You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labours Economic Policy U Turn !
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labours Economic Policy U Turn !


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
chris123 Flag hove actually 14 Oct 15 4.09pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Oct 2015 3.50pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 3.11pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 3.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 14 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 1.21pm

The Labour Party has been significantly re-engineered to put the membership in a controlling position. Labour MPs have to listen to what their local party wants (and most want Corbyn and his principles) or face deselection. They undermine Corbyn-and therefore the will of the membership- at their own risk.
Two thirds of them aren't conviction politicians anyway so it matters little if they toe the new line or bugger off.

PS. He had another great PMQ's today. Clever use of follow-pn qustions. Cameron squirming and Tories trying to laugh JC down on Tax Credit cuts, housing and (sick b******s) on Breast Cancer Rates.

Edited by Red-Blue-Yellow (14 Oct 2015 1.27pm)

So are you saying that any Labour MP who holds moderate views cannot be a 'conviction politician' and is simply a careerist?

No, rather that a moderate by conviction will not be at home in a more radical environment so, depending how 'moderate' they are, the LibDems beckon or the Tories or whatever.
Anyone who believes that moderation is the best way to tackle such far-right legislation, as is coming before Parliament now, needs to rethink and do so quickly.

Happy to debate this, but not sure to which legislation you refer. Great unemployment numbers by the way.

Not in Scotland though ha ha.


Low oil prices are great for the motorist and inflation - not so good if you work on the supply side.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Oct 15 4.15pm

Quote npn at 14 Oct 2015 3.54pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Oct 2015 3.50pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 3.11pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 3.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 14 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 1.21pm

The Labour Party has been significantly re-engineered to put the membership in a controlling position. Labour MPs have to listen to what their local party wants (and most want Corbyn and his principles) or face deselection. They undermine Corbyn-and therefore the will of the membership- at their own risk.
Two thirds of them aren't conviction politicians anyway so it matters little if they toe the new line or bugger off.

PS. He had another great PMQ's today. Clever use of follow-pn qustions. Cameron squirming and Tories trying to laugh JC down on Tax Credit cuts, housing and (sick b******s) on Breast Cancer Rates.

Edited by Red-Blue-Yellow (14 Oct 2015 1.27pm)

So are you saying that any Labour MP who holds moderate views cannot be a 'conviction politician' and is simply a careerist?

No, rather that a moderate by conviction will not be at home in a more radical environment so, depending how 'moderate' they are, the LibDems beckon or the Tories or whatever.
Anyone who believes that moderation is the best way to tackle such far-right legislation, as is coming before Parliament now, needs to rethink and do so quickly.

Happy to debate this, but not sure to which legislation you refer. Great unemployment numbers by the way.

Not in Scotland though ha ha.


All part of the SNP plan to reduce inequality by making EVERYONE poor!


They knocked about 20% off the figures for the whole UK with their increased unemployment.

That'll be down to their oil industry once again, that was going to fuel everything post-independence, no doubt.

Edited by Stuk (14 Oct 2015 4.17pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Oct 15 4.16pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 4.09pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Oct 2015 3.50pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 3.11pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 3.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 14 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 1.21pm

The Labour Party has been significantly re-engineered to put the membership in a controlling position. Labour MPs have to listen to what their local party wants (and most want Corbyn and his principles) or face deselection. They undermine Corbyn-and therefore the will of the membership- at their own risk.
Two thirds of them aren't conviction politicians anyway so it matters little if they toe the new line or bugger off.

PS. He had another great PMQ's today. Clever use of follow-pn qustions. Cameron squirming and Tories trying to laugh JC down on Tax Credit cuts, housing and (sick b******s) on Breast Cancer Rates.

Edited by Red-Blue-Yellow (14 Oct 2015 1.27pm)

So are you saying that any Labour MP who holds moderate views cannot be a 'conviction politician' and is simply a careerist?

No, rather that a moderate by conviction will not be at home in a more radical environment so, depending how 'moderate' they are, the LibDems beckon or the Tories or whatever.
Anyone who believes that moderation is the best way to tackle such far-right legislation, as is coming before Parliament now, needs to rethink and do so quickly.

Happy to debate this, but not sure to which legislation you refer. Great unemployment numbers by the way.

Not in Scotland though ha ha.


Low oil prices are great for the motorist and inflation - not so good if you work on the supply side.


It's lucky for them that this government is bringing so much investment to the Clyde, that the SNP keep saying they don't want. Otherwise they'd be really f***ed...

 


Optimistic as ever

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Oct 15 4.17pm

Quote ghosteagle at 14 Oct 2015 3.36pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 14 Oct 2015 3.30pm

Corbyn gives the noisy minority something to do for the next 4 years (maybe)
The amount of back peddling and compromises that will occur in the coming months is going to be hugely embarrassing to Labour.

I will predict that they could be the third party come next election.
Britain is moving to the right and Corbyn is a square peg in a round hole.

I would argue that it is too early yet to say which and indeed if the country is making any signifigant moves in terms of politics but that the election of Corbyn alone indicates that there is an appetite within the country for a leftward shift.
I don't see any danger of Labour becoming the third party as the Lib Dems have yet to recover from the disaster (for them) which was the coalition government.
A lot depends on the rise of poverty and inequality within the UK and if Corbyn can harness the associated anger that will come with it. Far too early to tell if his message will spread beyond his core supporters but it will be interesting to see how it plays out.

For you perhaps.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (14 Oct 2015 4.18pm)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 14 Oct 15 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Oct 2015 4.16pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 4.09pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Oct 2015 3.50pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 3.11pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 3.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 14 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 1.21pm

The Labour Party has been significantly re-engineered to put the membership in a controlling position. Labour MPs have to listen to what their local party wants (and most want Corbyn and his principles) or face deselection. They undermine Corbyn-and therefore the will of the membership- at their own risk.
Two thirds of them aren't conviction politicians anyway so it matters little if they toe the new line or bugger off.

PS. He had another great PMQ's today. Clever use of follow-pn qustions. Cameron squirming and Tories trying to laugh JC down on Tax Credit cuts, housing and (sick b******s) on Breast Cancer Rates.

Edited by Red-Blue-Yellow (14 Oct 2015 1.27pm)

So are you saying that any Labour MP who holds moderate views cannot be a 'conviction politician' and is simply a careerist?

No, rather that a moderate by conviction will not be at home in a more radical environment so, depending how 'moderate' they are, the LibDems beckon or the Tories or whatever.
Anyone who believes that moderation is the best way to tackle such far-right legislation, as is coming before Parliament now, needs to rethink and do so quickly.

Happy to debate this, but not sure to which legislation you refer. Great unemployment numbers by the way.

Not in Scotland though ha ha.


Low oil prices are great for the motorist and inflation - not so good if you work on the supply side.


It's lucky for them that this government is bringing so much investment to the Clyde, that the SNP keep saying they don't want. Otherwise they'd be really f***ed...


Probably just as well that they aren't going to France next year.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Oct 15 4.28pm

I know what's caused it.

They've stopped the deposit on glass Irn-Bru bottles, which has been a Scottish career option for decades.

[Link]

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Oct 15 5.57pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Oct 2015 3.50pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 3.11pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 3.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 14 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 1.21pm

The Labour Party has been significantly re-engineered to put the membership in a controlling position. Labour MPs have to listen to what their local party wants (and most want Corbyn and his principles) or face deselection. They undermine Corbyn-and therefore the will of the membership- at their own risk.
Two thirds of them aren't conviction politicians anyway so it matters little if they toe the new line or bugger off.

PS. He had another great PMQ's today. Clever use of follow-pn qustions. Cameron squirming and Tories trying to laugh JC down on Tax Credit cuts, housing and (sick b******s) on Breast Cancer Rates.

Edited by Red-Blue-Yellow (14 Oct 2015 1.27pm)

So are you saying that any Labour MP who holds moderate views cannot be a 'conviction politician' and is simply a careerist?

No, rather that a moderate by conviction will not be at home in a more radical environment so, depending how 'moderate' they are, the LibDems beckon or the Tories or whatever.
Anyone who believes that moderation is the best way to tackle such far-right legislation, as is coming before Parliament now, needs to rethink and do so quickly.

Happy to debate this, but not sure to which legislation you refer. Great unemployment numbers by the way.

Not in Scotland though ha ha.

Why am I not surprised that you think people being unemployed is funny?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Oct 15 6.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Oct 2015 5.57pm

Quote Stuk at 14 Oct 2015 3.50pm

Quote chris123 at 14 Oct 2015 3.11pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 3.04pm

Quote matt_himself at 14 Oct 2015 2.55pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 14 Oct 2015 1.21pm

The Labour Party has been significantly re-engineered to put the membership in a controlling position. Labour MPs have to listen to what their local party wants (and most want Corbyn and his principles) or face deselection. They undermine Corbyn-and therefore the will of the membership- at their own risk.
Two thirds of them aren't conviction politicians anyway so it matters little if they toe the new line or bugger off.

PS. He had another great PMQ's today. Clever use of follow-pn qustions. Cameron squirming and Tories trying to laugh JC down on Tax Credit cuts, housing and (sick b******s) on Breast Cancer Rates.

Edited by Red-Blue-Yellow (14 Oct 2015 1.27pm)

So are you saying that any Labour MP who holds moderate views cannot be a 'conviction politician' and is simply a careerist?

No, rather that a moderate by conviction will not be at home in a more radical environment so, depending how 'moderate' they are, the LibDems beckon or the Tories or whatever.
Anyone who believes that moderation is the best way to tackle such far-right legislation, as is coming before Parliament now, needs to rethink and do so quickly.

Happy to debate this, but not sure to which legislation you refer. Great unemployment numbers by the way.

Not in Scotland though ha ha.

Why am I not surprised that you think people being unemployed is funny?


That isn't the source of my mirth, as you well know.

 


Optimistic as ever

Hoof Hearted 15 Oct 15 10.32am

I believe more Scots now think they dodged a bullet by voting no in the referendum despite the election result which saw SNP take nearly all the seats.

The oil price reduction from £120 a barrel down to less than £50 a barrel would have scuppered SNP's economic plans for independence.

Add to that all the government naval work moving away from the Clyde, Financial Institutions like Standard Life and Scottish Widows moving south and the state of their fishing industry... where would their revenues come from?

I think we have them over a barrel (no pun intended) and should not give into any more SNP demands.

Tell Jimmy Kranky to do one and try to go solo if she wants... they will be the losers if they vote yes, but the canny scots love money and will still vote no!

 

Stuk Flag Top half 15 Oct 15 1.37pm

Made no difference to the vote either way, as predicted.

Labour voted against the Conservatives' Charter for Budget Responsibility, but 21 of their MPs abstained.

It came as shadow chancellor John McDonnell said his decision to reverse Labour's stance was "embarrassing".

 


Optimistic as ever

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 16 Oct 15 12.21am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Oct 2015 9.41am

[Link]

Credibility in tatters and another nail in Corbyn's coffin.

Two weeks ago at conference they confirmed they would vote for Osborne's proposal on the fiscal charter, now they say they won't.

This is boiling up nicely.... senior Labour MP's are furious, the BBC are even saying it's a shambles and the voting public (not the paid up ideological Labour membership)will distance themselves from Labour even further than they did last May.

strip stuff down and the fact is that Gideon said he would wipe out the debt in one parliament. He didn't

He said borrowing would be 37bn in 2015 but it was 87bn

He said public sector debt would be 69% in 2014-14 but its 80%

The press let him get away with it but the truth is he fails time and time again and unless you are rich the economy is still on the floor. He is a good politician but a crap chancellor.

Gideon is a Shakespearean tragedy in the making. The Tories will see Great Britain become Little England and when Gideon, the Daily Mail, the Sun, the Telegraph and Daily Express are long gone, that bit of history and their involvement in it will still be being retold; while the ghost of Huffy marches around the executive flats that Selhurst Park has become, muttering its all to do with mini skirts and Liberal England in the 1960s.


 

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Oct 15 7.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 16 Oct 2015 12.21am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Oct 2015 9.41am

[Link]

Credibility in tatters and another nail in Corbyn's coffin.

Two weeks ago at conference they confirmed they would vote for Osborne's proposal on the fiscal charter, now they say they won't.

This is boiling up nicely.... senior Labour MP's are furious, the BBC are even saying it's a shambles and the voting public (not the paid up ideological Labour membership)will distance themselves from Labour even further than they did last May.

strip stuff down and the fact is that Gideon said he would wipe out the debt in one parliament. He didn't

He said borrowing would be 37bn in 2015 but it was 87bn

He said public sector debt would be 69% in 2014-14 but its 80%

The press let him get away with it but the truth is he fails time and time again and unless you are rich the economy is still on the floor. He is a good politician but a crap chancellor.

Gideon is a Shakespearean tragedy in the making. The Tories will see Great Britain become Little England and when Gideon, the Daily Mail, the Sun, the Telegraph and Daily Express are long gone, that bit of history and their involvement in it will still be being retold; while the ghost of Huffy marches around the executive flats that Selhurst Park has become, muttering its all to do with mini skirts and Liberal England in the 1960s.



Oh yes and just won a general election, lowest borrowing rates - bonds and retail, about the highest minimum wage in Europe, falling unemployment, and even the IMF who were originally against austerity have now changed their minds.

 

Hoof Hearted 16 Oct 15 10.57am

Quote Bert the Head at 16 Oct 2015 12.21am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Oct 2015 9.41am

[Link]

Credibility in tatters and another nail in Corbyn's coffin.

Two weeks ago at conference they confirmed they would vote for Osborne's proposal on the fiscal charter, now they say they won't.

This is boiling up nicely.... senior Labour MP's are furious, the BBC are even saying it's a shambles and the voting public (not the paid up ideological Labour membership)will distance themselves from Labour even further than they did last May.

strip stuff down and the fact is that Gideon said he would wipe out the debt in one parliament. He didn't

He said borrowing would be 37bn in 2015 but it was 87bn

He said public sector debt would be 69% in 2014-14 but its 80%

The press let him get away with it but the truth is he fails time and time again and unless you are rich the economy is still on the floor. He is a good politician but a crap chancellor.

Gideon is a Shakespearean tragedy in the making. The Tories will see Great Britain become Little England and when Gideon, the Daily Mail, the Sun, the Telegraph and Daily Express are long gone, that bit of history and their involvement in it will still be being retold; while the ghost of Huffy marches around the executive flats that Selhurst Park has become, muttering its all to do with mini skirts and Liberal England in the 1960s.



And there he goes again with the Tory Press analogies.

Change the record Bertram..... is there not a music shop in downtown Epsom?

 

Red-Blue-Yellow Flag Surrey 16 Oct 15 12.04pm

Quote chris123 at 16 Oct 2015 7.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 16 Oct 2015 12.21am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Oct 2015 9.41am

[Link]

Credibility in tatters and another nail in Corbyn's coffin.

Two weeks ago at conference they confirmed they would vote for Osborne's proposal on the fiscal charter, now they say they won't.

This is boiling up nicely.... senior Labour MP's are furious, the BBC are even saying it's a shambles and the voting public (not the paid up ideological Labour membership)will distance themselves from Labour even further than they did last May.

strip stuff down and the fact is that Gideon said he would wipe out the debt in one parliament. He didn't

He said borrowing would be 37bn in 2015 but it was 87bn

He said public sector debt would be 69% in 2014-14 but its 80%

The press let him get away with it but the truth is he fails time and time again and unless you are rich the economy is still on the floor. He is a good politician but a crap chancellor.

Gideon is a Shakespearean tragedy in the making. The Tories will see Great Britain become Little England and when Gideon, the Daily Mail, the Sun, the Telegraph and Daily Express are long gone, that bit of history and their involvement in it will still be being retold; while the ghost of Huffy marches around the executive flats that Selhurst Park has become, muttering its all to do with mini skirts and Liberal England in the 1960s.



Oh yes and just won a general election, lowest borrowing rates - bonds and retail, about the highest minimum wage in Europe, falling unemployment, and even the IMF who were originally against austerity have now changed their minds.

Unemployment isn't falling....the number of people on JSA is due to the huge rise in the number of ex-claiments excluded on the flimsiest of resons. It's an unspoken but obvious policy in action. It's also the only way to get the 'jobless' total down - these people no longer exist as far as that stat goes.

 


I also enjoy posting on: Love Everton Forum, the Acceptable Face of Scouse Football.
[Link]
twitter.com/LuvEvertonForum
Come and give it a look, new members would be lovely.
Come and JOIN.
Or they'll nick your telly.

Hoof Hearted 16 Oct 15 12.21pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 16 Oct 2015 12.04pm

Quote chris123 at 16 Oct 2015 7.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 16 Oct 2015 12.21am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Oct 2015 9.41am

[Link]

Credibility in tatters and another nail in Corbyn's coffin.

Two weeks ago at conference they confirmed they would vote for Osborne's proposal on the fiscal charter, now they say they won't.

This is boiling up nicely.... senior Labour MP's are furious, the BBC are even saying it's a shambles and the voting public (not the paid up ideological Labour membership)will distance themselves from Labour even further than they did last May.

strip stuff down and the fact is that Gideon said he would wipe out the debt in one parliament. He didn't

He said borrowing would be 37bn in 2015 but it was 87bn

He said public sector debt would be 69% in 2014-14 but its 80%

The press let him get away with it but the truth is he fails time and time again and unless you are rich the economy is still on the floor. He is a good politician but a crap chancellor.

Gideon is a Shakespearean tragedy in the making. The Tories will see Great Britain become Little England and when Gideon, the Daily Mail, the Sun, the Telegraph and Daily Express are long gone, that bit of history and their involvement in it will still be being retold; while the ghost of Huffy marches around the executive flats that Selhurst Park has become, muttering its all to do with mini skirts and Liberal England in the 1960s.



Oh yes and just won a general election, lowest borrowing rates - bonds and retail, about the highest minimum wage in Europe, falling unemployment, and even the IMF who were originally against austerity have now changed their minds.

Unemployment isn't falling....the number of people on JSA is due to the huge rise in the number of ex-claiments excluded on the flimsiest of resons. It's an unspoken but obvious policy in action. It's also the only way to get the 'jobless' total down - these people no longer exist as far as that stat goes.


I think the rest of us are quite happy to accept the official version of events.

I'm surprised you didn't mention "seasonal adjustments" affecting the figures!

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Oct 15 12.29pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 16 Oct 2015 12.04pm

Quote chris123 at 16 Oct 2015 7.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 16 Oct 2015 12.21am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Oct 2015 9.41am

[Link]

Credibility in tatters and another nail in Corbyn's coffin.

Two weeks ago at conference they confirmed they would vote for Osborne's proposal on the fiscal charter, now they say they won't.

This is boiling up nicely.... senior Labour MP's are furious, the BBC are even saying it's a shambles and the voting public (not the paid up ideological Labour membership)will distance themselves from Labour even further than they did last May.

strip stuff down and the fact is that Gideon said he would wipe out the debt in one parliament. He didn't

He said borrowing would be 37bn in 2015 but it was 87bn

He said public sector debt would be 69% in 2014-14 but its 80%

The press let him get away with it but the truth is he fails time and time again and unless you are rich the economy is still on the floor. He is a good politician but a crap chancellor.

Gideon is a Shakespearean tragedy in the making. The Tories will see Great Britain become Little England and when Gideon, the Daily Mail, the Sun, the Telegraph and Daily Express are long gone, that bit of history and their involvement in it will still be being retold; while the ghost of Huffy marches around the executive flats that Selhurst Park has become, muttering its all to do with mini skirts and Liberal England in the 1960s.



Oh yes and just won a general election, lowest borrowing rates - bonds and retail, about the highest minimum wage in Europe, falling unemployment, and even the IMF who were originally against austerity have now changed their minds.

Unemployment isn't falling....the number of people on JSA is due to the huge rise in the number of ex-claiments excluded on the flimsiest of resons. It's an unspoken but obvious policy in action. It's also the only way to get the 'jobless' total down - these people no longer exist as far as that stat goes.


The numbers come from ONS, which is overseen by the UK Statistics Authority, which is wholly independent of Government - unless you know better of course.

 

Red-Blue-Yellow Flag Surrey 17 Oct 15 8.46pm

Gawd 'elp us......
Falling unemployment is measured by comparing the numbers of people CLAIMING UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS against previous figures. It does not derive from the number of people who found work, although they obviously make up a percentage of that figure.

Iknow of more people who have been excluded from benefits in the past year than have got jobs.

From my friends/acquaintances the figures are:

Got a Job - 2 (and 1 only a 3month contract)
Excluded from benefits - 5, possibly 6 as one was fighting it.

 


I also enjoy posting on: Love Everton Forum, the Acceptable Face of Scouse Football.
[Link]
twitter.com/LuvEvertonForum
Come and give it a look, new members would be lovely.
Come and JOIN.
Or they'll nick your telly.

chris123 Flag hove actually 17 Oct 15 9.59pm

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 17 Oct 2015 8.46pm

Gawd 'elp us......
Falling unemployment is measured by comparing the numbers of people CLAIMING UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS against previous figures. It does not derive from the number of people who found work, although they obviously make up a percentage of that figure.

Iknow of more people who have been excluded from benefits in the past year than have got jobs.

From my friends/acquaintances the figures are:

Got a Job - 2 (and 1 only a 3month contract)
Excluded from benefits - 5, possibly 6 as one was fighting it.

Read this please and digest

[Link]

 

Red-Blue-Yellow Flag Surrey 20 Oct 15 12.03am

Quote chris123 at 17 Oct 2015 9.59pm

Read this please and digest

[Link]


As you might have guessed, I'm a big fan of this government... so much so that I can justifiably ignore all evidence which does not agree with my point of view.

 


I also enjoy posting on: Love Everton Forum, the Acceptable Face of Scouse Football.
[Link]
twitter.com/LuvEvertonForum
Come and give it a look, new members would be lovely.
Come and JOIN.
Or they'll nick your telly.

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labours Economic Policy U Turn !