You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Maine Eagle Flag USA 08 Aug 19 12.07pm

I rate this lad, and I think I wasn’t the only one who noticed the other J Mac was really slowing down last year.

We now have 2 extra true midfielders in the mix and with who we already have that is a solid midfield now.

Jimmy Mac can be a bench player now and Jimmy Mac can fill the void. Oo er.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Aug 19 12.09pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I rate this lad, and I think I wasn’t the only one who noticed the other J Mac was really slowing down last year.

We now have 2 extra true midfielders in the mix and with who we already have that is a solid midfield now.

Jimmy Mac can be a bench player now and Jimmy Mac can fill the void. Oo er.

Well, they can't play together, way too confusing. I think that's why we got rid of Sako!

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 08 Aug 19 12.09pm

F*cking bang average and an absolute sick note. Waste of money. If I was Wilf I would want to leave as well based on our busiest far in the window.

 

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 08 Aug 19 12.15pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

F*cking bang average and an absolute sick note. Waste of money. If I was Wilf I would want to leave as well based on our busiest far in the window.

He’s had a bad few years with injuries , over 300 career appearances at 28 says he isn’t a sick note.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 08 Aug 19 12.19pm

Originally posted by comeonyoueagles20

He’s had a bad few years with injuries , over 300 career appearances at 28 says he isn’t a sick note.

[Link]

Over 700 days injured with various issues suggests that yes he really is a sick note and had been for longer than a couple of years.

 

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 08 Aug 19 12.25pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

[Link]

Over 700 days injured with various issues suggests that yes he really is a sick note and had been for longer than a couple of years.

And over half of that was a serious leg brake , which could happen to any player. like i said over 300 career appearances , and that includes missing a whole year from a leg break....

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 08 Aug 19 12.31pm

McArthur slowing down? Sign a player trying to recover from a leg break and hardly any football for years.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 08 Aug 19 12.37pm

Originally posted by comeonyoueagles20

And over half of that was a serious leg brake , which could happen to any player. like i said over 300 career appearances , and that includes missing a whole year from a leg break....

Take out the leg break and it’s still a terrible injury record, he is absolutely a sick note

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 08 Aug 19 12.38pm

I’m not gonna write this guy off, in fact the opposite.

I’m going to welcome him to our club and give him the support he deserves and make my own mind up over the coming weeks & months.

At the moment I’m far more inclined to take notice of the positive comments from the Everton supporters on the link of the now locked thread in ‘Transfer Talk’. With respect, their experience of him is far greater than anyone on here and they rate him very highly indeed. With an ageing McArthur and the uncertainty over keeping Luka (final year of his contact) this could be a very good signing.

Let’s give the bloke some sound encouragement.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 08 Aug 19 12.40pm

Very pleased with this signing. Obviously his fitness level will become clearer over time but for 3m this is a solid purchase.

In my opinion we only had two viable true holding midfielders in Luka and Kayoute. McArthur has always impressed more further up the pitch IMO.

Midfield is certainly looking strong this year with experience, depth and variety.

Defense is a concern if we pick up more injuries.

Forwards are a concern...but IF Benteke returned to form we could surprise a few.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 08 Aug 19 1.26pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Take out the leg break and it’s still a terrible injury record, he is absolutely a sick note

His injuries have been hamstrings apart from double leg break

[Link]

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 08 Aug 19 1.45pm

Originally posted by Painter

His injuries have been hamstrings apart from double leg break

[Link]

And knee injuries and groin injuries.

I’m fully gonna support this bloke when he plays and hope he does well, but I still believe that this is a shocking signing and an absolute waste of money on a player that even when fit is decidedly average.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 08 Aug 19 2.02pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

And knee injuries and groin injuries.

I’m fully gonna support this bloke when he plays and hope he does well, but I still believe that this is a shocking signing and an absolute waste of money on a player that even when fit is decidedly average
.

3 million quid, Coulsdon Eagle.

That is 3 Sorloths. Get a grip man. Jordon Mutch was more expensive.

You absolutely cannot sign proven experienced premier league players for 3 million.

This is a good signing, despite the risk, because of the cost.

It is not a "shocking signing" this is fanciful. Its not Neymar but again, it is 3 million pounds. He is 28 years old. Yes he has had injuries but calling him bang average is also pretty nonsensical. He is a well respected proven premier league footballer.

I think you might think you support Barcelona, you dont.

When Palace sign players like McCarthy, they aint bang average son, they are Palace average.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 08 Aug 19 2.37pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

3 million quid, Coulsdon Eagle.

That is 3 Sorloths. Get a grip man. Jordon Mutch was more expensive.

You absolutely cannot sign proven experienced premier league players for 3 million.

This is a good signing, despite the risk, because of the cost.

It is not a "shocking signing" this is fanciful. Its not Neymar but again, it is 3 million pounds. He is 28 years old. Yes he has had injuries but calling him bang average is also pretty nonsensical. He is a well respected proven premier league footballer.

I think you might think you support Barcelona, you dont.

When Palace sign players like McCarthy, they aint bang average son, they are Palace average.

I don’t agree at all that this guy is worth anywhere close to that 3 million. What f*cking use is premier league experience if it sits in the sick room all season. It’s a waste of money and time because we have pressing positions that need filling. On top of that I think he is absolutely average even before his injuries.

Where is the long term vision in signing an injury prone player in his late 20s in a position that we already have Luka playing in with Kouyate as cover and several other midfielders who are capable of stepping up.

Just because 3 million is cheap, doesn’t mean it’s not 3 million wasted. I know we aren’t Barcelona son, but I reserve the right to think this signing is like the Cahill one, short sighted and far below what we should be aiming for having finished a season with our record points tally and selling an academy graduate for 50 million.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 08 Aug 19 2.46pm

Agree with Coulsdon. It’s £3m and £50k a week. That’s £15k more than Luka. 29 years old and a recent broken leg and played 7 games in 2 years.
Should have sorted out the Russian weeks ago.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

new_in_Wait Flag Lewisham 08 Aug 19 2.54pm

Originally posted by kevlee

Agree with Coulsdon. It’s £3m and £50k a week. That’s £15k more than Luka. 29 years old and a recent broken leg and played 7 games in 2 years.
Should have sorted out the Russian weeks ago.

I'm thinking at best he'll match Joe Ledley or Puncheon. He'll give the ball away, get into a lot of tackles because that's part of the job and thus increase his chances of getting injured. maybe score the odd long-range effort in a 2-2 draw with Burnley. you don't build a team around a guy like him.

Roy had a boycrush on him for some reason for a while, and he finally got him. If he's sixth choice central mid, that's fine. But if he keeps Meyer on the bench, I'll have some intricate hand gestures for the bench and the president's lounge.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Aug 19 2.58pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

I don’t agree at all that this guy is worth anywhere close to that 3 million. What f*cking use is premier league experience if it sits in the sick room all season. It’s a waste of money and time because we have pressing positions that need filling. On top of that I think he is absolutely average even before his injuries.

Where is the long term vision in signing an injury prone player in his late 20s in a position that we already have Luka playing in with Kouyate as cover and several other midfielders who are capable of stepping up.

Just because 3 million is cheap, doesn’t mean it’s not 3 million wasted. I know we aren’t Barcelona son, but I reserve the right to think this signing is like the Cahill one, short sighted and far below what we should be aiming for having finished a season with our record points tally and selling an academy graduate for 50 million.

Coulsdoneagle

I concur with the general thrust of these sentiments.
A very good post.Hats off.

Would just like to add that we sold an academy graduate for a sizeable sum,right-back is a key area which needs strengthening and 6 weeks after that sale we still haven't brought anyone in with the window closing in a couple of hours.

Edited by Willo (08 Aug 2019 3.02pm)

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 08 Aug 19 4.03pm

"One Jimmy Mac, there's only one Jimmy Mac"...... D'oh.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 08 Aug 19 6.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

Coulsdoneagle

I concur with the general thrust of these sentiments.
A very good post.Hats off.

Would just like to add that we sold an academy graduate for a sizeable sum,right-back is a key area which needs strengthening and 6 weeks after that sale we still haven't brought anyone in with the window closing in a couple of hours.

Edited by Willo (08 Aug 2019 3.02pm)

You like a good thrust, Willo.

Some fans are never happy. I am the first to criticize Parish and have for years, but there is nothing wrong at all with this signing and time will prove me correct.

People who slate a signing like this dont understand football to my money.

Oh and you are bang on about a right back but dont forget Wardy can do a job there.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 08 Aug 19 9.24pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

F*cking bang average and an absolute sick note. Waste of money. If I was Wilf I would want to leave as well based on our busiest far in the window.

Sick note for Everton bit I agree with but not bang average.. nearly every Everton supporter you speak to will tell you that IF he stays fit he is a quality player.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy