This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
What better time to discuss the referendum, the crux of which is border control and immigration, than in the aftermath of a horrendous terrorist attack that could have been directly avoided were it not for Europe's complete inability to track those who wish to move across its borders? We have now suffered two atrocities in the space of six months as a direct result of free movement in Europe, not taking into account the multiple other terrorist attacks that occurred last year. The sickening irony is that had the Paris attacker been caught at the time rather than managing to exploit the lack of border control AGAIN by escaping into Belgium, then today's revenge attack for his capture wouldn't have happened. Like it or not, today's attack has a clear bearing on the fact that our country is about to make the biggest choice of a generation and one that will directly influence our capacity to prevent these atrocities occurring here in the future. Yet anybody who dares mention it is called an idiot and accused of exploiting a tragedy. Well, as far as I'm concerned it's the attempt to brush the issue under the carpet that is the real insult to the victims. If you think us not being in Europe and other countries will see their own home-grown loopy terrorists laying down their explosives and arms if free movement is restricted then all I can say is that really is idiotic. No offence. The London bombers came from oop North. That Abdelsam bloke who attacked Paris was a French national. The attacks will still happen. But in different locations than they might have been.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
If you think us not being in Europe and other countries will see their own home-grown loopy terrorists laying down their explosives and arms if free movement is restricted then all I can say is that really is idiotic. No offence. The London bombers came from oop North. That Abdelsam bloke who attacked Paris was a French national. The attacks will still happen. But in different locations than they might have been.
Kermit I'm not peddling a thing, partially because I've seen enough of the tedious political rows on this website to know that nobody ever changes their opinion but primarily because I haven't decided which way I'm voting yet. What I take exception to is the fact that the pro-EU brigade have deemed it acceptable to lambast anybody who dares contextualise the events on a broader scale as heartless, politically-opportunistic monsters. That is what is disingenuous here because frankly I don't believe for a minute that if Cameron could find an angle to argue that the attacks prove we should stay that he wouldn't take it.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
If you think us not being in Europe and other countries will see their own home-grown loopy terrorists laying down their explosives and arms if free movement is restricted then all I can say is that really is idiotic. No offence. The London bombers came from oop North. That Abdelsam bloke who attacked Paris was a French national. The attacks will still happen. But in different locations than they might have been.
Having control over our borders will reduce the threat. Edited by matt_himself (23 Mar 2016 7.42am)
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Mar 16 9.25am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Having control over our borders will reduce the threat. Edited by matt_himself (23 Mar 2016 7.42am) Is the right answer.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Having control over our borders will reduce the threat. Edited by matt_himself (23 Mar 2016 7.42am) Will it? How exactly? People move around from the UK all the time, tourists come and go, and all of them require passports to get into the UK, which are checked and verified by the Borders Agency (the details of which are stored electronically and verified against the warning index). Very few of the incidents and arrests in the UK or the arrests have involved foreign nationals. The idea that we don't control our borders at all is a misnomer - and its people who travelled overseas and returned to places like pakistan, Afghanistan etc who were likely the weak links that led the Security Services to identifying cells. Now I do agree that we should control immigration from the EU more than we do, but no exit from the EU is going to result in a situation where suddenly the UK has more power to prevent people travelling to and from the UK - It will only require people to apply for working visas if they EU citizens - and it certainly won't apply to people coming as tourists, to study etc. A Britexit isn't going to result in some idealised view where only British people live or come to the UK, or that the UK will have more much more power to prevent people coming to the UK, or that you could even ban Muslims from travelling to and from the UK. It'll just return it to a pre-EU Freedom of Movement - which means applying for a working visa. In fact it would only affect 48% of UK migration. You still need travel documents such as passports etc to legally enter the UK.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Will it? How exactly? People move around from the UK all the time, tourists come and go, and all of them require passports to get into the UK, which are checked and verified by the Borders Agency (the details of which are stored electronically and verified against the warning index). Very few of the incidents and arrests in the UK or the arrests have involved foreign nationals. The idea that we don't control our borders at all is a misnomer - and its people who travelled overseas and returned to places like pakistan, Afghanistan etc who were likely the weak links that led the Security Services to identifying cells. Now I do agree that we should control immigration from the EU more than we do, but no exit from the EU is going to result in a situation where suddenly the UK has more power to prevent people travelling to and from the UK - It will only require people to apply for working visas if they EU citizens - and it certainly won't apply to people coming as tourists, to study etc. A Britexit isn't going to result in some idealised view where only British people live or come to the UK, or that the UK will have more much more power to prevent people coming to the UK, or that you could even ban Muslims from travelling to and from the UK. It'll just return it to a pre-EU Freedom of Movement - which means applying for a working visa. In fact it would only affect 48% of UK migration. You still need travel documents such as passports etc to legally enter the UK. A Brexit will give us more power over our borders. We could arbitrarily ban people from certain countries coming to the UK. We could introduce an ESTA type visa system to people from certain countries and we wouldnt be bound by Schengen, so there wouldnt be the automatic transit of people from the EU. I do not agree with your 'it would change' nothing stance on Brexit. Its quite clear you are ideologically wedded to the social engineering project that is the EU. Why don't you just admit rather than pouring out meaningless blurb and 'Jamiefacts'?
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
A Brexit will give us more power over our borders. We could arbitrarily ban people from certain countries coming to the UK. We could introduce an ESTA type visa system to people from certain countries and we wouldnt be bound by Schengen, so there wouldnt be the automatic transit of people from the EU. We do kind of do that anyhow with non-EU countries and immigration regulations (If you're from Somalia, for example, it takes a remarkable effort to legally enter the UK. You'll need a visa, reason, references, proof of funds, an interview etc and often a background check - And that will be before you get on the plane. There will never be a blanket ban on people from country x, there will only ever be reasonable precautions and measures. High risk countries arrivals tend to be stopped at Immigration and customs, unless they have the requisite documentation. Certainly, even if we exit the EU, the UK won't have a ban on European nationals travelling to the UK. There is no way the UK will ever issue something like a ban on say French or Belgium nationals say. We didn't even ban Irish and Northern Irish citizens from travelling to the UK, during the 60s and 70s. Originally posted by matt_himself
I do not agree with your 'it would change' nothing stance on Brexit. Its quite clear you are ideologically wedded to the social engineering project that is the EU. Why don't you just admit rather than pouring out meaningless blurb and 'Jamiefacts'? You mean the EU I'm voting to leave? Yeah I'm very ideologically wedded to its exploitation of the UK and Member states working classes for corporate profit, and its preference for corporate policy over nation and citizen representation. I'm a fan of the ECHR, and always have been, since the European court, because it serves to protect the rights of citizens against nation states. I also like the fact its elected by proportional representation. It has some good, some bad. But the problem with the EU for me, is that it undermined the Working classes, for the benefit of Government and Business interests.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
How's about after Brexit we adopt Australia's immigration policy? Seems to work perfectly to me? Without EU interference, we might be able to tweak it so that it works even better for us. One thing is certain though, if the UK votes to stay, we'll have no chance again to try and control our borders ever again. In truth, having travelled around Europe a lot between 92 and 94, and then recently, not much has changed. You show your passport, go through security to get out. Its harder by plane, than by ferry and I've not been on the Eurostar, so I can't comment. But it all feels the same pretty much. You mean the country with 200 different languages where 25% of the population were born overseas. Mandatory detention only applies to people claiming asylum and refugee status. It doesn't apply to people travelling on legal documentation. I don't really have a problem with the idea of detention of asylum applicants pending their application, provided the accommodations are reasonable and the treatment fair (i.e. they're used to fairly process people - Decent access to solicitors, translators, independent advice family wings, social rather than the reality of turning them into prisons). Thing is, in the UK, asylum applications aren't a real problem.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Mar 16 11.25am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
In truth, having travelled around Europe a lot between 92 and 94, and then recently, not much has changed. You show your passport, go through security to get out. Its harder by plane, than by ferry and I've not been on the Eurostar, so I can't comment. But it all feels the same pretty much. You mean the country with 200 different languages where 25% of the population were born overseas. Mandatory detention only applies to people claiming asylum and refugee status. It doesn't apply to people travelling on legal documentation. I don't really have a problem with the idea of detention of asylum applicants pending their application, provided the accommodations are reasonable and the treatment fair (i.e. they're used to fairly process people - Decent access to solicitors, translators, independent advice family wings, social rather than the reality of turning them into prisons). Thing is, in the UK, asylum applications aren't a real problem. So.... I'm imagining all the problems associated with immigration am I ? Shortage of houses, hospitals, GP's, Schools etc are just a figment of my imagination! Who'd have known? Voting to stay in the EU will be disastrous for everyone except the politicians and big business and it will impact on the rest of society.... and it will get steadily worse as Turkey joins the EU and even more people will flood in to an already over populated island. It's not just about asylum seekers.... they just add to an already growing problem.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Will it? How exactly? People move around from the UK all the time, tourists come and go, and all of them require passports to get into the UK, which are checked and verified by the Borders Agency (the details of which are stored electronically and verified against the warning index). Very few of the incidents and arrests in the UK or the arrests have involved foreign nationals. The idea that we don't control our borders at all is a misnomer - and its people who travelled overseas and returned to places like pakistan, Afghanistan etc who were likely the weak links that led the Security Services to identifying cells. Now I do agree that we should control immigration from the EU more than we do, but no exit from the EU is going to result in a situation where suddenly the UK has more power to prevent people travelling to and from the UK - It will only require people to apply for working visas if they EU citizens - and it certainly won't apply to people coming as tourists, to study etc. A Britexit isn't going to result in some idealised view where only British people live or come to the UK, or that the UK will have more much more power to prevent people coming to the UK, or that you could even ban Muslims from travelling to and from the UK. It'll just return it to a pre-EU Freedom of Movement - which means applying for a working visa. In fact it would only affect 48% of UK migration. You still need travel documents such as passports etc to legally enter the UK. How effective border controls are depends on how draconian they are. A total ban on movement from the middle east and deportation of selected individuals would help a lot. Is it fair or desirable? No, but did we let Germans of Italians or Japanese come here in WW2? We are in a war now so let's act like it if we really want to reduce risk.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Mar 16 11.28am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
How effective border controls are depends on how draconian they are. A total ban on movement from the middle east and deportation of selected individuals would help a lot. Is it fair or desirable? No, but did we let Germans of Italians or Japanese come here in WW2? We are in a war now so let's act like it if we really want to reduce risk. I suggested that in a thread after the Paris massacres last year. Turns out I was "racist" for saying it Hrolf.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
I suggested that in a thread after the Paris massacres last year. Turns out I was "racist" for saying it Hrolf. The fact is that European governments would rather let citizens die than do something that would cost them and their corporate buddies money.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
So.... I'm imagining all the problems associated with immigration am I ? Shortage of houses, hospitals, GP's, Schools etc are just a figment of my imagination! Who'd have known? Voting to stay in the EU will be disastrous for everyone except the politicians and big business and it will impact on the rest of society.... and it will get steadily worse as Turkey joins the EU and even more people will flood in to an already over populated island. It's not just about asylum seekers.... they just add to an already growing problem. No I agree, but this is about security and terrorism. The issues you mention are one of the reasons I'm inclined towards an out vote. EU working migration which amounts to 48% of European Migration. I don't for a minute believe that exiting the EU will significantly prevent people coming to and from the UK who could be involved in terrorism against the UK. I'm not ideologically wedded to staying in the EU or leaving it. Asylum is only a problem really because of the disparity in emigration and migration figures is heavily driven by EU migration. In terms of terrorism, I don't believe that an EU exit will result in any real impact on terrorism - it might even make sharing information with EU countries and Security Services more problematic.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
I suggested that in a thread after the Paris massacres last year. Turns out I was "racist" for saying it Hrolf. It would be financially disastrous for the UK to not do business with the middle east, and problematic in terms of diplomacy, because that involves countries like Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, UAE etc on whom we have a significant resource and financial relationship and dependency. The likely response of such a political move would be to see those countries and their nationals responding in kind, withdrawing investment, provision, oil supply and import trades. Deportation becomes problematic if they've been granted asylum in the past, and most of the problem people are UK nationals or granted asylum from the country that wants them. Internment - Rarely works. WWII the UK interned people that were a high risk or considered a risk - Meanwhile, the US found that German and Italian nationals were quite keen to fight for the US. Internment of the Japanese was a mistake, as it set back the US War Intelligence effort significantly. Certain people, certainly, they're a threat. Provided they given POW status, that seems fair to me, in a war on terror. But its worth noting that Internment in NI actually worked to the benefit of the Republican and Loyalists, as it gave them a safe 'command and communication', as well as bring the IRA and Loyalists. Problem when you intern people, is you're detaining them without trial, in a democracy and you often end up detaining the wrong people (Mosely in WWII would likely have encouraged British Union of Fascists to fight for the allies).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Turns out the suicide bombers who were brothers were born in Brussels and Belgian. As I said earlier this is nothing to do with the EU.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.