You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Puncheon


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Feb 17 10.18pm

Originally posted by mattteo



That's so bull****
Leicester, Arsenal and Tottenham have only had less goals scored than 4th place Man City. But they've had more goals scored than the other 16 participants, that's why they finished higher.

This is what happens in every league, around the world, ALWAYS.

Yes, a good attack isn't all there is, this isn't rocket science and you can still get relegated with 50 goals, like Stuttgart did. But if you score more you have a higher percentage chance of finishing in a better position. Especially since the introduction of the 3 points per win rule. The rest are exceptions

But they all conceded less than City too.

The season before Chelsea weren't top scorers but had the best defence & won the league.

The season before that saw 2 of the top 3 with best defence as well as goals scored.

The same the season before that.

So, not so b******* after all.

To use an Allardyceism, if you don't concede you only need 1 goal to win a game. I seem to recall Arsenal underlining this several years ago.


 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Mstrobez Flag 05 Feb 17 10.23pm

Originally posted by mattteo


FOR MY KNOWLEDGE WHAT??? HOW IS ANY OF WHAT YOU WROTE THERE SUPPOSED TO CONTRADICT WHAT I SAID OR IMPROVE MY KNOWLEDGE?

WHY ARE YOU BEING A JACKASS AND TELLING ME THAT I DON'T SUPPORT THIS TEAM?

IT DISPROVES YOUR POINT BECAUSE FOR THE MAJORITY OF THERE CAREER THEY PLAYED IN CENTRAL MIDFIELD NOT ON THE WING LIKE PUNCHEON.

Are you really trying to continue this comparison between Pirlo and Puncheon, saying that what this desperate team right now needs is for Puncheon to play as the holding mid.

Hahaha. I'll give it to you, you are one colossal bell end.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Feb 17 10.23pm

Originally posted by mattteo

That is so incorrect. WBA have A LOT of shots each game. Mainly because they're masters of counter attack

Really? According to the official EPL stats they've had 5 more than Hull, 4 more than Burnley & 43 less than us.

Go figure...

Edit: To save you the effort, it's here: [Link]

Edited by Nobbybm (05 Feb 2017 10.26pm)

Edited by Nobbybm (05 Feb 2017 10.27pm)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Mstrobez Flag 05 Feb 17 10.27pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

So were Thierry Henry & David Trezeguet but if you think you can compare them to Punch then you are deluded.

You do actually understand that Football Manager is not 'real' don't you?

Quoting stats does not prove knowledge of the game, just knowledge of the numbers. Take yesterday's Hull V Liverpool: the scousers had:

72% possession
22 shots v 7
15 corners v 1

but, guess what, they lost 2-0.

PS: no need to SHOUT we can read in lower case too.

He really doesnt understand that point mate, I've been trying to tell him this since he listed his 48 million transfer targets a few weeks ago. Dunno who this guy thinks he is

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Mstrobez Flag 05 Feb 17 10.34pm

Originally posted by mattteo

The idea is that when Pirlo got slow and couldn't run anymore as a winger, he became a central midfielder.
Not that Puncheon is as good as him. Proportions must be kept, we're talking about Juventus and Palace here. But Benteke is still the type of Mandzukic striker and Mandanda is still a goalkeeper like Buffon.

The point is that Pirlo played first man in front of the defence when Juventus won their first title under Conte. 3 at the back: Bonucci, Barzagli, Chiellini. Pirlo in front of the defence, with Vidal and Pogba as box-to-box. 2 strikers: Tevez and Morata.

In Allegri's first season, they even ditched Barzagli and played Marchisio as a third box-to-box midfielder and still won the league by a great margin.
Now, they go between 3-5-2 and 4-4-2. But they still have a playmaker in front of the defence: Pjanic.

And many low level teams have one too, to distribute the balls: Huddlestone for Hull, Shelvey for Newcastle, Charlie Adam for Stoke, Wilshire plays there many times, Jurado for Espanyol, Huszti for Eintracht.....

All of those players were a lot faster when younger, but got slower and more intelligent with the passage of time. I don't see why Puncheon can't play like this as long as he has Cabaye and McArthur to sweep in front of him. Do you think Milivojevic is that much different from Puncheon? Good technique, slow feet. This is exactly what you'll get from him

No he f***ing didn't you clueless clueless person, he was a central midfielder at his peak and then played more holding as he aged as many many central midfielders do. If he played his youth as a winger whatever no one gives a f***, your talking complete and utter horse s***.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

buzzby Flag West Sussex 05 Feb 17 11.53pm

He goes missing.
Cant Tackle and has no vision.

The only place that he could play is out wide on the left

 


rub a dub dub who's buying the next round in the Pub?

mattteo Flag 06 Feb 17 10.02am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

Really? According to the official EPL stats they've had 5 more than Hull, 4 more than Burnley & 43 less than us.

Go figure...

Edit: To save you the effort, it's here: [Link]

Edited by Nobbybm (05 Feb 2017 10.26pm)

Edited by Nobbybm (05 Feb 2017 10.27pm)

Well, kuddos to you for pointing that out to me. It's the first time someone has really brought up arguments and I have to admit I was wrong about WBA.
I was basing my estimation on what I've seen lately:

[Link]

[Link]


[Link]


But, following your line of thought and the link you provided, you HAVE TO notice a correlation between the shots created by each team and their position in the league.
With 3 exceptions: WBA being higher than normally, Southampton and Crystal Palace (sadly) being lower, all the other 17 teams are pretty much right where they should be. Chelsea has the highest number of shots ON TARGET. About West Ham it's tricky. They have shots, but very few shots on target.

Of course defensive statistics are very important too. But I stick to my analysis that offensive stats count for more.
Just click on the clean sheets button on the bottom of the page and you'll notice that it correlates less with the position of the teams. Southampton is in Champions League position, Bournemouth and Middlesbrough are in Europa League spots, Watford is in the relegation are although they are pretty much SAFE.
All that is because a clean sheet and a 0-0 result only brings you 1 point, instead of 3. 10 clean sheets with 2 wins and 8 draws get you 14 points. No clean sheets but 5 wins and 5 losses get you 15 points. And an entire league lasts even longer than that.

TLDR: You were right about WBA. They aren't that good on the counter attack as I said. Still, they are an EXCEPTION. The best thing to do is to CREATE in every game. If you have 15+ shots and 7+ shots on target each game, you will probably reach your goal, even though there will be matches in which you will lose.

One guy said on the previous page that Liverpool still lost at Hull. Yes, but it was 1 match. You can't control luck, extraordinary saves, a penalty, suspensions once in a while. But OVERALL, controlling matches is the goal. At the end of the season, Liverpool will be in a much better position than Hull.

For Palace to be in better position than Sunderland, Middlesbrough and Burnley, the team needs to create much more than them.
Of course, closing in spaces in defence and not neglecting it.

Edited by mattteo (06 Feb 2017 10.04am)

 

mattteo Flag 06 Feb 17 10.29am

Originally posted by Mstrobez


Are you really trying to continue this comparison between Pirlo and Puncheon, saying that what this desperate team right now needs is for Puncheon to play as the holding mid.

There really are only 3 players in the Palace team that can distribute the balls in front of the defence: Puncheon, Cabaye and, now, Milivojevic (from what I've seen he's a smooth passer and has technique, but lacks stamina).
Honestly, I don't think it's possible to play without a coordinator/playmaker in the Premier League anymore:

Tottenham: Dembele
Liverpool: Wijnaldum and Lallana (4-3-3 system)
Arsenal: Cazorla or Ramsey
Man Utd: A. Herrera
Man City: Toure and D. Silva/Gundogan (4-3-3 system)
Everton: Barry (?remember he was once like Puncheon?)
Southampton: Hojberg and even Clasie/Romeu are they are schooled in the Netherlands and Spain, where passing is key
Leicester: Drinkwater
West Ham: Noble
Stoke: Charlie Adam
Bournemouth: Wilshire or Arter
Middlesbrough: Marten de Roon and Forshaw (4-3-3 system)
Hull: Huddlestone
Swansea: Ki Sung Yeong


Sure, WBA play with Darren Fletcher and Yacob there, but again....they're an anomaly, an exception relying on high balls and free kicks converted by their tall players.
How would you have Palace play if you don't use one of Cabaye/ Puncheon/ Milivoljevic in front of the defence? Oh, with long balls on Benteke and then hopefully something coming out of that. Yeah, great tactic. Modern football!!


The team has already played the trio of McArthur, Cabaye and Puncheon in the middle. But THE ENTIRE POINT of what I've been trying to say is that their triangular distribution with Puncheon behind the striker is wrong. He should be in front of the defence distributing balls. The other 2, who can run faster should be box-to-box. At least that's how I've seen modern football change it. You can't play behind the striker if you don't have pace, if you're not a Michael Owen type of player. And Puncheon can't play there anymore. He can't appear fast enough in the opposing box to finish and he can't track back fast enough to close spaces.
But...in front of the defence it's not about pace but about smart movement and covering spaces. That's why I gave the examples of Pirlo, Motta or Kroos, not because Puncheon is in any wat as good as them. They're just well known. I could have just said Gareth Barry or Carrick. Look at those 2. Hardly any pace, but they never reach the box of the other team, they always maintain position. And, if they aren't protected by the other midfielders in front of them and are caught alone, they make a fault.


So, yeah, I'm dead serious when I say that Puncheon is one of the few options Palace as as holding mf. There are only 3. If you can tell me anyone else who can get the ball out of our defence and create attacks, please do. I really doubt that McArthur or Flamini can do that. The ball will bite them!

Sure, Punch is good on the wing too, as he has that natural left foot. Baut there are plenty left footed wingers already (Townsend, Schlupp, Sako), so I'd rather see him as playmaker.
Many will say that his place is on the bench ) Yes, but it is there because he wasn't used right. Cabaye is capable of playing box-to-box, he's not

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Feb 17 2.16pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Well, kuddos to you for pointing that out to me. It's the first time someone has really brought up arguments and I have to admit I was wrong about WBA.
I was basing my estimation on what I've seen lately:

[Link]

[Link]


[Link]


But, following your line of thought and the link you provided, you HAVE TO notice a correlation between the shots created by each team and their position in the league.
With 3 exceptions: WBA being higher than normally, Southampton and Crystal Palace (sadly) being lower, all the other 17 teams are pretty much right where they should be. Chelsea has the highest number of shots ON TARGET. About West Ham it's tricky. They have shots, but very few shots on target.

Of course defensive statistics are very important too. But I stick to my analysis that offensive stats count for more.
Just click on the clean sheets button on the bottom of the page and you'll notice that it correlates less with the position of the teams. Southampton is in Champions League position, Bournemouth and Middlesbrough are in Europa League spots, Watford is in the relegation are although they are pretty much SAFE.
All that is because a clean sheet and a 0-0 result only brings you 1 point, instead of 3. 10 clean sheets with 2 wins and 8 draws get you 14 points. No clean sheets but 5 wins and 5 losses get you 15 points. And an entire league lasts even longer than that.

TLDR: You were right about WBA. They aren't that good on the counter attack as I said. Still, they are an EXCEPTION. The best thing to do is to CREATE in every game. If you have 15+ shots and 7+ shots on target each game, you will probably reach your goal, even though there will be matches in which you will lose.

One guy said on the previous page that Liverpool still lost at Hull. Yes, but it was 1 match. You can't control luck, extraordinary saves, a penalty, suspensions once in a while. But OVERALL, controlling matches is the goal. At the end of the season, Liverpool will be in a much better position than Hull.

For Palace to be in better position than Sunderland, Middlesbrough and Burnley, the team needs to create much more than them.
Of course, closing in spaces in defence and not neglecting it.

Edited by mattteo (06 Feb 2017 10.04am)

The 'Goals Conceded' link shows a closer correlation to the actual league table though.

If you look at the stats for games such as Everton v Man City or Burnley v Liverpool or even West Ham v Palace - all of those games, like many others in recent years, have 1 thing in common, the winning team had the same number of shots on targets as goals scored. Clearly that shows you don't need loads of chances but you need to make them clear ones & be clinical with them.

It's why world class 'keepers are valued at the same level as strikers these days.

Your final comment makes me think that maybe you are actually Alan Pardew

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

mattteo Flag 06 Feb 17 2.20pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm


Your final comment makes me think that maybe you are actually Alan Pardew

He's overrated as an offensive manager. He's a schmuck who was playing Ward and Kelly as fullbacks and even as left backs. He didn't like offensive football. He just got lucky cause Zaha scored some goals and created some more and everybody hailed Pardew as "offensive".
But no, I'm not him and I don't really like him

 

Mstrobez Flag 06 Feb 17 4.57pm

Originally posted by mattteo

There really are only 3 players in the Palace team that can distribute the balls in front of the defence: Puncheon, Cabaye and, now, Milivojevic (from what I've seen he's a smooth passer and has technique, but lacks stamina).
Honestly, I don't think it's possible to play without a coordinator/playmaker in the Premier League anymore:

Tottenham: Dembele
Liverpool: Wijnaldum and Lallana (4-3-3 system)
Arsenal: Cazorla or Ramsey
Man Utd: A. Herrera
Man City: Toure and D. Silva/Gundogan (4-3-3 system)
Everton: Barry (?remember he was once like Puncheon?)
Southampton: Hojberg and even Clasie/Romeu are they are schooled in the Netherlands and Spain, where passing is key
Leicester: Drinkwater
West Ham: Noble
Stoke: Charlie Adam
Bournemouth: Wilshire or Arter
Middlesbrough: Marten de Roon and Forshaw (4-3-3 system)
Hull: Huddlestone
Swansea: Ki Sung Yeong


Sure, WBA play with Darren Fletcher and Yacob there, but again....they're an anomaly, an exception relying on high balls and free kicks converted by their tall players.
How would you have Palace play if you don't use one of Cabaye/ Puncheon/ Milivoljevic in front of the defence? Oh, with long balls on Benteke and then hopefully something coming out of that. Yeah, great tactic. Modern football!!


The team has already played the trio of McArthur, Cabaye and Puncheon in the middle. But THE ENTIRE POINT of what I've been trying to say is that their triangular distribution with Puncheon behind the striker is wrong. He should be in front of the defence distributing balls. The other 2, who can run faster should be box-to-box. At least that's how I've seen modern football change it. You can't play behind the striker if you don't have pace, if you're not a Michael Owen type of player. And Puncheon can't play there anymore. He can't appear fast enough in the opposing box to finish and he can't track back fast enough to close spaces.
But...in front of the defence it's not about pace but about smart movement and covering spaces. That's why I gave the examples of Pirlo, Motta or Kroos, not because Puncheon is in any wat as good as them. They're just well known. I could have just said Gareth Barry or Carrick. Look at those 2. Hardly any pace, but they never reach the box of the other team, they always maintain position. And, if they aren't protected by the other midfielders in front of them and are caught alone, they make a fault.


So, yeah, I'm dead serious when I say that Puncheon is one of the few options Palace as as holding mf. There are only 3. If you can tell me anyone else who can get the ball out of our defence and create attacks, please do. I really doubt that McArthur or Flamini can do that. The ball will bite them!

Sure, Punch is good on the wing too, as he has that natural left foot. Baut there are plenty left footed wingers already (Townsend, Schlupp, Sako), so I'd rather see him as playmaker.
Many will say that his place is on the bench ) Yes, but it is there because he wasn't used right. Cabaye is capable of playing box-to-box, he's not

I literally give up in responding to your nonsense. You THINK your intelligent and have outstanding insight but the reality is very very different mate. Some of the stuff you come out with is utter delusion.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

mattteo Flag 06 Feb 17 5.00pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I literally give up in responding to your nonsense. You THINK your intelligent and have outstanding insight but the reality is very very different mate. Some of the stuff you come out with is utter delusion.

If you tell me your age then I'll agree with anything you want. But, please, be honest. I' m not asking this to make fun or disrespect you, but you underlined a passage about Gereth Barry being like Puncheon and called me deluded.

I really thin you're too young to have seen the days Barry was playing as WINGER

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 06 Feb 17 5.31pm

Originally posted by mattteo

If you tell me your age then I'll agree with anything you want. But, please, be honest. I' m not asking this to make fun or disrespect you, but you underlined a passage about Gereth Barry being like Puncheon and called me deluded.

I really thin you're too young to have seen the days Barry was playing as WINGER


Barry was not really a winger but a left back and the only thing Punch has in common with Barry is both born in England.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 06 Feb 17 5.48pm

Originally posted by mattteo

If you tell me your age then I'll agree with anything you want. But, please, be honest. I' m not asking this to make fun or disrespect you, but you underlined a passage about Gereth Barry being like Puncheon and called me deluded.

I really thin you're too young to have seen the days Barry was playing as WINGER

Barry was never a winger, he played in the back 4 to begin with before moving into midfield. He played on the left for a while but not as a winger before settling at a CM/DM. Very different to Puncheon. Barry has always been a defensive player where as Puncheon has always been the opposite. Either way your idea of Puncheon, his role, ability and ideas of comparing him to deep lying midfielders is way off the mark.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 06 Feb 17 6.01pm

All Puncheon is able to do is this ridiculous 360 degrees pirouette and pass it backwards. He can't tackle and slows every attack down to walking pace. I am afraid JP is not the answer. As for Gareth Barry he was a left back for most of his early career and could never be classed as a left winger.

Edited by Bexley Eagle (06 Feb 2017 6.02pm)

 

OldFella Flag London 06 Feb 17 6.30pm

Originally posted by mattteo

There really are only 3 players in the Palace team that can distribute the balls in front of the defence: Puncheon, Cabaye and, now, Milivojevic (from what I've seen he's a smooth passer and has technique, but lacks stamina).
Honestly, I don't think it's possible to play without a coordinator/playmaker in the Premier League anymore:

Tottenham: Dembele
Liverpool: Wijnaldum and Lallana (4-3-3 system)
Arsenal: Cazorla or Ramsey
Man Utd: A. Herrera
Man City: Toure and D. Silva/Gundogan (4-3-3 system)
Everton: Barry (?remember he was once like Puncheon?)
Southampton: Hojberg and even Clasie/Romeu are they are schooled in the Netherlands and Spain, where passing is key
Leicester: Drinkwater
West Ham: Noble
Stoke: Charlie Adam
Bournemouth: Wilshire or Arter
Middlesbrough: Marten de Roon and Forshaw (4-3-3 system)
Hull: Huddlestone
Swansea: Ki Sung Yeong


Sure, WBA play with Darren Fletcher and Yacob there, but again....they're an anomaly, an exception relying on high balls and free kicks converted by their tall players.
How would you have Palace play if you don't use one of Cabaye/ Puncheon/ Milivoljevic in front of the defence? Oh, with long balls on Benteke and then hopefully something coming out of that. Yeah, great tactic. Modern football!!


The team has already played the trio of McArthur, Cabaye and Puncheon in the middle. But THE ENTIRE POINT of what I've been trying to say is that their triangular distribution with Puncheon behind the striker is wrong. He should be in front of the defence distributing balls. The other 2, who can run faster should be box-to-box. At least that's how I've seen modern football change it. You can't play behind the striker if you don't have pace, if you're not a Michael Owen type of player. And Puncheon can't play there anymore. He can't appear fast enough in the opposing box to finish and he can't track back fast enough to close spaces.
But...in front of the defence it's not about pace but about smart movement and covering spaces. That's why I gave the examples of Pirlo, Motta or Kroos, not because Puncheon is in any wat as good as them. They're just well known. I could have just said Gareth Barry or Carrick. Look at those 2. Hardly any pace, but they never reach the box of the other team, they always maintain position. And, if they aren't protected by the other midfielders in front of them and are caught alone, they make a fault.


So, yeah, I'm dead serious when I say that Puncheon is one of the few options Palace as as holding mf. There are only 3. If you can tell me anyone else who can get the ball out of our defence and create attacks, please do. I really doubt that McArthur or Flamini can do that. The ball will bite them!

Sure, Punch is good on the wing too, as he has that natural left foot. Baut there are plenty left footed wingers already (Townsend, Schlupp, Sako), so I'd rather see him as playmaker.
Many will say that his place is on the bench ) Yes, but it is there because he wasn't used right. Cabaye is capable of playing box-to-box, he's not

That's a minute of my life I'll never get back.
Serious zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz alert...

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Mstrobez Flag 06 Feb 17 6.56pm

Originally posted by mattteo

If you tell me your age then I'll agree with anything you want. But, please, be honest. I' m not asking this to make fun or disrespect you, but you underlined a passage about Gereth Barry being like Puncheon and called me deluded.

I really thin you're too young to have seen the days Barry was playing as WINGER

Gareth Barry and Jason Puncheon are not even remotely similair players, you're deluded.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Mstrobez Flag 06 Feb 17 6.59pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Barry was never a winger, he played in the back 4 to begin with before moving into midfield. He played on the left for a while but not as a winger before settling at a CM/DM. Very different to Puncheon. Barry has always been a defensive player where as Puncheon has always been the opposite. Either way your idea of Puncheon, his role, ability and ideas of comparing him to deep lying midfielders is way off the mark.

Is the point, just like pretty much every other theory you've come out with since joining the Hol.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 06 Feb 17 7.03pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Is the point, just like pretty much every other theory you've come out with since joining the Hol.

Hang on he's just writing another 1000 word essay...

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 06 Feb 17 7.56pm

This is now officially a 'mattteo thread'

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon