Putitout Oxford 01 Mar 21 2.55pm |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Agree with much of this. But in my view it is the manager’s job to set us up in a way to get the best out of Eze and Riedewald. Clearly the current method does not suit them from observation of recent games. If we were persist with this way of playing Mcarthy would be a more suitable choice in midfield with his tackling and robust approach. It would be a shame though that a way could not be found to accommodate two of our better footballers.
Thing is , if we actually went out with no intention of getting at the opposition, then take those two out straight away. I agree. Buts that’s the point, they are only in the side to hurt the opposition, and when they don’t it’s not because we are set up wrong, it’s because they in particular are not doing what they were actually sent out to do. That’s not to say they should not get into defensive positions, but it does require them to be capable of getting into attacking mode far better than they do. LC, and Cabaye, could both drop in when needed, LC still does for Fulham, Someone mentioned Gallagher, he does, or can. The fact is these two are thought to be two of our better players, and it’s for them to show how good they are, if oppositions can prevent them playing out ,as consistently as has been the case in recent weeks, it’s them that have answer the questions.
|
PatrickA London 01 Mar 21 3.29pm |
|
|
I understand your point about the onus being on the players. But in fairness we have so many players behind the ball what are their options for forward passes or building momentum? Ayew does not run in behind defences or seek to play wall passes.He’s the original head down merchant. Townsend is conscientious in his defensive work but is no longer a threat in the final third apart from the occasional flourish. Benteke is not a mobile forward or one who runs the channels. So inevitably Eze and Riedewald have a lack of options when looking forward. Perhaps this will improve with the return of Zaha and Schlupp. Originally posted by Putitout
Thing is , if we actually went out with no intention of getting at the opposition, then take those two out straight away. I agree. Buts that’s the point, they are only in the side to hurt the opposition, and when they don’t it’s not because we are set up wrong, it’s because they in particular are not doing what they were actually sent out to do. That’s not to say they should not get into defensive positions, but it does require them to be capable of getting into attacking mode far better than they do. LC, and Cabaye, could both drop in when needed, LC still does for Fulham, Someone mentioned Gallagher, he does, or can. The fact is these two are thought to be two of our better players, and it’s for them to show how good they are, if oppositions can prevent them playing out ,as consistently as has been the case in recent weeks, it’s them that have answer the questions.
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 02 Mar 21 10.14am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I understand your point about the onus being on the players. But in fairness we have so many players behind the ball what are their options for forward passes or building momentum? Ayew does not run in behind defences or seek to play wall passes.He’s the original head down merchant. Townsend is conscientious in his defensive work but is no longer a threat in the final third apart from the occasional flourish. Benteke is not a mobile forward or one who runs the channels. So inevitably Eze and Riedewald have a lack of options when looking forward. Perhaps this will improve with the return of Zaha and Schlupp.
Neither looked very effective on Sunday. The whole midfield area looked congested and neither seem to make any space for themselves. On another note Guaita's kicks just seemed to be kicking into that area as well.
Edited by Booted Eagle (02 Mar 2021 10.18am)
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
palace99 New Mills 02 Mar 21 11.03am |
|
Originally posted by Putitout
The mid field containing Loftus, Cheek, Cabaye, was in a totally different class to what we have now. Replicate what they brought to the side , and the problems we are having right now would be over to a fair degree. What we have now has not got the ability to transition play under pressure into the opposition half . Luca, is principally there to break opposition moves up, it doesn’t make him a fan favourite, and probably never will , because he doesn’t even have to win the ball to achieve that. The others though have to offer far more than just bolstering Lucas, work. Riedewald , Eze, are not proving effective when closed down well, in doing what they should if we are ever going to set up any sort of effective attacking play. It’s not that the are not capable of looking the part if allowed, we have seen both come good when allowed, but to many sides have been able to close these two down to the point were their best contribution is standing in front of the defence, confronting the ball now again , not often winning it though. Jimmy Mac, gives it a go when fit, but the edge is coming off this 34 year old. It’s definitely not a case of being told not to attempt breaking out of defensive positions, but a simple case of not having the where with all to do it at this moment, disappointing all round.
Loftus and Cheek are the same player! We could have got him in the summer but chose Batman instead! Cabeye was IMHO over rated and the few good games overshadowed some pretty average performances.
My point is we could still play a similar pass and move style we did then - Eze could play the RLC role for example. Obviously Zaha was key to that formation but the players are not massively different. Google the goals from that game - the 1st and 2nd were exceptional, quick passing and movement around the box
|
Eaglecoops CR3 02 Mar 21 11.24am |
|
Originally posted by palace99
Loftus and Cheek are the same player! We could have got him in the summer but chose Batman instead! Cabeye was IMHO over rated and the few good games overshadowed some pretty average performances.
My point is we could still play a similar pass and move style we did then - Eze could play the RLC role for example. Obviously Zaha was key to that formation but the players are not massively different. Google the goals from that game - the 1st and 2nd were exceptional, quick passing and movement around the box
We were after Gallagher in the window and he even had his medical but moved to Bats as we obviously decided a CF was more important.
Cabaye was not over rated. He was understated if anything. You watch him and think he is doing very little but look at his stats at the end of the game and he was invariably the top of the stats for interceptions and passes completed. Whenever he was injured we looked a worse team and we have never managed to replace him.
RLC and Gallagher would transform our midfield although I’m sure there are a number of others who could fulfill the roles where we require a bit of youthful exuberance and pace.
|
Putitout Oxford 02 Mar 21 11.53am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I understand your point about the onus being on the players. But in fairness we have so many players behind the ball what are their options for forward passes or building momentum? Ayew does not run in behind defences or seek to play wall passes.He’s the original head down merchant. Townsend is conscientious in his defensive work but is no longer a threat in the final third apart from the occasional flourish. Benteke is not a mobile forward or one who runs the channels. So inevitably Eze and Riedewald have a lack of options when looking forward. Perhaps this will improve with the return of Zaha and Schlupp.
Their lack of options is a fair point, as it is a team game. I mentioned them being pressured by the opposition, and not coping with that . But it’s true to say , that when it comes to being truly creative under pressure there isn’t much throughout the team and that creates pressure of sorts in its self.. Zaha, and Schlupp, do give more in the way of outlets,. But both Readwalde, and Eze, have consistently not been able to make much happen unless the opposition stand off them. If you can’t as a team close the opponent down, high up the pitch putting the pressure on them to play out then the boot is on your own foot. Then it’s a matter of how well you deal with the pressure coming your way ..So it’s not all their fault, it’s happening , but as we see at times they don’t always cope that well. In taking play into the opposition half. Sometimes virtually non existent. The head down approach of Ayew, is hardly surprising , because all to often he is coming deep and having to carry, when quiet honestly the midfield should be making it possible to receive the ball far further up the pitch with more options around him. Even when that has been achieved , and it does happen, another failure area comes into play ball retention. It’s not good enough, and the pressure is back on.
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 02 Mar 21 12.00pm |
|
|
Ayew not doing enough, works his socks off every game and takes foul after foul for the team.
Respectfully disagree 100%
Originally posted by doombear
Agreed. Between them, Eze, Townsend and Ayew aren't doing enough. In fact I wonder whether we would be better dropping Eze and one of the other two, moving Riedewald further forward and playing both McCarthy and Kouyate alongside Luka in midfield with Kelly in at CB.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
Putitout Oxford 02 Mar 21 12.14pm |
|
Originally posted by palace99
Loftus and Cheek are the same player! We could have got him in the summer but chose Batman instead! Cabeye was IMHO over rated and the few good games overshadowed some pretty average performances.
My point is we could still play a similar pass and move style we did then - Eze could play the RLC role for example. Obviously Zaha was key to that formation but the players are not massively different. Google the goals from that game - the 1st and 2nd were exceptional, quick passing and movement around the box
Yes we know who he is. If we could we would play the same way as we did with LC, and Cabaye in the side.The fact is we don’t. It may well be Eze, was expected to give something of LC, to the team, I say something because they are not the same players, Eze, is nowhere near as advanced in development as Loftus, and it shows. Eze , is appearing to be a little limited in some aspects, if we had Gallagher, along with him it might start to work. Hodgson, encouraged Loftus, to international caps, man of the match contributions,. He said , how Roy had helped him develop,. It’s hardly likely Roy is holding Eze, back. If it’s there it will happen.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Mar 21 12.22pm |
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Ayew not doing enough, works his socks off every game and takes foul after foul for the team.
Respectfully disagree 100%
Probably didn't make myself clear. I accept Ayew works his socks off and gives his all. What I was trying to say was that between them, Eze, Townsend and Ayew aren't ACHIEVING enough. - Eze looks lost most of the time the way we've been playing recently. - Townsend has lost what pace he had and whilst he puts in half-decent performances from time to time, his final ball or decision making is often poor. - As for Ayew, as has been said, he's often too deep when he picks up the ball and has little option but to put his head down and run forward until he gets fouled. We need him to receive the ball further forward, but in order to achieve that we need someone playing in a more forward midfield position who is comfortable on the ball and can see a forward pass. I'd be interested to see how Jairo would perform in that role.
|
Palace Old Geezer Midhurst 02 Mar 21 12.31pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
Probably didn't make myself clear. I accept Ayew works his socks off and gives his all. What I was trying to say was that between them, Eze, Townsend and Ayew aren't ACHIEVING enough. - Eze looks lost most of the time the way we've been playing recently. - Townsend has lost what pace he had and whilst he puts in half-decent performances from time to time, his final ball or decision making is often poor. - As for Ayew, as has been said, he's often too deep when he picks up the ball and has little option but to put his head down and run forward until he gets fouled. We need him to receive the ball further forward, but in order to achieve that we need someone playing in a more forward midfield position who is comfortable on the ball and can see a forward pass. I'd be interested to see how Jairo would perform in that role.
I agree with this assessment Doom.
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 02 Mar 21 12.57pm |
|
|
I am no expert so can't talk to your points technically.
For me Ayew always puts in great shift, scores some belters and generally doesn't get the credit he deserves.
Andros hasn't really featured enough for comparison, was interested Tekkers saying he did much better when Andros crossed from the left.
Eze has skill and flair to spare, great delivery of dead ball, but even I can see if we set up in a certain way he has to run around in circles looking to make an impact.
When he and Wilf play together on the left that's full of promise and excitement
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
palace99 New Mills 02 Mar 21 1.08pm |
|
Originally posted by Putitout
Yes we know who he is. If we could we would play the same way as we did with LC, and Cabaye in the side.The fact is we don’t. It may well be Eze, was expected to give something of LC, to the team, I say something because they are not the same players, Eze, is nowhere near as advanced in development as Loftus, and it shows. Eze , is appearing to be a little limited in some aspects, if we had Gallagher, along with him it might start to work. Hodgson, encouraged Loftus, to international caps, man of the match contributions,. He said , how Roy had helped him develop,. It’s hardly likely Roy is holding Eze, back. If it’s there it will happen.
The mid field containing Loftus, Cheek, Cabaye, was in a totally different class to what we have now.
Says the guy who previously typed "Loftus, Cheek, Cabeye" - listing 3 players when only 2 exist !!!
|
Eaglecoops CR3 02 Mar 21 1.22pm |
|
Originally posted by palace99
The mid field containing Loftus, Cheek, Cabaye, was in a totally different class to what we have now.
Says the guy who previously typed "Loftus, Cheek, Cabeye" - listing 3 players when only 2 exist !!!
Oh dear, the punctuation police are out. Why post that, you know exactly what he meant.
|
Mstrobez 02 Mar 21 1.24pm |
|
Originally posted by palace99
The mid field containing Loftus, Cheek, Cabaye, was in a totally different class to what we have now.
Says the guy who previously typed "Loftus, Cheek, Cabeye" - listing 3 players when only 2 exist !!!
Forget the midfield, the squad containing Cabaye & Loftus Cheek was different class to what we have now. Primarily because it was a lot younger & has had very limited investment since then. This is evidenced in the performances under Roy in his first season at the club which were, at times, very good & disprove the notion that he is just another Big Sam or Pulis.
We're the Arthur over ere!
|
Putitout Oxford 02 Mar 21 2.00pm |
|
Originally posted by palace99
The mid field containing Loftus, Cheek, Cabaye, was in a totally different class to what we have now.
Says the guy who previously typed "Loftus, Cheek, Cabeye" - listing 3 players when only 2 exist !!!
Yes it was a poor effort , even for on the run ,off the cuff response. But if you come on this football site , looking for perfection your not likely to get it either in English language , or in the way Palace go about business on the pitch. Any way I don’t come on here to criticise other peoples literary efforts . Maybe their football knowledge in a mild manner.. But then football is name of the game on this site.
|
silvertop Portishead 02 Mar 21 2.09pm |
|
Originally posted by Putitout
Yes we know who he is. If we could we would play the same way as we did with LC, and Cabaye in the side.The fact is we don’t. It may well be Eze, was expected to give something of LC, to the team, I say something because they are not the same players, Eze, is nowhere near as advanced in development as Loftus, and it shows. Eze , is appearing to be a little limited in some aspects, if we had Gallagher, along with him it might start to work. Hodgson, encouraged Loftus, to international caps, man of the match contributions,. He said , how Roy had helped him develop,. It’s hardly likely Roy is holding Eze, back. If it’s there it will happen.
Needs Wilf?
|
Putitout Oxford 02 Mar 21 2.27pm |
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Forget the midfield, the squad containing Cabaye & Loftus Cheek was different class to what we have now. Primarily because it was a lot younger & has had very limited investment since then. This is evidenced in the performances under Roy in his first season at the club which were, at times, very good & disprove the notion that he is just another Big Sam or Pulis.
This is the point that the Roy, out, people conveniently overlook .when he has had the players able to carry it off he doesn’t send sides out to not get at the opposition at every opportunity. The fact is if we have just two or three key players missing at any one time our attacking options are drastically reduced. There is little doubt we need more out of what’s available in respect of attacking play. It’s never not asked for or not wanted. From a managerial point of view it’s lucky he can get a good effort rate out of them most times. And they know how not to lose to often.
|
Eaglehamster Storrington 02 Mar 21 3.08pm |
|
|
What seems to stand out for me is lack of planning to have so many contracts expiring simultaneously. It has the distinct look of a disaster waiting to happen.
There seem to be many players we'd like to lose but will have to offer new contracts to.
I hope that it's an opportunity to blood some youngsters into the squad (some hope).
I think it'll need some careful and inspired management to come out the other side with a decent squad.
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 02 Mar 21 3.14pm |
|
Originally posted by Putitout
This is the point that the Roy, out, people conveniently overlook .when he has had the players able to carry it off he doesn’t send sides out to not get at the opposition at every opportunity. The fact is if we have just two or three key players missing at any one time our attacking options are drastically reduced. There is little doubt we need more out of what’s available in respect of attacking play. It’s never not asked for or not wanted. From a managerial point of view it’s lucky he can get a good effort rate out of them most times. And they know how not to lose to often.
It’s a rather damning indictment of the rest of the team that Schlupp, Zaha and McArthur out means we go from being a competitive side to one which barely leaves its own half even though we have just spent £16m-£20m on Eze and looking to spend a similar amount on Mateta and having taken one of Belgium’s top strikers on loan.
If this is the case why has our recent transfer business been in none of the positions where we are currently desperately short?
|
taylors lovechild 02 Mar 21 3.14pm |
|
|
Because of the way we are setting up with a low block when we get the ball the players are too close to each other and there is little opportunity to stretch the opposition. This means we either look for a quick break with one or two players carrying the ball 50+-yards upfield, we hit it long in hope, or we end up passing sideways and backwards until the opposition has had plenty of time to recover and get men behind the ball. The opposition also know that they can simply foul Eze, Andros or Ayew inside our own half to limit any threat on the counter. It might be crude, but it seems highly effective and something we often have no answer to.
If we had a big man up top who could make the ball stick this could help us get out, but we do have a severe lack of pace meaning there is often a huge gap between the forward(s) and the midfield (again due to the low block). There also seems to be a distinct lack of movement when we are in possession meaning our more creative players often end up going backwards due to a lack of options. This is one of the most significant things that goes missing when Wilf is out, as he goes looking for the ball and looks for the best ways to link things up.
It's difficult as when we were a bit more expansive for a few games we conceded a lot of goals and looked so open. Probably the most important area we need to look at for next season is adding pace through the middle both in defence and midfield as until we do that we will struggle to play higher up the pitch without being exposed.
|