This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Can Benteke redeem himself?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Elpis In a pub 10 Dec 17 8.51pm |
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
This is how I apportion the blame:
75% tekkers 9% Dann 7% Luka 9% Roy
Benteke now owes us a huge debt...one he is perfectly capable of repaying if he works himself back into top form.
Disagree it was 100% Bentekes fault . As soon as he insisted he was taking it he would have put extra pressure on Luka if he then insisted he was taking it . From going up to confidently smash the ball in the net he would be thinking about a row with a team mate seconds earlier .In fact Benteke has now put extra pressure on any future penalty's we may get by his selfish action .
As for his future at Palace I think it will be as a bench warmer at best .If it wasn't for the huge amount of money we paid for him and the fact we have little option if we want to play a CF he wouldn't be getting a game. Not only is he lazy but appears to be unable to kick the ball with any purpose, dosen't get into the right positions and even his heading has become weak . Nobody is going to pay what we did for him so I guess unless the management are prepared to take a big hit on selling him we will just have to suffer until his contract runs out .
I expect us to have someone lined up to sign on 1st January so we dont have to put up with his useless perfomances anymore.
Of course he could also proove me wrong
|
EddieMac 10 Dec 17 9.05pm |
|
|
Lads, I am still absolutely fuming over that penalty. He should be ashamed of himself for what he's done.
In my opinion before that peno he was close to being our man of the match. I thought he had a great game.
There is no way in hell Roy will lollipop him on Tuesday as he has no one to replace him with. I just pray to god he gets an easy early chance and scores because if he misses his first chance the abuse is going to start and it will be downhill from there.
It is good we have a game so soon, so hopefully we can but this debacle behind us.
|
VinceHilaire London 10 Dec 17 9.10pm |
|
|
I’m ready to be shot down, but he does not deserve any further criticism.
Yes....he made the wrong decision...yes....we are all livid...
....I thought he played very well and was dominant in the air. Perhaps he thought the goal would help really get his season underway.
We all make mistakes....I hope he gets his chance on Tuesday to prove a point and score a hatrick.
|
iheartcpfc SE25 10 Dec 17 9.11pm |
|
|
Fine him and see how he responds next game. Play for the shirt and maybe we can forgive but man, it doesn't look good for him. Still f***ing fuming.
|
EddieMac 10 Dec 17 9.35pm |
|
|
Exactly, My view (previous 2 posts)
I have mixed views on what he did but the fact that he was willing to stand up and take the risk say's to me that he does care about the club.
If he starts scoring goals then we will stay up if he doesnt we are in trouble, so like it or not we just have to get behind him and just stay in this division and then get a new striker next year.
The chances of us signing a decent striker in January is slim to none so we need Benteke.
I am praying he scores a couple of goals on Tuesday night then we can all move on.
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 10 Dec 17 11.06pm |
|
|
Would be a disgrace if he was picked for the next match.
How anyone can say he cares for the club when he bullied Luka off the ball and went against the managers decision to take the kick himself.
And then the kick its self... absolute shambles of a kick. We are meant to think this guy cares about the club when he pushes a guy with 100% conversion rate off the ball so he can take a half arsed pen him self.
Alternative striker or not... Benteke has got to benched at the very least.
Oh and talking of caring about the club...? Where's his apology?
f***ing nowhere to be seen that's where....
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 10 Dec 17 11.23pm |
|
|
I am not sure he has got it in him, he has got a strange attitude if you ask me. Anyone else, if you had failed at taking a penalty the way he takes them you would try something else, not carry on with the same predictable method.
I'm still angry and it's nearly midnight the next day...
|
redshift Toronto 10 Dec 17 11.39pm |
|
|
A little story. My home club TFC here in Toronto had Jermaine Defoe a few years ago. We had a situation where we had a free kick a bit outside the 18 yd box and this was usually Defoe's territory but we also had a higher end striker from Brazil named Gilberto who was not having a good season and was scoreless.
He wrestled the ball away from Defoe and set up for the kick and put a rocket up into the upper right corner with all the frustration and anger of his season to that point behind it. Thankfully it sailed over the wall because it would have killed anyone in front of it. Even Defoe laughed.
My point is.. if you take the ball away from someone, you better be sure about what you're doing.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.
|
Michaelawt85 Bexley 10 Dec 17 11.50pm |
|
|
Chop out the dead wood. Flog wickham and benteke in January. Strikers who are cracked or useless. Get someone else in. Can't get any worse can it
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC
|
Michaelawt85 Bexley 10 Dec 17 11.52pm |
|
|
He behaved like an egotistical prat going for glory. No one would have minded had he scored it. Fine balance. However said it several times why was the captain not taking charge and bossing the situation. Drama at every turn with this club
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC
|
redshift Toronto 11 Dec 17 12.04am |
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
He behaved like an egotistical prat going for glory. No one would have minded had he scored it. Fine balance. However said it several times why was the captain not taking charge and bossing the situation. Drama at every turn with this club
I think this points out the problem with having your GK as captain. He's just not physically situated in any place where he can have an impact. He'd have to run the length of the field to get to the action. GK as captain to me is just a total mistake regardless of who he is.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.
|
chateauferret 11 Dec 17 12.45am |
|
|
Can anyone remember when it was that he fluffed a pen after a similar Billy Big Bollocks insistence on taking it? It was in the Pardew era and Pardew said "Oh, we just let the players decide who takes the penalty", which is the diametric opposite of what Hodgson said after the Bournemouth game.
It was bad enough then but in those days you could reasonably argue that Cabaye and Puncheon were also quite s***e at penalties. But when you're standing next to Milivojevic FFS!?
============ The Ferret ============
|
baldeagle73 Leamington spa 11 Dec 17 1.33am |
|
|
Nobody stepped in to tell benteke he shouldn't be anywhere near a penalty puncheon would have had the guts to tell him play him till January then sell him to big sam or villa on loan
walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 11 Dec 17 4.01am |
|
|
If we get relegated and the difference is 2 points, then Saturday's penalty miss will be the talking point. Head down and smash it, in my opinion is far better than walking up to it and passing it to the keeper.
This was once a quality forum....
|
.TUX. 11 Dec 17 6.26am |
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
He behaved like an egotistical prat going for glory. No one would have minded had he scored it. Fine balance. However said it several times why was the captain not taking charge and bossing the situation. Drama at every turn with this club
100% this.
We have a designated penalty-taker. End of.
Buy Litecoin.
|
stayloa Beckenham 11 Dec 17 6.31am |
|
|
My worry is that the crowd will boo him tomorrow. As much as I hate him for what he did, whether he's a sub or a starter, we have to get behind him.
It's for the manager to sort him out and for us to cheer on the team.
We're not blessed with strikers and he does still hold the ball well and win headers.
That said, 4-4-2 with Andros and Wilf up top for me with Jimmy Mac, Loftus Cheek, Mili, Cabaye (if fit) in the middle.
|
Midlands Eagle 11 Dec 17 6.34am |
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
If we get relegated and the difference is 2 points, then Saturday's penalty miss will be the talking point.
Unfortunately there will be other talking points including Lee Chung-Yong's suicidal back pass, Kelly's fannying about on the ball and Speroni kicking the ball out to Dann for starters
|
n wales eagles llandudno 11 Dec 17 6.59am |
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
Chop out the dead wood. Flog wickham and benteke in January. Strikers who are cracked or useless. Get someone else in. Can't get any worse can it Maybe do a stop with John Lewis moz as he will be looking for work in January and would have same workrate and presence Watched him at wba and his workrate was pathetic and wilf had to do all the closing down as Ben didn't seem bothered.he's no heart for the palace which for you lads and lasses who cheer us on every week must be so frustrating.Until Roy feels he can drop Ben's I am a superstar attitude then bench him for 20 min stints that may put some fire in his belly for the cause but from what I've seen the fires long gone hopefully a team out asia way would fancy a Chinese ben tekaway
|
Slimey Toad Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 11 Dec 17 7.02am |
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Unfortunately there will be other talking points including Lee Chung-Yong's suicidal back pass, Kelly's fannying about on the ball and Speroni kicking the ball out to Dann for starters
And the Niasse dive, De Boer, Parish, lack of strikers etc. etc.
If we go down it will be because of the failure to deliver results on the pitch.
|
bexleydave Barnehurst 11 Dec 17 7.08am |
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
Chop out the dead wood. Flog wickham and benteke in January. Strikers who are cracked or useless. Get someone else in. Can't get any worse can it
As it stands we need a striker in January, a difficult enough task in itself, as history has shown. Under your plan we'd need to sign three, which would be extremely difficult in the summer and impossible (especially for a relegation candidate) in January.
Bexley Dave
Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!
"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)
|