This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by michaelpearce
And look where we are!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
And look where we are! 5th year in the PL
|
|
|
Originally posted by europalace
5th year in the PL Agree. I have a Charlton friend and I am glad we don't have their chairman. He is trying to sell the club but so far the suitors appear to be as bad as he is. Thank god for Parish. Mistakes and all I would rather have him than some of the football club owners like Oyston at Blackpool.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
It depends on the quality of the strikers and keepers. Palace already have the 11th highest wages in the PL. Quite possibly adding a new striker on £60-100k a week and a keeper on £30-40k a week would indeed be a recipe for going bust, or failing FFP. Burnley's wage bill is 35% lower than ours. It's a gamble as relegation is so costly but it's also possible to pay a striker 100k a week and for him to only score very occasionally. Remember also that Steve Mandanda was reportedly on £70k a week.
We are 5th largest NET spender. That comes as much from player retention as big spending - probably more. The players we have let go have largely been from the Championship days and Holloway splurge and have raised relatively little in sales. Our attempt to build our squad with some expensive marquee signings is, I would have thought, a positive step. Had we not done that can you imagine the reaction on this site to only buying "bargain basemenent and rejects"? Note comments on the January window...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Agree. I have a Charlton friend and I am glad we don't have their chairman. He is trying to sell the club but so far the suitors appear to be as bad as he is. Thank god for Parish. Mistakes and all I would rather have him than some of the football club owners like Oyston at Blackpool. ------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
Originally posted by europalace
5th year in the PL That's all well and good, but do you not think we've underperformed consistently ever since Dec 2015, with the bounce then flounce from Sam apart? Given the squad we have it seems clear that the mistakes that have been made by the ownership have continually held us back. Not sacking Pardew earlier very nearly took us down, also backing him to rebuild and 'evolve the playing side' or whatever bollocks catchprase they used was a massive waste of an opportunity, as it nearly dismantled what got us up here in the first place. Then the failure to keep on to Sam (and IMHO it's clear as day he thought we weren't a good long term proposition and was always coming back to the game), the disaster of the summer with De Boer, then failing to back him in the window, the massive, ridiculous gamble with having one striker on the books, the sun coming up, two keepers at the club over two conseqtive T/windows, no cover for the wingers... I appreciate under Parish we got promotion, and have stayed there, but it's been far more down to luck than judgement in recent years, and that cannot last. He keeps repeating the same mistakes over and over, yet seems to get more arrogant and flippant about the potentialities of them going tits up. I fully expect Roy to walk this summer, giving Parish his hat trick of capable managers that walk out on him after one season.
"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?" |
|
|
Good post. He's done incredibly well but continues to make mistakes. Is he the Arsene Wenger of Chairman
|
|
|
Originally posted by Happiness Stan
That's all well and good, but do you not think we've underperformed consistently ever since Dec 2015, with the bounce then flounce from Sam apart? Given the squad we have it seems clear that the mistakes that have been made by the ownership have continually held us back. Not sacking Pardew earlier very nearly took us down, also backing him to rebuild and 'evolve the playing side' or whatever bollocks catchprase they used was a massive waste of an opportunity, as it nearly dismantled what got us up here in the first place. Then the failure to keep on to Sam (and IMHO it's clear as day he thought we weren't a good long term proposition and was always coming back to the game), the disaster of the summer with De Boer, then failing to back him in the window, the massive, ridiculous gamble with having one striker on the books, the sun coming up, two keepers at the club over two conseqtive T/windows, no cover for the wingers... I appreciate under Parish we got promotion, and have stayed there, but it's been far more down to luck than judgement in recent years, and that cannot last. He keeps repeating the same mistakes over and over, yet seems to get more arrogant and flippant about the potentialities of them going tits up. I fully expect Roy to walk this summer, giving Parish his hat trick of capable managers that walk out on him after one season. Stan, you keep posting the same thing, why do you think Roy will walk? He may leave because he is in his 70's and he's had enough, but walk because of Parish, no, I think Roy is more of a pragmatist than that and he knows that Palace can't afford to buy a team into the top 6.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nead1
You seem to have a conveniently short memory. How does the following stack up - Sure there have been some mistakes/frustrations along the way but actually not that many in my book. Remember also that this is a club functioning on gates of 25,000 max - not big by PL standards. My instincts are to get behind him - endless criticism tends to ultimately drive someone away. Who is it you want to take over? Yes get all that and certainly not knocking him for any of that, But this all needs to be managed in conjunction with the most important aspect, the squad of players. Its a difficult job but its what he signed up to. We are in the big league now and should and could have done better. Steve also does not help himself with the comments he comes out with raising expectations etc and then knocking all all back down. I honestly think he needs more media training. Edited by MonsterMunch (09 Feb 2018 11.16am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Stan, you keep posting the same thing, why do you think Roy will walk? He may leave because he is in his 70's and he's had enough, but walk because of Parish, no, I think Roy is more of a pragmatist than that and he knows that Palace can't afford to buy a team into the top 6. Lets assume that we stay up finishing around 15th. What's in it for Roy, having saved his reputation, if he believes (as i suspect he does) that Parish is unreliable, deceptive and ultimately will let him down in the transfer market. He will have performed superbly in keeping us up, and will have one more year on his current deal. Why risk that rep that he's just saved, by another relegation struggle under a chairman who is failing to back him in the market? If he gets a bit more bad luck, he either has a relegation on his final year in the game, or maybe if things go really badly, gets sacked. If, as i suspect, he doesnt rate parish or trust him to competently do his job, then why gamble another year under him, rather get out on a high.
"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?" |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Stan, you keep posting the same thing, why do you think Roy will walk? He may leave because he is in his 70's and he's had enough, but walk because of Parish, no, I think Roy is more of a pragmatist than that and he knows that Palace can't afford to buy a team into the top 6. Only you has mentioned the top 6. Roy kept raising needing a keeper and we didn't get one. If Roy thinks he's going to go into next season half c0cked with a shambles of a window then anyone may walk. We all know it.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Saying how good Parish has been because of our 5th year in the prem is great but the problem is coming out of every window under equipped, apart from Sam's January window, and there's no signs of it changing. What about the January window under Pulis that ultimately led us to finish 11th?
|
|
|
Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme
What about the January window under Pulis that ultimately led us to finish 11th? The one where Pulis threatened to walk out if Parish didn't pull his finger out and sign the players he wanted?
"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?" |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Only you has mentioned the top 6. Roy kept raising needing a keeper and we didn't get one. If Roy thinks he's going to go into next season half c0cked with a shambles of a window then anyone may walk. We all know it. I mentioned the top six because Roy has actually mentioned it in one of his interviews when talking about the fact that we cannot afford to buy our way into that position. Surely the ultimate target of any PL side is top 6 otherwise we might as well be happy where we are and happy with the way we go about it. So are you and Stan saying that you are not happy with the way things are going and we should be striving to change our management structure, ie get rid of Parish and if so, what sort of person do you think should be in place to stop Roy from walking in the summer? Its alright saying Parish should have done this and Parish should have done that, but what is the alternative and are you absolutely convinced that will be better for the club?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Happiness Stan
That's all well and good, but do you not think we've underperformed consistently ever since Dec 2015, with the bounce then flounce from Sam apart? Given the squad we have it seems clear that the mistakes that have been made by the ownership have continually held us back. Not sacking Pardew earlier very nearly took us down, also backing him to rebuild and 'evolve the playing side' or whatever bollocks catchprase they used was a massive waste of an opportunity, as it nearly dismantled what got us up here in the first place. Then the failure to keep on to Sam (and IMHO it's clear as day he thought we weren't a good long term proposition and was always coming back to the game), the disaster of the summer with De Boer, then failing to back him in the window, the massive, ridiculous gamble with having one striker on the books, the sun coming up, two keepers at the club over two conseqtive T/windows, no cover for the wingers... I appreciate under Parish we got promotion, and have stayed there, but it's been far more down to luck than judgement in recent years, and that cannot last. He keeps repeating the same mistakes over and over, yet seems to get more arrogant and flippant about the potentialities of them going tits up. I fully expect Roy to walk this summer, giving Parish his hat trick of capable managers that walk out on him after one season. How do you measure underperformance? What is the performance metric? And what is your benchmark? Other clubs of our size? How do you measure our size? One of my friend's husband supports Charlton - she is always reporting his annoyance at our good fortune and continued presence in the Premier league. Perspective is everything. No one can say Parish is tight - god we have the 5th highest net spend and yet the squad is still a mishmash and needs work. But I remember where we started and there was zero depth in many positions. As for all the ridiculous comments about Roy leaving. He has a two-year contract I'd be surprised if he doesn't see it out. Harping back to Pulis is, well, silly. Pulis is Pulis - his record is great but he has his own agenda. So did Big Sam. And remember he is a northerner - its a long way to travel for a struggling club. No surprise to see him take on Everton is it? As for the original post - I don't think Parish will explain the window. He'd be giving away too much sensitive info if he did. Nor should he. The basic premise of this thread is that Parish isn't doing his best for the club. Well he's not doing a bad job as this is our longest stay in the top division.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.