You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What did we learn about our Team today or ?
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What did we learn about our Team today or ?


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 21 Dec 20 3.25pm

What did we learn? Too much back passing, a high percentage of passes when unpressed goes straight to opposition players. MacArthur and Luka two of the worst culprits.
And that refs still are pretty biased (but Jon Moss is not to blame for the result). Why did he not pick up the yellow card when Trent-Alex kicked the ball away when Palace where on top of the game (down 0-2) and PVA went bananas?
Some of the tackles from Liverpool warranted yellow - Moss hardly gave us a free-kick.
And the VAR episode when Clyne tackled a scouser. It was checked for red card or penalty. But avoided the fact that the Liverpool player was offside. It should have been a free-kick to Palace - Moss gave them the free-kick and yellow to Clyne.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 21 Dec 20 5.26pm

Thank you brother genuinely laughing out loud. When your right your right. For me the posted response of the season.

Originally posted by Ketteridge

We learnt that the cliche rollercoaster doesn't do Palace justice it is more like a bungee jump into an alligator filled grand canyon with my old gran's knicker elastic as a cord

 

gurru991 Flag Edmonton, Canada 22 Dec 20 1.53am

I feel that the team hasn't got worse but neither has it got better. Roy has done well, neither failed or succeeded and for me the time has come to hire a young manager, preferably British. The club needs imagination to progress.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 22 Dec 20 2.09am

Originally posted by gurru991

I feel that the team hasn't got worse but neither has it got better. Roy has done well, neither failed or succeeded and for me the time has come to hire a young manager, preferably British. The club needs imagination to progress.

That's harsh. Roy has taken us from a shambles to an organised, professional outfit. From relegation battles each year, to mid table safety almost guaranteed.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Dec 20 8.06am

Originally posted by Dougie

If it is any comfort this is not the worst ever home defeat as we lost 2-9 to Liverpool back in Steve Coppell's time. It was a blessing in disguise as it was the first game of the season and prompted the board to spend some money to fix problem positions. Best was a million for Nigel Martyn.

I don't recall any 2-9 home defeat to Liverpool.

I of course recall the 9-0 debacle at Anfield in 1989 but that was not our first game of the season.

Edited by Willo (22 Dec 2020 8.12am)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Dec 20 8.17am

Originally posted by Willo

I don't recall any 2-9 home defeat to Liverpool.

I of course recall the 9-0 debacle at Anfield in 1989 but that was not our first game of the season.

Edited by Willo (22 Dec 2020 8.12am)

I recall a 2.6 at home against Liverpool :-(

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Dec 20 8.23am

Originally posted by palace chick

I recall a 2.6 at home against Liverpool :-(

I have no recollection of a 2-6 defeat.
I have a recollection of a 1-6 debacle back in yesteryear.

Edited by Willo (22 Dec 2020 8.23am)

 

PatrickA Flag London 22 Dec 20 8.55am

I was at that 1-6 defeat.
I seem to recall a young Robbie Fowler scoring and Liverpool were as impressive on that day as they were on Saturday.
I’m tempted to see Saturday’s game as a one off.
For them to score 7 goals from 8 shots is remarkable.
We’re in for an up and down season, but I genuinely believe there are at least three teams that are worse than us.
And I’m a pessimist by nature.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Dec 20 9.57am

Originally posted by Willo

I have no recollection of a 2-6 defeat.
I have a recollection of a 1-6 debacle back in yesteryear.

Edited by Willo (22 Dec 2020 8.23am)

It was also Ray Wilkins debut and only game for us, I recall.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Dec 20 10.33am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I was at that 1-6 defeat.
I seem to recall a young Robbie Fowler scoring and Liverpool were as impressive on that day as they were on Saturday.
I’m tempted to see Saturday’s game as a one off.
For them to score 7 goals from 8 shots is remarkable.
We’re in for an up and down season, but I genuinely believe there are at least three teams that are worse than us.
And I’m a pessimist by nature.

I believe this is a reflection on our abject defending rather than their scoring prowess.
I was appalled at what I witnessed.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Dec 20 10.35am

Originally posted by beak


Zaha leaving may well be what we need, canny re-investment might be the catalyst to greater things.

Or relegation

 

PatrickA Flag London 22 Dec 20 10.48am

While I agree our defending left a lot to be desired, to score 7 goals from 8 shots is remarkable and something I've never witnessed in more than 50 years watching football.
I doubt I'll be witnessing it again too soon either.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 22 Dec 20 11.09am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I was at that 1-6 defeat.
I seem to recall a young Robbie Fowler scoring and Liverpool were as impressive on that day as they were on Saturday.
I’m tempted to see Saturday’s game as a one off.
For them to score 7 goals from 8 shots is remarkable.
We’re in for an up and down season, but I genuinely believe there are at least three teams that are worse than us.
And I’m a pessimist by nature.

I too was there that day, sat in the AW.

What I remember from that game was Steve Macmanaman wreaking havoc down the wing and tearing us a new one...unplayable.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Dec 20 11.59am

i learnt that as a Palace supporter you must never forget we have these results in us (not just the 9.0, how about losing 5.0 at home to Wimbledon, 4.0 to scunthorpe, 7.1 at Huddersfield etc).

It also reminded me that we will never be an established Premier League side.

Each game we need 11 players playing to a specific system that limits our opposition and allows us to catch them on the break.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 22 Dec 20 5.10pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Roy is still naïve in this league.. the time he should have had more cautious tactics, at 5-0 down, he wasnt telling his players to defend and keep the score down, 2nd half should have been a tight defence. I like attacking but some teams will rip you apart..Roy never changed the tactics at 0-4.

If the poster isn't being ironic, he has a point. If we get relegated on goal difference at the end of the season, then the failure to prevent 0-4 turning into 0-7 may well have had ramifications. It also makes the interesting point about how a manager should respond when his team is getting absolutely panned. Does he try to attack and score ('Bielsa' approach), or just settle for 'damage limitation' and do everything not to concede again? In Hodgson's case, this will have been extremely poignant. Don't forget that he has managed in Italy. At the time he did, you almost got the impression that the 'Holy Grail' of the Italian manager was a 1-0 win. Or even better a 0-1 win. Only slightly tongue-in-cheek do I suggest that such managers would rather win 1-0 than 5-0. Why so? Because to score five, you play expansively and in so doing open yourself up to the possibility that you concede a goal. If it's reprehensible to concede a goal, then imagine what conceding seven is like. 0-7 isn't just 'A Bad Day at the Office', 0-3 is a 'A Bad Day at the Office'. Otherwise you must work in a pretty relaxed office with a tolerant, not to say negligent Office manager. It'll be interesting to see how Hodgson reacts for the Villa game. His reputation is that he 'sets up teams that are so hard to score against'. So much for that last Sunday. I suspect his reaction will be to go back into his tactical bunker.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 23 Dec 20 11.39am

And Liverpool seem to play 3 games a week every week with the CL matches??

Originally posted by Cpfc1861

The fact is we played 3 games in 6 days is ridiculous tbh that being said I dont wanna see PVA in a palace shirt again.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Dec 20 12.13pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

And Liverpool seem to play 3 games a week every week with the CL matches??


Indeed but they don't have a geriatric squad. The older you are, the more recovery time you will generally need.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 23 Dec 20 12.37pm

One thing i have learnt is people on this site know nothing about the game, we had chances and never took them Roys fault as he wasnt on the pitch.
Liverpool today by Klopps admission had there shooting boots on, all deflects went there way its called football people as i said before stop looking for negative's to make it sound like you know what your talking about,
Zaha doesnt play and we dont score its because Zaha wasnt playing, Yes he is our 30 goals a season, oh sorry no he struggles to get to double figures which is rare, games he doesnt play we make the same about of chances and dont convert them than when Zaha plays, that is fact. So people we are not liverpool or any of the big clubs so results like that happen, liverpools 7-2 defeat was worse than our 7-0 as villa shouldnt beat liverpool like that

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 23 Dec 20 12.46pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

One thing i have learnt is people on this site know nothing about the game

Rude, arrogant and untrue.

 

GujiMadDog Flag England 23 Dec 20 1.29pm

We played well in the first half and could have easily gone in at half time 2:3 down. With a bit more quality upfront and better defending, we may even have gone in level.

Thier 4th, coming as early as it did in the 2nd half killed the game as a contest. For sure Liverpool were ruthless but our midfield and defence, inexplicably gave up.... completely. I couldve accepted going down by 4, maybe even, 5 but 7? That is unforgivable.

We have not had a settled back 4 this season. Injuries to our backline has now become a constant. The issue of age magnified further by the games per week this season.

Nor does our midfeild look too healthy. McArthur is a Palace stalwart but whatever pace he had is gone. We need a young 'McArthur'. Milivojevic has come in for a lot of criticism of late, most of it justified. However, during the first half, I was impressed by his passes down the channel that opened up Liverpool time and again. Townsend is a workhorse with an ability to drop a shoulder now and then. But as highlighted by Shlupp, Townsend, like McArthur, lacks pace too.

Upfront Benteke looks like he's turned a corner. Though its too early to say whether its for real or flattering to decieve. Regardless direct competition is needed. Batsman is not it and nor is Ayew. To be fair, Batsman doesnt fit into the way we play and Ayew brings a different proposition. If it werent for Ayew's rustiness, we may have got a goal or two on Saturday. The forward line Eze, Shlupp, Zaha and Ayew played well despite the thrashing.

Humiliated by Saturdays loss, for sure. Despondent about the future? Far from it but further improvements must be made.

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What did we learn about our Team today or ?