You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Marcus Rashford
November 21 2026 9.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Marcus Rashford


Page 5 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 1.16pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

I have the answer to solve all these problems and it’s really quite simple.

If you can’t afford to bring up kids, don’t have them!

At least until you can afford to.

Why people have kids when they don’t even have work is beyond me.

Solves nothing for the children currently living with hunger. What will you do for them?

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Oct 20 1.25pm

[Link]

Isn’t a lot of this already happening?

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Oct 20 1.42pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

A hungry child needs a meal not a lecture on quantitive easing.

No ones saying the don't. The discussion is over how it should be funded to get best value. With a side point about how the left are more interested in chucking cheap insults around rather than seeing what the best way to solve to problem would be.

Your wilful ignorance of of understanding basic funding mechanisms shows how stupid the populist virtue signalling over this issue is.

I suggest you read back through my comments.

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Oct 20 1.51pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This.

MPs, on their recently-increased £80k salary, get a £25 per day food allowance and we’re happy to fund that, but we draw the line at starving kids.

How does one square that off?

£80k if f*** all compared to the responsibilities, job security, and exposure MP's have.

The reason MP's were paid in the first place was to make it more accessible for people who have the means to do the job for free.

I think it should be doubled. The Labour Party stand to benefit the most as it will attract better candidates.

Corbyn, Blair, Cameron, and Johnson all come from wealthy families (although 3 of them had successful careers before entering politics).

If you want decent talent, you have to pay for it.

£25 is the standard allowance for any lunch claimed on expenses. It's set by HMRC.

More populist nonsense.


 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 2.19pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

£80k if f*** all compared to the responsibilities, job security, and exposure MP's have.

The reason MP's were paid in the first place was to make it more accessible for people who have the means to do the job for free.

I think it should be doubled. The Labour Party stand to benefit the most as it will attract better candidates.

Corbyn, Blair, Cameron, and Johnson all come from wealthy families (although 3 of them had successful careers before entering politics).

If you want decent talent, you have to pay for it.

£25 is the standard allowance for any lunch claimed on expenses. It's set by HMRC.

More populist nonsense.


You are terribly confused

MPs' pay and Ministers pay are not the same

Those in positions to make decisions are paid £104k minimum plus generous expenses provisions. Secretaries of State are paid £149,437.
The Prime Minister £154,908.

In addition having been in Government, people almost always earn hugely once they leave their roles. For some reason the experience is regarded as valuable.

£25 is not the standard lunch allowance. It happens to be the maximum you can claim for subsistence without paying tax on a BIK if you are travelling for more than 15 hours. If it is just lunch, the maximum rate is £10.

 

DanH Flag SW2 23 Oct 20 2.33pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

I have the answer to solve all these problems and it’s really quite simple.

If you can’t afford to bring up kids, don’t have them!

At least until you can afford to.

Why people have kids when they don’t even have work is beyond me.

So you're meant to guarantee a steady job and income for all 18 years of a child's life before you have one?

What about people who have lost their job or having to live off a % of their wages through no fault of their own during the pandemic?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 23 Oct 20 2.33pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

It seems that you know the price of everything and the value of nothing.

As every good cynic should.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 2.35pm

Originally posted by DanH

So you're meant to guarantee a steady job and income for all 18 years of a child's life before you have one?

What about people who have lost their job or having to live off a % of their wages through no fault of their own during the pandemic?

According to the CPAG, the cost of raising a child (excluding housing, childcare and council tax) from birth to 18 is now: £75,436 for a couple family. £102,627 for a single parent/guardian.

So it's very simple really, once the money is in the bank account you can unlock.

Edited by Mapletree (23 Oct 2020 2.37pm)

Cage.jpg Attachment: Cage.jpg (15.80Kb)

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Oct 20 2.55pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

You are terribly confused

MPs' pay and Ministers pay are not the same

Those in positions to make decisions are paid £104k minimum plus generous expenses provisions. Secretaries of State are paid £149,437.
The Prime Minister £154,908.

In addition having been in Government, people almost always earn hugely once they leave their roles. For some reason the experience is regarded as valuable.

£25 is not the standard lunch allowance. It happens to be the maximum you can claim for subsistence without paying tax on a BIK if you are travelling for more than 15 hours. If it is just lunch, the maximum rate is £10.

Thanks for the clarification but splitting hairs I feel.

The point is that it's the same old argument shouting MP's get paid to much, when the Chartist campaigned for MP's to get paid to reduce barriers to entry.

Compared to their private sector counterparts its peanuts. Hence, why government and civil service is full of so many duds.

Same with the PM's earnings after standing down, it's the barrier to entry that's the problem.

If it were to be doubled it might de-risk the job for more talented applicants (and make them exempt from tax on to remove the conflict of interest when it comes to raising tax for high earners).

Can't wait till tomorrows game so I can get back to concentrating about important issues.

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Oct 20 3.08pm

Originally posted by Mapletree
According to the CPAG, the cost of raising a child (excluding housing, childcare and council tax) from birth to 18 is now: £75,436 for a couple family. £102,627 for a single parent/guardian.

So it's very simple really, once the money is in the bank account you can unlock.

Edited by Mapletree (23 Oct 2020 2.37pm)

A stick and carrot approach that's likely to motivate the masses and create huge increases in productivity to record levels. Although, I wouldn't like to see your search history

Also, much more likely to make teenagers work hard in school thus stopping people falling into poverty.

Seems like a harsh system, but we used to tell people who had children outside of wedlock that they would face eternal damnation.... so rather progressive in context.

One could also ask, if this is cruel, isn't it crueller to bring a child into the world that you can't afford. You wouldn't be allowed a puppy you can't afford.

Would you be willing to settle for a mortgage based system with affordability checks based on a credit rating?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 3.30pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Thanks for the clarification but splitting hairs I feel.

The point is that it's the same old argument shouting MP's get paid to much, when the Chartist campaigned for MP's to get paid to reduce barriers to entry.

Compared to their private sector counterparts its peanuts. Hence, why government and civil service is full of so many duds.

Same with the PM's earnings after standing down, it's the barrier to entry that's the problem.

If it were to be doubled it might de-risk the job for more talented applicants (and make them exempt from tax on to remove the conflict of interest when it comes to raising tax for high earners).

Can't wait till tomorrows game so I can get back to concentrating about important issues.

I didn't say I think they are overpaid. But I don't think they are underpaid. Effectively they work in the Not for Profit sector. And I repeat, if you are successful you will get a big pay-day later. Many MPs are only worth £82k on the other hand. Plus of course a final salary pension scheme, gold dust in this day and age.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 3.32pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

A stick and carrot approach that's likely to motivate the masses and create huge increases in productivity to record levels. Although, I wouldn't like to see your search history

Also, much more likely to make teenagers work hard in school thus stopping people falling into poverty.

Seems like a harsh system, but we used to tell people who had children outside of wedlock that they would face eternal damnation.... so rather progressive in context.

One could also ask, if this is cruel, isn't it crueller to bring a child into the world that you can't afford. You wouldn't be allowed a puppy you can't afford.

Would you be willing to settle for a mortgage based system with affordability checks based on a credit rating?

I really like the idea that if you can't afford your children they get repossessed and sold on.

Alternatively you could pay into some form of income protection scheme like with a mortgage so you don't lose them if you lose your job. We could call it, I don't know, how about 'National Insurance'?

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 4.22pm

Originally posted by DanH

So you're meant to guarantee a steady job and income for all 18 years of a child's life before you have one?

What about people who have lost their job or having to live off a % of their wages through no fault of their own during the pandemic?

Nope, that’s not what I said at all, is it.

If you lose your job etc that is entirely different. But why have kids if you don’t work? Some girls I know have gone on to have many kids and yet they have literally never done a days paid work in their life!

All these kids have to be paid for. Parents need to take responsibility for their own children.

One day Dan you and your boyfriend may wish to adopt, I just hope you will be responsible daddies.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

jeeagles Flag 23 Oct 20 4.38pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I really like the idea that if you can't afford your children they get repossessed and sold on.

Alternatively you could pay into some form of income protection scheme like with a mortgage so you don't lose them if you lose your job. We could call it, I don't know, how about 'National Insurance'?

Excellent plan. Effectively, social services can repossess a child at the moment but the powers they have aren't strong enough. We just need better regulation of the parenting. Like what happened to the banks in 2008.

Problem solved through hard work and creativity you'd expect from Palace. Up yours Marcus Rashford. Stop trying to cover up crap performances with stupid ideas. School's should concentrate on teaching. You should concentrate on football. 3-1

Edited by jeeagles (23 Oct 2020 4.45pm)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 23 Oct 20 4.46pm

You can buy a medium sized chicken for £2.95 from Tesco.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 4.48pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Nope, that’s not what I said at all, is it.

If you lose your job etc that is entirely different. But why have kids if you don’t work? Some girls I know have gone on to have many kids and yet they have literally never done a days paid work in their life!

All these kids have to be paid for. Parents need to take responsibility for their own children.

One day Dan you and your boyfriend may wish to adopt, I just hope you will be responsible daddies.

Didn't Dan say a while ago he was married? Strange that you make an assumption he has a boyfriend. It's almost as though you are trying to use homosexuality as a weapon against someone you disagree with.

Returning to the point, I think this says it all really:

[Link]

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 4.50pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Solves nothing for the children currently living with hunger. What will you do for them?

Feed them.

But the cycle needs to be broken.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 4.51pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Excellent plan. Effectively, social services can repossess a child at the moment but the powers they have aren't strong enough. We just need better regulation of the parenting. Like what happened to the banks in 2008.

Problem solved through hard work and creativity you'd expect from Palace. Up yours Marcus Rashford. Stop trying to cover up crap performances with stupid ideas. School's should concentrate on teaching. You should concentrate on football. 3-1

Edited by jeeagles (23 Oct 2020 4.45pm)

What do you mean up yours. Blokes doing a fine job and is a proper role model. He is showing a lead as he should. Someone in the limelight like him should show what morality looks like.

A bit bleeding different from the current politician group and its advisors.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Oct 20 4.54pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Feed them.

But the cycle needs to be broken.

Look, if you do that how will they be able to get down the shops?

Let's not confuse longer term policy issues with a real and immediate emergency.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 20 4.54pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I cannot overstate how dreadful this post is. No wonder the other site no longer accepts such comments.

The children aren't ignorant or selfish are they? You sacrifice the innocents.

As for the 'uneducated underclass' that has 'filled up the country' there is no doubt that such people are helping you to maintain your lifestyle and health.

As a matter of interest 11% of children were living in households with persistent low income between 2013 and 2017. In FYE 2018, 12% of children fell below the threshold of low income and material deprivation in the UK. And you write this off as not your problem, only that of their parents.

FYI, in schools it is the white low income children that do least well. The most materially deprived (Bangladeshis and pakistanis) actually do quite well so very soon you will need to change your words to white uneducated underclass.

We need to care, look after the children and consider the future. Apart from the basic humanity - which seems to pass you by - there is also self-interest in avoiding the development of large groups of helpless people. We need to provide support not snarling derision.

You and they can't handle the truth.

I suggest you get off your moralising self righteous high horse because the fact is that too many people have children they can't afford and too many spend money on themselves rather than feeding their kids.

All the time mass immigration allows more and more potential low earners to arrive here, the problem will get bigger.

 

Page 5 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Marcus Rashford