You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cultural Attacks against Masculinity
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cultural Attacks against Masculinity


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Stirlingsays Flag 05 May 17 11.15am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Shouldn't this thread be in Bender Talk?

No, but you are welcome to comment all the same.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 May 17 11.17am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's a good post but I feel your last paragraph does kind of still deny how strongly biology determines reality for many people.

'We' don't need to do anything, 'individuals' are perfectly able to identify themselves as psychologically whatever they like along the males and female scale. Just as long as they don't impose that onto how others should think or feel.....Unfortunately a lot of that feeds through.

I suppose we differ upon seeing the affect of feminism as being for the social good. Don't get me wrong, I and many others regard some of the early cultural and legal changes as being positive....They enabled more choices for women....that corrected an obvious unfairness.

However many women today don't regard the ideas of modern feminism as positive either. Many notice how it devalues and demonises masculinity.

I think some feminism is beneficial, not all - Specifically that based in academic feminist theory. I don't think that by default that every declaration made by feminists is true, or reliable, just as every statement made in defence of masculinity is reliable or true.

The problem is that there is an industry that has sprung up around popularist nonsense, that is more opinion and wishful thinking than research orientated - And that this has especially informed the third wave feminism and new wave of feminism where the idea of female empowerment is about 'women first', rather than addressing the imbalance of social power.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 05 May 17 11.30am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think some feminism is beneficial, not all - Specifically that based in academic feminist theory. I don't think that by default that every declaration made by feminists is true, or reliable, just as every statement made in defence of masculinity is reliable or true.

The problem is that there is an industry that has sprung up around popularist nonsense, that is more opinion and wishful thinking than research orientated - And that this has especially informed the third wave feminism and new wave of feminism where the idea of female empowerment is about 'women first', rather than addressing the imbalance of social power.

I wouldn't disagree and I agree that feminism that enables practical fair choices for women is generally a positive outcome. I think a lot of the worthwhile early battles were won.

It's an interesting discussion but I'm wary of going beyond my remit of arguing against the ill treatment of masculinity and how it is characterized in our modern culture.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 May 17 11.37am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Shouldn't this thread be in Bender Talk?

That shouldn't that be 'pomosexual discourse'

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

DanH Flag SW2 05 May 17 11.39am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I really couldn't be any clearer.

I said your comments so far come across to me as anti masculinity and were a part of the problems with attitudes that the article refers to.

Medical science does seek to subvert nature that's correct. But in the vast number of cases it does it with the willing consent of the people concerned. It isn't telling people that masculinity is wrong.

Your suggestion that men, 'pretend' to live up to an image is quite annoying yes. It is no doubt true for some but not for others but do you suggest this about women with femininity? I doubt it. I think the word, 'pretend' just doesn't get it.

How men perceive their masculinity is no less valid than any other perception. The idea that it needs to be corrected or altered to fit some other perception is nothing but hubris.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 May 2017 10.03am)

I think you're missing my point somewhat. I clearly said masculinity is fine; it's a natural trait in the majority of men.

What isn't fine is the societal construct that anything other than being a red blooded male who likes tits, beer and beating geezers up is not OK.

Earlier on in the thread I said the best advice anyone can be given is to be yourself. That doesn't matter whether you're a turbo lad or like dressing up in a tutu on a Friday night and pirouetting around your living room (really sorry to keep bringing you up in this thready dannyh).


Edited by DanH (05 May 2017 11.39am)

Only I could make a typo on a discussion about masculinity to make me sound really camp.

Edited by DanH (05 May 2017 11.45am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 May 17 3.19pm

Originally posted by DanH

I think you're missing my point somewhat. I clearly said masculinity is fine; it's a natural trait in the majority of men.

I must of missed that bit...fair enough.

Originally posted by DanH

What isn't fine is the societal construct that anything other than being a red blooded male who likes tits, beer and beating geezers up is not OK.

I'm not that sure that we have ever really had that culture as mainstream 'you need to behave like this' anyway. Maybe it's more of a thing in Australia for example but I'm pretty sure that diversity in behaviour amongst males has always been accepted.

Originally posted by DanH

Earlier on in the thread I said the best advice anyone can be given is to be yourself. That doesn't matter whether you're a turbo lad or like dressing up in a tutu on a Friday night and pirouetting around your living room (really sorry to keep bringing you up in this thready dannyh).

I think what you are stating is that you don't like any social pressures on how you 'should' behave as a male. I get that....What I'm complaining about is the culture we are living in now actually puts a lot of pressure upon males...especially young boys at school....to regard masculinity as something negative. It's not stated plainly but the messaging is definitely there. Girls and femininity are emboldened within our culture using images that are far rarer in society...look at the 'strong' women image used in films now...Men calling themselves 'feminists'...What it is to be a male is often mocked and signaled as a negative. All the advantages that women have are downplayed yet any disadvantages are sung from the rooftops....Yet with men...It's the opposite.

The messages from the mainstream culture aren't balanced and the agenda is quite obvious.

Edited by DanH (05 May 2017 11.39am)

Only I could make a typo on a discussion about masculinity to make me sound really camp.

Edited by DanH (05 May 2017 11.45am)

Tis fine....Not once did you type, 'shut that door'.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 17 May 17 4.11pm

More evidence of how women are treated differently to men for the same crime.

[Link]

The usual suspects the BBC don't even mention the glaring injustice of it.

I view this as a part of the discrimination against masculinity.

I wouldn't really mind so much myself but the sheer hypocrisy of it when seen against the equality movement just winds me up.

Just seen that this is the subject of another thread so I'll have a look at that.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 May 2017 4.13pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

HeathMan Flag Purley 17 May 17 6.04pm

A very stimulating set of posts - thank you.

 

johnno42000 Flag 18 May 17 1.20pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

More evidence of how women are treated differently to men for the same crime.

[Link]

The usual suspects the BBC don't even mention the glaring injustice of it.

I view this as a part of the discrimination against masculinity.

I wouldn't really mind so much myself but the sheer hypocrisy of it when seen against the equality movement just winds me up.

Just seen that this is the subject of another thread so I'll have a look at that.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 May 2017 4.13pm)

I know I haven't always seen eye to eye with your views in the past but you are spot on regarding this issue.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

VeganPower Flag Chesham 18 May 17 1.27pm

I am a feminist, and will continue to be so until 50% of Government, big business and media jobs are held by women.

Equality is important for a healthy society, I am a feminist because I love and respect my mum, my wife and my two daughters.

 


22 years eating a vegan diet. Perfectly happy and healthy on it.

johnno42000 Flag 18 May 17 2.59pm

Originally posted by VeganPower

I am a feminist, and will continue to be so until 50% of Government, big business and media jobs are held by women.

Equality is important for a healthy society, I am a feminist because I love and respect my mum, my wife and my two daughters.

Right on, sister

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Kiwi 20 May 17 6.29am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Suicide isn't a biologically male thing

It might be. For example it could be related to testosterone? It could also be related to other things.

Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its clearly not biologically defined either, as disparity between male and female suicide rates change over time, quite dramatically, having nearly doubled since records were started in 1981.

Could not both biological and social factors play a part? Could the social factors themselves not be influenced by biology?

Originally posted by jamiemartin721
if it was a biological trait passed genetically, with suicide being the most common cause of death in young men, across a period of history, you would expect evolution to have probably have sorted that out.

Why would you expect evolution to have sorted it out? Males have disproportionately high rates of all kinds of genetic defects.

In evolutionary terms, men are the more disposable sex, and the sex within which the most successful specimens can potentially have very large numbers of offspring. This is why you have twice as many female ancestors as male ancestors.


 

Kiwi 20 May 17 6.32am

Originally posted by VeganPower

I am a feminist, and will continue to be so until 50% of Government, big business and media jobs are held by women.

Equality is important for a healthy society, I am a feminist because I love and respect my mum, my wife and my two daughters.

And will you remain a feminist until 50% of garbage collectors, s*** shovelers, etc. are women?

You want 50% representation in workplace deaths? Homicide deaths? Combat deaths?

You want 50% representation in the prison population?

 

Kiwi 20 May 17 6.36am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

More evidence of how women are treated differently to men for the same crime.

[Link]

The usual suspects the BBC don't even mention the glaring injustice of it.

I view this as a part of the discrimination against masculinity.

I wouldn't really mind so much myself but the sheer hypocrisy of it when seen against the equality movement just winds me up.

Just seen that this is the subject of another thread so I'll have a look at that.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 May 2017 4.13pm)

Indeed. . .

Check out the link below for some more detailed analysis - better than anecdotal evidence from news reports.

[Link]

It's also really worthwhile going through the rest of that website. The guy behind it tackles a whole bunch of other topics too (domestic violence, suicide, paternity fraud, universal suffrage), each time backing his arguments with a host of government statistics, case law, medical research, and other solid sources. It's a goldmine for countering some of the misconceptions being spread by feminism.

Edited by Kiwi (20 May 2017 6.53am)

 

Kiwi 20 May 17 6.37am

This movie (The Red Pill) is worth a watch.

[Link]

It's about the US, but the content applies equally to the UK.

 

Kiwi 20 May 17 6.42am

There's also a political party (Justice for Men and Boys, and the Women who Love them) engaged in fightback against the cultural attacks on masculinity.

[Link]

I think they do some good work. In fact I even joined them for a street protest last year when I was in the UK.

 

Kiwi 20 May 17 6.48am

I shouldn't post so much, but I'm interested in this topic, so here's one more. . .

Another person worth listening to on this stuff is Karen Straughan. She has a great way of explaining things.

Below is a talk she gave on toxic masculinity and toxic femininity:

[Link]

She has a ton more videos on her own Youtube channel - just search for her name.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 07 Dec 17 11.16pm

[Link]

Looks an interesting book that posits the idea (after research on hormones) that the inequalities between men and women is a cultural phenomenon rather than being the natural order.

Testosterone, so we’re told, is the very essence of masculinity, and biological sex is a fundamental force in our development. Not so, says psychologist Cordelia Fine, who shows, with wit and panache, that sex doesn’t create male and female natures. Instead, sex, hormones, culture and evolution work together in ways that make past and present gender dynamics only a serving suggestion for the future – not a recipe. Testosterone Rex brings together evolutionary science, psychology, neuroscience and social history to move beyond old ‘nature versus nurture’ debates, and to explain why it’s time to unmake the tyrannical myth of Testosterone Rex.

Edited by nickgusset (07 Dec 2017 11.31pm)

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 08 Dec 17 12.44am

We have now have a media of soy boy journalists who push their brand of "masculinity" to everyone. Four men from Buzzfeed recently had their testosterone tested and found it to be the levels of a teenager. Shock.

There was a university study this year that showed weaker men are more likely to go for socialist policies than stronger ones.

Edited by Penge Eagle (08 Dec 2017 12.45am)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 08 Dec 17 12.54am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

We have now have a media of soy boy journalists who push their brand of "masculinity" to everyone. Four men from Buzzfeed recently had their testosterone tested and found it to be the levels of a teenager. Shock.

There was a university study this year that showed weaker men are more likely to go for socialist policies than stronger ones.

Edited by Penge Eagle (08 Dec 2017 12.45am)

In other words 'Inherent Benders' **Courtesy of C Funt

 


Pro USA & Israel

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cultural Attacks against Masculinity