You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Nya Kirby
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Nya Kirby


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
inflikted Flag 06 Jan 19 3.23am

It seems pretty clear that Roy has no plans to play him yet, despite the fact he's very highly rated. There's been talk of him going out on loan this month but my question is, where should he go? So far seen him linked with teams like Blackpool and Charlton.

While he'd almost certainly play, I'm not sure if League One is the best place for him to gain experience. Lowest level I'd like to see him at would be the Championship, or maybe seeing if any clubs on the continent e.g. Germany would want to take a chance, as it's done wonders for other players who've gone out there (see: Jadon Sancho, Reiss Nelson). The only concern regarding Germany though, is if they want him permanently. Palace already lost Mandela Egbo that way.

 


Milkshakes Against Fascism

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Jan 19 8.27am

The big German sides are being very crafty. They can carry a talented kid -- just like our top sides can in certain games. So they go after the cream of the academies where the players have interesting contract situations.

No idea how much longer we have Kirby, but our huge weakness as a club is not really being able to risk competitive minutes for younger players.

It's one reason I'd like to see a European friendly ladder that Palace could participate in. Say about 10 games a season for fringe 1st team, reserve and youth players.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Jan 19 10.02am

Not sure why we consider young players a risk (although I accept that Roy does), as we have a subs bench and I would be all for giving say Kirby a start and if he is struggling replace him with experience. We will never know if he is good enough if we don’t play him.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 06 Jan 19 10.51am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

The big German sides are being very crafty. They can carry a talented kid -- just like our top sides can in certain games. So they go after the cream of the academies where the players have interesting contract situations.

No idea how much longer we have Kirby, but our huge weakness as a club is not really being able to risk competitive minutes for younger players.

It's one reason I'd like to see a European friendly ladder that Palace could participate in. Say about 10 games a season for fringe 1st team, reserve and youth players.

why cant we?

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


chris123 Flag hove actually 06 Jan 19 11.32am

If we are going to run an academy that feeds the first team with some home grown talent, that youth needs to be give a chance. I'm not sure of the answer, but feel our transitioning is not as good as it might be. A few WZ's and AWB's helps reputation and economics, but only if the first team coach plays 'em!

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 06 Jan 19 11.33am

Unfortunately for Kirby, central midfield is one position where the first team is pretty well-stocked.

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 06 Jan 19 1.12pm

Seem to be well stocked in goalkeepers defenders and midfielders Maybe we should just have a striker only academy .

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 06 Jan 19 1.18pm

Hopefully once we’ll secure our Premiership status with a few games to spare we can start to phase him in then. It’s difficult and high risk at the moment. Perhaps get him on the bench for the next round of the cup and get him if we’re comfortably ahead

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 06 Jan 19 3.15pm

While battling relegation is surely serious business this still is a choice. I don't believe youngsters should be brought overly careful and generally that seems to be the case in the PL. Think it is mainly due to public opinion/media-fan pressure but if a player is good enough he is good enough. Who does not remember: you'll never win anything with kids. While experience can be very valuable I think it often is also overrated.

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

The big German sides are being very crafty. They can carry a talented kid -- just like our top sides can in certain games. So they go after the cream of the academies where the players have interesting contract situations.

No idea how much longer we have Kirby, but our huge weakness as a club is not really being able to risk competitive minutes for younger players.

It's one reason I'd like to see a European friendly ladder that Palace could participate in. Say about 10 games a season for fringe 1st team, reserve and youth players.


 

inflikted Flag 06 Jan 19 4.47pm

If Kirby does end up going to League One, I think I'd rather he go to Charlton than Blackpool. Charlton are chasing promotion and are closer, so it'll be easier to keep tabs on his progress, while Blackpool's facilities are borderline Conference tier because the Oystons refuse to invest any money in the club, and I don't think the shoddy training facilities there will benefit Nya in any way.

 


Milkshakes Against Fascism

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 06 Jan 19 6.50pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

The big German sides are being very crafty. They can carry a talented kid -- just like our top sides can in certain games. So they go after the cream of the academies where the players have interesting contract situations.

No idea how much longer we have Kirby, but our huge weakness as a club is not really being able to risk competitive minutes for younger players.

It's one reason I'd like to see a European friendly ladder that Palace could participate in. Say about 10 games a season for fringe 1st team, reserve and youth players.

Interesting post, like it. The only thing I'd disagree with is in bold. We are able, just not brave enough. Frustrating to see Puncheon, Lee, Mutch etc getting bench spots in the past knowing they can't impact a match.

I don't understand why English clubs don't explore partnering with European clubs to loan players. Imagine the benefits for young centre backs to go to Seria B, or Midfielders to go to Holland or Spain? I think young strikers should be playing games over here, no matter the level. Look at Abrahams at Villa. It's absolutely criminal for young lads of 17, 18, 19 not to be getting competitive game time. It's the only way to improve.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Jan 19 7.54pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Interesting post, like it. The only thing I'd disagree with is in bold. We are able, just not brave enough. Frustrating to see Puncheon, Lee, Mutch etc getting bench spots in the past knowing they can't impact a match.

I don't understand why English clubs don't explore partnering with European clubs to loan players. Imagine the benefits for young centre backs to go to Seria B, or Midfielders to go to Holland or Spain? I think young strikers should be playing games over here, no matter the level. Look at Abrahams at Villa. It's absolutely criminal for young lads of 17, 18, 19 not to be getting competitive game time. It's the only way to improve.

That is what the Premier money has done. Big clubs are far more guilty hoovering up all the best young talent with money bribes to parents, mainly to stop competitors getting them. Its all about winning now, managers wont risk putting in a youngster, no matter how good they are Chelsea and Man City have many examples. They pay them good wages to play reserve football, its crazy as they become millionaires without playing in the first team.
AWB was an exception, who just happened to adapt very well, if it wasn't for Wards and Kelly being injured he wouldn't on seen the first team.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 06 Jan 19 10.29pm

Originally posted by Painter

That is what the Premier money has done. Big clubs are far more guilty hoovering up all the best young talent with money bribes to parents, mainly to stop competitors getting them. Its all about winning now, managers wont risk putting in a youngster, no matter how good they are Chelsea and Man City have many examples. They pay them good wages to play reserve football, its crazy as they become millionaires without playing in the first team.
AWB was an exception, who just happened to adapt very well, if it wasn't for Wards and Kelly being injured he wouldn't on seen the first team.

Got to agree, seems very shortsighted. Given our catchment area and history of producing good youth players that go on to have good careers (if not always prestigious), it's really a failure of 2010 only to have AWB to boast of from 6 years in the top flight. Like you say, his chance came because the stars aligned!

I'd like to see investment in the setup so we achieve the highest rank possible for youth football short term and a commitment to bringing them on. Why not have a formal policy of if you get professional terms you have to go out on loan immediately for a season? Do these kids the world of good, especially the advantages of experiencing different footballing cultures around Europe.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 10 Jan 19 10.49pm

RLC can't get into the Chelsea team
Nya can't get into ours
The problem is similar, there is always someone with more experience to come on for the last 20 minutes when you need experience.

The answer is to take the risk but what manager will seriously risk it

Giving youth a chance has to be in the ethos of the club.

With Puncheon gone (sadly) then Nya must play if we need to attack and jaïro if we need to defend

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Teo15 Flag 10 Jan 19 11.01pm

Originally posted by MrCParrot

RLC can't get into the Chelsea team
Nya can't get into ours
The problem is similar, there is always someone with more experience to come on for the last 20 minutes when you need experience.

The answer is to take the risk but what manager will seriously risk it

Giving youth a chance has to be in the ethos of the club.

With Puncheon gone (sadly) then Nya must play if we need to attack and jaïro if we need to defend

Parrot

And maybe that’s what the plan is? Getting rid of the deadwood to make way for the youngsters like Nya and Jairo

 

Username Flag Horsham 11 Jan 19 12.27pm

Originally posted by inflikted

It seems pretty clear that Roy has no plans to play him yet, despite the fact he's very highly rated. There's been talk of him going out on loan this month but my question is, where should he go? So far seen him linked with teams like Blackpool and Charlton.

While he'd almost certainly play, I'm not sure if League One is the best place for him to gain experience. Lowest level I'd like to see him at would be the Championship, or maybe seeing if any clubs on the continent e.g. Germany would want to take a chance, as it's done wonders for other players who've gone out there (see: Jadon Sancho, Reiss Nelson). The only concern regarding Germany though, is if they want him permanently. Palace already lost Mandela Egbo that way.

I'm not sure how anyone who doesn't watch him in training can make a call on what level he needs to play at?

If the club feel he's not ready to play in the Championship then there isn't much point in sending him to a club where he won't play regularly.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

chateauferret Flag 11 Jan 19 1.10pm

Loaned to Blackpool.

[Link]

 


============
The Ferret
============

coulsdoneagle Flag London 11 Jan 19 1.14pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Loaned to Blackpool.

[Link]

Good move. Bit of physicality in that league and won’t be having his hand held. If he is as good at football as everyone says, by the end of the season he will have begun to shine at that level and can make a step up.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Jan 19 1.22pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Good move. Bit of physicality in that league and won’t be having his hand held. If he is as good at football as everyone says, by the end of the season he will have begun to shine at that level and can make a step up.

Joined Blackpool at a time when they have lost 4 of their last 5 league games and play in front of crowds often not that more than 3,000.In fact in their last home game, against Sunderland, there were more away supporters than home in the crowd of nearly 11,000.

Edited by Willo (11 Jan 2019 1.23pm)

 

seasider Flag 11 Jan 19 2.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

Joined Blackpool at a time when they have lost 4 of their last 5 league games and play in front of crowds often not that more than 3,000.In fact in their last home game, against Sunderland, there were more away supporters than home in the crowd of nearly 11,000.

Edited by Willo (11 Jan 2019 1.23pm)

I am sure you understand why Pool's home crowds are so low. Hopefully some movement on our situation soon and the fans can come back. On another note, Newcastle have been praising Blackpool for bringing on Sean Longstaff last season. Kirby certainly won't be molly-coddled and if he is any good it will help him in the long run. We're feeling Glad All Over lol

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Nya Kirby