This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by CPFC1965
Looks like this could possibly be a repeat of Saigon. God help them. Allah help them as well. Just to be PC as this is what got them there. No PC rules on the battlefield and the taliban would have been gone. Self fulfilling prophecy by the woke brigade protecting terrorists.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Allah help them as well. Just to be PC as this is what got them there. No PC rules on the battlefield and the taliban would have been gone. Self fulfilling prophecy by the woke brigade protecting terrorists. Woke people should have watched more episodes of The Simpson's. The idiolistic woke groups have greated anyone that appose uppose them with vitriol and hate, despite claiming to be tolerant (they sound a bit like the Taliban). They were told time and time again that worse would happen if the West don't intervene, but they were too arrogant to listen. Now all you can do is hope the people in Afghanistan will be safe, and the violence doesn't spread. 40 million people thrown to the wolves.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Woke people should have watched more episodes of The Simpson's. The idiolistic woke groups have greated anyone that appose uppose them with vitriol and hate, despite claiming to be tolerant (they sound a bit like the Taliban). They were told time and time again that worse would happen if the West don't intervene, but they were too arrogant to listen. Now all you can do is hope the people in Afghanistan will be safe, and the violence doesn't spread. 40 million people thrown to the wolves. 10 million of them are of fighting age though.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
But I have to some points to make on what you wrote: Firstly the size of the army reflects the will of that people to fight for the society they want. They are good wages compared to what's on offer elsewhere. You don't need air cover to fight.....if you actually want to fight something against militant Islam. Some in Afghanistan would have especially the trained special forces but it has never had the numbers in terms of vanguard soldiers....the ones who do the killing that wins battles. While that Taliban have those in droves. Badger made the point why that is earlier, the Taliban have degrees of support outside the cities....which is most of the country. Secondly, the Americans have given the Afghan army considerable equipment, including planes and training for decades. The only reason the Taliban aren't in the air using it now is because they don't have the training for those planes. The Taliban now have some serious equipment to add to their willingness to fight.
The Taliban maintained and operated 5 L-39 Albatross Fighters during the civil war with the Northern Alliance, the original 5 have since fallen into disrepair/blown up but the west (I believe it was Slovakia/Czech Republic) actually sold a load of new ones to the Afghan Air force, its not much of a leap that the Air & groundcrew flipped sides to align more closely with their tribes & the Taliban. So yeah its likely the Taliban have a squadron of fighter Jets & the means to maintain/fly them. Ironically out here was a bit of an air display the other week and I watched a Mig 21 & a L-39 Albatross do a few flybys. I also got the chance to have a play with an AR-15 rifle showing up a Slovak soldier (who didnt have a clue) in the process, he got the hump and told me to put it down but I digress.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The reason we are where we are, defeated, is the behaviour of the USA President Biden and his predecessor, and of the flawed american system of investing unlimited power in one individual. There was never any need for withdrawal from Afghanistan. Only a short while ago the taliban were confined to rural areas in the south, the country was stable and peaceful with the occasional outrage you get anywhere, including here. The lot of women and society was enhanced, no acts of terrorism since 2001 from Afghan soil. Now we can only guess. Biden and Trump saw 'saving americans tax dollars' and headline-grabbing 'bringing the boys back home', well they won't be getting either. The did not consider the welfare of the people of Afghanistan at all. I feel revolted by them.
Its difficult to pin this on Trump, he was already actively reducing military numbers in Afghanistan with little to no increase in grief from the Taliban. What he would have done is impossible to say and tbh pointless now but I imagine it would have been along the same lines he was already doing which was reducing numbers over time. This falls on Biden & his weak as f*** progressive administration.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
While I'd agree that the decision to get out has been US and hence western foreign policy for sometime now I think the far greater criticism has to be given to Biden.....because its his administration making these judgements and implementing their decisions. Firstly the incompetence is staggering. Nothing seems to have been learnt from the past. I thought teaching Saigon and military mistakes was 101 in the academies. However, the Democrats have their chosen people making these decisions and implementations.....What is happening is unforgivable and it proves that whoever is making these decisions has been over promoted. But secondly because he broke the deal Trump had made with the Taliban and moved the date back. It seems that it was purely based upon the idea that leaving would then be seen to be his accomplishment rather than Trump's. Incredible really that foreign policy should be that childish. Still at least he stayed on holiday at Camp David whilst Kabul fell
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Lets be honest, it all falls on our entire modern political class. Bought and paid for, with very, very few notable exceptions, by Saudi petrodollars, Israeli biased media organizations and the Corporations, often in an unholy combination of all three. We can all take the side of our particular political flavour but what is playing out tonight at Kabul Airport, and I suspect it is going to get far messier than even today's shocking events, is a testimony that we have a collection of utterly venal sociopaths running the West. And we vote for them. All true mate. Unless we don't vote it's all just a variation upon the same bosses......that's by design.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Just watching Biden’s speech. The way he is criticising the Afghan army is a f***ing disgrace, claiming they are not prepared to fight for their own country! They were, until being hung out to dry ( probably wrong expression). Everyone s fault except his Edited by Spiderman (16 Aug 2021 9.10pm) Seconded. I have a bad feeling he will get away with it. Notice how he always talks about money, never the Afghan people.
|
|
|
There are already skirmishes between allied forces and the Taliban, Biden is talking complete nonsense.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
There are already skirmishes between allied forces and the Taliban, Biden is talking complete nonsense. If he's lying about what's possible to make them look better.....he needs to be taken to the cleaners. And they have to find someone sensible and competent.....Harris is a joke....she isn't even liked and wasn't voted for in her own party. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Aug 2021 9.42pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Lets be honest, it all falls on our entire modern political class. Bought and paid for, with very, very few notable exceptions, by Saudi petrodollars, Israeli biased media organizations and the Corporations, often in an unholy combination of all three. We can all take the side of our particular political flavour but what is playing out tonight at Kabul Airport, and I suspect it is going to get far messier than even today's shocking events, is a testimony that we have a collection of utterly venal sociopaths running the West. And we vote for them. Best comment on the thread Matov.I wasn"t going to bother posting but have put tinny on, first was that Trump agreed all this last year in Dohar, and has criticised Biden for delaying the withdrawal, perhaps as Stirling says-for him to get the credit. But it was Trumps baby. Today i saw our own foreign secretary, Domonic Raab, on tv saying NOBODY could see this coming(the speed of the Taliban). I think he was defending his own position and the pm, both are in serious trouble as this is the worst crisis on foreign policy since suez. Taking his words as gospel, as the majority voted for him , thus trust him, Nobody could perhaps, just perhaps, include the president of the United States america(sic), and indeed his predesessor !
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
I think he is finished,The Democrats will sacrifice him like an Afghan goat. Step forward Kamala Harris -.-' Edited by Ouzo Dan (16 Aug 2021 9.37pm) Or indeed be a hero for bringing the boys home, in time for next years mid term elections!
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Best comment on the thread Matov.I wasn"t going to bother posting but have put tinny on, first was that Trump agreed all this last year in Dohar, and has criticised Biden for delaying the withdrawal, perhaps as Stirling says-for him to get the credit. But it was Trumps baby. Today i saw our own foreign secretary, Domonic Raab, on tv saying NOBODY could see this coming(the speed of the Taliban). I think he was defending his own position and the pm, both are in serious trouble as this is the worst crisis on foreign policy since suez. Taking his words as gospel, as the majority voted for him , thus trust him, Nobody could perhaps, just perhaps, include the president of the United States america(sic), and indeed his predesessor ! Trump would have definitely left as well. He would have left late last year if his military establishment hadn't been dishonest. Maybe Trump's implementation would have been just as bad. We don't know...it didn't happen. If this disaster had happened under Trump I can assure you I'd have been just as angry.....I hate military incompetence as it cuts to the core. But the implementation of this has been the Biden administration's. All the decisions have been made by them: Trump is the past....just an occasionally talking head....though it's criminal that he's censored from much of the wider public. Raab is talking out of his backside. If they didn't consider this a possibility when rapid advances have been a seen both in Syria and elsewhere in falling governments then I really hold my head in my hands. Do we truly have idiots leading us? I suspect the average soldier on the ground there could have said that this outcome was at least possible unless the withdrawn was properly planned for.....Even a layman knows that you need boots on the ground to firstly get your civilian people out first.....then the military are the last to go....with considerable air cover. It's not exactly rocket science is it.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Best comment on the thread Matov.I wasn"t going to bother posting but have put tinny on, first was that Trump agreed all this last year in Dohar, and has criticised Biden for delaying the withdrawal, perhaps as Stirling says-for him to get the credit. But it was Trumps baby. Today i saw our own foreign secretary, Domonic Raab, on tv saying NOBODY could see this coming(the speed of the Taliban). I think he was defending his own position and the pm, both are in serious trouble as this is the worst crisis on foreign policy since suez. Taking his words as gospel, as the majority voted for him , thus trust him, Nobody could perhaps, just perhaps, include the president of the United States america(sic), and indeed his predesessor ! Again Trump had agreed a deal with the Taliban and was already reducing numbers with no pushback from the Taliban, beyond this its theory crafting and pointless. Biden bet everything on the W & rolled an L.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Aug 2021 9.53pm)
But these people are not idiots. They are sociopaths. And venal with it. Willing to sell their souls early on in their careers for a shot at the top. And when they get there, already bought and paid for. What we are seeing here is yet another example of chaos being created. Sending out even more waves of refugees and all heading West. Iraq. Libya. Syria. And now Afghanistan. All situations deliberately destabilised. No other explanation makes any kind of plausible sense.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.