You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Gaffer
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Gaffer


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Feb 19 2.21am

[Link]

Very interesting piece.

Some on here slate Roy and think he is terrible but he is a top manager in the game.

He makes mistakes, but you can see in the comments from ex players and Lewington that he is massively respected.

Interesting comments from Lewington on it being ok to play badly, as long as you are following the game plan. Might explain a few selection choices now and then!

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

jjsperling Flag 22 Feb 19 4.56am

People on here slag on and on about Roy on how he's toothless and never tries anything exciting. But the truth of the matter is that were one of the most structured teams in the league and that comes down to Roy

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Feb 19 6.11am

Originally posted by jjsperling

People on here slag on and on about Roy on how he's toothless and never tries anything exciting. But the truth of the matter is that were one of the most structured teams in the league and that comes down to Roy

Im sure that doesnt go unoticed and is appreciated.
Some games are boring though and in game management with roy can be lacking.
Everton away a prime example.
Lack of subs in time on at least this occasion pretty sure cost us points.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Feb 19 9.11am

Has a few faults but a brilliant manager overall, under whom we've played some excellent football. If we'd got a proper striker in the summer, we'd be top half now.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Feb 19 9.19am

Hodgson is hugely respected in the game as a manager and as a person and one could advance the argument that had it not been for him we would not now be in the hallowed land of the PL.

Plaudits for him on this thread but should we succumb to a defeat at Leicester tomorrow, I suspect that he will come in for some of the ordure he has received in the past.

 

windsoreagle Flag Windsor 22 Feb 19 9.27am

I stumbled on this piece before coming here and reading this thread. I think also that the article sheds some light on his approach to the players at CPFC; most particularly in respect to Christian Benteke. He appears to work and rehearse them hard at training, but is sympathetic unless they don't follow through on that training during a match. I think the piece is fair, complimentary, and (whilst of course nobody is perfect) tells me how lucky we are to have him as manager. Because other teams have a different ethos and way of doing things (perhaps most notably Liverpool), he is not such a good fit for them. Well done RH.

 


The power of the Executive to cast a man into prison without formulating any charge known to the law, and particularly to deny him the judgment of his peers, is in the highest degree odious and is the foundation of all totalitarian government whether Nazi or Communist.
WINSTON CHURCHILL, 1943.

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Feb 19 9.29am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

[Link]

Very interesting piece.

Some on here slate Roy and think he is terrible but he is a top manager in the game.

He makes mistakes, but you can see in the comments from ex players and Lewington that he is massively respected.

Interesting comments from Lewington on it being ok to play badly, as long as you are following the game plan. Might explain a few selection choices now and then!


Maybe that washes once motivationally: "it's ok lad, you did as you were told and it didn't work out, we'll work on it for next time" but every week?

It's pure belligerence. Basically Wodgson and his staff are valuing obedience over talent as it protects their authority and therefore their jobs. There is some merit in this, but the balance should be loyalty and talent.

We would easily be top ten if he didn't wait 15-20 games for players to come good or just keep picking the same trusty carthorses over a bit of flare.

And in terms of respect within the game? I've heard plenty of ex players on podcasts and in the media who speak negatively about his style.

He's extremely one dimensional and predictable, no matter how good the passing and positional discipline has looked at times.

Edited by ChrisGC (22 Feb 2019 9.30am)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 22 Feb 19 10.15am

Originally posted by ChrisGC


Maybe that washes once motivationally: "it's ok lad, you did as you were told and it didn't work out, we'll work on it for next time" but every week?

It's pure belligerence. Basically Wodgson and his staff are valuing obedience over talent as it protects their authority and therefore their jobs. There is some merit in this, but the balance should be loyalty and talent.

We would easily be top ten if he didn't wait 15-20 games for players to come good or just keep picking the same trusty carthorses over a bit of flare.

And in terms of respect within the game? I've heard plenty of ex players on podcasts and in the media who speak negatively about his style.

He's extremely one dimensional and predictable, no matter how good the passing and positional discipline has looked at times.

Edited by ChrisGC (22 Feb 2019 9.30am)

Classy.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 22 Feb 19 10.24am

Originally posted by jjsperling

People on here slag on and on about Roy on how he's toothless and never tries anything exciting. But the truth of the matter is that were one of the most structured teams in the league and that comes down to Roy

Managers like Roy, Pulis and Fat Sam get slated, but as all of them have said in the past, if you’re letting in 2 or 3 goals every game, whatever division you’re in, you’re only going one way, down!!

Yes we feel like we should be higher up the league and we should be scoring more goals, and yes I do get the feeling constant relegation battles could catch up with us, but at the moment Roy’s got us organised and competitive, as did Pulis and Allardyce. We were definitely going down with Holloway and Pardew’s more attacking style because we were shipping goals.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Feb 19 10.28am

Originally posted by monkey

Managers like Roy, Pulis and Fat Sam get slated, but as all of them have said in the past, if you’re letting in 2 or 3 goals every game, whatever division you’re in, you’re only going one way, down!!

Yes we feel like we should be higher up the league and we should be scoring more goals, and yes I do get the feeling constant relegation battles could catch up with us, but at the moment Roy’s got us organised and competitive, as did Pulis and Allardyce. We were definitely going down with Holloway and Pardew’s more attacking style because we were shipping goals.

Didn't know Pardew or Holloway had a style. Well, unless s h I t is a style.

 


Red and Blue Army!

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 22 Feb 19 10.46am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Didn't know Pardew or Holloway had a style. Well, unless s h I t is a style.

We used to play it in the Orpington and Bromley sunday league,throw everything forward and f*** the defence

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 22 Feb 19 1.32pm

I’m sure that our outstanding traveling supporters will have something entirely appropriate at Leicester tomorrow for Roy, especially when the clock strikes 71.

Edited by kenbarr (22 Feb 2019 1.33pm)

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 22 Feb 19 2.18pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC


Maybe that washes once motivationally: "it's ok lad, you did as you were told and it didn't work out, we'll work on it for next time" but every week?

It's pure belligerence. Basically Wodgson and his staff are valuing obedience over talent as it protects their authority and therefore their jobs. There is some merit in this, but the balance should be loyalty and talent.

We would easily be top ten if he didn't wait 15-20 games for players to come good or just keep picking the same trusty carthorses over a bit of flare.

And in terms of respect within the game? I've heard plenty of ex players on podcasts and in the media who speak negatively about his style.

He's extremely one dimensional and predictable, no matter how good the passing and positional discipline has looked at times.

Edited by ChrisGC (22 Feb 2019 9.30am)

Seems like not many members agree with your jaundice opinion of Hodgson, in fact none so far.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 22 Feb 19 2.54pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Seems like not many members agree with your jaundice opinion of Hodgson, in fact none so far.

I think some fans need to remember that well worn phrase now ‘careful what you wish for’ . Things could be better without Roy, but chances are they could get a whole lot worse as well

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards andyachtie Flag Monte Giberto 22 Feb 19 4.19pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC


Maybe that washes once motivationally: "it's ok lad, you did as you were told and it didn't work out, we'll work on it for next time" but every week?

It's pure belligerence. Basically o and his staff are valuing obedience over talent as it protects their authority and therefore their jobs. There is some merit in this, but the balance should be loyalty and talent.

We would easily be top ten if he didn't wait 15-20 games for players to come good or just keep picking the same trusty carthorses over a bit of flare.

And in terms of respect within the game? I've heard plenty of ex players on podcasts and in the media who speak negatively about his style.

He's extremely one dimensional and predictable, no matter how good the passing and positional discipline has looked at times.

Edited by ChrisGC (22 Feb 2019 9.30am)

Knob.... Bet you were a bully at school.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Feb 19 4.33pm

Originally posted by andyachtie

Knob.... Bet you were a bully at school.

Haha, no pal: I was neither bullied nor a bully. Were you bullied by any chance?

Not that having left school nearly 20 years ago and now existing in the adult world do I really care about your feelings or the fact that you were the school punchbag to be fair.

Bit odd to accuse someone else of being a bully after insulting them just because you disagree with their opinion, but there you go. I'm sure the irony is lost on you.

Edited by ChrisGC (22 Feb 2019 4.53pm)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Feb 19 4.35pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Seems like not many members agree with your jaundice opinion of Hodgson, in fact none so far.

Only my opinion sweet chuck, not bothered whether it's popular or not.

As for people saying "careful what you wish for" etc, we are only a couple of results away from being in the relegation zone...

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 22 Feb 19 5.55pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Only my opinion sweet chuck, not bothered whether it's popular or not.

As for people saying "careful what you wish for" etc, we are only a couple of results away from being in the relegation zone...

That’ll be me then

We’re also only a couple of results from being in the top half.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 22 Feb 19 6.19pm

Originally posted by monkey

That’ll be me then

We’re also only a couple of results from being in the top half.

Very true.

 

dg1937 Flag 22 Feb 19 6.33pm

I was chatting to a Charlton fan last night and he could see the funny side of the thought that sacking Curbishley had indeed taken them to another a level.

We are lucky to have Roy, some of the football this season has been excellent (and some of it hasn't) but I can remember times when the football was consistently dreadful to watch - Freedman anyone?

As to his use of subs, many times there has been no quality on the bench, that's changing now and, surprise, surprise, he is making more use of subs. I seem to recall Pardew being slated for his use of subs - basically managers can't win.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Gaffer