You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Assess the transfer window
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Assess the transfer window


Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
deetee Flag 08 Aug 19 9.53pm

Our priority should have been a striker, someone like Mitrovic. £35 - 40M of the AWB money would have got him.

Sack Freedman, as a spotter of talent he doesn't have a clue.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Aug 19 9.53pm

Originally posted by chris123

I'll sit on the fence for a few games and see how we are set up - but not replacing AWB and Bats is difficult to understand. Wilf can't do it on his own and it looks to me that we start this season with a weaker team than finished last season.

Yep. After all the profligacy we then bought who was available. Now we mainly buy whoever is being chucked out in the rubbish.

The squad is so imbalanced again it’s mad.

 


COYP

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 08 Aug 19 10.03pm

Grossly underwhelming .....
I have to say when I heard that Zaha was staying I was disappointed and I never thought I would say that. A golden opportunity to sell for what appears to be good money and freshen up the side with someone such as Sarr. As it seems it was all smoke and mirrors and through to Aldi closing time. Now RH has the task of trying to motivate Wilf without his toys staying out of the pram. Of course this takes planning which, we are p**s poor at.
As has been said on here today to sign no right back and no centre forward is an utter disgrace.

So the financials .....
Out
AWB. £50m

In
Ayew. £2.5m
McCarthy. £3.0m
Cammy. £1.50m (initial loan fee)
Cahill. Free

Total. £7.0m

Net profit £43.0m

Same ambitions clearly as before....just finish out of the bottom 3!

Happy days for the shareholders and Directors.

 


Bring back Brolin

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 08 Aug 19 10.05pm

Utter tripe of a window Freedman should by sued for robbing a living from the club. No striker again, no right back, we are owned by a penny pinching cretin...almost miss Noades, at least we knew where we stood with him.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 08 Aug 19 10.14pm

According to transfermarkt.com the net spend of each Prem League club is as follows (- figures denote a profit made)

Man City 150 million
United 143
Villa 133
Arsenal 121
Wolves 87
Spurs 74
Brighton 59
Sheff Utd 42
Newcastle 30
West Ham 30
Southampton 26
Bournemouth 20
Everton 20
Leicester 17
Watford 14
Norwich 2
Burnley 0
Liverpool -30
Palace -43
Chelsea -75

We've shown no ambition and it could get worse still if a big European club comes in for Zaha. Hope we sign Sturridge on a free as, at the moment, I do not see where the goals are coming from.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

dreamwaverider Flag London 08 Aug 19 10.17pm

Originally posted by You What

What a terrible transfer window. Why are we getting two midfielders when we needed a right back and a striker!!! What does Freedman do??? We just went for whoever was available on the cheap and not what we needed. We’ve needed a striker for years!!! Unbelievable! This stinks of a take over!

Take over? Great news if true.

 

martinelliff Flag Staffordshire 08 Aug 19 10.33pm

Unlike on Championship Manager signing players is a nightmare especially with all the hangers on looking for their 10%. Unless you throw big money you have not got at a player, who may end up being be a dud anyway. The transfer market is nuts. 74m for Lukaku, the rich man's Adi Akimbyi. Palace have spent beyond their means for the first 5 years in the premier league and have had to reign back spending in the Roy era. It is foolhardy to expect each transfer window to solve all the problems like a majic wand with money we don't have. I would imagine several right backs were sort but we're either injured, overpriced or not interested in joining a mediocre team. I hope we fill any gaps in the squad with academy players like Daly. AWB would never had a chance without our last failure to sign a right back as cover. Zaha only flourished due to Palace being broke and s***e. Reidwald can play emergency cover if they are afraid of adding in a youngster. Enjoy the rollercoaster rather than complain about things we don't have full knowledge about. 90% of clubs are in the same boat and have fans complaining just the same about their lack of quality signings. As long as the team put the effort in the games are there to be won. Hopefully Roy will try something different if his regular setup fails to work. I hope but I don't expect.

Edited by martinelliff (08 Aug 2019 10.53pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Aug 19 10.41pm

Originally posted by CPFC1965

Utter tripe of a window Freedman should by sued for robbing a living from the club. No striker again, no right back, we are owned by a penny pinching cretin...almost miss Noades, at least we knew where we stood with him.

With the utmost respect, one cannot allocate culpability in the direction of Freedman for the current dealings in the transfer window.

 

martinelliff Flag Staffordshire 08 Aug 19 10.50pm

Palace average net spending is 30m per season since promotion. This is currently the only season with a transfer profit of 43m. The wages eat up most of the TV money. Until Palace get more bums on seats, break into Europe, get more TV games or risk a billionaire takeover we have to balance the books. The fate of Bolton, etc awaits who do not.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 08 Aug 19 10.52pm

Originally posted by martinelliff

Unlike on Championship Manager signing players is a nightmare especially with all the hangers on looking for their 10%. Unless you throw big money you have not got at a player, who may end up being be a dud anyway. The transfer market is nuts. 74m for Lukaku, the rich man's Abi Akimbyi. Palace have spent beyond their means for the first 5 years in the premier league and have had to reign back spending in the Roy era. It is foolhardy to expect each transfer window to solve all the problems like a manic wand with money we don't have. I would imagine several right backs were sort but we're either injured, overpriced or not interested in joining a mediocre team. I hope we fill any gaps in the squad with academy players like Daly. AWB would never had a chance without our last failure to sign a right back as cover. Zaha only flourished due to Palace being broke and s***e. Reidwald can play emergency cover if they are afraid of adding in a youngster. Enjoy the rollercoaster rather than complain about things we don't have full knowledge about. 90% of clubs are in the same boat and have fans complaining just the same about their lack of quality signings. As long as the team put the effort in the games are there to be won. Hopefully Roy will try something different if his regular setup fails to work. I hope but I don't expect.

Sorry, you cannot say that the club have not had time to find players to fill holes in the squad that have been there for several years. You cannot say it is too hard to recruit when teams that were around us last season have managed to improve their squads. You cannot argue that the average age of the squad hasn't actually got older in the transfer window or that any of the players we have signed will have any re-sale value, Finally we have a number of players with one year left on their contracts who haven't signed new contracts and will walk away for free at the end of this season which surely is just terrible management.

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 08 Aug 19 10.57pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the utmost respect, one cannot allocate culpability in the direction of Freedman for the current dealings in the transfer window.

Absolutely, we have no idea what constraints were given in this window. Of course we all want a striker a left back the list never ends.

But maybe we’re in the crap financially, no backing from owners so no transfer cash , we have to sell to get back in the black a fact.

DF and SP may well of played a blinder bringing in 5 players for less than we pissed up the wall with Sorloth, face the facts we can’t carry on losing cash like we were, it’s club suicide if we go down.

So what if Br1-3ton spent 59 mill, they will finish below us as will Sheffield, Villa , and 3 or 4 more.

We actually have a better team than we give ourselves credit for, we just need RH to find a way to get our forward line working.

Time to put this to bed and get behind the team Saturday, and let’s beat that s***ty scouse team and that tosser of a manager they have.

 

martinelliff Flag Staffordshire 08 Aug 19 11.03pm

I am not saying the lack of signing a right back or a spare striker does not matter. Ideally they would have kept AWB so would not have needed one. I am merely pointing out we do not have a clue what goes on. I have tried my socks off to buy a dayvan on eBay but some bugger or other always outbids me. The wife is constantly moaning that I am equally as inept as Dougie etc. If I had money to burn I'd have a van now and would be off to the beach every month, but I am poor and so have to search for scraps with everyone else.

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 08 Aug 19 11.05pm

Originally posted by martinelliff

I am not saying the lack of signing a right back or a spare striker does not matter. Ideally they would have kept AWB so would not have needed one. I am merely pointing out we do not have a clue what goes on. I have tried my socks off to buy a dayvan on eBay but some bugger or other always outbids me. The wife is constantly moaning that I am equally as inept as Dougie etc. If I had money to burn I'd have a van now and would be off to the beach every month, but I am poor and so have to search for scraps with everyone else.

Dam I just sold my T4 all tricked out .. would of been perfect

 

Mattyp20uk Flag Rainham (Kent) 08 Aug 19 11.12pm

Not getting a new right back is the worst thing about the transfer window for me as it was obvious that we were never going to spend £30m+ on trying to get the bat back or risk throwing more money away on unproven Championship striker or the likes of Augustin whose stats in Germany are not exactly that great against what we have already. Yet again not even using our 2 domestic loans seems odd as we can all see positions we are light in even if it meant giving game time to a youngster from one of the top 6 ahead of our own. Would also like to know how Bournemouth, Watford and now even Brighton can spend the amounts of money they are on players every summer yet we are constantly balancing books or at supposed risk of breaching FFP?

 

martinelliff Flag Staffordshire 08 Aug 19 11.13pm

I bet the agent fees would have made the deal fall through

Originally posted by kev64

Dam I just sold my T4 all tricked out .. would of been perfect

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 08 Aug 19 11.17pm

£43 million up and that doesn’t take in to account any of the £100m TV money we haven’t spent.

Considering normally we spend £30m on players we’re actually £73m better off...

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 08 Aug 19 11.24pm

Got some good players in so I'm happy and looking forward to the season.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 08 Aug 19 11.28pm

A couple of years ago SP said that we should be aiming higher. To do that you need to speculate, not buy 4 ageing rejects, with 1 decent addition. 2-3 years ago I thought we had a team that was a couple of players light of getting close to Europe. Now we are hoping we can survive.

With ageing players, players with contracts expiring and not a pot to do the proverbial in, I think we could be in League 1 within 2-3 years. This was the window where we had to try and reverse the trend after a few of cost cutting. We didn’t and if we do survive we won’t be a good option for anyone to join unless we are prepared to invest.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 08 Aug 19 11.47pm

A failure. No RB, no striker, no LB, no winger (Ayew doesn't count). Camarasa is good, McCarthy will be a fans favourite I think but Cahill is past it and Ayew is only good for pressing. Henderson is a s*** keeper as well but who cares, he'll never play. A real lack of ambition permeates this miserable summer

3/10

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 09 Aug 19 3.44am

Ok so this window sucked - bit time. What with the Wilf BS and losing AWB and getting no cover for LB or RB it's not good.

But....

We as fans have no idea what's going on behind the scenes. One thin SP did say when 2010 save the club was that we'd never be in that position again under his watch. So for my reading 'between the lines' its not a lack of ambition that's held us back but a lack of funds. Whether that's because the Yanks want out and need to get paid or because we've overspent to stay in the 'lodsadosh' league I don't know.

We're weakened, down on the canvas and hurting. Good - that's when we fire up the Palace spirit! If not then it's back to the Championship!

The first 5 or 6 games will be a good indication - COYP!

Its never easy as a Palace fan (of 53 years)....

 

Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Assess the transfer window