A kind of....All roads lead to Berlin....The only difference was the route taken.

I shall say this only once - Do you mean Vicki Michelle out of 'allo 'allo?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 07 Aug 15 1.57pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Aug 2015 8.28am

I have a question for both of you, legal and Stirling.

Hitler's admiration for the British, and particularly the Empire, is well documented through Mein Kampf and other sources - he placed immense emphasis on the importance of some kind of alliance with Britain. Had he achieved such an alliance, would he have kept to it?

Whilst it's true that his track record on treaty observance was pretty piss poor, notably with the Soviet Union, he stuck with Mussolini to the end. Would he have viewed his alliance with Britain as a matter of temporary expediency or would he genuinely have stuck to it? He wanted Europe as his own fiefdom but he seemed to believe that Britain and her Empire was a vital cog in supporting his own particular version of the new world order .

Would eventual conflict have always been inevitable? Or would Britain and Germany genuinely have walked hand in hand off into the sunset together?

I've read some interesting arguments on both sides as to how it might have panned out - what do you lads think?

Hitler wanted a Europe/world ruled by Germany.......I'd say if it wasn't so downbeat the modern day outcome is almost amusing.

If Germany had beaten the USSR and come to some arrangement with the US (the US being beaten wasn't realistic with the bomb)....Probably involving the Axis ditching Japan and the war in the pacific....though their involvement was limited.

It's possible that Germany could have come back to just fighting on one front.

I think Churchill could have been over-ruled
Then Britain would have at the least have had a government similar to the Vichy government.

If Britain had still choosen to fight then it was a war of attrition.....But one we couldn't without American help and control of the air..... once air superiority was won Germany would still have had an army of around half a million to defeat.

Hitler would have preferred installing a Vicky style government rather than defeating it......He would have been more concerned with controlling the newly defeated USSR.

With a Vicky style government Churchill and others would have probably operated a resistance....and in time been done away with.

Essentially all defeated nations were regarded in arian terms by Hitler....All subservient to Germany. In comparison to the Poles and slavs the British would have been treated reasonably well.....God help the Jewish population here though.

The same kind of revisionism that teaches that the atom bomb was justifiable would have been used to teach young British children that the British defeat was necessary for a united Europe......A kind of....All roads lead to Berlin....The only difference was the route taken.


Well they got there in the end

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Aug 15 2.05pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 12.58pm

I don't mean that at all. I believe that it was the right course of action and that you and sundry can judge the situation through revisionist glasses all you like, however, the reality of the situation was that it had to happen.

Freeing the Japanese people from the Emperor and ending the war by use of atomic weapons was the right course of action.


I think this is just incredible I really do.....If the shoe had been on the other foot I very much doubt you'd believe this desensitized nonsense.

So you are basically saying that because you don't believe anything other than 'unconditional surrender' was good enough that it was justifiable to vapourise and burn thousands upon thousands of women, children and babies.

The demonstration of the bomb on an unpopulated area would have made things very plain.....It wasn't even tried.

I don't see how a conditional surrender....Which Japan had asked the USSR to mediate.... couldn't have involved significant limitation of fighting forces and also significant American control of their economy and government.

The lessons of the deal given to Germany in WW1 wouldn't have been repeated.

I'm sorry Matt.....But outside of retaliation... the use of the Atom bomb can have no justification.

There were definitely alternatives.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Aug 15 2.11pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Aug 2015 1.57pm


Well they got there in the end


Don't we know it.

No jackboots perhaps but dominance in Europe via hegemony......A parliament that controls a reduced amount of laws.....A peaceful self imposed Vichy rule.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 07 Aug 15 2.20pm

Quote TheJudge at 07 Aug 2015 12.09pm


Someone has been spending too much time on Wiki.

You have named a few deluded individuals, but I'm talking about a large numbers of people. Yes to use epithets like left and right is simple minded of course but the fact is that the left/union mentality still resisted the war effort in many cases because they put their own interests before the nations. The link I provided which you conveniently ignored just demonstrates that the same attitudes still prevails. The left always trying to claim the moral high ground but ultimately always the spanner in the works.

Most not from wiki;its an area I have an interest in anyway

The point ,IMO, being that it is you always claiming the moral high ground for the "right".My posts were aimed at your focus solely on "the left",about whom you cant resist another silly dig above and lumping all kinds of views into one supposedly solidified bloc.A minority on the "right" were dodgy 1930's onwards,a minority on the left were dodgy 1939-41.Two wrongs make two wrongs,not only the wrong you want to see.And,of course any suggestion certain inappropriate traits of such minorities being replicated (such as the widespread antipathy towards non Anglo-Saxons prevalent on the right in the 30's) today are plain silly to make if limited only to what you think are "faults" of the left whilst being blind to equivalency on "the right"


 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 07 Aug 15 2.25pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 12.26pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Aug 2015 9.25am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Aug 2015 7.51am

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 10.16pm

Quote matt_himself at 06 Aug 2015 8.19pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am

It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US.

They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender.

The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known.

A heinous act.

The Japanese, due to their belief that their Emperor was a God, we're not going to surrender.

Bear in mind that up until 1974 there were Japanese soldiers in places like Micronesia still fighting the war and when they were found by locals, they persisted in killing them as they had not had instruction to down weapons.

Plus the Japanese human rights record in the war was barbaric. They tortured and raped at will. Chinese, Koreans, Malay, Singaporean, etc., they didn't care. POW's were treated as sub human scum.

Additionally, the Japanese weren't afraid to sacrifice hundreds of thousands of their own.

The use of nuclear weapons was the last resort but in a situation like that, where you have an enemy who is so intractable, what do you do?

Talk and provide humanitarian aid in the hope they bow down?


Edited by matt_himself (06 Aug 2015 8.20pm)


I don't disagree with the use of the bomb at that particular time but strongly disagree with the actual geographical targets. Mass murder, basically. Those 140,000 civilians young and old weren't the ones trying to kill US soldiers so don't really get the narrative that it was done in order to save lives.

My old library master had been tortured by the Japs and couldn't speak save for a desperate rasp. They had been brutalized into savagery akin to the Hitler Youth being brainwashed with 'strength through joy' and other zeitgeist phrases.

read about the power the Emperor had over the Japanese. The bombs were dropped to save lives as the Emperor employed a scorched earth policy and would rather see his country and people wiped out than surrender.

However the bombs changed opinion.

Not nice, hope we never have to use them again but ultimately the correct course of action.

The US had essentially beaten Japan back to the mainland, its navy was almost incapable of operation and total air superiority could have been achieved within a few days. The US had other options, but it did have a super weapon, that had cost a massive fortune to produce, that no one else in the world possessed.

I don't really think the decision was taken for the good of POWs, Japans future, negating the necessity of an invasion, but because it would effectively demonstrate the capability of the US militarily, probably force an unconditional surrender (that was only a matter of time - Japan would probably have accepted a conditional surrender).

If Japan was truly committed to a everyman to the death, for the glory of the Emperor, scorched earth policy, then Nagasaki and Hiroshima would have made no difference to that. The US were also quite keen on covering up the full effects of radiation poisioning after the war, and the consequences to those affected by the bombs.

I think its hard to escape the conclusion that it remains one of the single most horrific acts of war targeted at a mostly civilian population.

I don't think you can really ever get away from the fact that it really was a war crime by any stretch of the imagination; it worked out for the best, probably, all told, but its hard to really justify any situation in which a country deliberately targets and kills at least 80,000 in a single indiscriminate attack.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (07 Aug 2015 9.29am)

I think you can get away from the 'fact' that it was a 'war crime' because it wasn't.

It was an act of war brought about by the circumstances of the time.


There is a simple definition of a war crime

"Wilful killing, torture or inhuman treatment, including... wilfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health....

Hiroshima was a war crime. So was the targeting of civilians and non-combatants during the Blitz and the British bombing of Hamburg and Dresden.

Anyone with an interest should read Among the Dead Cities by AC Grayling

 

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Hiroshima