You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > HS2 Review
November 21 2026 9.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

HS2 Review


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 26 Sep 23 8.31am

HS2 has always looked like a phenomenal waste of money just to save a few minutes on the train journey to Manchester.

Osborne and Hestletine claim that stopping the project will cause irreparable damage to the North. How? Far better to spend the money on new hospitals.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Sep 23 11.49am

I used to look forward to my trip from Euston to Birmingham, the relaxed feeling of comfort and following the Grand Union Canal, at the other end just a step to my destination.

It felt like an experience each time, there's something about a train journey.

And its dying.

The death of the ticket office, soulless contactless world, automatic machines (often not working) connections miles from anywhere no help but talk into this machine.

And these days you can probably do the work from your office anyway.

If this had been what the brochures initially described a streamlined national project connecting us to the regions, to the airport and Europe, if it was actually deliverable, I would have been its greatest supporter.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Sep 23 11.58am

Originally posted by georgenorman

We should certainly abolish the Welsh and Scottish parliaments.

My brain agrees with you but my heart says no. When ever people point out how badly the country is doing under the Tories I say look to the Socialist paradises of Scotland and Wales.

Nah let's keep them the latest wheeze 20mph speed limit in Wales, I hear the locals love it , still they voted for them.

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 26 Sep 23 12.02pm

Good few years ago since I last went on a train and then it was crowded and a fairly unpleasant experience with ridiculously confusing ticket prices and unhelpful staff.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Sep 23 12.08pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Good few years ago since I last went on a train and then it was crowded and a fairly unpleasant experience with ridiculously confusing ticket prices and unhelpful staff.

Oh so you've met the hard working loyal dedicated train staff then. You probably didn't meet the Guard they are far too busy hiding in their little cubby hole

 


One more point

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 26 Sep 23 1.00pm

Andy Burnham grandstanding he will sue the Govt, really. Who will sue who for what exactly?

Are Manchester council tax payers keen to fund a massive court case.

I would bin HS2 and spend some money immediately on connectivity between Northern and Midland cities, some in the South West and system wide electrification.

Old Oak Common station is probably too advanced to scrap but should be repurposed to fit in with existing lines only.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 26 Sep 23 1.03pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Oh so you've met the hard working loyal dedicated train staff then. You probably didn't meet the Guard they are far too busy hiding in their little cubby hole

It's fair to say when I have been on rail in the UK recently, quite a lot in 2023 there seem to be a lot of staff standing around or sitting about not doing very much. Clapham Junction, St Pancras, Kings Cross.

The staff at Selhurst and Norwood Junction are very busy whenever I am there.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 26 Sep 23 1.42pm

More cash stripped out of the public coffers - nothing more, nothing less.

This governments only remaining ambition is to get their hands on as much taxpayer money as they can get away with before they inevitably lose power.

China have built 20,000 miles of high speed rail infrastructure in the time that we have failed to build 140 miles.

China’s cost $17-21m per km. Mainland Europe have built similar projects at $25-39m per km.

HS2 is costing $475m per km.

India have landed a rover on the moon for $75m. The planning application alone for the Lower Thames Crossing costs four and half times that.

It’s all a racket.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 27 Sep 23 10.20am

In the south at least you will normally have a good train service with enough trains and quite punctual if not always.

Not so in the north, you're lucky if you get either of those.

So why are northern mayors not addressing this, but instead forming alliances in favour of HS2 to Manchester a money-pit with no benefit except to vanity.

Think of a number and double it, 180 billions I have seen, that's HS2 but it just doesn't do anything much anyway.

In fact as Khan points out today the service to London is going to be considerably longer than at present due to the new station.

It is an embarrassment and there is enormous reputational damage to the country in addition to all the devastation.

The PM, Sunak seems to agree that the British are not much cop and that seems to be the basis of his announcements.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 Sep 23 10.52am

The problem with HS2 was doing it in the first place when the money could have been spent better elsewhere.
The north does not use public transport like we do in London. It does however suffer from poor connections between northern towns, which might explain some reluctance to use it. That is where the money should be spent

That said, stopping HS2 when it is half built seems like compounding one bad idea with another.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 27 Sep 23 8.38pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

More cash stripped out of the public coffers - nothing more, nothing less.

This governments only remaining ambition is to get their hands on as much taxpayer money as they can get away with before they inevitably lose power.

China have built 20,000 miles of high speed rail infrastructure in the time that we have failed to build 140 miles.

China’s cost -21m per km. Mainland Europe have built similar projects at -39m per km.

HS2 is costing 5m per km.

India have landed a rover on the moon for m. The planning application alone for the Lower Thames Crossing costs four and half times that.

It’s all a racket.

It’s the planning process that’s the problem and it’s not going to be easy to solve because doing what ought to be done, and over-riding objections in order to reduce costs and speed delivery, would be so politically unpopular that no government will do it.

The only way is a consensus between all the political parties to agree to do this, which will not happen with our present system. So we are stuck until we change it.

If you have ever had to fight your way through the planning process you will understand what a nightmare of stupidity it is.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Sep 23 1.02pm

'The relationship between those profiting from these big projects and those in power is such that no one truly costs or controls them'.

How true, and HS2 has never even had a budget.

It really looks like you hand your chit in and the civil servants or tory ministers just carry on doling you out.

It is a gravy train and nobody is even mentioning getting the taxpayers money back.

That would just be ridiculous.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 28 Sep 23 3.09pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It’s the planning process that’s the problem and it’s not going to be easy to solve because doing what ought to be done, and over-riding objections in order to reduce costs and speed delivery, would be so politically unpopular that no government will do it.

The only way is a consensus between all the political parties to agree to do this, which will not happen with our present system. So we are stuck until we change it.

If you have ever had to fight your way through the planning process you will understand what a nightmare of stupidity it is.


Edited by Forest Hillbilly (29 Sep 2023 7.33am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 29 Sep 23 7.32am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Planning played little part in the mega fck-up. A convenient smoke screen for total financial and Governmental mismanagement.

The Government knew well in advance what the Planning Regulations were. The Regulations haven't changed. What do you suggest ? Because Planning Regulations are (allegedly) inconvenient in this instance, we should change the law ? And (for example) move homes onto contaminated land ? As Boris used to refer to inconvenient laws as "red tape". Planning Regulations are there to protect the existing environment and regulate for quality developments.
Perhaps you were one of the people that wanted the age of consent raised to 18, just for the Russell Brand allegations ? You can't change the law just because it doesn't suit your view in one particular instance.
Laws and Regulations are there to protect people and property.

much like the Gas Appliances Regulations, which some people choose to ignore.


 


I disengage, I turn the page.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Sep 23 10.43am

HS2 must be completed. People said the same about the big white tent in Greenwich, the M25 and other major projects. Yes you can build schools and hospitals with the money but then the ongoing costs of those will need finding. As a country the infrastructure is vitally important. If rail or road or waterways etc. progress costs and if not now the railways will need to be replaced at some stage as they are wearing out. This would be the start of those projects.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Sep 23 11.27am

Not intended to be whataboutery but an example of costs over running in other places as well.

[Link]

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 Sep 23 11.34am

Originally posted by cryrst

HS2 must be completed. People said the same about the big white tent in Greenwich, the M25 and other major projects. Yes you can build schools and hospitals with the money but then the ongoing costs of those will need finding. As a country the infrastructure is vitally important. If rail or road or waterways etc. progress costs and if not now the railways will need to be replaced at some stage as they are wearing out. This would be the start of those projects.

The infrastructure of the country in particular the rail network, is not improved, but reduced, by HS2.


 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 29 Sep 23 1.21pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The infrastructure of the country in particular the rail network, is not improved, but reduced, by HS2.


Agreed, lunatic project.

 

nobody Flag sussex 04 Oct 23 10.07am

Now that we know what Rishi has decided on this subject it will be interesting to see if the Beeb and outher media start pressing Starmer on whether he will re instate it.

Much squirming at Labout HQ I expect

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 04 Oct 23 11.36am

Originally posted by steeleye20

The infrastructure of the country in particular the rail network, is not improved, but reduced, by HS2.

Agreed. Nonsense project just so folk on a train can arrive in Leeds a few minutes earlier than existing train. Anyway, we don't have the same amount of room in our countryside for huge infrastructure compared with France, Spain and other countries used as examples.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > HS2 Review