This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
so would I
|
|
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
so would I I suspect this might be a minority view amongst our supporters! In general terms a club may have to consider a number of factors if they are approached by a rival for one of their players.
|
|
|
Originally posted by pompeyeagle
Benteke is a complete waste of space and we need to get rid of him as soon as possible. If big Sam wants him I hope something can be worked out. Good riddance! And he can take Ayew with him, buy one get one free! I don't get the anti-Ayew stuff - he's been poor this season compared to last but he was amazing last season, and he worked his wotsits off most games - his form has dipped but he deserves a bit of patience - nine goals out of 32 last season when the team was parking the bus every week is good going - and the goals v west ham, watford and brighton! - I don't see how anyone cud disrespect him so much, he doesn't deserve it even accounting for his woeful performance v Man City (playing as hold up centre forward which is not his game). Looks like we've got the Benteke replacement now, and it will be good to get the big man's wages off the payroll. Ayew is an excellent squad player, competing with central and wide forwards for a first team place.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
I don't get the anti-Ayew stuff - he's been poor this season compared to last but he was amazing last season, and he worked his wotsits off most games - his form has dipped but he deserves a bit of patience - nine goals out of 32 last season when the team was parking the bus every week is good going - and the goals v west ham, watford and brighton! - I don't see how anyone cud disrespect him so much, he doesn't deserve it even accounting for his woeful performance v Man City (playing as hold up centre forward which is not his game). Looks like we've got the Benteke replacement now, and it will be good to get the big man's wages off the payroll. Ayew is an excellent squad player, competing with central and wide forwards for a first team place. I see the value of retaining the services of Ayew.
|
|
|
Originally posted by pompeyeagle
Benteke is a complete waste of space and we need to get rid of him as soon as possible. If big Sam wants him I hope something can be worked out. Good riddance! And he can take Ayew with him, buy one get one free! Is the wrong answer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by GujiMadDog
Doesn't look like he's going... And from the clips ive seen, Mateta offers something different from the Benteke role. With Batsman's and Ayew's poor forms this season and Wickham perpetually injured, it would be wise to keep CB until end of season at least. Would I renew him? Not at £120K a week, that's for sure. Im guessing he has costs us over £1m per goal/assist so has he been a waste of money? One thing is for sure, his goals when he first came kept us up and gave us all the financials that goes with that. On balance, we do need to bring in another striker who fits into the Hodgson way of play. Until then I would renew him but not at £120k a week.
Good points ! Would you keep him till the end of the season and let him leave on a free or get his wages of 120k a week off the books and maybe 3 mill transfer fee ? all hypothetical .
|
|
|
Originally posted by alexdyoung87
The more I think about it, the more a Benteke/Mateta battering-ram partnership appeals to me. They can both hold the ball up well for the likes of Eze, Zaha and Townsend to link up to and, at 6ft 4” are both a threat aerially. Im not sure Benteke has been a threat aerially for a long time now. And I dont buy into this excuse of ... "yes but he holds it up well". Last time I remember him receiving the ball in the box he controlled it with all the finesse of an 8 year old with a beachball. We've been waiting far too long for him to rediscover his mojo. To continue to pay big money for a striker who doesnt score is madness.
|
|
|
Originally posted by alexdyoung87
The more I think about it, the more a Benteke/Mateta battering-ram partnership appeals to me. They can both hold the ball up well for the likes of Eze, Zaha and Townsend to link up to and, at 6ft 4” are both a threat aerially. Sorloth is 6' 4", should we have him back too? What a forward line that would be, no need for a midfield, just long hoofs from the back, classy!
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Sorloth is 6' 4", should we have him back too? What a forward line that would be, no need for a midfield, just long hoofs from the back, classy! Is Crouch available?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Is Crouch available? Age-wise yes, he's only 39, should fit in easily
|
|
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
Im not sure Benteke has been a threat aerially for a long time now. And I dont buy into this excuse of ... "yes but he holds it up well". Last time I remember him receiving the ball in the box he controlled it with all the finesse of an 8 year old with a beachball. We've been waiting far too long for him to rediscover his mojo. To continue to pay big money for a striker who doesnt score is madness. this with bells on. People have been making excuses for Benteke for so long it seems like they've forgotten that the primary role of a striker is to score goals. Holding the ball up, tracking back, defending corners are secondary and tertiary, depending on the striker concerned, not a reason to keep him. Shows how bad things have got. For some reason, I was going through former Palace strikers in my head last night (it was a nice mental exercise!). There were the obvious greats, and the better ones. But even some of the ones that lacked a lot of the technical skills still had endeavour, threat on goal and occasionally goals in their locker. Benteke has none of that in the vast majority of his games. Edited by Frickin Saweet (25 Jan 2021 4.28pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
this with bells on. People have been making excuses for Benteke for so long it seems like they've forgotten that the primary role of a striker is to score goals. Holding the ball up, tracking back, defending corners are secondary and tertiary, depending on the striker concerned, not a reason to keep him. Shows how bad things have got. For some reason, I was going through former Palace strikers in my head last night (it was a nice mental exercise!). There were the obvious greats, and the better ones. But even some of the ones that lacked a lot of the technical skills still had endeavour, threat on goal and occasionally goals in their locker. Benteke has none of that in the vast majority of his games. Edited by Frickin Saweet (25 Jan 2021 4.28pm) Agreed , far too many excuses made for him . No more extensions please .
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Sorloth is 6' 4", should we have him back too? What a forward line that would be, no need for a midfield, just long hoofs from the back, classy! Sorloth is long gone and was $hite anyway ... Bats and Ayew are not performing whereas Benteke has looked more promising since he's featured in the team. Why on Earth would we loan/ sell any in form player mid season? Edited by Henry of Peckham (25 Jan 2021 6.50pm)
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
I Hope Big Sam persuades him. And that we demand "play all 90 minutes when WBA comes to Selhurst Park."
|
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
Benteke has looked more promising since he's featured in the team. Why on Earth would we loan/ sell any in form player mid season? According to Roy he knows nothing about the prospect of Benteke leaving so either Parish / Freedman are getting rid of players without Roy's knowledge which I sincerely hope isn't true or else it's just a load of agent / media driven testicles
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
According to Roy he knows nothing about the prospect of Benteke leaving so either Parish / Freedman are getting rid of players without Roy's knowledge which I sincerely hope isn't true or else it's just a load of agent / media driven testicles don't fall for Roy's dumb act. I read the same crap in the notes from the presser. Really? Roy hasn't read the rumours that have been all over the national press plus Sam openly declaring his interest? It's funny how they use the old "it's impossible to avoid what's being written in the papers" act when it suits them, then bury their heads in the sand the next week. "Christian's in our team at the moment, I didn't know Sam had been talking about it, but he hasn't been speaking to me about it"
|
|
|
Roy never lies Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
don't fall for Roy's dumb act. I read the same crap in the notes from the presser. Really? Roy hasn't read the rumours that have been all over the national press plus Sam openly declaring his interest? It's funny how they use the old "it's impossible to avoid what's being written in the papers" act when it suits them, then bury their heads in the sand the next week. "Christian's in our team at the moment, I didn't know Sam had been talking about it, but he hasn't been speaking to me about it"
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.