This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Players are only doing what their Managers ask them to do.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Having real punishment for simulation would help - either within the game that it takes place in - 15 or 30 mins sin bin (depending upon circumstances) or red card - Or if its a retrospect punishment (& I have only ever seen 1 player penalised after the game) the offending side loses a point & aggrieved side gains 1 point - Obviously that's just a top of my head suggestion & it would probably need fine tuning but you get the drift. Sin-bins will never happen in our lifetime as FIFA doesn't want them. Tho, a damm good idea, works in rugby union to good effect. We have had 'retrospective punishment' it was stopped in favour of VAR which fans, managers & pundits wanted.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Regarding refs, and as someone pointed out a few posts ago, they haven't played the game at any level really as they start so young in order to get up the leagues in time to be a premier league ref. Based on the teenage boys who referee my sons under-11s games, I doubt too many of them will end up in the top flight no matter how early they start, but Christ knows there aren't enough people who want to be refs, and if we took away the incentive that a youngster might make it to the top if he starts young enough then it'd be even harder to get officals for grass roots football. Anyway, I don't think the idea of referees having played the game is all that important really. Firstly (and this is the lesser point), if they played professional football until 35 before starting out as a ref, they would either be 50+ years old by the time they had enough training and experience to officiate at the top level (and be called too old and slow to keep up with play) or be fast-tracked into top-flight refereeing with no experience behind them (and be called under-qualified and unproven). Secondly (and this is the big issue for me), whatever playing experience and insight a ref might have doesn't really matter if he is not allowed to use it. The current system of refereeing (including VAR) seems to place no value at all on upholding the wider spirit of the game, focusing entirely on the technical rules, applied blindly and in total isolation to any one split second incident. That same system promotes and demotes referees, so even if an ex-pro has a better idea of what a player is up to when they 'draw' a foul, that ref still has to implement the wishes of the wider system if they want to stay at the top. I'd say most poor decisions (especially VAR ones) stem from fear of not implementing the letter of the law in a technical way, leading to the abandonment of the spirit of the game and fouls given for the most fleeting of contacts. TV has a lot to answer for here - if they didn't analyse every decision then perhaps refs wouldn't feel such pressure to overreact to contact. Besides, listening to the likes of Shearer say that a forward has 'the right to go down' when contacted, or has 'been clever there' (something Vieria himself said about Jota on Sunday lets not forget), I'm not sure I want many ex-pros anywhere near a whistle. On your second point, I'm not sure players ever played with true sportsmanship. From the hatchet men of the old days to the divers of today, they will get away with whatever they can because they are competitive animals under pressure to win. Obviously, it helps hugely when referees wise up (they let more contact go early this season and it made a very positive difference), but any lasting change in the honesty of players would only come about when their own fans demand it. Perhaps that means you and I have to criticise (perhaps boo or barrack?) our own players when they go over too easily, and not just reserve that treatment for Jota, Kane etc. Perhaps we have to applaud the ref when he waves play on at Zaha or Ayew, rather than join the chorus of pressure to give a free-kick. Not an easy thing to do. Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 2.47pm) Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 2.52pm) BTP, you sir are a star, exactly this & youv'e worded it better than I tried to do.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Regarding VAR, and that stat that no ref has overturned it this season, it seems obvious to me that players will be encouraged to "try it on", knowning that if it goes to VAR there is a very good chance of the cheat being rewarded by referees who don't have the balls to challenge the VAR master. He who holds the VAR key can dictate the game. This is a very dodgy state of affairs. Edited by southnorwoodhill (26 Jan 2022 6.57pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Irrelevant what may have happened if Firmino was onside because the fact is, according to the laws of the game he was offside and there is absolutely no Exactly this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
So it was not a penalty, what is going to happen to Friend and Pawson? I think we know the answer
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
So it was not a penalty, what is going to happen to Friend and Pawson? I think we know the answer Obviously I don't know the thinking of Craig Pawson in determining that it was a "Clear and obvious error" but I believe it is feasible that he concluded that there was a coming together and Guaita used his left arm to push Jota to the ground.Others of course have viewed this incident differently !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Clearly we are not 'Birds on the same twig' apropos officials, in fact we have always had a difference of opinion on this matter. I have no desire to enter a protracted debate on this issue as it will only disintegrate into a dastardly Willo thread. we most certainly are not, you believe referees are honest and infallible, whereas I believe they are liars incompetent and almost certainly corrupt, and Friend has just reinforced my beliefs. Edited by the silurian (26 Jan 2022 8.17pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
So it was not a penalty, what is going to happen to Friend and Pawson? I think we know the answer We do, absolutely nothing will happen to them, other than a pat on the back for helping Liverpools cause and quite possibly a nice little bonus
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
we most certainly are not, you believe referees are honest and infallible, whereas I believe they are liars incompetent and almost certainly corrupt, and Friend has just reinforced my beliefs. Very wise as yet another dastardly Willo thread awash with high-grade and inexorable animosity would not be in the interests of HOL. Edited by Willo (26 Jan 2022 8.24pm)
|
|
|
Friend been demoted to Championship for Millwall game. Presumably be back when PL reconvenes. Don’t know why they bother Edited by Spiderman (26 Jan 2022 8.49pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Baires Eagle
So we put Clattenburg, Friend and Pawson in a bullet-proof perspex dome. Each are strapped to a Joe 90 chair in triangular formation facing one another with one hand free from their straight-jackets. Steve hands them the gun, one at time, for the Palace roulette. One live shot in 8 barrels.... it's a 22 of course. Could it last 90 mins or will it go to extra time ! There in the corner is a hot grill, a machete and 5 bags of charcoal. But, how long can the survivor stay alive???????? Tix are free for season ticket holders and registered Palace supporters.
Don’t forget Bobby Madley.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pigglelet
Well if the ref is always going to (or be instructed to) accept the VAR decision, what the heck is the point of them wasting time reviewing the action on the pitch-side monitor? Is it to add to the excitement for the fans? It should be like in cricket where the Decision Review System is final. It would save a lot of time if the ref didn’t have to fanny about pretending he might actually uphold his original call. Or better still just scrap VAR. In the sport of cricket the DRS is based on factual information provided by technology, as it is for offsides in football. The VAR in the hub makes a subjective decision apropos penalties,serious foul play etc, before advising the match referee to review the decision he has made. Edited by Willo (27 Jan 2022 12.54pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
In the sport of cricket the DRS is based on factual information provided by technology, as it is for offsides in football. The VAR in the hub makes a subjective decision apropos penalties,serious foul play etc, before advising the match referee to review the decision he has made. Edited by Willo (27 Jan 2022 12.54pm) Thank you, Willo. I refer you to my last sentence. On Sunday we had two debateable offside situations where apparently VAR didn't even get involved. Edited by Pigglelet (27 Jan 2022 1.05pm)
"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt." |
|
|
Originally posted by Pigglelet
Thank you, Willo. I refer you to my last sentence. On Sunday we had two debateable offside situations where apparently VAR didn't even get involved. Edited by Pigglelet (27 Jan 2022 1.05pm) In terms of the incident leading up to the second goal,maybe the VAR did notice that Firmino was offside but the ball sailed over his head and the VAR deemed he was not interfering with play.A subjective decision which of course has caused much controversy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
In terms of the incident leading up to the second goal,maybe the VAR did notice that Firmino was offside but the ball sailed over his head and the VAR deemed he was not interfering with play.A subjective decision which of course has caused much controversy. A subjective decision which was totally wrong according to the laws of the game
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.