You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Watford vs. Palace match thread
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Watford vs. Palace match thread


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 25 Aug 21 10.47am

Originally posted by doombear


Not at all. It was clearly more important for Vieira to give his first team more time to get used to playing together with the new system. The players let him down because our front three couldn't hit the proverbial barn door.

Vieira is nothing like Hodgson.

Agree. PV needs to work on his team and system. Which to be fairness looks to be working. Apart from the scoring bit.

Would be interested to hear the chat between PV and Parish this morning.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 25 Aug 21 10.58am

Sometimes you have to let things fail in order to be able to improve them.

PV's selection last night has only served to highlight the problems we have on the pitch.

To continue this season post transfer window with Mateta and Benteke as our only senior options up top will see us in deep trouble.

The clock is ticking....if the Board were in any doubt as to whether more players are needed, they surely have their answer now.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Swindy Flag Bromley 25 Aug 21 11.35am

Having gone last night, although the result was disappointing, there were positives, the passing and approach play was much better. The 3 new signings are clearly improvements on what we had, Andersen for example certainly has an eye for a pass !
A difficulty in scoring goals is hardly a new phenomenon !!
Vieira would not have come to Palace without proper assurances that there would be significant funds available for investing in the team (his reputation is also at stake) and we assume that spending has not finished and that the striker situation is yet to be tackled (there has been a rumour of Mateta being released early from his loan).
Another typical Palace thing, which also doesn't help matters is that the new manager was appointed right on top of the start of pre-season so there has not been a great deal of time for the players to get accustomed to a different playing style.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 25 Aug 21 12.05pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

It's gonna be a long hard season let's not pretend otherwise. This was always going to take time.. The blame lays squarely at the feet of the board who somehow thought that letting a squad deteriorate to a level of having 11 players out of contract was the best way to progress a club.

People have got to be patient... Hopefully we won't get cut off at the bottom of the table by the time things come together a bit more.

none of those players were worth keeping and were a significant financial drain. As is clear, and has been for a long time, our problem is our attacking/goalscoring and not much has changed or been lost there. We need a striker that can score at the top level. That coupled with Olise and Eze returning should sort things out somewhat

 

taylors lovechild Flag 25 Aug 21 12.13pm

Originally posted by Therealeaglestilidie

I was at the game. We did control a lot of the game and looked assured playing out from the back. The problem was in the final third and a lack of creativity. Gallagher was a bundle of energy again and I think he was subbed to be saved for the weekend. Zaha was glued to the touchline most of the game but when he did get it there was still something missing.
Good to see Anderson start to send those long passes out of defence like he was doing to Lookman last season.
I would have liked to see Rak-Saki given a go in the second half. The three new signings looked class. The longer the game went on without us scoring the more you feared from a break away sucker punch and in the end that how it played out.

Thanks for the write up. I can't imagine it can have been worse than our cup performances over the last few years even if we did still lose.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 25 Aug 21 12.17pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

none of those players were worth keeping and were a significant financial drain. As is clear, and has been for a long time, our problem is our attacking/goalscoring and not much has changed or been lost there. We need a striker that can score at the top level. That coupled with Olise and Eze returning should sort things out somewhat

Disagree that we need a striker that can score at the top level, what we need are midfielders that can supply strikers and also midfielders that can score goals between them. Goals need to come from all over, including defenders at set plays. Yes, Benteke needs service from out wide which isn’t happening but he is a top striker in my opinion for which we rely on just him? Would have been interesting to see what Vieira would have done with Townsend? Midfielders need to open up play as well for which our one seem better defensively but not attacking wise? Let’s hope we get some quality in before the window closes.

Realise posters have picked up and disagree with me about Benteke but my main points are that we don’t have goals throughout the team, Especially midfielders. Plus the existing midfielders don’t have a split the opponents defence pass to give our forward(s) goal scoring chances. If Benteke had more than one chance a game he would stick at least one away unlike Mateta at this time. I understand we made chances for him last night and no goals resulted? Perhaps Vieira is changing things but we need goals from everyone and not just the main forward. Sadly Zaha doesn’t seem the player he was as well :-(

Edited by palace chick (25 Aug 2021 1.11pm)

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 25 Aug 21 12.26pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Disagree that we need a striker that can score at the top level, what we need are midfielders that can supply strikers and also midfielders that can score goals between them. Goals need to come from all over, including defenders at set plays. Yes, Benteke needs service from out wide which isn’t happening but he is a top striker in my opinion for which we rely on just him? Would have been interesting to see what Vieira would have done with Townsend? Midfielders need to open up play as well for which our one seem better defensively but not attacking wise? Let’s hope we get some quality in before the window closes.

You expect a striker playing for the best international team (Belgium) around, to be able to do more than heading the ball. Like, anticipate where the ball is coming low inside the box. Benteke never seem to have any clue. The sooner we get a proper striker, the better....

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 25 Aug 21 12.39pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Disagree that we need a striker that can score at the top level, what we need are midfielders that can supply strikers and also midfielders that can score goals between them. Goals need to come from all over, including defenders at set plays. Yes, Benteke needs service from out wide which isn’t happening but he is a top striker in my opinion for which we rely on just him? Would have been interesting to see what Vieira would have done with Townsend? Midfielders need to open up play as well for which our one seem better defensively but not attacking wise? Let’s hope we get some quality in before the window closes.

Benteke has 16 league goals since the start of the 2017/18 season (4 and bit seasons).

He's played 139 games in that time.

The sooner we give up this fantasy that he's a top striker who might come good and score enough goals, the sooner we actually recruit someone who might.

An absolute joke that he's had his contract extended because he decided to pull his finger out for 5 games at the end of the year when he needed a new deal - took us to the absolute cleaners.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 25 Aug 21 12.42pm

Problem with Benteke, yes he does have something but he is a statue in the box with no movement whatsoever. Compare that with somebody like Calvert Lewin where the crosses go into space and he attacks it. CB makes it easy for defenders

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 25 Aug 21 12.49pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

You expect a striker playing for the best international team (Belgium) around, to be able to do more than heading the ball. Like, anticipate where the ball is coming low inside the box. Benteke never seem to have any clue. The sooner we get a proper striker, the better....

I guess neither Benteke (or Batts for that matter) really play for the national team.

But your point is still correct, a 'top' footballer needs to have more to his game than we currently get

 

CP81 Flag Kent 25 Aug 21 1.06pm

Watford was another opportunity for PV to assess who he has.
It's gonna need time and patience. The next few games will be a rough ride.
But please, for the love of the Red & Blue god's, get a strike force that can hit a barn door.

 


Palace 2 Charlton 0 1981

palace chick Flag South Croydon 25 Aug 21 1.12pm

Realise posters have picked up and disagree with me about Benteke but my main points are that we don’t have goals throughout the team, Especially midfielders. Plus the existing midfielders don’t have a split the opponents defence pass to give our forward(s) goal scoring chances. If Benteke had more than one chance a game he would stick at least one away unlike Mateta at this time. I understand we made chances for him last night and no goals resulted? Perhaps Vieira is changing things but we need goals from everyone and not just the main forward. Sadly Zaha doesn’t seem the player he was as well :-(

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 25 Aug 21 1.30pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Realise posters have picked up and disagree with me about Benteke but my main points are that we don’t have goals throughout the team, Especially midfielders. Plus the existing midfielders don’t have a split the opponents defence pass to give our forward(s) goal scoring chances. If Benteke had more than one chance a game he would stick at least one away unlike Mateta at this time. I understand we made chances for him last night and no goals resulted? Perhaps Vieira is changing things but we need goals from everyone and not just the main forward. Sadly Zaha doesn’t seem the player he was as well :-(

good post, totally agree

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 25 Aug 21 1.35pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I guess neither Benteke (or Batts for that matter) really play for the national team.

But your point is still correct, a 'top' footballer needs to have more to his game than we currently get

No surprise as Lukaku is everything in a striker that they are not. Take his goal against the Arse. Held the ball up, layed it off to James who played it low across the box for him to finish. No thinking time needed, knew exactly how the play would go and where he needed to be. James showed there and on his goal how you play on the wing, albeit the defending was shocking. Push it low first, second time clear sight at goal take a shot. Unfortunately for us at the moment, service and/or movement in attack just isn't there. Hopefully (surely ?) we are looking at further options.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

briandavis Flag Udon Thani 25 Aug 21 1.46pm

I don't know about 'mentality'. We just need clinical finishers, they don't have to be pretty, just capable of hitting the net, more than the floodlights.Players who can take a far greater percentage of chances created. Hitting the target in the first place at least gives a chance of scoring.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 25 Aug 21 2.06pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Realise posters have picked up and disagree with me about Benteke but my main points are that we don’t have goals throughout the team, Especially midfielders. Plus the existing midfielders don’t have a split the opponents defence pass to give our forward(s) goal scoring chances. If Benteke had more than one chance a game he would stick at least one away unlike Mateta at this time. I understand we made chances for him last night and no goals resulted? Perhaps Vieira is changing things but we need goals from everyone and not just the main forward. Sadly Zaha doesn’t seem the player he was as well :-(

Think part of Benteke's problem, which I have been Critical in the past, is That he does not make runs in the box and expects things to be on a plate for him. However, if he does not expect the ball to come in - which we have been guilty of in the past - then he will not make the correct run.
He needs to learn where to position himself for playing with our new midfield.. (which currently looks like our old midfield!) hopefully Olise (and eze - and even Ferguson when/if they return) will provide more of this, which CB will need to learn to be on the end of.

As for goals all over the pitc - I whoeheartedly agree. Although even with our new signings, I'm not sure we have any goalscoring midfielders? and have Anderson/Guehi ever been a threat in the opposition box ?


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 25 Aug 21 3.30pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Disagree that we need a striker that can score at the top level, what we need are midfielders that can supply strikers and also midfielders that can score goals between them. Goals need to come from all over, including defenders at set plays. Yes, Benteke needs service from out wide which isn’t happening but he is a top striker in my opinion for which we rely on just him? Would have been interesting to see what Vieira would have done with Townsend? Midfielders need to open up play as well for which our one seem better defensively but not attacking wise? Let’s hope we get some quality in before the window closes.

Realise posters have picked up and disagree with me about Benteke but my main points are that we don’t have goals throughout the team, Especially midfielders. Plus the existing midfielders don’t have a split the opponents defence pass to give our forward(s) goal scoring chances. If Benteke had more than one chance a game he would stick at least one away unlike Mateta at this time. I understand we made chances for him last night and no goals resulted? Perhaps Vieira is changing things but we need goals from everyone and not just the main forward. Sadly Zaha doesn’t seem the player he was as well :-(

Edited by palace chick (25 Aug 2021 1.11pm)

I don't really disagree with anything you're saying about the rest of the team needing to contribute to goals. However Benteke has proven beyond doubt that he's a waste of space and we need to move on from him.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 25 Aug 21 4.28pm

Benteke is not a top striker. He will only score if you put the ball on his head without him having to actually move. Sometimes think he has his boots on the wrong feet. What will help us score goals and the midfield create more, would be a decent nippy forward who actually made decent runs to allow the midfield to be creative.

Originally posted by palace chick

Disagree that we need a striker that can score at the top level, what we need are midfielders that can supply strikers and also midfielders that can score goals between them. Goals need to come from all over, including defenders at set plays. Yes, Benteke needs service from out wide which isn’t happening but he is a top striker in my opinion for which we rely on just him? Would have been interesting to see what Vieira would have done with Townsend? Midfielders need to open up play as well for which our one seem better defensively but not attacking wise? Let’s hope we get some quality in before the window closes.

Realise posters have picked up and disagree with me about Benteke but my main points are that we don’t have goals throughout the team, Especially midfielders. Plus the existing midfielders don’t have a split the opponents defence pass to give our forward(s) goal scoring chances. If Benteke had more than one chance a game he would stick at least one away unlike Mateta at this time. I understand we made chances for him last night and no goals resulted? Perhaps Vieira is changing things but we need goals from everyone and not just the main forward. Sadly Zaha doesn’t seem the player he was as well :-(

Edited by palace chick (25 Aug 2021 1.11pm)

 

Fatherken Flag 25 Aug 21 4.33pm

Remember it was Mateta that missed most of chances in the game .
Now there is a player we could well do without .

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 25 Aug 21 5.00pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

none of those players were worth keeping and were a significant financial drain. As is clear, and has been for a long time, our problem is our attacking/goalscoring and not much has changed or been lost there. We need a striker that can score at the top level. That coupled with Olise and Eze returning should sort things out somewhat

It doesn't matter whether they were worth keeping or not (which a few of them were) They nearly all played a role in the first team. Allowing a squad to deteriorate to that level is not healthy for morale or good business sense. And not fair on a new Manager coming in to try and build a new team.

I'd love for you to show me another Premiership club who have the same business model as us and allowed that to happen.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Watford vs. Palace match thread