You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Gomez challenge on benteke
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gomez challenge on benteke


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 11.12am

Originally posted by cpfc1976

You are completely wrong. It can still be dangerous play and it was.

Sort of undermines your credibility in assessing Clattenburg if you don't understand the rules.

If the referee doesn't see it though, he can't call it as such. If there was any justice, the FA / PML would penalise Gomes with a caution or ban, because it was reckless and intentional.

But the referee has to see this, from across the pitch, in the midst of play. Its not like he has a good view of this, and nor does the lino or 4th official.

Which is why Football should have replays for decisions when the ball has stopped and a decision made.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 28 Dec 16 11.17am

Originally posted by Inapickle

Thank you sir.

Hahaha... if ever a red card was deserved.... this one was....

It's bad enough that we have to read Trollo's WUM posts, let alone read someone's praising them FFS !

Hats off to the Mods!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 16 11.23am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

If the referee doesn't see it though, he can't call it as such. If there was any justice, the FA / PML would penalise Gomes with a caution or ban, because it was reckless and intentional.

But the referee has to see this, from across the pitch, in the midst of play. Its not like he has a good view of this, and nor does the lino or 4th official.

Which is why Football should have replays for decisions when the ball has stopped and a decision made.

Jamie

I totally agree with these sentiments.

At the end of the day a referee can only give/ not give what he sees from his angle. He doesn't have the benefit of umpteen replays from different angles.

Regarding technology I believe that whilst I understand the clarion calls for it's introduction when one looks into it in depth perhaps the phrase "The devil lies in the detail" is very appropriate.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 28 Dec 16 11.23am

Originally posted by Willo

I've not seen this incident but it might have totally differed from the one against Watford in terms of the keepers challenge.One has to accept that perhaps no two challenges are identical in every shape or form.

No it didn't differ/both the same/identical, what other description would you like; so please stop trying to protect Clattenburg. This ought to have been at least a yellow and as others on here have said if the goalie was an outfield player it would possibly have been a red, his boot caught Benteke on the side of the knee. Do you ever see any wrong in our favourite ref because if you have I have never read it? Even he said that he makes mistakes and Mark this was one of them, do you agree Willo?

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 16 11.31am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

No it didn't differ/both the same/identical, what other description would you like; so please stop trying to protect Clattenburg. This ought to have been at least a yellow and as others on here have said if the goalie was an outfield player it would possibly have been a red, his boot caught Benteke on the side of the knee. Do you ever see any wrong in our favourite ref because if you have I have never read it? Even he said that he makes mistakes and Mark this was one of them, do you agree Willo?

From what I have seen I believe it would have been a mistake to brandish a 'Yellow' as I would say the same even if the referee was someone other than Clattenburg.

All referees make mistakes from time to time but in my book Clattenburg was "Spot-on" in his decision making regards the incident.I would have been really disappointed if our keeper had been given a 'Yellow' in similar circumstances.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 11.54am

Originally posted by Willo

From what I have seen I believe it would have been a mistake to brandish a 'Yellow' as I would say the same even if the referee was someone other than Clattenburg.

All referees make mistakes from time to time but in my book Clattenburg was "Spot-on" in his decision making regards the incident.I would have been really disappointed if our keeper had been given a 'Yellow' in similar circumstances.

If he sees the video, he gives a yellow. Its a deliberate foul by the keeper and a stonewall penalty - and the challenge is in no way aimed at getting the ball - Yellow all day long.

From his position, he can't give that, unless he's sure - its a penalty but the yellow, no I think its probably siding on what he can be sure of.

I think he was wrong on Zaha, but I can also see why he gave it. It certainly wasn't a foul or a penalty, but there was physical contact, and enough to disturb his balance.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 28 Dec 16 12.29pm

Originally posted by Willo

From what I have seen I believe it would have been a mistake to brandish a 'Yellow' as I would say the same even if the referee was someone other than Clattenburg.

All referees make mistakes from time to time but in my book Clattenburg was "Spot-on" in his decision making regards the incident.I would have been really disappointed if our keeper had been given a 'Yellow' in similar circumstances.

youd have been disappointed then, as , if it were Hennessey making that foul, he would have got a RED all day long, we know it and you know it !

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 12.32pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

If the referee doesn't see it though, he can't call it as such. If there was any justice, the FA / PML would penalise Gomes with a caution or ban, because it was reckless and intentional.

But the referee has to see this, from across the pitch, in the midst of play. Its not like he has a good view of this, and nor does the lino or 4th official.

Which is why Football should have replays for decisions when the ball has stopped and a decision made.

Absolutely - if he doesn't see of course he can't give it. I was responding to that 'pickle troll who said it's not dangerous play if it is unintentional.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 12.35pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

Absolutely - if he doesn't see of course he can't give it. I was responding to that 'pickle troll who said it's not dangerous play if it is unintentional.

A odd concept given its impossible to determine whether something is intentional or not. There is clearly unintentional, like ball to hand etc. Dangerous play is not reckless play, it doesn't matter intent, if its a two footed lunge, its an automatic red, even if it doesn't connect.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 28 Dec 16 12.39pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

A odd concept given its impossible to determine whether something is intentional or not. There is clearly unintentional, like ball to hand etc. Dangerous play is not reckless play, it doesn't matter intent, if its a two footed lunge, its an automatic red, even if it doesn't connect.

Unless your name is already Red (Rojo)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

chateauferret Flag 28 Dec 16 12.43pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Unless your name is already Red (Rojo)

Or unless your shirt is red (Manchester United).

 


============
The Ferret
============

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 28 Dec 16 1.48pm

I,ve just watched the Benteke foul on i-player about six times and if anybody thinks Gomez was going for the ball is either deluded or needs new glasses. The ball was on the deck and Benteke was kicked just below the knee.

No yellow card at the very least was a joke and shows Clattenf*** will never give Palace anything, ever.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 28 Dec 16 1.54pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

I,ve just watched the Benteke foul on i-player about six times and if anybody thinks Gomez was going for the ball is either deluded or needs new glasses. The ball was on the deck and Benteke was kicked just below the knee.

No yellow card at the very least was a joke and shows Clattenf*** will never give Palace anything, ever.


Apart from a penalty of course and he was very lenient in not giving one against us for the first Delaney foul, which was worse than the second one.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 28 Dec 16 2.25pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

A odd concept given its impossible to determine whether something is intentional or not. There is clearly unintentional, like ball to hand etc. Dangerous play is not reckless play, it doesn't matter intent, if its a two footed lunge, its an automatic red, even if it doesn't connect.

Yes, that was my point in my response to him, but thankfully he's been banned now and probably understood all too well but was just trolling.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 28 Dec 16 2.59pm

Originally posted by Willo

I can assure you this is NOT the case.Just giving my honest opinion.

At the end of the day when Mark's performance is analysed as part of a 'Forensic' analysis, which is normal, they might decide that a card should have been awarded, all I am doing is giving my opinion based on what I have seen.

ok lets assume that the "forensic analysis" says a card should have been awarded.....what happens to "mark" and how indeed does that help us....
Will mark be suspended, dropped a division or just patted on the back and told "well done son, youve f***ed them over again, keep up the good work???

 

chateauferret Flag 28 Dec 16 4.14pm

Originally posted by the silurian

ok lets assume that the "forensic analysis" says a card should have been awarded.....what happens to "mark" and how indeed does that help us....
Will mark be suspended, dropped a division or just patted on the back and told "well done son, youve f***ed them over again, keep up the good work???

If "Mark"'s performance were ever really subjected to forensic analysis by someone impartial with powers and accountability for ensuring fair play his feet wouldn't touch the floor.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Dec 16 5.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

I've not seen this incident but it might have totally differed from the one against Watford in terms of the keepers challenge.One has to accept that perhaps no two challenges are identical in every shape or form.

Your darling Mark f***** up again

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 16 5.36pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Your darling Mark f***** up again

No that was Benteke with that "Back pass" of a penalty.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 28 Dec 16 5.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

No that was Benteke with that "Back pass" of a penalty.

Still not answering my question I see! Why would that be?

 

bicycle repair man 28 Dec 16 5.45pm

If any other player on any other part of the pitch had hacked at someone like Gomez did they would have been booked,the fact that he wasn't defies all credibility on the referee's part.

 

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Gomez challenge on benteke