You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Dwight Gayle
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dwight Gayle


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Jacey Flag 11 Dec 16 8.11am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

So that's a comparison with 3 players who left the club before we sold Gayle and one proven premier league striker who so far we haven't seen due to injury.

Gayle is a good player at Championship level he was too lightweight for the top flight.

Agreed, although he still managed to be our top scorer for all the seasons he was with us.
Will be very interesting just how many he scores in the Premiership next season with Newcastle under a truly class act as Benitez

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Dec 16 9.20am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

So that's a comparison with 3 players who left the club before we sold Gayle and one proven premier league striker who so far we haven't seen due to injury.

Gayle is a good player at Championship level he was too lightweight for the top flight.

Disagree. 16 goals in a season is a good player at Championship level. 16 goals December 10 is downright phenomenal.

He's prem class...we just haven't had a decent manager to get the best out of him. (Imo of course)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Dec 16 6.56pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

We made our money back and some on a player that did not fit our system.

He didn't fit Newcastle's system either but their manager was clever enough to change their system to play to Gayle's strengths and he seems to be reaping benefits

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 11 Dec 16 7.53pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

He didn't fit Newcastle's system either but their manager was clever enough to change their system to play to Gayle's strengths and he seems to be reaping benefits

It's very easy when you have the best squad in an inferior league. If we had done the same I put money on Gayle banging them in for us. In the Championship. Manager after manager came here and noone could make it work for him and with good reason, unless the squad has the abilities within to change to accomodate 1 player then that player will not fit. Our squad hasn't been and isn't good enough to do that hence we've spent big money on one that does fit.

Edited by Icepick Tony (11 Dec 2016 7.54pm)

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Dec 16 8.10pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

He didn't fit Newcastle's system either but their manager was clever enough to change their system to play to Gayle's strengths and he seems to be reaping benefits

Nail. Head.

But what do we expect? They have Rafa Benitez...we have had Holloway, Warnock, Pulis and Pardew.

 

bodge Flag 11 Dec 16 8.47pm

By the way he dives.

 

Jacey Flag 11 Dec 16 9.17pm

Originally posted by sprites

Nail. Head.

But what do we expect? They have Rafa Benitez...we have had Holloway, Warnock, Pulis and Pardew.

None of our managers could get the best out of Gayle even though he was our top scorer in every season while with us.
His exceptional scoring abilities were noticed by a tactically astute, class manager, Benitez and ignored by our past and current plonker in chief, Pardew,who has achieved very little in 300 Premiership games,up against the sensational record of Rafa.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 11 Dec 16 11.21pm

Originally posted by Jacey

None of our managers could get the best out of Gayle even though he was our top scorer in every season while with us.
His exceptional scoring abilities were noticed by a tactically astute, class manager, Benitez and ignored by our past and current plonker in chief, Pardew,who has achieved very little in 300 Premiership games,up against the sensational record of Rafa.

Not in the league, where it counts, he wasn't.

In the Premier League:

He tied with Jason Puncheon with 7 in 2013-14.

Glenn Murray was our top scorer, followed by Jason Puncheon in 2014-15.

2015-16: Bolasie, Cabaye, Dann, and Wickham all got more league goals.

The argument about Gayle also ignores the fact that we score plenty of goals now. It's at the back where we look frightful.

He did score goals against lower league opposition. He still does, but it will be interesting to see if he can manage it if Newcastle get promoted.


Edited by NickinOX (11 Dec 2016 11.22pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 12 Dec 16 12.16pm

The truth is none of us know what DG would have achieved it he played in the right formation or with the right manager in the PL.

But 4 successive managers did not think him good enough to play in the formations that best suited our team while in this division. And when he did play in that role he was very rarely any form of success.

The simple fact is we didn't have the personnel to be able to control a game with 2 men in midfield. So we couldn't play 442.

I don't think I have ever seen many suggest DG isn't a natural goalscorer or wouldn't be able to score goals. But he simply can't do it as a lone striker.

I'm pleased for him. His record this season is terrific. And he's looking likely to make me some decent money as top scorer (bet at 10-1).

But on the assumption we would have still played 451/433 then can anyone say he should still be at the club? Can anyone imagine him getting in ahead of Big Ben, or even a fit Wickham in that lone striker role?

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 14 Dec 16 9.46am

I don't hate the fact that we sold him.

But let's be far why did we sign Remy? Surely to play alongside Benteke...

Therefore Gayle could have done that job.

That's all.

Oh and this little link [Link]

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 14 Dec 16 10.58am

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

I don't hate the fact that we sold him.

But let's be far why did we sign Remy? Surely to play alongside Benteke...

Therefore Gayle could have done that job.

That's all.

Oh and this little link [Link]

Not really relevant as its in a lower standard of football and i reckon, injuries permitting, Messi will outscore Gayle over the season.

 

Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 14 Dec 16 11.36am

Originally posted by OknotOK

The truth is none of us know what DG would have achieved it he played in the right formation or with the right manager in the PL.

But 4 successive managers did not think him good enough to play in the formations that best suited our team while in this division. And when he did play in that role he was very rarely any form of success.

The simple fact is we didn't have the personnel to be able to control a game with 2 men in midfield. So we couldn't play 442.

I don't think I have ever seen many suggest DG isn't a natural goalscorer or wouldn't be able to score goals. But he simply can't do it as a lone striker.

I'm pleased for him. His record this season is terrific. And he's looking likely to make me some decent money as top scorer (bet at 10-1).

But on the assumption we would have still played 451/433 then can anyone say he should still be at the club? Can anyone imagine him getting in ahead of Big Ben, or even a fit Wickham in that lone striker role?

When we played two up top eg Liverpool game Murray/Gayle IMO we looked great.
This Season when we went Benteke and Wickham up front we improved.
Benteke/Gayle would be superb.
Remember Wright&Bright.

 

Jacey Flag 14 Dec 16 12.22pm

Originally posted by Bill Glazier

When we played two up top eg Liverpool game Murray/Gayle IMO we looked great.
This Season when we went Benteke and Wickham up front we improved.
Benteke/Gayle would be superb.
Remember Wright&Bright.

Wish Gayle would return together with , Benitez.

 

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 14 Dec 16 12.36pm

How nice it would have been to have him up there with Benteke now.Think it will prove to be a major mistake MR. Pardew,,,,

 

Jacey Flag 14 Dec 16 12.53pm

Originally posted by Asian Eagle

How nice it would have been to have him up there with Benteke now.Think it will prove to be a major mistake MR. Pardew,,,,

Agreed, although hindsight is easy.

He was an absolute steal for Newcastle,probably the bargain of the season when you consider goals scored already.
We should have kept him, bearing I mind 20 % of his sale price went back to Peterborough,so not the brilliant piece of business many claim.

 

pssguy Flag 17 Dec 16 8.36pm

Originally posted by Jacey

We should have kept him, bearing I mind 20 % of his sale price went back to Peterborough,so not the brilliant piece of business many claim.

But we needed to sell to buy Townsend

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 16 8.43pm

Originally posted by pssguy

But we needed to sell to buy Townsend

Yes just compare the impact that Gayle and Townsend have had on their new teams this season !

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 16 8.55pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes just compare the impact that Gayle and Townsend have had on their new teams this season !


One against some of th best defenders in the world, the other in the Championship

 

Painter Flag Croydon 19 Dec 16 9.37pm

Originally posted by Jacey

None of our managers could get the best out of Gayle even though he was our top scorer in every season while with us.
His exceptional scoring abilities were noticed by a tactically astute, class manager, Benitez and ignored by our past and current plonker in chief, Pardew,who has achieved very little in 300 Premiership games,up against the sensational record of Rafa.

He was given a number of chances, but not consistent enough and struggled. Shame he was our best finisher, but was never our top scorer in the Premier, most goals came in the cups. It was never in question he would thrive against Championship sides.
Rafa is not that sensational or Liverpool wouldn't of sacked him.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Dec 16 7.46am

Originally posted by Willo

just compare the impact that Gayle and Townsend have had on their new teams this season !

Everyone thought at the time that we had got the better end of the swap by far. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

I wonder if the many people saying that Gayle is only any good in the Championship are the same people constantly clamouring for Murray to come back

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Dwight Gayle