You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Smoking ban in pub gardens.
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Smoking ban in pub gardens.


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
TheJudge Flag 15 Aug 15 2.41pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 15 Aug 2015 11.18am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)


If you do label yourself as 'tolerant' (as people like yourself frequently do), then you're just another clichéd comedy leftie and I shall treat all your posts accordingly.

So a straw man argument followed by a hugely inaccurate assumption.

Good work.

I have been called a few things, but "Leftie" ?
That takes the biscuit.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards so many memories Flag basingstoke 15 Aug 15 2.41pm

Arnott-man+in+moon..jpeg Attachment: Arnott-man+in+moon..jpeg (150.79Kb)

 


Get it on-get it in-F**K OFF ALAN HANSEN!!

TheJudge Flag 15 Aug 15 2.45pm

Enough already.

I'm abandoning all of you smokers and smoker enablers to your cloudy, wheezy, stinky, carcinogenic heaven.

I'm out.

 

becky Flag over the moon 15 Aug 15 3.12pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 2.45pm

Enough already.

I'm abandoning all of you smokers and smoker enablers to your cloudy, wheezy, stinky, carcinogenic heaven.

I'm out.


Take a deep breath before you go, there could be smokers outside........

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 15 Aug 15 4.10pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 2.41pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 15 Aug 2015 11.18am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)


If you do label yourself as 'tolerant' (as people like yourself frequently do), then you're just another clichéd comedy leftie and I shall treat all your posts accordingly.

So a straw man argument followed by a hugely inaccurate assumption.

Good work.

I have been called a few things, but "Leftie" ?
That takes the biscuit.


Well, you will insist on coming out with this totalitarian drivel which leads to perfectly understandable conclusions.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 15 Aug 15 4.28pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 2.45pm

Enough already.

I'm abandoning all of you smokers and smoker enablers to your cloudy, wheezy, stinky, carcinogenic heaven.

I'm out.


Don't go now, you've been a breath of fresh air.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

cpfanron Flag andover 18 Aug 15 9.38am

Quote becky at 15 Aug 2015 3.12pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 2.45pm

Enough already.

I'm abandoning all of you smokers and smoker enablers to your cloudy, wheezy, stinky, carcinogenic heaven.

I'm out.


Take a deep breath before you go, there could be smokers outside........

Also take an even bigger breath, you may pass the disgusting bar-bar Q smoke that wafts through the air that hopefully pollutes the so called judges lungs,F------, windbag!!!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Aug 15 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Aug 15 9.45am

Quote Cucking Funt at 15 Aug 2015 4.10pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 2.41pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 15 Aug 2015 11.18am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)


If you do label yourself as 'tolerant' (as people like yourself frequently do), then you're just another clichéd comedy leftie and I shall treat all your posts accordingly.

So a straw man argument followed by a hugely inaccurate assumption.

Good work.

I have been called a few things, but "Leftie" ?
That takes the biscuit.


Well, you will insist on coming out with this totalitarian drivel which leads to perfectly understandable conclusions.

I'd imagine that Stalin was pretty pro-smoking, after all you can't personally order the death of everyone. Nazi's were one of the first major anti-smoking campaigners, unless they were smoking 'undesirables'


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 18 Aug 15 10.36am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.



Not if the law says they don't.

Our rights are balanced against the good of our society.

That's what laws are for. Surely you know this.

 

TheJudge Flag 18 Aug 15 10.37am

Quote cpfanron at 18 Aug 2015 9.38am

Quote becky at 15 Aug 2015 3.12pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 2.45pm

Enough already.

I'm abandoning all of you smokers and smoker enablers to your cloudy, wheezy, stinky, carcinogenic heaven.

I'm out.


Take a deep breath before you go, there could be smokers outside........

Also take an even bigger breath, you may pass the disgusting bar-bar Q smoke that wafts through the air that hopefully pollutes the so called judges lungs,F------, windbag!!!

You must be a nicotine addict. How's that going for you ?

 

johnfirewall Flag 18 Aug 15 12.18pm

You get smoke blown in your face or end up down-wind of it walking down a busy street. At least sitting at a bench in a pub garden, your smoking friends are more likely to consciously blow it in the other direction wind permitting.

Banning smoking with kids in a car is a sensible move but I don't really know who the pub garden ban is designed to protect. Scummy parents smoking over their kids are on every high-street.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Aug 15 12.56pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 10.36am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.



Not if the law says they don't.

Our rights are balanced against the good of our society.

That's what laws are for. Surely you know this.

Smoking doesn't harm the 'good of society', in any real meaningful way, and contributes a large amount of revenue. The good of society is protected better by allowing freedom of individuals to make decisions for themselves, than dictating acceptable behavior, especially where consensus of right is divided among the populace.

Plus of course, you weren't presenting an argument based on social good and social well being, but on personal distaste and personal opinion.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 18 Aug 15 1.22pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 12.56pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 10.36am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.



Not if the law says they don't.

Our rights are balanced against the good of our society.

That's what laws are for. Surely you know this.

Smoking doesn't harm the 'good of society', in any real meaningful way, and contributes a large amount of revenue. The good of society is protected better by allowing freedom of individuals to make decisions for themselves, than dictating acceptable behavior, especially where consensus of right is divided among the populace.

Plus of course, you weren't presenting an argument based on social good and social well being, but on personal distaste and personal opinion.


Your post contradicts itself.

You state as if a fact that smoking doesn't harm society and then say that my view is just an opinion.

News alert. Your assertion is just an opinion as well.

The difference is that there is scientific proof that passive smoking is bad for the health. In any case, smoking is not harmless a past time, it is a genuine addiction. It boils down to a group of addicts and their enablers telling us, the majority of non smokers, that we should tolerate their disgusting unhealthy stink because we are mean and small minded not to.

Poppycock. Maybe we should allow pubs to open a crack house next to the kiddies play area. That will boost their turnover.

Edited by TheJudge (18 Aug 2015 1.23pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Aug 15 1.42pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 1.22pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 12.56pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 10.36am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.



Not if the law says they don't.

Our rights are balanced against the good of our society.

That's what laws are for. Surely you know this.

Smoking doesn't harm the 'good of society', in any real meaningful way, and contributes a large amount of revenue. The good of society is protected better by allowing freedom of individuals to make decisions for themselves, than dictating acceptable behavior, especially where consensus of right is divided among the populace.

Plus of course, you weren't presenting an argument based on social good and social well being, but on personal distaste and personal opinion.


Your post contradicts itself.

You state as if a fact that smoking doesn't harm society and then say that my view is just an opinion.

News alert. Your assertion is just an opinion as well.

The difference is that there is scientific proof that passive smoking is bad for the health. In any case, smoking is not harmless a past time, it is a genuine addiction. It boils down to a group of addicts and their enablers telling us, the majority of non smokers, that we should tolerate their disgusting unhealthy stink because we are mean and small minded not to.

Poppycock. Maybe we should allow pubs to open a crack house next to the kiddies play area. That will boost their turnover.

Edited by TheJudge (18 Aug 2015 1.23pm)

An individuals health is not the good of society. Society is a collective of individuals. Collectively it raises revenue for society, from taxation. Also, paradoxically, it reduces the burden on the state in terms of individuals, due to the 33% of smokers who die prematurely (thus reducing the burden in terms of state pension, care provision and the cost of treating late life diseases).

See there is an issue you are missing, regarding health, everyone is going to die, sooner or later. So the good of society, and the individual's health are not the same thing.

Its also better for the good of society, to allow people the agency of choice, where no definitive consensus can be reached, as opposed to a 'moralist tyranny'.

The down side, is that some people find smoking to be distasteful and unpleasant. You also don't have to tolerate their unhealthy stink, as exposure to fresh air renders second hand smoke insignificant, due to the dispersion in open air.

Even in a relatively small pub, with a garden, you have plenty of space, generally, to avoid smoke (not least indoors).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Aug 15 1.54pm

Quote johnfirewall at 18 Aug 2015 12.18pm

You get smoke blown in your face or end up down-wind of it walking down a busy street. At least sitting at a bench in a pub garden, your smoking friends are more likely to consciously blow it in the other direction wind permitting.

Banning smoking with kids in a car is a sensible move but I don't really know who the pub garden ban is designed to protect. Scummy parents smoking over their kids are on every high-street.


I saw a women crossing over Roman Way last week pushing a pram with a phone clamped to her face, fag in her mouth and heavily pregnant to boot.

 


Optimistic as ever

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 18 Aug 15 1.54pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 1.22pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 12.56pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 10.36am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.



Not if the law says they don't.

Our rights are balanced against the good of our society.

That's what laws are for. Surely you know this.

Smoking doesn't harm the 'good of society', in any real meaningful way, and contributes a large amount of revenue. The good of society is protected better by allowing freedom of individuals to make decisions for themselves, than dictating acceptable behavior, especially where consensus of right is divided among the populace.

Plus of course, you weren't presenting an argument based on social good and social well being, but on personal distaste and personal opinion.


Your post contradicts itself.

You state as if a fact that smoking doesn't harm society and then say that my view is just an opinion.

News alert. Your assertion is just an opinion as well.

The difference is that there is scientific proof that passive smoking is bad for the health. In any case, smoking is not harmless a past time, it is a genuine addiction. It boils down to a group of addicts and their enablers telling us, the majority of non smokers, that we should tolerate their disgusting unhealthy stink because we are mean and small minded not to.

Poppycock. Maybe we should allow pubs to open a crack house next to the kiddies play area. That will boost their turnover.

Edited by TheJudge (18 Aug 2015 1.23pm)


Jamie's right when he says it doesn't harm society - people have been smoking for hundreds of years and, guess what, society is still here. The things that really harm society are things like war, bubonic plague, floods and, dare I say it, do-gooders and social engineers who try to alter people's behaviour to align with their own particular views.

Sure, smoking can be harmful on a personal level and possibly to those in the immediate vicinity but, then again, so is the amount of air pollution generated by cars, buses, lorries, aircraft etc. and numerous industrial installations. In fact, the effect of second-hand smoke on the environment is negligible by comparison. Your view on this is totalitarian and you don't even seem to realise it.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

I'mPalace Till I Die Flag 18 Aug 15 2.22pm

Judge - You mentioned earlier that pollution from motor vehicles is not the same. But if you drive to a football match for example, this is not essential and is clearly self indulgent. There are other alternatives should you choose such as electric cars/ e-cigarettes. But these still have some negative impact too. You sound like the fun police with your totalitarian views or maybe you are just hypocritical and only picking on self indulgent activities that don't suit your lifestyle and personal choices. I bet you live a far from perfect green friendly and anti-indulgent life! Who gives you the right to cherry pick what someone else should and should not do whilst living a life of sin (sin is based upon self-indulgence) yourself

 

TheJudge Flag 18 Aug 15 3.50pm

Quote I'mPalace Till I Die at 18 Aug 2015 2.22pm

Judge - You mentioned earlier that pollution from motor vehicles is not the same. But if you drive to a football match for example, this is not essential and is clearly self indulgent. There are other alternatives should you choose such as electric cars/ e-cigarettes. But these still have some negative impact too. You sound like the fun police with your totalitarian views or maybe you are just hypocritical and only picking on self indulgent activities that don't suit your lifestyle and personal choices. I bet you live a far from perfect green friendly and anti-indulgent life! Who gives you the right to cherry pick what someone else should and should not do whilst living a life of sin (sin is based upon self-indulgence) yourself


Did I? I don't think so. Pollution from cars and lorries is also disgraceful, especially the grave error of promoting diesel as a cleaner fuel. The particulates in the air are far too high as is all the polluting that is going on globally. Smoking cannot even be said to be the bi product of a necessary activity. At least cars have and factories have a use.
Maybe I'll come round and crap on your lawn seeing as you think that we should all be passive about everything.

 

TheJudge Flag 18 Aug 15 3.54pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 18 Aug 2015 1.54pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 1.22pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 12.56pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 10.36am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 9.43am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am

A very silly article.

Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does.
Secondly, anyone who wants to spend that much time in a pub needs to get a life.
As far as eating a big pub lunch is concerned. Unlike nicotine and all the other carcinogens related to cigarettes,there is no evidence that enjoying a fatty, high calorie meal occasionally is bad for you. It's when you do it most days that it is likely to become a problem.

Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ?

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am)

Isn't a carcinogen.



I did not mean to imply that it was, but that is just a diversion on your part.

When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant.

Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence.

Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am)

All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.



Not if the law says they don't.

Our rights are balanced against the good of our society.

That's what laws are for. Surely you know this.

Smoking doesn't harm the 'good of society', in any real meaningful way, and contributes a large amount of revenue. The good of society is protected better by allowing freedom of individuals to make decisions for themselves, than dictating acceptable behavior, especially where consensus of right is divided among the populace.

Plus of course, you weren't presenting an argument based on social good and social well being, but on personal distaste and personal opinion.


Your post contradicts itself.

You state as if a fact that smoking doesn't harm society and then say that my view is just an opinion.

News alert. Your assertion is just an opinion as well.

The difference is that there is scientific proof that passive smoking is bad for the health. In any case, smoking is not harmless a past time, it is a genuine addiction. It boils down to a group of addicts and their enablers telling us, the majority of non smokers, that we should tolerate their disgusting unhealthy stink because we are mean and small minded not to.

Poppycock. Maybe we should allow pubs to open a crack house next to the kiddies play area. That will boost their turnover.

Edited by TheJudge (18 Aug 2015 1.23pm)


Jamie's right when he says it doesn't harm society - people have been smoking for hundreds of years and, guess what, society is still here. The things that really harm society are things like war, bubonic plague, floods and, dare I say it, do-gooders and social engineers who try to alter people's behaviour to align with their own particular views.

Sure, smoking can be harmful on a personal level and possibly to those in the immediate vicinity but, then again, so is the amount of air pollution generated by cars, buses, lorries, aircraft etc. and numerous industrial installations. In fact, the effect of second-hand smoke on the environment is negligible by comparison. Your view on this is totalitarian and you don't even seem to realise it.


People have been murdering each other for hundreds of years too. Does that make it alrght too ?

In case you weren't aware, society is made up of people. Things that affect people affect society.

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Smoking ban in pub gardens.